HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kergonath

10,687 karma · joined April 12, 2020

submissionscomments
kergonath··on Casablanca: How an unproduced play marched into movie history
Brilliant essay. Thanks for the link.
kergonath··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
Not necessarily. Both NMS and Minecraft are still selling quite well a decade or more after release. Not to mention things like WoW (22 years and still millions of daily players).
kergonath··on No Man's Sky Cosmos
To be fair, it sounds like you got a decent play time for a one time purchase ages ago. It’s ok not to love everything.

Personally, I like to do the expeditions, and then maybe a couple of hours after. It’s not the focus of my game library, but I enjoy the star seeing every now and then.

kergonath··on Netherlands pulls gold out of the US
> Everyone yells loudly about how bad the us is, but then you realize that the whole world voted with there feet that every other alternative is worse.

The main problem right now is that the US are not the US for which we voted with our feet. They are a worse alternative to the US that created the status quo (to their advantage obviously, but much of the world also benefitted from free trade and the lack of other world wars).

kergonath··on Why are European countries moving their gold out of North America?
> These were not wars! These were American offensive aggressions against sovereign countries that lasted years if not decades for the people in power to suck resources into and out of the military complex andfor their own agenda.

I don’t entirely disagree. But they were large scale military operations, however one-sided. They were expeditionary wars for all intents and purposes, just like Russia’s occupation in Ukraine is, even though no war was formally declared.

> A war has two or more participating countries and a dialect between the two to resolve the conflict.

That was how it worked historically between peer countries, a kind of gentlemen’s agreements. Asymmetric warfare is not so clear cut. Colonial wars were messier. So can be civil wars, which can spread across borders (just look at the Balkans).

> A war has casualties and losses on both sides of the border

Coalition soldiers died in Afghanistan. Many American died in Viet Nam as well, which contributed to the US finally losing in both cases.

kergonath··on Why are European countries moving their gold out of North America?
> we can say that it's a process started long time ago and now simply accelerating and escalating after Ukrainian conflict and confiscation of a european partner assets?

For France, not really. It was De Gaulle and his successors wanting to remove levers that the America government could use against France. It was a sovereignty issue, not really fear that the gold would be seized or frozen. It took decades because it was not really a top priority either.

For the Netherlands (which is why the BBC is talking about this), it’s directly a consequence of Trump using underhanded tactics against allies. In the words of the Dutch government, "geopolitical lawlessness". It has more of a sense of urgency, as well.

> what is the sense of having it abroad if the abroad partner can switch idea of ownership anytime?

There are practical reasons to have some gold abroad. The stuff is heavy and cumbersome, and vulnerable in transit. So, when transactions can be managed by just moving a bunch of ingots from one pile to another in the same facility, it makes transactions easier.

Other than that, countries do not do that if they don’t trust the reserves won’t be seized. In practical terms, either they are close allies, or they have some leverage so stealing the gold has a cost. In the end, it’s a risk/reward analysis on both sides.

kergonath··on Why are European countries moving their gold out of North America?
> But I believe you can relax, because this is all nonsense.

Tell that to Iran. Or Canada. Nobody in Europe is certain that he won’t do anything stupid in Greenland, either. We’re already in a trade war (mostly one-sided but still).

kergonath··on Why are European countries moving their gold out of North America?
Typically they move gold to allies when it’s safer to keep the reserves away (e.g., it’s really hard to imagine the US getting invaded, but that happened to almost all European countries in the last century or so) or when politics become unstable. They take the gold back when the calculus changes. Famously, France got a chunk of its gold back from the US in the 1979s (and finished that process this year).

The rabbit hole goes quite deep: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gold_repatriation .

kergonath··on Why are European countries moving their gold out of North America?
> Does anyone in power anywhere actually think China has finally overtaken the US hegemony?

No, not really. For now we are headed towards a multipolar world rather than a hegemony.

kergonath··on Why are European countries moving their gold out of North America?
The US lost these wars politically. This has always been the US weakness rather than pure military power.

The US was better at getting what they wanted through either soft power or threat of military action than as a result of actual intervention. Which is why it’s really counterproductive when the government does not believe in soft power anymore. It’s the one thing you did well and that allowed you to get your way most of the time.

kergonath··on Why are European countries moving their gold out of North America?
> Also to note, why was the US trusted before?

Trust was never absolute. What we trusted was that the US would act rationally to further their interests. The US benefited tremendously from economic development across the world (industrialisation, free trade, rebuilding after the wars, etc). Sometimes the US government miscalculated (like in Iraq), but there was nothing really destructive like what Trump is doing.

Even when we disagreed we could still talk things through and agree on other things. Now, you have Trump insulting allies and praising ennemies every day. Of course there is no trust.

kergonath··on France's tax agency got hacked (in French)
That could be cockney, though.
kergonath··on Why some US restaurants are banning tips
> What if the chef forgot to add salt?

