HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

king07828

88 karma · joined January 22, 2017

submissionscomments
king07828··on A basic income experiment in Kenya
>Foundations and other aspects of the private sector are capable of doing this on a larger scale than we realize

Exactly. And more specifically, if Silicon Valley were to identify this as a problem to solve with its brains, money, and technology, then the problem might be solved much sooner, more easily, and more efficiently as compared to waiting for a politically correct solution from a government.

One experiment for basic income that has not been tried: create a new cryptocurrency that makes UBI distributions to all wallets. The question created by such a cryptocurrency is whether the issues created by making such distributions (such as preventing people from making an infinite number of wallets) have practical technological solutions.

If there are technological solutions to the problems inherent in a UBI cryptocurrency, then the idea should be implementable by either a cryptocurrency or a government (if a government ever got around to it). Furthermore, if there are not solutions to the problems inherent in a UBI cryptocurrency, then that could help convince UBI supporters that 1) UBI might not be a good solution and 2) a solution other than UBI needs be identified.

king07828··on SF engineer came to money and now wants wife to sign a post-nuptial agreement
>"protect himself and his work"

From what? The other spouse or the legal system? Most would assume it is protection from the other spouse. To verify, one could offer to sign a prenup that splits everything 50/50, i.e., that codifies what would happen under community property law. This provides the benefit of clarifying how a separation would occur to protect the spouses and their work from the legal system.

If protection from the legal system is sought, then the 50/50 prenup should be agreeable.

If protection from the other spouse is sought, then what is the first spouse (the one demanding the prenup) going to give up in order to gain that protection?

If the first spouse is demanding a one-sided prenup that only benefits the first spouse, then it can be argued that the first spouse has broken a marriage vow by seeking to enrich his or her self at the expense of the other. [1]

[1] None of this is legal advice and should not be used as such.

king07828··on Where’s the Next Silicon Valley? VC Is Betting on the Midwest
The invalidity of non-compete clauses and the inability to take IP away from employees are, perhaps, geese laying golden eggs for California. It can be argued that they give phenomenal power to employees that figure out the right way to do something and punish employers that won't listen. As a hypothetical, a former employee might start a competing company and let the market figure out who is right. Without these, it can be argued that employees are less motivated to figure things out because they have no way to capitalize on their ideas unless the decision makers of the employer (whom they probably may never meet in their lifetime) buy in to the idea. [1]

[1] This is not legal advice.

king07828··on Haemophilia A trial results 'mind-blowing'
>cosmetic changes that can be easily done by less expensive means

The less expensive means (contacts, hair dyes) are temporary and require maintenance. The benefits of a genetic treatment is that it is permanent (no cleaning of contacts, no subsequent salon visits), but should also be reversible

king07828··on Haemophilia A trial results 'mind-blowing'
This is awesome!

from the link:

>Historically, MAP in humans has been difficult to study as it cannot be seen under an ordinary microscope and is very difficult to grow. Testing for MAP by the presence of its DNA (using PCR) has found MAP in up to 92% of Crohn’s patients but until now no-one has developed a test to show MAP in-situ in the tissues of people with Crohn’s disease.

It is fascinating that there is a virus that evades regular diagnostic techniques (i.e., using a microscope). That the virus can be found using genetic testing speaks to the power of genetic technology and how revolutionary the true understanding of genetics will be

king07828··on Haemophilia A trial results 'mind-blowing'
>they think of themselves as companies that address diseases. They are concerned with the ill, rather than people seeking cosmetic changes

Agreed. The joke being that black hair (or blonde hair or red hair) is a disease that can be "cured" by a different hair color :)

>backlash ... [against] designer babies

Agreed that this is an issue, especially if the treatment were marketed at unborn children. It may be better to focus on cosmetic treatments for adults to try and avoid this.

I expect this technology will eventually become ubiquitous in our lifetimes, with the only question being the time frame for which it will come to pass

king07828··on Haemophilia A trial results 'mind-blowing'
>the cost of manufacturing ...

>it is incredibly expensive ...

These may be outweighed by the potential market size of 3 billion people (a rough estimate of everyone connected to the internet). If R&D and manufacturing have a total cost of 10 billion dollars, then this reduces to $3.33 per person of the potential market size.

>cant dose these drugs more than once

This may be a showstopper for now. At a certain point, the technology should improve to allow multiple treatments so that a single individual could have red hair for a year, blonde hair for a year, black hair for a year, ...

The cool thing about growing blonde hair instead of dying hair blonde, is that nothing more needs to be done and no further treatments need to be had (unlike dyes). This does assume that the individual has enough patience for the growth process

king07828··on Haemophilia A trial results 'mind-blowing'
I am sorry, but to be honest your comment suggests that you do not have tiniest idea of how insulting the first sentence of your comment is. Instead of simply conveying the idea that things are expensive, the first sentence of your comment is styled as a personal attack, which does not add to the discussion and should not have been included. For example, an alternative first sentence, which conveys the point being made without being a personal attack would be "Medical research is hard."

Regarding the substance of your remarks, if 10,000 people have a rare disease then the 100 million dollars it takes to develop that therapy can only be amortized over that small pool, which translates to $10,000 per person, assuming that every person pays for the therapy.

If 3 billion people (a rough estimate of everyone connected to the internet) is the market size for hair/eye color treatment and the 10 billion dollars of R&D gets amortized over that full-size, then the cost is $3.33 per person. If only 10% of people want to change colors, and only 10% of those people are willing to partake in the therapy, then the cost becomes $333.33 per person to amortize the R&D expense, which is in the same order of magnitude as contacts or a salon hair treatment.

king07828··on Haemophilia A trial results 'mind-blowing'
This is awesome. I have Crohn's and am looking forward to an eventual cure.

One thing I don't understand is why big pharma and VCs seem to focus on rare diseases instead of a gene therapy for changing eye color or hair color. With eye/hair color gene treatments, patients could undergo the therapy multiple times (if desired) and the pool of patients is all humans (not just rare diseases sufferers). This allows for amortization of the R&D expense over substantially more treatments. Plus the advances in gene therapy technology could then be applied to therapies for rare diseases

king07828··on Ask HN: What would you do with $5k/mo basic income for rest of life?
Is Alpha Zero is a paradox when it plays itself, since it can never truly beat itself?
king07828··on Google's AlphaZero Beats Stockfish In 100-Game Match
Still need to solve the game model development problem and the I/O problem.

The game models for each Alpha Zero (Chess, Shogi, and Go) look to have been created by a human, as well as the input and output translation (e.g., a human would need to intervene[1] to help AZ Chess to play and win Atari 2600 Video Chess).

[1] Intervene by doing the translation by the human or by writing a program to convert AZ I/O to Atari 2600 I/O.

king07828··on Google's AlphaZero Beats Stockfish In 100-Game Match
Looks like a residual network (ResNet) feeding a Monte Carlo tree search (MCTS) solves the strategy optimization problem.

A critique is that the game model (rules, pieces, movements, legal moves) is still bespoke and painstakingly created by a human being. One next step would be for an algorithm that develops the game model as well as the strategy and the I/O translation. E.g., use Atari 2600 Video Chess frame grabs as the input and the Atari controller as the output. After experimentation the algorithm creates everything: the game model (chess, checkers, shogi, go), the strategy for the game, and the I/O processing needed to effect the strategy with the available inputs and outputs.

king07828··on Ask HN: What would you do with $5k/mo basic income for rest of life?
If computers can successfully play go better than humans (alphago), then eventually computers should be able to successfully trade stocks better than humans as well
king07828··on Ask HN: What would you do with $5k/mo basic income for rest of life?
If it failed, and it would not meet the criterion of successfully trading.

A successful algorithm would likely need to be able to adjust based on the amount of capital being controlled using the algorithm and the number of parties that are using the algorithm

king07828··on Ask HN: What would you do with $5k/mo basic income for rest of life?
Then part of the process becomes quantifying what additional data is needed and determining how to generate or otherwise gather that data
king07828··on Ask HN: What would you do with $5k/mo basic income for rest of life?
If it stopped working, then it would not meet the criterion of successfully trading.

A successful algorithm would likely need a way to tolerate increased usage of the algorithm, much like how successful human traders do so currently.

king07828··on Ask HN: What would you do with $5k/mo basic income for rest of life?
This sounds like www.quantopian.com, which has already been done and has not removed the need/desire for UBI. The purpose is not to capitalize on the idea myself. Rather, it is to allow unwashed masses to pay their bills themselves, which is why it should be open source.
king07828··on Ask HN: What would you do with $5k/mo basic income for rest of life?
I would consider retiring so that I could write and open source robot trading platform that utilizes the latest advances with neural networks to analyze and successfully trade in the stock market that is simple enough for any high school graduate to use so that UBI would no longer be needed
king07828··on Seed funding has declined
Excellent point.

The issue is more than simply the increase in cost. To address the issue, small companies and inventors would likely have to file appeals to the Federal Circuit and then file appeals to the Supreme Court AND and hope that enough judges go against the grain of the current environment to help with the plights of small companies and inventors.

By definition, small companies and inventors do not have the money for this litigation and investors are unwilling to fund litigation that will probably not be successful in the current environment.

king07828··on Seed funding has declined
> Patent rights have not diminished one bit.

There are several that think quite the opposite of this extreme statement. [1]

More to the point, the courts have finally addressed one of the major problems with patent trolls, which is the cost difference between a plaintiff and a defendant for adjudicating an arguably frivolous case. [2] [3] With this new interpretation of venue, it is significantly harder, if not impossible, for plaintiffs to pick a friendly venue where plaintiff costs are 1/10 to 1/100 the cost of defendants for arguably frivolous adjudication.

However, past attempts to whack patent trolls (the AIA, IPRs, and PTAB) are still harming the patents of small companies and inventors. [4] [5]

[1] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/08/11/us-inventor-patents-on-...

[2] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/05/26/supreme-court-reverses-...

[3] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/09/21/federal-circuit-strikes...

[4] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/08/08/problem-inter-partes-re...

[5] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/07/22/ptab-number-one-enemy-i...

king07828··on Seed funding has declined
This is exactly the problem. Patents used to be a tool that little guys could use against the big guys. Like when Google started with a patent on its search algorithm that prevented Yahoo from copying its idea.

Interestingly, this was also a form of wealth redistribution that forced large companies to give money to smaller companies with good ideas.

If you assume that the patent system is being weakened, it is interesting how it aligns with a reduction in seed funding while at the same time seeing massive market valuations for already enormous tech companies.

king07828··on Seed funding has declined
I don't find that logic compelling either.

If $NEWCO_A and $NEWCO_B are effectively equivalent (team, advantages, etc.), but $NEWCO_A has a provisional patent application that protects the idea and $NEWCO_B does not, then the value of $NEWCO_A should be greater than the value of $NEWCO_B. Thus, patents (i) should add value and (ii) may make an average investor more likely to invest.

If the value of the patents of small companies is being reduced because patents cost more [1] and are harder to enforce [2], then $NEWCO_A will have less of an advantage and won't receive as much funding as it would have otherwise. Thus, there may be fewer investors willing to invest because of the decrease in the value of patents of small companies.

[1] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/07/16/real-staggering-cost-ge... [2] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/11/16/ipr-petitions-virnetx-p...

king07828··on Seed funding has declined
I expect you are biased against patents and had your TLDR conclusion in mind before writing your post. While patents may not be the only thing affecting the decrease in seed funding, saying that "patents have absolutely nothing to do with the decrease in seed funding" seems a little extreme.

The "campaign" includes Supreme Court opinions [1], Inter Partes Reviews [2], the Patent Trial and Appeal Board [3], and biased government actions that favor, e.g., Google over smaller companies and inventors [4].

"patent rights are still strong ..." Yes, anyone can file a patent, but the costs for enforcement are higher and higher [5], while the probability of successful enforcement is lower and lower [6].

"What [is] the company going to do, sue them?" Yes. If patent rights were "strong" like when BlackBerry got sued and settled for $612M [7], then investors would be lining up to fund the company and its litigation.

[1] https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=778413475528498... [2] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/08/08/problem-inter-partes-re... [3] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/07/22/ptab-number-one-enemy-i... [4] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/11/13/ptab-targeted-advertisi... [5] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/07/16/real-staggering-cost-ge... [6] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2017/11/16/ipr-petitions-virnetx-p... [7] http://money.cnn.com/2006/03/03/technology/rimm_ntp/

king07828··on Video Startup Can’t Outspend YouTube, So It Created New Currency to Pay Creators
After reading the YouNow whitepaper, I am unsure how to argue that they are not doing exactly that
king07828··on Seed funding has declined
I realize this won't be popular with this crowd.

One big reason is the campaign against patents in general, and against software and e-commerce patents in specific.

Why would an investor put down money for an idea for a new website where FB Google Amazon Apple MS will simply copy the idea and use their economy of scale to remove even the hint of success?

king07828··on Video Startup Can’t Outspend YouTube, So It Created New Currency to Pay Creators
Wasn't comparing to US dollars, was comparing to other types of assets that YouNow could have sold (e.g., stocks or bonds) that each require something more than a crypto wallet to exchange making them possibly less liquid than the cryptocurrency
king07828··on Video Startup Can’t Outspend YouTube, So It Created New Currency to Pay Creators
A properly traded cryptocurrency allows anyone to trade at anytime (so long as miners are still going), whereas a central intermediary may not be as liquid. Thus, the cryptocurrency route may include a liquidity premium
king07828··on Video Startup Can’t Outspend YouTube, So It Created New Currency to Pay Creators
1) start an ad based website;

2) pay content creators with a new cryptocurrency;

3) require advertisers to use the cryptocurrency in order to buy ads.

If YouNow implements step 3, then they might have something.

king07828··on A basic income could boost the US economy by $2.5 trillion
Is $1000 per month too high to start with? Okay, then start with $100 per month. Too low? Okay, then go up to $500 ... settle on an amount > $0. Also, eliminate all other welfare programs and require attending at least one 3 hour class per week (or teaching a class or do 3hrs of volunteer work). Financial feasibility, check. Getting people to do more than smoke or gamble, check. What more do you want?
king07828··on Myths About Choosing a College Major
I wish, I wish, I wish someone would have had this talk with me pre-college: "Why are you going to college? To learn a skill that you can use to pay the bills with, i.e., to make money, right? If the goal is to make money, then wouldn't it be a good idea to try a major where they literally teach you to make money? Which college does that? Does engineering, science, or liberal arts teach you how to make money? Or do they just teach you how to spend other people's money? Hint, as an engineer you are someone else's cost. The college of business literally teaches you how to make money, especially in finance, where they teach how to start with a pile of money and make it a larger pile of money. Granted, some grounding in the hard sciences is nice, but minors are good for that. Final recommendation is Finance major with Computer science minor, and then get an MBA after that as quickly as you can.”

I have bachelor’s degrees in electrical engineering and in computer science, a law degree (years later in night school), and an MBA (years later again in night school). I do not like that the only advice on picking a major was “do what you enjoy/love”. I loved each of my majors when getting them and when applying them, but I did not enjoy learning the hard way that I want to be the guy paying others to make money for me, instead of the guy getting paid to make money for someone else.

← PreviousPage 3 of 4Next →