HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kaydub

638 karma · joined April 7, 2020

submissionscomments
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
What hard problems are you working on?
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
I knew nothing about game development a few months ago. Now I've built a simple godot game. I'm sure the game is all pretty common (simple 2d naval combat game) but it's still impressive that a couple claude/gemini/codex cli sessions spit out a working game (admittedly, I'm not a professional artist, so THAT part of it has been painful since I can't rely on generative AI to do that, I have to do it myself with aesprite. But maybe a professional artist would know HOW to prompt for the artwork)

Agentic programming still needs devs/engineers. It's only going to take your lunch if you let it. And by that, I mean the FUD and complete refusal to give good faith attempts to use the ai/llm tools.

kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
How long have you been coding? How many languages and frameworks have you worked with? Where has your professional focus been?

I've written professional code in production for the past 15+ years in VB, C# (MVC2/MVC3 + Razor), Php(Yii, Yii2, Symfony), Perl, Python(Flask, Cherrpy), Java(Spring MVC, Spring boot, JSF, J2EE), Golang, Rust, Ruby. I've worked on build/ci pipelines from Jenkins, CircleCI, Github, Gitlab, Teamcity, etc. I've had to deploy/manage infrastructure from bare metal to the cloud with Ansible, Puppet, Saltstack, Terraform, Cloudformation. I've had to run on MySQL, Postgres, Mariadb, SQL Server and use ActiveMQ, RabbitMQ, Kafka, SQS, SNS, MSK, Kinesis (of all flavors). I could literally keep going and going and going.

I'm tired. It's way easier to prompt than keep track of all this shit at this point. I don't need to know how to implement $feature or $tool in each and every framework, I'll let the machines worry about that.

kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
Always have another agent around that is just reviewing code. "Look for duplicate code, code smells, bad architecture, future scalability problems..."

I usually keep one agent/prompt/context ripping through new features and another 1-3 agents/prompts/contexts reviewing, testing, planning.

kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
So waterfall sdlc...
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
Yeah, I'm huge on using LLMs for coding, but one of the biggest wins for me is that the LLM already knows the frameworks. I no longer need to learn whatever newest framework there is. I'll stick to my frameworks, especially when using an LLM to code.
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
I think a lot of the people pro-llm are already in the middle. It's the naysays that are sticking to a strict definition of "vibe coding" as if it's random people typing in "make me $app but make no bugs" and getting a 100% working $app with no bugs. You have the gastown folks trying to do that, but nobody serious putting in good work with llm agents is "vibe coding" in that way.
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
> I wonder if the LLMs "converge" on a particular UI if not given specific instructions?

Purple. They really fucking like this purple gradient background for some reason lol.

kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
There's a lot of reasons. There's a lot of breadth to "software engineering" (FAANG, web dev, embedded, OS, small business, etc.)

I'm sure there are some places where LLMs are bad due to lack of training data. There are some places where the LLMs are bad because the code base is terrible (and there's always "rockstars" at these jobs that severely overestimate their skills because they're always the one fixing the mess... which they also probably caused). Some devs/engineers feel threatened. Many devs/engineers think they're special and super smart so surely no machine can do their job.

kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
Yeah, I don't know why you'd drop using frameworks and libraries just because you're using an LLM. If you AREN'T using them you're just loading a bunch of solved problems into the LLMs context so it can re-invent the wheel. I really love the LLM because now I don't need to learn the new frameworks myself. LLMs really remove all the bullshit I don't want to think about.
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
Feels like code written by a co-worker. No different than working on any decent sized code-base anywhere.

I've stopped writing code too. Who the fuck wants to learn yet ANOTHER new framework. So much happier with llm tools.

kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
The excitement hasn't cooled off where I'm working.

Honestly, I'm personally happy to see so many naysayers online, it means I'm going to have job security a little longer than you folks.

kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
The AI agents can ALREADY "de-slopify" the code. That's one of the patterns people should be using when coding with LLMs. Keep an agent that only checks for code smells, testability, "slop", scalability problems, etc. alongside whatever agent you have writing the actual code.
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
We already do. It's the same tool.
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
I hope you realize that means your position is in danger.
kaydub··on Coding agents have replaced every framework I used
The hubris is with the devs that think like you actually.
kaydub··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
> I have no idea how people use mac.

Meh, it has a terminal. Good enough for me. It's worth putting up with MacOS for the hardware.

kaydub··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
If there was an easy and supported way to put linux on a macbook I'd be back on linux but I can't give up the hardware.
kaydub··on Microsoft forced me to switch to Linux
I haven't even touched a Windows PC in years at this point. Don't know why you'd do that to yourself. I was hanging on to a gaming PC, but it broke during a move over 2 years ago now. I decided that was the last windows box I'd own at that point.
kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
I haven't used it because there's been absolutely no reason to even try again. I jumped on copilot when it first came out. I had a personal account and they got us subscriptions at work. It was the first LLM/AI tool I dropped. It was around 2 months ago they dropped our subscriptions at work too.

I only have an IDE open these days to review, maybe update a config or parameter on occasion.

kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
Rtkit... what are you even working on?
kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
Nope, haven't tried recently because the cli tools were so much better and more powerful I haven't felt like there's a reason to ever go back.
kaydub··on Things I've learned in my 10 years as an engineering manager
And most the meetings end up with the same people in them where we're just repeating the same shit to an additional 1-2 people per each meeting
kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
I just feel like using Copilot would be like early car designers trying to steer their new car with reins.
kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
I just round robin them until I run out on whatever subscription level I'm on. I only use claude api, so I pay per token there... I consider using claude as "bringing out the big guns" because I also think it's the top-level coder.
kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
Yeah, I've been working with LLMs since openai released that first model. What I'm doing today is VASTLY different than anything we thought possible back then, so I wouldn't call it "vibe coding"
kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
Nope, you couldn't have written it yourself in the same time. That's just a false assumption a lot of you like to make.
kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
I've had success across quite a few languages, more than just python and js. I find it insanely hard to believe you can write code faster than the LLM, even if the LLM has to iterate a couple times.

But I'm thankful for you devs that are giving me job security.

kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
I don't see people treating AI practices as trade secrets. It's just the nature of a non-deterministic system.
kaydub··on After two years of vibecoding, I'm back to writing by hand
You can update the spec as you go... There's nothing that makes the spec concrete and unchangeable.
← PreviousPage 5 of 10Next →