That’s a perfectly valid reason for complaining, then. Politely, of course, but the chef might use the feedback.

kergonath··on Why some US restaurants are banning tips
> Also Europeans are not, I think, accustomed to asking for salt, or ketchup, on already seasoned food.

I would expect to find salt, pepper and mustard on the table in a decent restaurant, in my corner of Europe. Not ketchup, though, except in a cheap burger place.

kergonath··on Xiaomi: New CPU matches Apple cores single threaded, much faster multithreaded
> Sure, but not the way West conducted it, by going and killing generations of people.

But they did. Look at Xinjiang, Tibet, and the history of Manchuria, among others. They did it to themselves as well, like most backwards dictatorship. And "the West” does not really do genocide anymore, either. This is more a consequence of it being a terrible strategy than Chinese benevolence (or anyone’s, really). At some point we realised that direct administration is a burden and that it’s much more cost effective to bribe nominally independent governments without having to deal directly with local populations. China does this a lot, just like evil western imperialist countries. Empires look different in the 21st century than in the 19th, that’s all. And where would you put Russia in a neat west-rest of the world dichotomy?

> You keep defending the West, even though its actions were much worse than "industrial espionage"

“The West” is not a monolith. It’s made of several countries, some of them better than others, and each one of them with its good and bad sides. It is not useful to work with generalisations like that. It obscures any information or lesson we could get and leads to wrong conclusions. It’s also counter-productive because for all its evil, there is nothing “the West” did that is unique. Except in scale, but then it’s more a quirk of history than something being intrinsically evil in “western” people.

kergonath··on Xiaomi: New CPU matches Apple cores single threaded, much faster multithreaded
You can normalise by surface area, which makes defects rate comparable across processes. At least to a first order approximation, keeping all other parameters constant, bigger chips are more likely to have a defect because they have larger surface areas.

If a process has a defect rate of x, the probability of a die having a defect is A*x. The limit is then the defect rate for a die with the surface area of a transistor, you cannot really get any better than this. But that’s not very useful if you want to extrapolate what the defect rate would be on an improved or cheaper process.

kergonath··on Xiaomi: New CPU matches Apple cores single threaded, much faster multithreaded
On the contrary, it is actually good. For all the hand wringing when someone’s favourite platform loses out on a Geekbench comparison, the benchmarks are quite consistent, even across platforms, and track SPEC results fairly accurately.

Of course it’s not perfect, but then, nothing is.

kergonath··on Andreessen Horowitz is investing billions into a bleak future
Yeah. Billionaire techbros and neofascists love to mis-read Tolkien, but this is a much better picture of the future they want to bring. Down to the mystical doom cult of Peter Thiel and the techno-feudalism on Mars that Musk wants.

Of course they’d imagine themselves as the High Lords on Terra, not amongst the untold billions who died eaten by bugs or enslaved by evil space elves.

kergonath··on Doomscrolling at work wastes time, but the real cost is what happens after
Stuff that ends up on the home page was not just submitted: it was also upvoted, otherwise you would never see it outside of the news feed (which is full of noise and bad crap anyway. Seriously, go have a look and you’ll see that filtering is actually quite good).

This means that enough of readers here think it is interesting. Those people are neither better or worse qualified than you to decide what should be on the front page.

Also, these stories are very easy to avoid. Just don’t click.

kergonath··on New Worlds: We are living in the future of J.G. Ballard or William Gibson
I don’t think that’s really it. Plenty of engineers care about elegance and functionality. I think calling them engineering-led is a disservice to engineers in general.

Everything out of Google is Rube-Goldberg machines held together with duct tape. It is engineering in a way, but by squirrels on crack. It’s alien to how engineering is done in the real world.

Everything out of Meta is pure evil. It is engineering-led if you could behavioural psychologists designing Skinner boxes as engineers. Actually, I’ll grant the Oculus division, which was mostly about engineering and designed cool products. The exception in the Borg.

kergonath··on New Worlds: We are living in the future of J.G. Ballard or William Gibson
(For those who did not get it, it’s the first line of Neuromancer).
kergonath··on Malicious Rust crate Arrayref runs a build-time payload
> We also have the classic example of PHP with numerous not safe stdlib ways to use mysql.

I think it goes without saying that emulating PHP is rarely a good decision.

kergonath··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
:D

(For the record, I read DF quite often as a Mac-minded techy weirdo, I just happen to disagree on this particular issue)

kergonath··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
I’m sorry, this is going to be a bit long but you made good points.

> The EU mandate for AI watermarking is likely the first step in the direction of prohibiting AI for specific use cases.

