629 karma · joined May 13, 2011
Saying that you are sticking to your lying eyes is not productive to the conversation when you are responding to someone else with a first person account too.
I am sure you mean well and you don't do this maliciously, but the end result is still this oppressive machine like system.
Your comment hits me hard because it just shows the covert way we perpetuate this uncaring system.
I think OP's idea is brilliant (putting aside concerns of copyright). It is a evidence based approach to determine a lot of things from the engineering culture.
I was once rejected from an interview because I was asking "too many questions about how the work is done" this led the interviewer believe that I was "too focused on that and probably wasn't a good team player". Reading between the lines, it seemed he just wanted to hire another drone.
I really wish I could escape from this industry sooner. I frankly hate this.
As for Nietzsche, I can't outline what he said. Any summary would be a disservice. In order to comprehend his ideas, he must be studied seriously. Otherwise, you might get the impression that he is a madman rambling.
I only will paste the following excerpt to give you enough curiosity for further reading:
“You desire to LIVE "according to Nature"? Oh, you noble Stoics, what fraud of words! Imagine to yourselves a being like Nature, boundlessly extravagant, boundlessly indifferent, without purpose or consideration, without pity or justice, at once fruitful and barren and uncertain: imagine to yourselves INDIFFERENCE as a power—how COULD you live in accordance with such indifference? To live—is not that just endeavouring to be otherwise than this Nature? Is not living valuing, preferring, being unjust, being limited, endeavouring to be different? And granted that your imperative, "living according to Nature," means actually the same as "living according to life"—how could you do DIFFERENTLY? Why should you make a principle out of what you yourselves are, and must be? In reality, however, it is quite otherwise with you: while you pretend to read with rapture the canon of your law in Nature, you want something quite the contrary, you extraordinary stage-players and self-deluders! In your pride you wish to dictate your morals and ideals to Nature, to Nature herself, and to incorporate them therein; you insist that it shall be Nature "according to the Stoa," and would like everything to be made after your own image, as a vast, eternal glorification and generalism of Stoicism! With all your love for truth, you have forced yourselves so long, so persistently, and with such hypnotic rigidity to see Nature FALSELY, that is to say, Stoically, that you are no longer able to see it otherwise—and to crown all, some unfathomable superciliousness gives you the Bedlamite hope that BECAUSE you are able to tyrannize over yourselves—Stoicism is self-tyranny—Nature will also allow herself to be tyrannized over: is not the Stoic a PART of Nature?... But this is an old and everlasting story: what happened in old times with the Stoics still happens today, as soon as ever a philosophy begins to believe in itself. It always creates the world in its own image; it cannot do otherwise; philosophy is this tyrannical impulse itself, the most spiritual Will to Power, the will to "creation of the world," the will to the causa prima.” ― Friedrich Nietzsche, Beyond Good and Evil
I think Nietzsche criticism against stoicism is on point. I would compare Absurdism which Nietzschean thought. The difference being Albert Camus is much more relatedable for the modern working man.
If this myth is tragic, that is because its hero is conscious. Where would his torture be, indeed, if at every step the hope of succeeding upheld him? The workman of today works everyday in his life at the same tasks, and his fate is no less absurd. But it is tragic only at the rare moments when it becomes conscious. Sisyphus, proletarian of the gods, powerless and rebellious, knows the whole extent of his wretched condition: it is what he thinks of during his descent. The lucidity that was to constitute his torture at the same time crowns his victory. There is no fate that can not be surmounted by scorn."
- The Myth of Sisyphus by Albert Camus.
I have zero autonomy over what I do, because I joined a extreme programming shop where I'm supposed to pair 8 hours a day. Do you know how hard it is to program all day without listening to music because you have to "communicate" all the time? The only thing I've been able to device to reduce this sense of dread and lack of autonomy is to focus on developing my own tools to work. But now, I can't even do that because some dolt complained that me using non-standard tools made him "confused" during our pair-programming sessions.
The standard advice for this situation is to get another job. But I know, that will not fix the main issue. The previous job I had, was a legacy tech debt nightmare, we were understaffed and management didn't want to address any of the issues while expecting us to do over-time support.
The job before that, had beautiful code but the code-reviews were insanely political and if the reviewer didn't like you, you would get 400 comments on a PR.
This industry has managed to take a beautiful thing like developing software and turn it into a nightmare. JUST LET ME CODE IN PEACE YOU IDIOTS!
As for solutions, the one that seems more rational to me is the "freelancing part time while working on my own product(s)". That's the one I'm betting my life on.
Wish me luck.
Good day, sir.
Sure, I guess I will try to assume that you are making this comment in good faith.
Tell me the name of your country and I will tell you why it wasn't socialism.
Socialism has properties that defines it, just like State capitalism has properties that defines it.
If the contional of those properties match one over the other, what does that tell you?
Socialism cannot be allowed to happen because it is too much of a threat to the powers that be.
The day Socialism is actually tried by any country, the surrounding countries will wage economic and physical war against it.
Propaganda to conflate state capitalism with socialism has been extremely successful.
How does democracy takes the voter's interests into account? In your example you describe a hypothetical employee who doesn't have interest in how the workplace is run, then ask me how his lack of interest is represented as an interest? What's wrong with having the interest of people who are interested in the outcome represented. I don't understand your point.
>What happens when a majority emerges composed of workers that are very interested and workers disinterested in workplace politics that they can make disfavorable decisions about the resulting minority?
Then that would prompt them to become interested? I have never met anyone in all my years of working who exhibit the apathy you describe. People become apathetic when their voices are not heard.
>Such company could face the risk of hostile takeover by new hires if there were a need of quick hiring to fulfill for example the needs of big new customer.
You could solve that with some probation period before voting or something like that. But why are you assuming new hires are hostile? Why will new hires take over? They are not a foreign army nor would they be a homegenous group with a malicious agenda.
Look I know hacker news is a hostile environment for these ideas. OP wanted a different perspective and I have given it to him. We can iron out details but overall high level thinking, I think is sound.
An alternative way of organising society and production would be to optimise for the good of society instead of just profit.
Attempts have been made to fix capitalism via regulations such as "the non-baby kill act of whatever". However, our "democratic" system is not really democratic, it more like an oligarchy. Therefore, MR CEO has to take into account bribing politicians to influence regulation in order to maximize profits.
Instead of patching capitalism, a better idea is to introduce democracy from the ground up. That is we acknowledge that the work place has a greater impact on our daily lives than the government itself. If the workplace is ruled as a dictatorship, then workers of that place spend most of their productive time under an authoritarian regime.
Democracy of the workplace would mean that every worker has a vote on how the company is ruled.
Compensation would be a matter of concensus between the workers. Which would address the inequality we currently face.
The idea that your friend had of a farmer working for free or some sort of barter is not something I share.
No thanks. That is not a good deal.