HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

keerthiko

4,022 karma · joined September 5, 2012

https://bitgym.com

https://keerthik.github.io

cofounder bitgym, olin college alum, former digital nomad.

O1A visa -> EB1 Green card holder with only an undergrad degree.

Feel free to reach out if you aren't trying to sell me anything @keerthiko

submissionscomments
keerthiko··on xAI joins SpaceX
without having watched the Big Short or having read the article, my first impression from the quote is "Megacorporations are failing dramatically, and the billionaires at their helm are freely doing financial gymnastics to pull the covers over the eyes of shareholders, while gaming the system to fully circumvent taxes and regulation -- the people with the power to do anything about it (legislators and regulators) watch idly (maybe profiting), the oligarchs make off like bandits despite copious failures, and the end consumer/taxpayer is either robbed or clueless this is going on, but most likely both, when there was a world where accountability could have been had and the common man was treated better."

the article headline immediately screams "financial gymnastics" to me so the rest followed from the quote.

keerthiko··on A few random notes from Claude coding quite a bit last few weeks
Almost always, notes like these are going to be about greenfield projects.

Trying to incorporate it in existing codebases (esp when the end user is a support interaction or more away) is still folly, except for closely reviewed and/or non-business-logic modifications.

That said, it is quite impressive to set up a simple architecture, or just list the filenames, and tell some agents to go crazy to implement what you want the application to do. But once it crosses a certain complexity, I find you need to prompt closer and closer to the weeds to see real results. I imagine a non-technical prompter cannot proceed past a certain prototype fidelity threshold, let alone make meaningful contributions to a mature codebase via LLM without a human engineer to guide and review.

keerthiko··on Vietnam bans unskippable ads
> By doing this, you'll chase the ads into

IMO regulation never was or is going to force this shift: it's already happening in unregulated ad markets, and is going to keep evolving in that direction because it's simply more effective/lucrative than ads done other ways.

> Break up Google. Don't tell content marketplaces how to run ads.

I'm all for breaking up megacorps, but there's no way a government like Vietnam can effectively accomplish that. The entire regulatory weight of the EU (90% of the non-US first-world consumer base) can't break up Google, so inflicting a series of wristslaps that hurt Google more than any small startup is the best way.

I'm no expert on the region, but I can't imagine a small video/social startup in Vietnam will be hurt more than Google by being forced to show a skip button after 5s on their ads — and generally speaking ads as a business model generally doesn't work all that well or mean much for small startups (<1M MAU), their survival and scalability hinges more on VC money and product-market fit than ad arbitrage.

keerthiko··on Vietnam bans unskippable ads
I would argue that limiting the amount of unrequested product evangelism shoved into users' eyeballs is a valuable public and mental health initiative. I wish we could have seen the alternate reality where ad-revenue was not the most lucrative business model for the internet.
keerthiko··on Texas app store age verification law blocked by federal judge
I just received an email from Google Play Developer today morning that they will not be activating the age verification APIs (they will throw an exception) because of the injunction, so there's nothing Apple specific about this.
keerthiko··on We replaced H.264 streaming with JPEG screenshots (and it worked better)
> The fix was embarrassingly simple: once you fall back to screenshots, stay there until the user explicitly clicks to retry.

There is another recovery option:

- increase the JPEG framerate every couple seconds until the bandwidth consumption approaches the H264 stream bandwidth estimate

- keep track latency changes. If the client reports a stable latency range, and it is acceptable (<1s latency, <200ms variance?) and bandwidth use has reached 95% of H264 estimate, re-activate the stream

Given that text/code is what is being viewed, lower res and adaptive streaming (HLS) are not really viable solutions since they become unreadable at lower res.

If remote screen sharing is a core feature of the service, I think this is a reasonable next step for the product.

That said, IMO at a higher level if you know what you're streaming is human-readable text, it's better to send application data pipes to the stream rather than encoding screenspace videos. That does however require building bespoke decoders and client viewing if real time collaboration network clients don't already exist for the tools (but SSH and RTC code editors exist)

keerthiko··on Show HN: Marvin, your own AI-powered game studio
I just wanted to preview one of the games. It requires me to "Claim a wallet" or "Create a wallet". I don't want to do those things, I just want to preview a game to see how it looks/feels. There is no "What is a wallet?" help. You don't mention this concept in your post either, or have functional TOS/FAQ that might answer this.

What am I looking at?

keerthiko··on Netherlands – Capital Growth Tax and Capital Gains Tax for Box 3
as worded is this tax not levied on any entity holding assets that can appreciate in value (businesses can hold stock too)?
keerthiko··on Dark Pattern Games
The premise of this site seems to be that anything designed to make the game "addictive" is a dark pattern — this is contradictory to the concept of "dark pattern" in products in general, which I would define as "when an interface biases users towards action that is more in the interest of the business controlling the interface than the user's goals for using the software."

When someone plays a game, the user's goal could be expected as "having fun for as much time as they want to." Being addictive is usually in service of that. A "slightly dark" pattern would be combining core addictive gameplay junctures with microtransactions (retry/next level/upgrade) — but in this economy this just feels like a basic mobile game business model. A moderately darker pattern would be making the game increasingly frustrating while still addictive, unless you perform a microtxn (eg: increasing difficulty exponentially, and charging money for more lives/retries or forcing more ads).

A "true dark pattern" would be sneaking things like push notification permissions, tracking permissions, recurring subscription agreements, etc. under an interface that looks similar to something the user doesn't read carefully and tries to get past out of habit, such as an interstitial ad with a "skip" button — but with a below-the-fold toggle button defaulted to "agree" and a "Confirm" button styled to look like the "skip" button at first glance.

keerthiko··on GrapheneOS and forensic extraction of data (2024)
most of the explanation from the horse's mouth will be found here:

https://grapheneos.org/faq#device-support

keerthiko··on New Mexico is first state in US to offer universal child care
From the article:

> This groundbreaking new initiative will make child care available to all New Mexicans, regardless of income, by removing income eligibility requirements from the state’s child care assistance program

What you are referring to is the progress they made prior to this news.

keerthiko··on Show HN: I built an app to block Shorts and Reels
You should never expect to have rights to anyone's server API endpoints, esp outside of their TOS, which is basically what trying to build your own front-end independent of youtube.com is. However, with most browsers, you have all the rights to build extensions that hide divs and change styling and add new elements with data that's already loaded (as long as you're not calling API endpoints that aren't called by the site's source though, you run into the same problems again) which would accomplish everything you were trying to do.
keerthiko··on Are We Creating Entrepreneurs or Just Privileged Risk-Takers?
People can have writing tics, i know i do — that said, this article does read very much like a scrape-n-translate + some "summarized insights" of Chinese forum threads. While that's fully within the scope of a human blogger, it is very much in the wheelhouse of a modern LLM.

More telling rather than any specific lines or phrases, to me, is that the tone gives off a strong "i don't have a single strong feeling about this topic, i'm just transcribing others' opinions and vaguely coming up with a C2A" vibe — no human who'd bother to write a personal-opinions blog would realistically channel that energy into an 850-word essay without LLMs doing all the drudgery.

keerthiko··on You know more Finnish than you think
IMO the hardest parts of learning a new language as an adult is

a) convincing yourself its worth the effort: almost every time an adult runs into a confusing element of a new language, they find themselves calculating how many people in the world speak this language, probability they don't speak english and likelihood of running into this person and circumstance, and it's easy to justify giving up and moving on

b) avoiding forcing it into the framework of your first language: if you have one distinctly favored language already, it's very hard not to try shove the new language you are learning into the former's mold, and this can be counterproductive in learning most languages that don't share an ancestor with your favored one.

a) is greatly mitigated by forcing yourself to be in said context by living in a place prioritizing that language. b) is greatly mitigated by already being bilingual+ with languages from distinct origins (eg: mandarin chinese and english) before learning a new one, so you can place the new language on a spectrum with the ones you already know instead of confined by the rules of just one.

keerthiko··on How I use Claude Code to implement new features in an existing complex codebase
to be fair, the linked youtube video from the article is literally 4 weeks old, so "at least a month in the past" is probably exactly accurate if you are moving at the same pace as the author.
keerthiko··on Vibe code is legacy code
Likely still cheaper than whatever these competitors have spent building their product and then hiring blackhat saboteurs.
keerthiko··on Measuring the impact of AI on experienced open-source developer productivity
IME AI coding is excellent for one-off scripts, personal automation tooling (I iterate on a tool to scrape receipts and submit expenses for my specific needs) and generally stuff that can be run in environments where the creator and the end user are effectively the same (and only) entity.

Scaled up slightly, we use it to build plenty of internal tooling in our video content production pipeline (syncing between encoding tools and a status dashboard for our non-technical content team).

Using it for anything more than boilerplate code, well-defined but tedious refactors, or quickly demonstrating how to use an unfamiliar API in production code, before a human takes a full pass at everything is something I'm going to be wary of for a long time.

keerthiko··on There are no new ideas in AI only new datasets
fair, and I edited my choice of words, but if you're reading that much aggression from my initial comment (which contains topical discussion) to say what you did, you must find the internet a far more savage place than it really is :/
keerthiko··on There are no new ideas in AI, only new datasets
When LLM's come up with answers to questions that aren't directly exampled in the training data, that's not proof at all that it reasoned its way there — it can very much still be pattern matching without insight from the actual code execution of the answer generation.

If we were taking a walk and you asked me for an explanation for a mathematical concept I have not actually studied, I am fully capable of hazarding a casual guess based on the other topics I have studied within seconds. This is the default approach of an LLM, except with much greater breadth and recall of studied topics than I, as a human, have.

This would be very different than if we sat down at a library and I applied the various concepts and theorems I already knew to make inferences, built upon them, and then derived an understanding based on reasoning of the steps I took (often after backtracking from several reasoning dead ends) before providing the explanation.

If you ask an LLM to explain their reasoning, it's unclear whether it just guessed the explanation and reasoning too, or if that was actually the set of steps it took to get to the first answer they gave you. This is why LLMs are able to correct themselves after claiming strawberry has 2 rs, but when providing (guessing again) their explanations they make more "relevant" guesses.

keerthiko··on There are no new ideas in AI, only new datasets
> generating a video under prompt constraints is basically playing a game

Besides static puzzles (like a maze or jigsaw) I don't believe this analogy holds? A model working with prompt constraints that aren't evolving or being added over the course of "navigating" the generation of the model's output means it needs to process 0 new information that it didn't come up with itself — playing a game is different from other generation because it's primarily about reacting to input you didn't know the precise timing/spatial details of, but can learn that they come within a known set of higher order rules. Obviously the more finite/deterministic/predictably probabilistic the video game's solution space, the more it can be inferred from the initial state, aka reduce to the same type of problem as generating a video from a prompt), which is why models are still able to play video games. But as GP pointed out, transfer function negative in such cases — the overarching rules are not predictable enough across disparate genres.

> I think you could prompt veo3 to play any game for a few seconds

I'm curious what your threshold for what constitutes "play any game" is in this claim? If I wrote a script that maps button combinations to average pixel color of a portion of the screen buffer, by what metric(s) would veo3 be "playing" the game more or better than that script "for a few seconds"?

edit: removing knee-jerk reaction language

keerthiko··on Man 'refused entry into US' as border control catch him with bald JD Vance meme
from the article:

> "They threatened me with a minimum fine of $5,000 or five years in prison if I refused to provide the password to my phone."

this isn't real/legal/enforceable (as the law currently stands) is it? how does one protect ourselves against this turn of events upon entry when the immigration officer's claim fails the smell test?

keerthiko··on My iPhone 8 Refuses to Die: Now It's a Solar-Powered Vision OCR Server
I'm pretty sure in a free market, how much someone is willing to pay for something is what determines how much a company charges for something, not how much it cost to provide. We wouldn't have inflation of most goods/services if it was based on how much it cost to produce/provide.
keerthiko··on Show HN: Patio – Rent tools, learn DIY, reduce waste
I used to live in Berkeley, CA circa 2013. They had a tool library, which was part of the local public library system, and tools were free (!) to rent. I miss it everyday, as it was a godsend for broke new grads who still wanted to do some quick but heavyduty DIY.

