HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

keithwhor

3,884 karma · joined March 14, 2013

hacker. canadian in sf. oss = <3. learning to be a CEO, one mistake at a time.

building Superuser, come join :)

https://superuser.app

https://x.com/keithwhor

submissionscomments
keithwhor··on Photorealistic Monocular 3D Reconstruction of Humans Wearing Clothing
I'd love to see indie game developers use these tools in combination with DALL-E to recreate the style of the PlayStation-era Final Fantasy games. 3d characters in 2d pre-rendered worlds. Presumably with the right tooling -- creating imagined geometry in DALL-E and generating boundaries programmatically or by hand, character models from friends / cosplayers found via craigslist and open animation sets -- you'd be able to generate a game of Final Fantasy VIII's caliber with team as small as a lone developer in only a few years, maybe shorter.
keithwhor··on The Dunning-Kruger Effect Is Autocorrelation
Taken at face value, what the DK data shows without autocorrelation is that more skilled people are, in fact, better at evaluating themselves than unskilled people. The correlation is positive. It's only when you introduce the difference in score vs. assessment (autocorrelation) that the correlation appears negative ("skilled people evaluate themselves as less skilled than they are").
keithwhor··on Heresy
Simply categorizing human beings as conventional vs unconventional and passive vs aggressive, and then establishing an enemy in one quadrant is an example. Unconventional people are the victims, aggressively conventional people are the others.

I think the thing Paul really has a problem with is social brigading and mobs attacking people unfairly. Which is fine; but you can make that argument without painting yourself or people like you as a victim. Otherwise you’re just using the same tactic mobs use.

We’re all guilty of this to different degrees because social media algorithms are finely-tuned to propagate outrage and we’re being conditioned to respond to and generate said outrage. I think the way out of the loop is to recognize this pattern and try to break it.

keithwhor··on Heresy
Aha. Great observation; what you interpret as anti-collectivist / pro-individualist I interpret as misanthropic.

Admittedly this is probably cultural on my part; growing up in a working class Canadian family bestows different social ideologies. It’s a complaint I have about Canadian culture (not individualistic enough) but I do think a problem with American discourse is it can err so far on the side of individualism as to become misanthropic: the extreme being the sentiment, “I, and people like me, are the only group that matters.”

That’s not what Paul is saying here at all. I just think discourse about “social heresy” might be more productively framed as — what do we all agree on, how can we focus on channeling that energy productively, and how can we accommodate the people who disagree? Generally speaking capitalism can be a force for good here if you pick big, juicy problems everyone is excited to solve. Climate, energy, etc. And I think Paul is funding some of those companies!

keithwhor··on Heresy
The biggest problem I have with Paul’s writing on these topics is the misanthropic undertones. The classification of folks as “conventional minded” mirrors other socially reductive language like referring to people as “simps,” “NPCs,” and more. Paul believes he is partly responsible for engaging a social immune response to the intolerance he perceives — forgetting that immune responses are inflammatory by nature and often destroy large amounts of healthy tissue and in some cases, entire organisms.

I don’t think his assertions are wrong but I don’t think castigating people as “aggressively conventional minded” is the right approach. In creating an us-vs-them mentality I think Paul may inadvertently be adding to the actual biggest problem in civilized discourse these days — weaponized victimization and othering. It’s not enough to have an opinion, there has to be a bad guy or an evil group of people intent on destroying society.

I’m not sure how to solve this problem — open to suggestions and brainstorming, it’s just something that’s been on my mind a lot recently.

keithwhor··on Elon Musk to join Twitter’s board of directors
Depends on how much the rest of the board really feels like arguing with Elon. Keep in mind these people have jobs outside of Twitter.

https://investor.twitterinc.com/corporate-governance/board-o...

keithwhor··on Ask HN: Should I give up and get a job?
You can totally build first. Developers always do. The problem is you have to sell at some point, if it's not customers to begin with then it has to be investors, but invariably you will be selling to customers. Products do not sell or market themselves.
keithwhor··on I was deceived about Covid vaccine safety
What I don't like about posts like these is they "infect" those serially susceptible to misinformation that refuse to look at statistics and raw data. So I did it for y'all.

First, Moderna and Pfizer vaccines are correlated with myocarditis risk [0]. Pfizer at 1 in 71,400 and Moderna at 1 in 23,800.

Alright - maybe scary to a few folks, right? Nobody wants an inflamed heart. Well before we dig in there, let's look at weekly COVID case rates for vaccinated vs. unvaccinated using December 4th, 2021 data from the CDC [1]. There were 1,006.39 / 100k cases of COVID that week in unvaccinated individuals and 443.69 / 100k in vaccinated individuals. This is including the most recent Omicron wave (which you can see in the data). Meaning you have a 2.27x higher chance of being diagnosed with COVID if you're unvaccinated.

Okay, so there's some protection - but clearly not 100%! The biggest concern we have is side effects, right? Because if risk of vaccine side effects outweigh the benefit to vaccination, then we shouldn't be vaccinating people. I think everybody can agree on that. So we'll want to look at death rate data... but first, let's tackle myocarditis.

Myocarditis has an occurrence rate of 1 in 23,800 post-Moderna vaccination. We can normalize that to 4.20 / 100k. However, did you know that myocarditis is actually a long-term symptom of COVID infection? So if you don't get vaccinated and get COVID, you're risking myocarditis anyway. But what's the rate of myocarditis post-COVID infection?

Turns out it's a staggering 150.00 / 100k, about 35.7x the risk of myocarditis after vaccination [2]! If you get vaccinated, you decrease your risk of contracting covid by about 56%. Which means you could still get myocarditis post-infection; but that risk is more than halved. Your risk of getting myocarditis, even if vaccinated, overwhelmingly comes from the risk from COVID itself causing it.

There's an argument to be made that maybe you just won't catch COVID at all. Factoring this in takes a lot of work; you can be re-infected, there are new strains emerging constantly. There were estimates that at the end of 2020 up to 1 in 3 Americans had been infected at least once [3]. It's very likely we're looking at a virus that has completely permeated the human biosphere. You can protect against, you can't avoid.

Okay: so where we're at is, myocarditis risk? Way higher by simply getting COVID. But that's just myocarditis! What about other post-COVID symptoms? Well, the worst is the terminal symptom: death. Relying on our CDC data from December 4th, 2021 [1] we can see that the weekly death rate for unvaccinated was 9.20 / 100k and the weekly death rate for vaccinated was 0.47 / 100k. Meaning you have a 19.57x higher chance of death from contracting COVID if you're unvaccinated. Also; your chance of dying from COVID if you're unvaccinated is literally 2.19x higher than getting myocarditis from getting vaccinated! I should also note that most bouts of myocarditis are minor and symptoms resolve without issue.

So that's where we're at. The numbers are here for anybody to look into and research themselves. These aren't anecdotes; they're hard data.

Vaccines work. There's more I have to say on the subject... like I'm excited about the next decade of biomedical research as a result of increase productive capacity of biomedical reagents due to the pandemic -- but this post is long enough.

[0] https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/...

[1] https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#rates-by-vaccine-s...

[2] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7035e5.htm?fbclid=I...

[3] https://www.publichealth.columbia.edu/public-health-now/news...

keithwhor··on Crypto enthusiasts want to buy an NBA team, after not purchasing US Constitution
How can you be sure this isn’t wash-trading organized by the largest owners so they can attempt to profit at the expense of individual retail investors?
keithwhor··on Friend Groups
I don't think there's anything more rewarding than building things with people you care about and are invested in the success of. Wins are amplified, losses are overcome more readily, there's a level of trust that extends beyond the bounds of immediate economic needs and into the iterated game.
keithwhor··on This word does not exist
I actually got a real word, albeit with an incorrect definition.

    adjective.
    nonexclusionary
    nonex·clu·sion·ary
    of or concerning people or organizations that don't receive due respect
    "nonexclusionary criticism of religion"
    a word that does not exist; it was invented, defined and used by a machine learning algorithm.
keithwhor··on Genetic Evolution Was a Prelude to Mimetic Evolution
I think you may have just inadvertently invented the concept of Meme drive [0].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene_drive

keithwhor··on About that time I had an outburst during the Y Combinator Interview
The armchair quarterbacking in this thread is ridiculous. This was a great, and really human, take on pitching that 99.99% of founders miss. Pitching VCs (or YC) is only ostensibly about raising financing. Pitching is about refining your idea, identifying problem / solution pairs and subsets (or supersets!) of your primary pitch you haven't considered, building relationships and a whole lot more.

That fact that Michael Seibel is responding to folks in this thread who are doing the quarterbacking speaks volumes to the success of this founder's pitch in spite of not receiving an invitation to YC this go-around. First, a rejection today is not a rejection tomorrow. Second, Michael is a busy guy. The fact he's taking the time to speak up for a founder he feels a connection with is perhaps worth more long-term than a single YC acceptance letter. There are YC-backed founders that never get that level of attention.

keithwhor··on Dear Mom, I'm Dropping Out
An undergraduate degree won't teach you to be a good engineer any more than it will teach you to be a good executive, or dentist, or doctor. It's why Waterloo's co-op program is almost universally regarded as the best training in the industry. I'm not surprised working in the industry expedited your growth as an engineer and it's a shame more schools don't adopt Waterloo's model. I have plenty of complaints about academia in general, but that's for a different thread. :)

The argument here is primarily that college is a unique experience that you don't really get to go back to and, in this specific case, the investment remaining is minimal. I can wax poetic about socialization and being young and a whole load of other things, but college is really just what you make of it. It is entirely within somebody's power to make their last remaining year of college enjoyable in the same way they have the capacity to make their first year in the workforce enjoyable.

Simon can do whatever he likes. The wonderful thing about his situation is that there are no bad options. That's when decisions are truly difficult, when you're maximizing EV between things that have unpredictable upside. I'd say -- from a pure EV perspective -- the downside of not having a degree (likely permanent) exceeds the upside of starting in the work force 8mo early (job offer effectively fungible, just have to wait 8mo). The scenario in which this would flip would be if the upside was an order of magnitude or more larger; like double-digit early equity in a promising company with traction that's starting YC.

keithwhor··on Dear Mom, I'm Dropping Out
There are a lot of comments here that echo my sentiment.

Simon, I am a Canadian founder. I got my first job offer in the US (San Francisco) at 25 years old. I took it right away. It was not FAANG, though I was interviewed there many times: not once was I given an offer. My degree was in Biochemistry, not CS. I probably would have been over the moon to get an offer from FB. So I can understand how you feel.

However; I think you should consider finishing your degree. The job offer from Facebook will always be around -- or some equivalent. If you can get that at 20/21 you can get it at 21/22. The only time where I'd recommend somebody drop out is if they're committed to a project that is either clearly a business or has the potential to be one and they're pursuing entrepreneurship. I know a number of founders that have pursued this route and are quite successful. That said; college is really a once-in-a-lifetime experience. I wouldn't trade my time in college for anything, even though coming to Silicon Valley at 25 years old made me feel ancient. If you focus your last year on personal growth, hacking, friends, your network, building relationships - both at McGill and around Silicon Valley - you'll be even more set up to succeed post-graduation.

Re: the FB offer. The ugly truth you're glossing over is that working at FAANG can -- for many -- ultimately be just as boring as coursework in college. If you want to get into startups and like the energy surrounding them, my recommendation is use your last year of college to (1) kick college's ass and get that degree so immigration is easier and (2) start a badass side project.

That's my $0.02 but YMMV. Shoot me a DM on Twitter if you feel like chatting.

keithwhor··on Don’t Let Architecture Astronauts Scare You (2001)
joel nailed it, xml was clearly peak internet
keithwhor··on GitHub’s engineering team has moved to Codespaces
The same thing was said about every programming abstraction to ever be introduced. How do we expect people to build memory-efficient applications when they become reliant on a garbage collector?
keithwhor··on Warning Signals for Collapse of The Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation
This is a pretty interesting take. Sort of an, "accelerate every country through their inevitable industrialization and all that comes with it so we can help them get past it faster."

I wonder how much of the US defense budget could be deployed to providing nuclear power to newly industrializing countries and what the long-term ROI would be re; staving off future climate refugee issues.

keithwhor··on A Contamination Theory of the Obesity Epidemic
Yeah I agree with you, that's what I was saying, I feel the same way about LotR. First book was a snooze and couldn't finish the rest.
keithwhor··on A Contamination Theory of the Obesity Epidemic
Ha -- I made another post summarizing the contents of this paper, but read another poster suggesting that it could be correlated with cigarettes, as nicotine is an appetite suppressant.

The authors of this paper suggest that the obesity trend started ramping up in the 70s - 80s and has continued unabated.

Sure enough, this is directly negatively correlated with tobacco consumption per capita.

https://cancercontrol.cancer.gov/sites/default/files/2020-06...

I'm surprised the authors didn't touch on this -- it's a really thorough research paper. I have to imagine that nicotine consumption (or lack thereof) is directly correlated with obesity considering it's both a neurochemical (something the authors were suggesting as a contaminant), we know it affects appetite (it's a stimulant), and those most prone to smoking are also most prone to obesity (remove cigarettes = more food intake).

keithwhor··on A Contamination Theory of the Obesity Epidemic
I only read the first chapter of LotR and I don't understand what the big deal is. Hobbiton is a pretty shitty place to stage an adventure novel, seems boring.
keithwhor··on A Contamination Theory of the Obesity Epidemic
This is a really neat and well-researched paper.

If you're looking for the summary, the most likely contaminants contributing to the obesity epidemic as identified by the authors are: (1) antibiotics in livestock that accumulate in both food and water supplies, (2) Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) which are ubiquitous and hard to destroy and (3) Lithium in the water supply.

The authors paint a convincing picture of why the obesity epidemic almost certainly is a result of environmental contaminants. This includes, but is not limited to (weakest to strongest, IMO);

- The research on modern diets showing they're most ineffectual

- Animals are getting predictably fatter at the same rates as humans in urban areas, and this is increasing

- The concept of lipostasis: human bodies having a set point of fat storage and the research around it

- Historically population BMI grew very slowly, starting at around 23, to suddenly ramp up unabated around the 1970s-80s

- Areas further away from primary watersheds (where water can pick up more contaminants) tend to have higher population BMIs as a function of distance traveled from watershed

- Lithium production was basically nonexistent until the 50s and spiked in the 70s-80s

- Lithium is directly correlated with weight gain (primary research provided) and areas with water testing higher in Lithium have higher population BMIs

... and a lot more. It's worth a read. I think anybody that's overweight should still index heavily on diet and exercise (even if there's a contaminant, it seems unavoidable), but it's interesting.

keithwhor··on A bug's life: Millimeter-tall mountains on neutron stars
> Neutron stars are some of the densest objects in the Universe: they weigh about as much as the Sun, yet measure only around 10km across, similar in size to a large city.

I'm going to be the Hacker News pedant here and say that this sentence bugged me. Weight is a measurement of force. Mass is the word they were looking for.

keithwhor··on Asymmetries in Fundraising
I think this is a good article.

I also think generalized fundraising advice mostly sucks. You're looking for a believer in you and your company. That's it. If you're lucky enough to find many believers in parallel you can use that to your advantage - this is where you can leverage asymmetries - but I think that's the exception to the rule, not the rule itself.

I treat fundraising like playing Final Fantasy VI. There are many paths towards defeating Kefka and many possible teams you can assemble. But the game isn't open-ended; most characters are NPCs, and there's a pre-defined single win state (defeat Kefka, build a big business) and loss state (you teams runs out of HP, your company folds). Finding investors is like recruiting Terra, Sabin, Mog, you name it.

In FFVI, you can typically tell who the PCs (Player Characters) are by distinctive sprite features and behaviors. NPCs walk around in circles. PCs engage dynamically, offer to help you, appear in short bursts, then disappear mysteriously for long stretches of time, only to return when you need them most. You may not recruit them when you first find them. You may forget about them entirely. You may miss them on your current playthrough. But it's obvious who they are.

Raising capital is kinda like that. You can figure out who the NPC investors are pretty easily - especially if you've spoken to a lot of investors. They might re-engage a lot but they obviously follow a script. They're not passionate about you or your business. They might have a large following or any number of PC characteristics, but the "tell", the equivalent to a unique sprite, is how they mesh and interact with you as a person. Note that some NPCs in FFVI and other games are scripted to bloviate and tell you how amazing you are. So simply telling you nice things is not an indicator of a PC. Actions speak much, much louder than words.

I'd say that fundraising is mostly about learning to discern NPCs from PCs and not wasting your time on the NPCs that don't move the story forward. And having the stamina to stick to it and acknowledge the PCs do exist and are out there. That's all there is to it. It takes a long time to find PCs and not all are accessible immediately, but I have the sense that when you find them you kinda just know who they are.

My advice to founders is when you find people you want to work with, just let them know and be kind. Be pushy. But be kind. The NPCs will get caught in a script, in a loop, they'll just keep doing and saying the same things over and over. They don't really know they're the NPCs in your business yet, because they're PCs in many other businesses. You'll figure it out sooner than they will. The PCs in your business will actively adapt to you, your business, your fundraise even if they don't join today. There'll be a fun backstory. You'll watch it happen organically.

Then again - this is generalized fundraising advice, so it also must kinda suck. Make of it what you'd like.

keithwhor··on Carbon dioxide peaks near 420 parts per million at Mauna Loa observatory
It terrifies me that we're asphyxiating ourselves and increased CO2 can seriously impair human cognition. At a global, population-level scale this is almost certainly statistically significant and it scares me that we could quite literally stupefy ourselves to the point of no return. We need to find solutions now before we're unable to stop ourselves from drowning in our own atmosphere.

[0] https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/201...

keithwhor··on How I raised a $5.1M seed as a first-time, female, solo founder for a biotech co
> “Yeah none of the partners here have a dog and [X head partner] actually really hates dogs”

Please, please, please name this firm. For the good of all founders.

keithwhor··on 50B birds live on Earth, new study finds
Imagine the joy that exists in nature at any given moment. Billions and trillions of creatures in various states of ecstasy, happiness, and contentment. Then multiply all those experiences for every time frame back to the first organisms.

I don't think people think about the implications of a billion years of the vast experiences life has to offer.

keithwhor··on Time flies in Google Earth’s biggest update in years
What's really striking to me about timelapse videos of the Earth is how, at a grand enough scale, the growth of human settlements on Earth really looks no different than the growth of bacterial and fungal colonies on Petri dishes.

We think of ourself as special, as having conquered environments, technology and more - and when zoomed out you could explain everything we've built and accomplished as the achievements of a sufficiently robust slime mold simply using available resources to continue growing.

keithwhor··on Eu_sst: 20% probability for large satellite collision
For anybody interested, they missed:

https://www.n2yo.com/?s=12443|10820

(Link further in thread.)

keithwhor··on Loss of myelin is one of the major factors of age-related brain deterioration
Out of curiosity, was it Parvovirus? Somebody I knew dealt with a bout recently and I never realized how common it was.
← PreviousPage 4 of 20Next →