1,443 karma · joined April 13, 2014
scientist.wang
Quick correction:
The article uses 0.6 and 1.5. In this setting, the population wealth increases and the wealth of almost any individual decreases.
In the comment you replied to, they propose 0.66 and 1.5. In this setting, the population wealth doesn't stay the same, it increases even more than before.
(In order for population wealth to stay the same, the payoffs should be 0.5 and 1.5)
An intuition is that log(wealth) represents utility. An intuition for why log(wealth) represents utility is that wealth has decreasing marginal returns. The logarithm is a function that fits this. If you play around with it a bit you might see that it conforms to your intuitions: increasing your net worth from $100k to $200k increases your utility significantly, maybe about as much as increasing your net worth from $1m to $2m, and much more than increasing your net worth from $1m to $1.1m.
For what definition of "average"? Yes, the most likely outcome would be to break even. But if we mean "expected value" when we say average, then on average, that repeated wager would be massively profitable for us (in terms of wealth). Maybe a better way to view it is that it would be massively unprofitable for the casino offering it (this is more straightforward since the casino's outcomes are more ergodic than the individual's).
---
Maybe a more clarifying discussion would be: what if you could accept these wagers (let's say 0.6x and 1.5x) if you can use a bet amount of your choice each time? That is, you don't have to wager your entire life savings, but you could choose to make the bet with $1, with the outcomes being $0.60 and $1.50.
Then, this wager is clearly a free money machine, right? We can come to the conclusion that it is a free money machine by looking at its expected value. That's why I disagree that "you lose more than you gain" and I disagree that "this is purely a result of the distribution of returns from a single toss".
---
I guess I should concede that I agree with your reasoning, if we make the reasonable assumption that utility is the logarithm of wealth. In that case, I agree that I would be indifferent to taking a 0.666 and 1.5 bet for my entire networth, and that I would not take a 0.6 and 1.5 bet for my entire networth. However, I still contend that we can analyze the value of these wagers using expected value -- we simply look at the expected value of what we actually care about (utility), not wealth.
> If you lose, it should then be divided by 1.5 (multiplied by 0.66..).
In what sense "should" this be true?
Yes, the article shows that almost certainly, any individual's wealth will approach 0 from repeatedly taking this gamble. However, the comments I replied to say:
> But this is purely a result of the distribution of returns from a single toss.
which I don't understand.
> But this is purely a result of the distribution of returns from a single toss.
Your examples contain two tosses.
I don't see how this is true. Winning adds 0.5x of your current bankroll. Losing subtracts 0.4x of your current bankroll. When you win, you win more than you lose. The gamble has positive expected value.
Not sure if people do this, but with a mechanism of action in place you can state a prior belief and turn your AB testing results into actual posteriors instead of frequentist metrics like p-values which are kind of useless.
lisasays: this is rubbish because there's no first-hand evidence e.g. of the vehicle fragments of the Debrief article
phyallow: here's first-hand evidence [link to the vice article]
me: this is just weird bits of rock, which isn't obviously a vehicle fragment, and so this article isn't really as much of a proper response to lisasays' comment as it seems.
"Grusch also said he has not seen photos of the alleged craft himself, but has spoken extensively with other intelligence officials who have." from https://www.newsnationnow.com/space/military-whistleblowe-us...
Although I guess for (2), his quote in the OP article does imply that he believes that these could be alien craft.
The original article seems to be implying that there's like some extraordinary clear evidence of a vehicle or something, which would be much more shocking.
I guess chess (without the 50-move rule), checkers, and go (with a certain ruleset) can go on for longer.