I am not sure how practical that would be. The cat’s already out of the bag and they won’t prevent companies in the whole world from releasing open weight models. Playing catch up by distilling flagship models is also relatively cheap; we’d see smaller companies setting up shop in friendly regimes. And I don’t see any appetite to go full child porn and criminalise the possession of a LLM. So we’d end up with a similar situation as with illegal downloads, i.e., everyone will do it and nobody will care.

> The pretext for outlawing (or at the very least controlling) the use of AI when the time comes will be something along the lines of data integrity or just general compliance legalese.

They could forbid using LLM for hacking, but hacking is already illegal. They could make it a factor when determining punishment, but I don’t think that would work terribly well. Most of the dangerous stuff we can do with LLMs is already illegal, or should become so. Things like propaganda, identity theft, harassment, scams. We need enforcement with teeth on these, not pointless feel-good legislation. Again, there are parallels with cryptocurrencies and torrenting software. These things have illegal uses, but it’s also really difficult to make them illegal, at least in semi-functioning democracies.

> So, the use cases that are being sold to mainstream audiences actually will be affected by detection tools, especially if the output is intended to be monetized in some way.

I don’t know that mainstream audiences are really against LLMs. They are mostly against AI in a nebulous sense, but even non-technical people use ChatGPT or equivalent. I think that the critical mass is already there and the tools are convenient enough that they couldn’t outlaw them without a massive uproar.

Detection tools don’t seem all that relevant to mainstream audiences’ use of LLMs. AI companies will sell this as a safeguard against misuse, and everyone will be happy about it. The politicians will say they accomplished something, the AI companies will slowly turn public opinion, and the public will have shiny toys.

> The number of legitimate use cases for costly frontier models drops significantly once eliminating professional jobs is off the table.

I don’t know. They can open possibilities that we don’t necessarily consider.

One example I have is a friend who is getting his house refurbished. He’s not an engineer or a material scientist. He does not have enough free time to read thoroughly on the many subjects involved. With a decent LLM, he could untangle the technical documents sent by the architect and the contractors to really understand what was going on and be involved, rather than passively follow the architect’s advice. For starters, the LLM was very useful in finding issues in the quotes he received when he was looking for an architect. Those were long, technical documents, with no really standardised structure and full of jargon. I don’t think that person is going to want to stop using LLMs now. Many people are having this sort of moments right now.

> In the near future the EU will likely come down with heavy intervention to prevent AI from impacting employment rates across Europe.

Maybe. But i don’t believe the EU is well equipped for that. Labour laws are largely local and different in each member state. The EU regulations are basically the common denominator, ore or less, and it is easy to see why: for regulations to get adopted, they need a strong enough majority in the Commission, in the Parliament, and in the Council. It is very difficult to get anything controversial that affect the sovereignty of member states passed.

The angle of the current AI regulations is that they set the rules for the single market, which is where the EU is the most legitimate. It is difficult to see market angle for the effect of AI in labour, and I think enough member states would be keen to kill the project.

Also, there are many influences at play, but the EU is fundamentally an economically liberal institution. It very rarely goes in the direction that reduces economic activity. Look at how clumsy it is at fighting against cheap Chinese imports. I don’t think the institutions themselves would really want to make AI illegal. Companies have too much to lose.

kergonath··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
I have, and I still do this occasionally. I don’t believe the plant on my desk (I don’t have a rubber duck) is intelligent. I don’t need it to be intelligent, either.

I also do it with a LLM every now and then and, while it’s feedback is more useful than a toy’s, it does not need to be intelligent either.

kergonath··on Anthropic's 'watermark' text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
I can’t speak for them, but I do this occasionally. Every now and then among the propositions there are one or two that did not come to my mind and that are actually quite good. I still write the whole thing myself, I just ask for advice occasionally.
kergonath··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
> After I read this post, (seeing they introduced it in August) I think it has to do with the watermarking.

The power of confirmation bias…

> Try it on a paragraph … the connections between sentences feel clunky now.

We might have a definitive explanation at some point, but there are about a dozen possible reasons for something like this. For starters, is this something really significant and not something you notice because you are looking for it (again, confirmation bias)? A bit like some people still lose their minds when they see a dash, even though statistical analysis showed that they are not a significant marker of AI-generated text?

kergonath··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
I am sure he is quite happy to have people disagree with him on HN. He usually wears it as a badge of pride. We might even have a follow-up in a couple of days about how these techy weirdos lost the plot.
kergonath··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
Very intelligent people should be able to grasp that a LLM is not intelligent.
kergonath··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
> The exact words matter to people who people who don’t use it to write for them.

Right. If the exact words matter, using a non-deterministic LLM is a terrible idea in the first place. I hope these people never try putting the same prompt in different sessions.

Also, now I am curious. How would these people interact with other humans? Is there anyone on earth who would provide the exact same reply, down to every single word, if we asked them the same question more than once?

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →