HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kevinr

506 karma · joined January 19, 2011

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kevinr; my proof: https://keybase.io/kevinr/sigs/eIOMxJmRlS93xkzabyB_S8zXnf6O517hq3APBJPHl1I ]
submissionscomments
kevinr··on Why Did a U.S. Destroyer Fail to Dodge a Cargo Ship?
A single submarine loss (the Thresher accident) was enough to prompt the US Navy to institute the SUBSAFE program, possibly the single most successful safety program in history.
kevinr··on Why Did a U.S. Destroyer Fail to Dodge a Cargo Ship?
Not the parent who mentioned _Normal Accidents_, but this is one of my hobby-horses, so I'm glad you asked!

Prof. Nancy Leveson of MIT has done extensive research over the last forty years on the safety engineering of complex systems, and her 2012 book _Engineering a Safer World_[0] (open-access PDF at that link) is partly a response to Perrow's _Normal Accidents_.

[0]: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/engineering-safer-world

In particular, and unlike Perrow, she thinks we really can design complex sociotechnical systems which aren't disasters waiting to happen, and her book provides a theoretical framework for doing so, plus a fully-worked design analysis technique and accident investigation technique using that framework. These have been and are being used under real-world conditions in a variety of industries including transportation, the military, and even software.

There's a conference every year at MIT which I've been going to every year for about four years now where folks present. Every year there are more industries and disciplines represented, and there have also been presentations of analysis techniques applying the theoretical framework in practical contexts like cybersecurity and privacy.

You're also very right that there are huge social and human factors components to safety, and her book talks a lot about getting that right and analyzing what went wrong at various levels of abstraction, including cultural and regulatory. I highly recommend it, if you're interested in this subject.

Based on what I know of the US Navy, I'm certain that the accident investigators working on this collision are doing so informed by this methodology.

kevinr··on The Stack Clash
As we have seen with old SSL versions and Windows XP, it will be 10-15 years before the whole world is migrated onto containerized software, so this exploit should have a long, long active life.
kevinr··on Colorado doesn’t need to replicate Silicon Valley
Friendly amendment: it's about access to capital relative to local costs. Arguably OP's point is that he had access to enough capital relative to his local costs in Colorado to afford to bootstrap, whereas he'd have needed VC to hit the same ratio in the Valley. Turned out well for him, and has worked for others like him.

"I'm going to invest 10 billion in startups but you have to relocate" is basically what Tony Hsieh did in Las Vegas, and it... based on how rocky that got, I think it's about more than just access to capital.

kevinr··on A plan for open source software maintainers
tav, I'm sorry for my delay getting back to you. I just sent you an email at your profile address to introduce you to someone on our New Business team, who may be able to help.

Open source funding is a cause near and dear to my heart, and I hope something is able to work out.

(And thanks!)

kevinr··on A plan for open source software maintainers
tav, have you looked at Stripe's Connect product (https://stripe.com/connect)? Stripe already is a payments company, and Connect is built to let you use it somewhat like your own payments company, to pay others. Lyft uses it to pay its drivers for example, who also tend to be distributed and dynamic.

(Disclaimer: I work for Stripe, as of like last week. :)

kevinr··on A new vantage point: Canonical CEO Jane Silber to step down
Why must there be something bad going on here? All good things come to an end, leadership positions among them, and the sign of the best leaders is a measured and orderly transition and an organization which lives on long after them.
kevinr··on A new vantage point: Canonical CEO Jane Silber to step down
No, that's a sign of stable and sane leadership transition planning. Big enterprises don't change course overnight.
kevinr··on Leverage Points: Places to Intervene in a System
I've been learning about systems theory for about five years now, and I've been frustrated by the same things, but I've come through them to something which I think provides a path forward.

I think changes which lead to positive progress are hard, and the bigger the problem or the higher up Meadows's leverage list, the harder the changes are. Cognitive dissonance and sunk cost thinking and other cognitive biases do increase the challenge as well. But I do see examples where I and others were able to make positive changes from our understanding of systems theory. I see making these changes as a marathon, not a sprint, so try to adopt an attitude of celebrating every step of the way ("dayenu"), and I also look to work like Nancy Leveson's[0], which tries to systematize the process of turning a systems understanding into actionable feedback.

It's often perceived to be the case that earlier interventions would have led to fewer losses, but it's important to adopt an understanding that the past is past, and all we can do to move forward is to change our behavior now. As the man says, the best time to plant a tree is twenty years ago, but the second-best time is today.

[0]: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/engineering-safer-world

kevinr··on In Manufacturing and Retail, Robot Labor is Cheaper Than Slave Labor Would Be
I don't have data, only anecdote. I've used two of the same supermarket chain which both had the machines, one in a mixed-use area next to a mid-sized research university, and one in a very residential area in an inner-ring suburb.

Around the university, the supermarket drew primarily from the adjacent neighborhoods, and got a lot of college students and local residents who were shopping on average weekly, so we quickly got skilled at using the machines. In the residential suburb, the supermarket draws from a much larger area, and there are more customers who shop there infrequently, so they never get skilled at using the machines. Even just as a skilled user, not as a professional checker, I would regularly stand in line behind people where I knew that I could have shaved minutes off their time merely if I had checked them out.

A lot of the skill involved was just in general operation: how to find barcodes, how to scan items reliably, how to identify produce and enter it correctly, how to use coupons, how to flag down help if the machine entered an unexpected state or required human assistance, how to use the payment terminal with cash, credit, and debit, how to bag items correctly and so that the machine would recognize them, what the various prompts mean and how to respond to them. There's a lot of complexity in operations which we denigrate as "unskilled" or "menial labor" which is only evident when you take the time to observe closely and see what people are actually doing in them.

kevinr··on In Manufacturing and Retail, Robot Labor is Cheaper Than Slave Labor Would Be
Fists ain't cheap.

Slaves are capital, and, like all capital, acquiring and maintaining them has nonzero cost.

In the antebellum American South, some tasks like ditch-digging were sufficiently hazardous that a plantation owner would rather not risk their investment in their slaves, and so would hire Irish ditch-diggers by the day, as the plantation owner would be out less money if they died while digging the ditch.

kevinr··on In Manufacturing and Retail, Robot Labor is Cheaper Than Slave Labor Would Be
> And they will be able to provide better and faster service.

On the contrary, my local grocery store took out their self-serve checkout kiosks and replaced them with human checkers. Turns out there was some skill involved after all.

kevinr··on In Manufacturing and Retail, Robot Labor is Cheaper Than Slave Labor Would Be
As is only appropriate, given the word's etymology.

> ro·bot (n.) 1923, from English translation of 1920 play "R.U.R." ("Rossum's Universal Robots"), by Karel Capek (1890-1938), from Czech robotnik "forced worker," from robota "forced labor, compulsory service, drudgery," from robotiti "to work, drudge," from an Old Czech source akin to Old Church Slavonic rabota "servitude," from rabu "slave," from Old Slavic orbu-, from PIE orbh- "pass from one status to another" (see orphan).

http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=robot

All that's old is new again.

kevinr··on MIT Media Lab Disobedience Award
Look: there were a lot of people to whom he mattered, whom he left behind, and they're good people, a number of them my friends, and I care a lot about them. Their voices and concerns deserve to be heard, whether or not I agree with them.

The people who never knew him, and who don't know MIT or MIT culture, and who want to turn Aaron into some kind of Internet freedom martyr all out of proportion to who he was and what he actually accomplished, those are the folks who I have a beef with.

kevinr··on MIT Media Lab Disobedience Award
I'm not talking about violating trespass laws or any other legal principle---I'm talking about guestright. Aaron Swartz abused MIT's institutional journal subscriptions, which he had access to as a guest of the institution. He was warned to stop by MIT IS&T to an e-mail address he wasn't monitoring. When his IP was blocked, he got a new IP and kept downloading. He knew, or should have known, that his behavior was out of line, and yet he continued.

Do I think he should have been rung up on federal charges? No. But he wasn't a student, or a teacher, or a visiting researcher, or an alum. He had no official affiliation to MIT, and he showed no understanding of or respect for our culture. The flip side of an open culture is respect for and maintenance of the commons, and instead he exploited ours. It was really hard to defend him at the time for abusing the openness of the MIT community.

(And now, in fact, MIT affiliates like Aaron and me no longer have access to MIT's institutional subscriptions, in what I can only assume is partly a response to his actions.)

MIT's history has no shortage of people who were part of the institution and part of the culture, who the administration failed to support when that support was more justified and more needed than it ever was in Aaron's case. I'm sorry for the outcome, and I don't think he deserved it, but I don't think he deserves either some kind of posthumous award, nor does MIT deserve the scorn heaped on it by those who would canonize him.

kevinr··on MIT Media Lab Disobedience Award
Unpopular opinion: Aaron Swartz abused the trust which was placed in him by MIT as its guest when engaging in his civil disobedience, and MIT was perfectly justified not to intercede in his case.

A bit like if your friend comes to your house, you tell him, "don't smoke weed outside, the cops around here will arrest you," and your friend says "I support marijuana legalization, so I'll smoke wherever I want." Your friend smokes up on your front steps, you try to get him to stop (it's your house after all), and then the cops show up, rough you up a bit, and arrest him.

There are many more deserving than Aaron Swartz of this award, within and without the MIT community.

kevinr··on Whiteboard Interviews
A 401k is not a savings account. It's a retirement account. You're not supposed to pull from it between jobs, and there are serious financial penalties for withdrawing before you're past retirement age.

A 401k is also supposed to be able to provide you with an income resembling your at-retirement income for at least 10 years, which is obviously impossible if you only have 2.5x your at-retirement salary in it.

kevinr··on Uber's 'hustle-oriented' culture becomes a black mark on employees' résumés
Every asshole I've ever known in tech got flagged by an interviewer during the hiring process, but the people making the hiring decision ignored the feedback. Often the person doing the flagging was female, or the hiring manager was desperate for a body, or it was otherwise easy for them to justify their decision to themselves. And in every case it wound up costing the company other, productive employees and millions of dollars.

It's very easy for assholes to 'hide' their assholishness if the people with power aren't looking for it, and won't listen to the people who see it. However, even people like that are now on notice that Uber employees are tainted.

kevinr··on Whiteboard Interviews
Can you say more about how they do handle it? I've very little visibility into other professions' hiring practices.

(My housemate who's a middle school history teacher and I were mutually horrified last night at our respective interview experiences. He was hired to teach eighth grade after a single 45 minute Skype interview. I had just had a half-hour phone screen followed a week later by a two hour in-person interview, and I considered that quite short by my standards. I thought his process was ridiculously short; he thought mine was absurdly long.)

kevinr··on Whiteboard Interviews
I say again: if all of that is true of the people you know, even in software, even making above-average salary for your area, you're very lucky.

Also, and I say this as someone currently going through the process: given the way hiring for senior to C-level roles goes in 2017, do not expect "several months" of savings alone will be enough to cover you. Most of the large companies you might like to work for (Google, Microsoft) have hiring processes which can't move much faster than six weeks, and they can stretch out to six months or more.

kevinr··on Uber's 'hustle-oriented' culture becomes a black mark on employees' résumés
Oh, they know people are on the market. That's the vultures circling. They also know they need to be on the lookout to disqualify you if you exhibit bad behavior, so they're going to be very picky in the hiring.
kevinr··on Whiteboard Interviews
> I don't think anyone has any issue with having to physically use a marker on a whiteboard during an interview.

I have friends whose RSI is sufficiently bad that it could be an issue.

kevinr··on Whiteboard Interviews
> Few people are in the situation of a single interview or they don't get to pay their bills next month.

If this is true of the people around you, then you know folks who are very, very lucky in their life and work.

kevinr··on Whiteboard Interviews
How do you feel about interviews for roles where it's required to keep a cool head under incredible pressure?

(This is a serious question. It describes a lot of the security incident response work I've hired for.)

kevinr··on Resources about programming practices for writing safety-critical software
Code like the Boeing 787's avionics package gets one better: the spec specifies what the register values should be after each step of execution, and there's a company which takes the code, puts the processor in single-step mode, and checks.
kevinr··on Resources about programming practices for writing safety-critical software
Parent's MIT Press link has a link to the final PDF, down the page on the left.
kevinr··on Sandstorm gets a security review
URLs aren't normally considered sensitive by users.

"Hey Carol, can you send me the link you're using to the wiki? Mine isn't working."

kevinr··on Sandstorm gets a security review
> Keep in mind that Sandstorm is meant to host internal-facing services.

This is not really obvious from any of your marketing copy or documentation, nor would it be a realistic expectation if it were. I think you need to secure like your users don't know or understand your intentions.

kevinr··on New GitHub Terms of Service require removing many open-source works
If, as joeyh says, the FSF are talking with them about it, maybe I'm going to wait until they're finished before doing anything drastic with my repos.
kevinr··on When “Dumb Pipes” Get Too Smart
Somebody needs to inform Linus. :)
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →