11,614 karma · joined December 27, 2010
> A centibillionaire (prefix: centi- from Latin centum 'hundred' and billionaire)[2] is an individual whose net worth is at least 100 billion units of a given currency, typically USD.
I agree it's weird - I would also have expected it to mean 1/100 of a billion, like a centimeter means 1/100th of a meter. I assume it's a term made up by an american or british person.
The problem is neoliberalism. Up until trump every single government since Reagan and the collapse of the soviet union has been neoliberal. A neoliberal but “bombastic” like newsom is just a fresh coat of paint on the same thing that’s been making these problems worse.
People can see this, tho they don’t know the word neoliberal, and want an alternative - and so far the only one that’s made it to the ballot has been populist fascist strongman.
This is simply a purity test. Just because they’re all bad, doesn’t mean there isn’t better and worse options.
Source, to preempt the inevitable musk stans: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/spacexais-colossu...
I can imagine biases in the model, and i can imagine someone post-training a model on hugging face to pwn someone, but for z.ai or qwen to do a large scale attack on random nerds running llms on their gaming gpu? They probably spent 10x more training the model than they could possibly exfiltrate before being detected.
Are we hallucinating now too, not just the bots?
My point is that open weights exists somewhere on the spectrum between closed source and open source, and imo much closer to open source than closed.
As evidence, see the thousands of open-weight model derived models on hugging face.
This just isn’t true. 2000s commercial software you buy under a restrictive license, and then extend using an sdk. You can’t modify or distribute the code only your plugin or extension. Open weight models you freely download and modify and extend using open source tools, and create derivative works. The licenses tend to be very permissive (e.g. Apache 2.0 https://huggingface.co/Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B/blob/main/LICENSE)
Perhaps you are not aware of the thousands of derivative models that have been created based on open weight models? Ones tuned for this or that task, expanded, hacked apart.
> akin to sharing an object file which you can compile into something
I see what you are getting at, but modifying object files isn’t practical or simple or commonly done. A model that’s been post trained isn’t the old model with a lump of new code attached to it. The weights have been irreversibly altered and it’s a new thing now. A derivative work.
My contention is that model weights are a form of source code. They the software AND a modifiable thing, closer to minified js than a binary blob. Less flexible than the full training data would be, in some ways, but more useful in others (unless you have a large data center at your disposal). Would you consider something closed source if it had a bunch of generated code, but didn’t include the code used to generate the generated code? I would.
Open source means you can modify, rebuild, and re-distribute the code and the resulting app. Open weights you can do two of those things - you can modify and re-distributed. They can't be re-built, since you're missing the original training data - but they are a form of open that exists somewhere between open source and closed source. Derivative works are allowed, but the source material isn't available.
I don't see people complaining about creative commons licensed images or audio being "not real open source", and open weight models seem about the same as that to me.