898 karma · joined December 9, 2014
So a solution is not yet another platform but everyone (that cares enough) to run their own decentralized way of accepting payments/support.
Just install BtcPayServer ( https://btcpayserver.org/ ) and you can start accepting payments in Bitcoin and other coins even via LN, without having to trust any intermediary plus no extra middlemen fees.
Cherry on-top they are now demanding passports (KYC) for those that fell for their ICO while nothing was mentioned when they are actually collecting the money.
Hopefully at least their software will be of some value and not a total scam like their rest practices.
- As for wallet bugs: if you're talking about Ethereum or low-quality software projects yes, but for Bitcoin it's been a long time since that was an issue
- Regarding power: setting aside all those sensationalistic headlines. Crypto-miners are a way that enable renewables to be optimized when there are imbalances on the demand/supply on the powergrid. Contracts with renewables enable further development of that infrastructure. Of the top of my head BitFury, one of the big crypto-mining firms are in majority if not completely powered by renewables.
- Also compare that to the multiples of power used today by gold mining, or infrastructure that Bitcoin aims to replace.
- In the end, it's like any other power usage, the market will decide if it's viable, govs could probably tax power usage on cryptocurrencies, but it won't matter since the market will adapt.
- There are decentralized exchanges trying to break through along with various different type of projects, albeit the space is crowded by scammers/ICOs like any new space it's the unfortunate nature of the people.
- Although it's illegal in Venezuela, Venezuelans protecting their wealth from the dictatorship is quite a use case. Also, what's the legal use case for owning gold? I do commerce legally just fine with Bitcoin although the tech is still evolving on that front.
Judging on a tech based on its current state is being blinded to the evolution of tech and I'm surprised to see it from an HN user.
I personally don't care about Blockchain or the ICOs, scams etc. unfortunately pop everyone, but I see value on Bitcoin, using your money completely permissionlessly with other people is a great feeling in our days.
I also see great applications in the future where we can have more native money on games/apps.
Like internet, people will abuse, scam and it can be dangerous but thing how it would have been if there was no free internet to browser any website you want, but only a regional app store.
Indeed.
- Onion Routing Protocol: https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lightning-rfc/blob/maste...
- P2P Node and Channel Discovery https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lightning-rfc/blob/maste...
This repo contains specs for a lot of parts of the LN, although probably there may be changes I imagine.
As for code, one of the implementations, LND (Go): https://github.com/lightningnetwork/lnd/tree/master/routing but there are at least 3 other implementations in the works.
https://github.com/ElementsProject/lightning (clang) https://github.com/ACINQ/eclair (Scala) https://github.com/mit-dci/lit (Go)
Also, note the core idea of LN (updatable non-broadcasted Bitcoin TXs with incentive-based security and eventual broadcast to the blockchain network) is a powerful idea and as we explore this scheme and more engineers get accustomed I am sure we will see even more exciting things.
The point is that it's disingenuous to deem a new tech dead, while the engineers working on it sill say that it's not yet fully-ready for production.
The implementation and the protocol still evolves, but the core idea behind it is rock solid and the most promising way forward to help with scaling AND enable use-cases that would be otherwise impossible (see microtransactions & realtime millisecond scale monetary transactions etc.)
It's an evolving software still in pre-alpha state. But the core idea is solid and if you follow the development you'll see the strides of progress that is being done on all fronts.
To your points.
1. Depending on the options you set to your channels, you could have a window of days (or anything the two parties agree to), to act in case the other party tries to broadcast outdated TXs i.e. steal funds. Also you don't need to have a computer constantly online, you can offload the task to Watchtowers, software dedicated to do that for multiple users concurrently. (You also can have multiple Watchtowers as backups). Also, I imagine it could even be a mobile app. So this is a non-issue.
2. Routing will keep being improved but it's already pretty good and the way you present it screams FUD.
3. Currently crazy low fees aside, LN basically enables the multiplication of on-chain TXs population. I think your assumption is that the retailer will close and reopen a channel for every LN payment they receive which it makes no sense whatsoever from any point of view.
4. If by huge you mean $100 of which the fee is $0.5, sure. You can add any amount you want on an LN channel. Basically it's like a hot-wallet, e.x you can add $1500 for $0.5 fee, and casually spend it for coffees and other small expenses with lower TX fees than a satoshi (since LN supports fees at the millisatoshi = 1/1000 satoshi level).
P.S: This FUD-wave is pretty pitiful, at least get some real arguments. I hope even more people start to recognize that a lot of people have incentives to attack new tech in order to push their narratives for their altcoins or w/e.
Also, pretty sure Cash and Banking trumps Bitcoin in all of the following: terrorism, human-trafficking, drugs. Shell companies and weird schemes having been used and are used for a long time.
Final note, I argue that a lot of Venezuelans and Zimbabweans are thankful Bitcoin exists and they are not destroyed by the irresponsibility of governments.
Coinbase basically did one of the most basic mistakes for new markets (or any newly-online market), to not allow orderbooks to be filled before trades can take place. And so people took advantage of it. I just hope inexperienced people didn't get caught in the middle of it.
It takes weeks for a really beefy machine to fully sync a full node. "Smart" contracts remain really difficulty to be written safely. Ethereum was unusualable when it reached its scaling limits just by one silly app of cat breeding. They are on the verge of doing another hard-fork to effectively revert some transactions and move some stuck ETH. It's really a clownfest that keeps on pushing badly written software just so they can sell it to greater fools and enterprise "smart"-dump money. Can't have respect for this kind of behavior.
SegWit being pretty much the most important update to Bitcoin so far with a lot of advantages, I would expect that CB would give top priority on supporting it. But Brian when asked about it, he replied with a job ad about new positions, while I would expect they would put their most experienced engineers on it, instead of depend on new recruits for such crucial and maybe challenging project.
That's one of the core values for me, however I can see that people are used to or just fine with their current bank relationships. Thinking that it's either the one or the other that work for everyone is naive.
Buy a hardware wallet (e.g. Trezor in my example) note down the 24 words that are basically your privatekey. But enable the passphrase (25th word/phrase) which you type yourself and could keep just in your mind.
You have the safety of multiple backups for the 24 words and the extra security from burglars and others with the 25th passphrase.
https://blog.trezor.io/hide-your-trezor-wallets-with-multipl...
It also serves as a plausible deniability because when you input your passphrase it will never say it's incorrect, it will merely open a different wallet (generate a different private key).
Helps with the $5 wrench attack. You could setup a "fake" wallet with some activity and a low amount of Bitcoins, and have a different passphrase for the real wallet with the big amount.
BYOB, freedom comes at a price.
Several big Bitcoin miners are setup near or just being powered by hydroelectric dams or other renewable energy sources. And all of them of course target low costs, which a lot of times means that there's an oversupply of power in essence helping in some cases use energy that would go to waste otherwise.
You have to compare the gold or bank industry's to Bitcoin's mining emissions. Gold is constrained by the gold mines positions, uses oil a lot, unless someone does a proper study, all this articles are just sensationalistic articles by clueless journos hunting pageviews and likes.
Sidenote, funny how this is filled under "Currency Manipulation"
The Bitcoin of ~a month ago is not the same as today, that's a big power, to have upgradable decentralized money. Certainly Bitcoin is not perfect, but the good thing is that there are a lot of talented engineers working on the issues and new features, the majority of them even before Bitcoin really was worth much. But having it being valuable at the moment also acts a huge security/bug bounty and an incentive for more people work on it and make it better.
= All about the price
Even if the price crashes horribly, unless there's a unrecoverable catastrophe, it will keep on going because there's an ecosystem around it and clear price-independent advantages. Using Bitwage to be paid in Bitcoins and avoid crazy cross-border/currency fees of banks will be still an advantage no matter the price of bitcoin. Same goes for prepaid/debit cards backed with bitcoin. Doing commerce painlessly without crazy procedures with Africa & Latin America or wherever. Being immune to capital controls and asset seizures.
= Hype
I hate the hype everywhere, but it's not the tech's fault so many cluessless & irrelevant gold-diggers try to ride the wave, just with a lot of things you can just ignore. If you follow the devs, they are pragmatic and don't try to pump-up things like most altcoins do, that's something I greatly respect.
Anyway, there's a long way to go, but just because there are flaws at the moment, it doesn't mean it's dead, it's a live technology. Being pragmatic is key, Bitcoin is not some Utopian perfect invention, but it's good enough for a lot of things at the moment and I see it getting better every year.
Bitcoin offers true permissionless commerce and ownership of wealth and it now might not make any difference in a lot of democratic countries until it begins to do.