HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kelnage

577 karma · joined May 21, 2009

submissionscomments
kelnage··on Android overtakes Windows as the internet’s most used operating system
I think this is part of the problem. I see a lot of hate thrown at Windows 10 for the automatic shutdown to install updates - and some of that is due to bad design choices by MS - but many seem to hate the idea of updates being automatically installed at all. They say they'd prefer to be insecure rather than be inconvenienced.
kelnage··on WikiLeaks Releases Trove of Alleged C.I.A. Hacking Documents
Agreed 100% - but methinks NYT (and others) still look to them for technical guidance on some matters - however misguided that might be.
kelnage··on WikiLeaks Releases Trove of Alleged C.I.A. Hacking Documents
Unfortunately, this is a line that Wikileaks themselves are running with: https://twitter.com/wikileaks/status/839120909625606152
kelnage··on Gmail – some users being signed out of their accounts unexpectedly
I would imagine that was because the comments are intended for discussion about that particular issue, not for random users to jump in with wild conjecture on its impacts. Honestly not that strange.
kelnage··on Gmail – some users being signed out of their accounts unexpectedly
Happened to me with a Gmail.com account and 2FA enabled. Checked Google's security log and everything seemed normal.
kelnage··on Show HN: A guide to all HTML5 elements and attributes
The website's CSS uses the following fonts for code blocks:

> "Inconsolata", "Source Code Pro", "Consolas", "Monaco", "Courier", monospace

So either it is using one of those fonts (Courier and Nimbus Mono L are similar I guess), the site is serving you special CSS that I'm not getting (and I've tested it on Linux and Windows), or Firefox has done some weird font aliasing and one of the above is being treated as Nimbus Mono L.

kelnage··on Show HN: A guide to all HTML5 elements and attributes
On the font issue: you're effectively saying "I don't like the default monospace font my browser is configured to use, please change your website to fix this" (since Nimbus Mono isn't in their CSS font family list). I feel you as a user have some responsibility in that case.
kelnage··on Introducing Keybase Chat
I can believe that is the case, but that just moves the attack vector to within Keybase's network, it doesn't mitigate it completely.
kelnage··on Introducing Keybase Chat
I'm entirely unconvinced by your argument regarding backing up a perfect forward secrecy chat. PFS is about preventing any listener of the messages in-transit from ever effectively decrypting those messages - it says nothing about security guarantees once the message is received.

It'd be like arguing that by enabling PFS also creates a social contract that the receiver guarantees that their device isn't compromised. Or that webservers that use PFS in TLS don't log most/all of the details for the requests they receive. I don't believe either of these to be true.

You seem to have extrapolated some social properties from a purely technical property and assumed everyone must think about it in the same way as you. But in doing so, you've made your protocol weaker against realistic attacks.

Oh, and the likelihood of an attacker stealing a device with WhatsApp installed and only being able to extract the identity keys and not the cached messages seems absurdly improbable.

Personally, I wish you'd either tried to work with OWS/WhatsApp/whoever to integrate in what makes keybase.io great (providing identity verification - something that all these could use) and not gone about adding to the already crowded area of chat providers.

kelnage··on The Number of Older Student Loan Borrowers Is Rising
Nothing - under the current rules the Government writes off the debt after a number of years (either when you turn 65, after 25, 30 or 35 years, depending on when you got the loan and where in the UK you went to Uni). Also, having a student loan has little to no effect on obtaining bank loans or mortgages.
kelnage··on Harvard research suggests an entire generation has lost faith in democracy
Well, consider the recent attempted coup in Turkey. The Western media definitely has portrayed the military in a sympathetic light and the Government/Erdogan less so. Not saying that's right or wrong - but it implies to me that not everyone will see these issues as black or white.
kelnage··on Goldman Sachs Drops Out of R3 Blockchain Group
I agree that the current systems are very far from optimised. But what benefit does the blockchain per se give them, given they already trust all participants? It only seems to introduce unnecessary costs, such as mining, when compared to the alternatives.
kelnage··on PayPal 2FA Bypass
Or they designed it to show a variable number of security questions (so management could come along and say "we need 4 questions now" without causing havoc). Then they'd iterate through the responses, verifying them against the appropriate question. Simply forgetting to enforce that the number of questions asked has to equal the number of responses sent would cause the described vulnerability.
kelnage··on European court says linking to illegal content is copyright infringement
I think you've misunderstood - Google, I am sure, is aware that it probably links to illegal content. But it has no way of knowing what is illegal or not - so it would not meet those conditions. It's a completely different situation to the case in question.
kelnage··on European court says linking to illegal content is copyright infringement
How do search engines meet requirement 2 (knowingly linking to illegal content)?
kelnage··on Is HTTP Public Key Pinning Dead?
The problem is if you dull HPKP, you potentially weaken the benefit that the really high-profile targets gain and therefore make it less useful for them.

Perhaps the answer is only a small number of websites actually need/want this functionality - and that's okay? Simply dulling it to broaden take-up may have a net negative affect.

kelnage··on Play along with NSA: The RAFTER unintentional radio emissions how-to
Does that balance the rights of the 5% who don't watch live TV but have license officers peering through their windows or (potentially) using detector vans to look through their walls to see what they're watching?

I agree neither are perfect (or maybe even good) solutions, but it's still a trade off somehow.

kelnage··on Play along with NSA: The RAFTER unintentional radio emissions how-to
On not needing a license if you have a TV but don't watch TV: that's exactly what I said.

I disagree with your second point. I have not had a TV license for 4+ years now, even though I own several devices capable of receiving TV broadcasts. Every two years the TV licensing people get in touch and check that I still don't need a TV license. Very smooth, no issues.

I'd be very interested if you could show me the part of the law where they assume guilt. Since it is a criminal conviction, the usual standard is they'd need to have evidence "beyond reasonable doubt".

kelnage··on Play along with NSA: The RAFTER unintentional radio emissions how-to
Taken from [1], under the heading "Will I need a TV Licence for all on demand programmes?".

You won't need a licence to:

(1) Download or watch S4C TV on demand on BBC iPlayer or listen to radio on BBC iPlayer.

(2) Download or watch programmes on demand from other providers, such as:

* ITV Hub, All 4 or Demand 5

* BT Vision, Virgin Media or Sky Go

* Netflix or Now TV

* Apple, Roku or Amazon

[1] http://www.tvlicensing.co.uk/check-if-you-need-one/topics/bb...

kelnage··on Play along with NSA: The RAFTER unintentional radio emissions how-to
You're wrong about when you have to pay the TV license. Currently the law states that you have to pay if you watch any streamed live TV (regardless of whether it is from the BBC, Sky or another TV provider). Having equipment capable of watching live TV does not automatically incur the license fee.

The law is changing in September, such that you will also be required to pay it if you use iPlayer - however, just having a system that can use iPlayer does not mean you have to pay it - it will be payable only if you use it to watch either live or catch-up TV on iPlayer (other catch-up applications such as ITV's or Channel 5's are not included in this). For some reason, the BBC has decided that either adding a login system or monitoring IP addresses that connect to iPlayer is not the way to go and their official line is that they will continue to monitor usage in the same way as they currently do.

There are many long arguments about whether the TV license vans even exist or if they use radio emissions from devices to monitor what you're watching - some contend that flat screen TVs do not produce sufficient emissions, but there is research that says otherwise.

kelnage··on UTF-8 Everywhere (2012)
No, I don't think that example does imply that. I interpret it as meaning that for the variants of the same "base word" (i.e. all characters are unaccented) the ordering is defined by the positions of the accents rather than their respective orderings. It says nothing about two words that have different lengths or bases.
kelnage··on Investigatory Powers Bill passes through Commons after Labour backs Tory spy law
The SNP did vote against IPB, but they only have 54 MPs, compared to the ~550 combined MPs of Labour and the Conservatives. Anything those two parties widely support will get through the parliament.
kelnage··on Investigatory Powers Bill passes through Commons after Labour backs Tory spy law
Really? They were clearly the smaller of the two parties and I feel the fact they got anything changed is frankly impressive.

Compared to what the current Conservative government is doing, I feel the Lib Dems did a pretty good job of tempering their ambitions, without bringing the entire system to a standstill (which I do not believe for a second to be a good idea).

kelnage··on Bitcoin 'creator' backs out of Satoshi coin move 'proof'
Except they were also working off the assurances of two major Bitcoin "nerds". Why not blame them too?
kelnage··on Hey Apple, a Five-Year-Old Computer Isn’t ‘Sad’
Is it a joke that Apple mark their computers as "obsolete" and stop providing support after they've been available for 5 years?

This "joke" might have a chance at being funny if they didn't apply the punchline to their own stuff.

kelnage··on Semantic Versioning 2.0.0
Is there any harm in doing both? I agree that good changelogs are incredibly helpful - but I can also see how consistent version numbering can be useful too. If nothing else, it can allow easier automated dependency management vs. parsing the contents on a changelogs.
kelnage··on Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29
That doesn't sound at all like what I've been experiencing on Windows 10 TP. I've found it remarkably stable - it's now my main OS on my gaming rig and I use it daily. Outside of the occasional game incompatibility (usually fixed by patches for recent games), it's been the most stable version of Windows I've used in a long time.
kelnage··on Turn It Off: NSA's Achilles' Heel
It might be worth researching Yakima a little further - its been planned for closure since 2012 [1].

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yakima_Training_Center#Ancillar...

kelnage··on Obama, NSA, Verizon and DoJ sued for $3B over PRISM
We are talking about the same Larry Klayman[1], right?

1. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larry_Klayman#Lawsuits

kelnage··on Double Fine launched a new game on Kickstarter
So I can't deny that Double Fine are having to find additional funds for Broken Age - it's true and they've been using multiple different ways. However, I think that's mainly because the scope of the game increased significantly due to way the Kickstarter blew up as it did - at the time I don't think anyone expected it to reach $3 million and as such, expectations are higher.

However, I can definitely say that judging Double Fine on purely their last game is a mistake. They've created many games that have had very favourable reviews in recent history (for example: Stacking, Costume Quest, Brutal Legend) [1].

[1] http://www.metacritic.com/company/double-fine-productions

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →