HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kergonath

10,687 karma · joined April 12, 2020

submissionscomments
kergonath··on Anthropic's 'watermark' text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
A lot of that rant is nonsense. Is Gruber also outraged that a RNG is already involved in everything LLM produce with a non-zero temperature? Surely it already leads to widespread use of “non-optimal words”. Simply the idea that there is a single optimal choice, down to every single word, to convey a meaning and anything straying from that is adulteration is laughable. It’s very difficult to take seriously an argument based on this kind of foundation.

He had a very similar rant a couple of days ago when he somehow thought that they would use invisible characters. It’s just as useless.

kergonath··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
> It is also in the AI companies' own best interest to be able to detect AI generated text so that they can avoid training on it

It’s also in their interest to demonstrate that they can be trusted and to show that they at least pay lip service to limit the obvious downsides of the tools they are selling. The use cases they sell to mainstream audiences are not affected by detection tools. The point of having a LLM do the work for you is that the work is done, and reliably. It does not matter if it is done by a LLM, and most of the time it is obvious anyway.

kergonath··on My Ten Years in No Man's Sky
I know, right? I got the same feeling for WoW’s 20th anniversary.
kergonath··on Anthropic's ‘watermark’ text adulteration in Claude is a perversion of writing
> And even that is not sufficient, as the text might have been generated with ChatGPT, Gemini, Grok, MistraL

I would think that these things would eventually converge and we’d get one watermarking algorithm as an industry standard. That way, all major provider would follow it and we’d get independent software for checking. This would partly limit the efficacy of the watermarks, but on the other hand if it’s done correctly, removing the mark could still be enough of a pain that casual users would not bother. That would obviously depend on a lot of factors. It would at least add significant friction in the production of daily slop.

Of course it wouldn’t do much for thing like foreign propaganda but that’s a whole other discussion we need to be having.

> Any university using AI detection in their submission pipeline, or lawyers, editorialists, proofreaders that check for AI marks will be sending significant amounts of text like unpublished research, books, potentially internal documents and more, most of which is high quality human written, to dozens of AI companies, blindly trusting they won't train on any of that.

Isn’t it already what they are doing right now with some of the plagiarism detection tools? Not every university is going to have a representative corpus, and yet they are all using the software. So I guess the provider is doing the work of feeding all that data to their algorithm.

kergonath··on The weekend is 100 years old
> Small communities are much more alive than gigantic ones.

My experience is that after a point it gets annoying, and then oppressive. The proximity in smaller communities can help when everything is right. Neighbours can check on you, bring your kids to school, this sort of things. But at some point personal issues arise, and then it’s impossible to get out of them. That’s how you end up with family feuds over centuries because at some point someone did not like someone else.

Also, it’s nice if you correspond to what the community expects. If you don’t and you don’t build your own niche very quickly you get typecast and then outcast. Humans can be vile and petty, even in small communities. It gets particularly hairy if your bully is somewhat popular locally. Ask me how I know.

Anyway, I much prefer larger communities. I can still make friends if I want to, and if we have a fight it’s not the end of the village.

kergonath··on Europe's scorched landscapes seen from space after summer heatwaves
The article in Le Monde is actually insightful. The tradeoff is a bit more complicated, and "no AC" is not intrinsically a left-leaning position. It’s actually quite interesting to have self-identified right-wing people, who even now moan about woke heat pumps at the same time campaign for AC everywhere.

Personally I am a bit ambivalent. It’s not needed in most cases most of the time, but it could help transitioning en masse to reversible heat pumps, which would be a step in the right direction. What I worry is that it would be hailed as a silver bullet and detract from improving thermal insulation and mitigating techniques that would not require constant energy supply.

We need to see where we will be, not where we are. The electric grid is not going to get more stable in the next years and will get more and more strained as more and more of our economy has to use electricity. Reducing energy use where appropriate should be a higher priority than an AC band-aid.

But my observation of the media landscape is that right-wing politicians hop on everything that can be shown as boneheaded leftists who refuse progress. Of course, the usual useful idiots like Mélenchon are happy to oblige, but the mainstream left-leaning parties are not particularly anti-AC.

kergonath··on Europe's scorched landscapes seen from space after summer heatwaves
> Nuclear and off coal/gas should have been priority for last 50 years.

No argument from me. It would not have completely saved us but we’d be in a better position now. The absolute priority should be to avoid burning fossil fuels for energy.

> But Russian propaganda entrenched in spy infested austria and germany forces cheap gas upon us

Indeed. Germany’s energy policy was a huge risk and set Europe back. I am not sure whether Schröder was a useful idiot or a willing pawn, but the fact that there was no reckoning is very disappointing. And all of Merkel’s balancing act came to naught anyway. So much time wasted…

kergonath··on Europe's scorched landscapes seen from space after summer heatwaves
I don’t know if you read beyond the paywall and you don’t present a single argument, so I struggle to see your point. The article has fuck all to do with actually getting shamed for buying AC. Regulations need to change with the climate, that’s a different discussion altogether. The whole point of the article is a nuanced discussion about pros and cons, and why we are where we are.
kergonath··on 388 years ago, Galileo worked out why human giants can't exist
> What he means is probably the idea of Earth Expansion.

No, it’s probably not what they meant, because otherwise that would be completely inconsistent with the bit about "increased gravity" (whatever that mean).

It’s also wrong. Less wrong than Earth being a living organism, but still quite wrong.

> This view is kinda ostracized in geology and considered heresy.

I know this is a figure of speech, but this is not the right metaphor at all for how science works.

kergonath··on Europe's scorched landscapes seen from space after summer heatwaves
No they cannot, it’s just a right-wing strawman. And something that perturbs some Americans, for some reason. Another "proof" that Europe is a terrible place inhabited by clueless idiots.
kergonath··on Europe's scorched landscapes seen from space after summer heatwaves
It’s the "it’s real, but we cannot do anything about it" rung on the climate denialist ladder. Yes, it is dangerous. It is also mainstream. There are several examples in this thread.
kergonath··on Europe's scorched landscapes seen from space after summer heatwaves
El Niño does not really hit Europe in any way. It influences several things, like the jet streams, but the effects on Europe are very indirect and much milder than in the Pacific. They are also delayed by a couple of months.
kergonath··on Europe's scorched landscapes seen from space after summer heatwaves
I don’t think el Niño affects Europe so directly. As a second order effect, sure, but here the heatwaves and el Niño are simultaneous. And this year is going to break records significantly. Again. No need to wait for next year, which could be the tail end of the current Niño, a regression to the mean, or the beginning of the next Niña.

In any case, Europe is warming up faster than the global average, Niño or not.

kergonath··on 388 years ago, Galileo worked out why human giants can't exist
Right, I know that. But that’s not the point.
kergonath··on 388 years ago, Galileo worked out why human giants can't exist
What do you mean? The Earth does not "grow" and is not really bigger now than at any point in the past (since the creation of the Moon). On the contrary, it is losing mass through the escape of light atoms escaping, but even that is absolutely tiny.

Also, the Earth is absolutely not a living organism.

kergonath··on 388 years ago, Galileo worked out why human giants can't exist
> do the artificial structures humans use, like house frames or bridges' trusses recover strength:weight ratio?

There is some improvement from computer design. We have better tools to know the margins that allow us to remove as much material as possible, things like that. So we can tweak existing designs to make them more efficient, like adjusting the section of beams to make them as strong but with a few percent less materials.

But the major improvements come from using different materials and new techniques, side-stepping the scaling issue.

For example, we could not scale old arch bridge designs very far. Getting steel beams let us build truss bridges, but even these cannot be that long in a single span. Suspended bridges were a step forward, with the improvement coming not from better beams, but from removing them altogether. Then, cable-stayed bridges solved some issues with older suspension designs and we can now have very large spans. Every time, scaling up is enabled by a change in strategy.

> Would a theoretical giant with a skeletal structure like a bridge or a house's frame be better off than one with a human-like skeleton of the same material?

Looking at things like elephants and dinosaurs, there certainly would be a way to have bones strong enough to support a 10m high human-like thing. Now, whether we would recognise that thing as human, I don’t know. Every time the problem was solved, there were significant compromises. I am not sure a giraffe’s vascular system could sustain a human’s brain. Elephants are not particularly agile. Whales cannot get out of the water.

kergonath··on Why does Opus 5 feel worse to work with?
Up to now it’s basically that even when hardware gets more expensive, it also gets more powerful so the price per FLOP still improves. It might be debatable for mainstream GPUs, where generation gains are underwhelming, but the HPC versions are still making progress as long as you don’t need double precision.