I now live in NYC, and my local Home Depot rents out power tools for $20-30/day. The typical tool would pay for itself in 2 days at these rates, but it's still worth it to me as these 2 days are often 2-3 years apart and I'd rather not store these tools in my cramped 1BR.

What I would love is a community-run tool rental service where we can donate a tool + pay a nominal membership fee, and borrow tools for free. I am happy to donate a $120 circular saw/impact driver if I can rent 10x different tools once each for $5/mo for the next year. The closest thing I have now is my local hackerspace, which is great, but I often have to work on my projects at the space, which limits the kind of home DIY I can do.

keerthiko··on A flat pricing subscription for Claude Code
i got $100 of credit at the start of the year, and have been using +1$ each month, starting at $2 in january using aider at the time. just switched to claude code this week, since it follows a similar UX. agentic CLI code assist really has been growing in usefulness for me as i get faster at reviewing its output.

i use it for very targeted operations where it saves me several roundtrips to code examples and documentation and stack overflow, not spamming it for every task i need to do, i spend about $1/day of focused feature development, and it feels like it saves me about 50% as many hours as i spend coding while using it.

keerthiko··on Open source Google Analytics replacement
If the IP address is hashed somehow it would no longer be personally identifying while still being unique enough for analytics purposes, correct?

Does geographic grouping data depend on the IP address? If so I suppose it would need to be extracted first before hashing the IP, and I wonder how much that weakens the anonymization.

keerthiko··on Careless People
this is a very good point, and a blind spot in my comment because IME people who left the small pond in the first place were dissatisfied and unfulfilled there.

it is absolutely possible that after experiencing the bigger pond, people can develop purpose in their "original" pond based on values like community and relationships, or even simply dislike the vibes in bigger ponds and want to undo as much as they can. this is a super valuable thing to society and humanity for the most part, as perhaps more change can happen this way than big things happening in big places.

personally i struggle with this, because whenever i re-enter a smaller ecosystem (including/such as the one i grew up around) i feel like everyone has a distorted view of the bigger pond and self-limit themselves, which is a contagious energy i can't stand.

keerthiko··on America's reputation drops across the world
yep (zen). same on arc/chrome
keerthiko··on Careless People
in my experience, people who grow up as the biggest fish in a small pond (whether concerning just fields they care about, or in general) are always 99% of the time, one of these two when they end up a middling fish in the big pond: like you, happy to find peers and inspiring exemplars to collaborate with and learn from, or those who hate that they are not the best anymore.

the former group probably leads the healthiest & happiest life fulfillment while pursuing their interests — i'm heavily biased though because i too fall into this category and am proud of this trait.

the latter group consists of people who either spin their wheels real hard and more often than not burn out in their pursuit of being the best, or pivot hard into something else they think they can be the best at (often repeatedly every time they encounter stronger competition) like gates & co, or in rare cases succeed in being the best even in the more competitive environment.

this last .001% are probably people whose egos get so boosted from the positive reinforcement that they become "overcompetitive" and domineering like zuck or elon, and let their egos control their power and resources to suppress competition rather than compete "fairly" ever again.

i think there's a subset of people from both main groups that may move from one into the other based on life experiences, luck, influence of people close to them, maturity, therapy, or simply wanting something different from life after a certain point. i don't have a good model for whether this is most people, or a tiny percentage.

keerthiko··on A look at Firefox forks
they have a ko-fi and a patreon, with about a 1000 "subscribers" across both at <unknown> amounts at the moment. it's not exactly enough to promise indefinite support, but tbh i don't really much reason to have that faith from products i've paid for but are closed-source either.
keerthiko··on I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
That is a pre-indicated stipulation of the green card validity, not revocation based on the whim of an evaluating (non-immigration judicial) official -- ie CBP and DHS and ICE cannot (read: should not be able to) revoke green cards.

The "basic US presence" requirement of green cards has always been present in the validity clause alongside the 5-10year expiry date, and not committing immigration fraud and other basic requirements to maintain green card -- a comical number of European green card holders gloss over/forget this clause every year, that is made explicit to them upon receiving the card and proceed to forfeit their green cards by not entering the US for over a year -- that is not a revocation (implies a subjective decision made by an official), it is a lapse of validity (implies some pre-stated condition was fulfilled).

← PreviousPage 2 of 23Next →