I have no idea how the current spike is affecting this: the suppliers we deal with are adapting and we haven’t yet seen a new generation of consumer hardware since the RAM price surge (it’s not really a spike yet as we haven’t passed the peak).

kergonath··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
Indeed. That’s part of why I prefer civil law to common law. I don’t vote in general elections anyway. I am a resident, not a citizen.
kergonath··on Count Binface receives over a quarter of votes in Clacton by-election
Maybe in a real election. Clearly the big parties had no need to get involved in this farce. I think they were right: Farage got publicly humiliated, all for nothing. Surely this has to be the highest score for a novelty candidate. Besides, I don’t think candidates, even from major parties, would really have a chance in the current situation.
kergonath··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
I am not sure. In French that would be the state (L’État). It’s more complicated in the U.K., with its layers of national, devolved country, and local governance. Then, it would be different again in federations like Germany.
kergonath··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
There are. In the constitution, as the court found. There are also reasonable arguments that they are an unavoidable consequence of Human Rights, as described in the declaration of 1789, which is also in the constitution.

The right to privacy is also explicitly in the Code Civil since 1970, in the European Convention on Human Rights and the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (both are binding to EU member states).

kergonath··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
Sometimes these things are a prelude to constitutional changes, or at least could be in the minds of the proponents.
kergonath··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
I don’t know about the whole of Europe but generally, no. The government is the executive branch or a subset of it.
kergonath··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
> if parliament passes a law that says oranges are now green, the supreme court is in no position to challenge it.

It’s a good thing MPs are serious people and Parliament would never do that, right? :)

kergonath··on France's top court blocks social media ban for under-15s
Cultural tangent: in France, "the government" is the group of ministries (or departments in the US), part of the executive branch. So, the judiciary is not part of the government, and the National Assembly and the Senate (legislative branch) are not either. The head of state is not part of the government either, which is how you can get headlines about disagreements between the President and the Government. It’s quite different from how things are managed in the US. My understanding is that it is somewhat similar in the UK, which would be relevant in a BBC story.
kergonath··on Mistral OCR 4.1
> I've heard that before though. I don't think you can compare economies like that since Russia has "near infinite potential" in natural resources, people, etc which Italy doesn't.

Fair enough. But most of the time, the figure is not used to say that Italy is more advanced than Russia, for whatever definition of advanced. It’s a check in the other direction: even if Russia does have advantages, in the grand scheme of things they are not that big.

> They can kick into a true war economy and then become significantly more of a threat. They haven't done so yet because the middle-class population likes their luxury lifestyle (for now).

They did, just in the parts of Russia that are poorer and less-connected (and less powerful politically). They leveraged their huge geographical advantage to spread the pain as much as possible in the regions that don’t matter politically. It is very difficult to see their situation and argue that they are not in a war economy. The middle class in Moscow and St Petersburg are sheltered, true, but still.

> I believe Russia is ramping up to find an excuse at some point to attack a NATO country, but in a way and during a point in time it's difficult for NATO to retaliate.

I don’t think that is likely. But then, of course Trump is making it more and more likely by the day as he insists on getting bogged down in Iran.

kergonath··on Mistral OCR 4.1
It was fun!

What was not so fun was to make it work reliably. I ended up with piles of ugly code to handle edge cases, and issues kept piling up. So in the end I was happy to use someone else’s solution.

kergonath··on Mistral OCR 4.1
Tesseract is not a substitute for these models, which understand complex layouts and also extract bounding boxes for things like tables and pictures. They are also much better at making sense of cursive scripts.

I’ve been there, implementing a way to linearise text from a document with pages with 1, 2 or 3 columns, some of them in landscape is a nightmare. And that’s not even considering equations.

In the end it’s way easier to use a specialised model, trained by other people to do exactly what I need.

kergonath··on Mistral OCR 4.1
I have been quite happy with Mistral OCR for the documents I needed to process (typeset, but old, with questionable scan quality, sometimes elaborate typesetting or, much worse, typewriter-and-handwriting approximations of it). I do not test every new model when they are released, but I did a review shortly after Mistral OCR 3 was released and it was a very good compromise: cheap, fast, and good results without further processing. I found generalist models to be way too much faf to get them to avoid unnecessary modifications to the text and report accurate bounding boxes for figures and tables.

That said, models have sometimes surprising weaknesses and a model could be terrible overall but magically work for one type of document.

kergonath··on France to ban unsolicited telemarketing calls
Come on! It was a reply. The people in question are in the parent. They are the "at least 900k+ people in France either immigrant from Marocco or with an origin and a 100k+ people with french nationality or origin living in Marocco". It’s rather obvious.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →