95 karma · joined May 11, 2018
Also, asking questions is fine but answering them is much better if you want to learn something. Other peoples q&a is just as useful. Lurking is fine. Just find the channel for every language and every tool you use and stay there forever.
Some channels have a separate #foo-social or #foo-offtopic place for [usually slow paced] interesting stuff that is unworthy of the main channel. Travel around, check out new places. Some are well hidden.
If you are truly a useful asset you get to behave.... uhmm... somewhat like an idiot.... don't go ask the biologists where the white stork gets the babies from on your first day.
Enjoy!
"Web pages only last about 100 days on average"[1]
http was nice, we gave it a good spin, it was certainly close enough for the cigar but in all honesty... where you have 100 days to find the content you want to consume it is not even a reasonable approach. I bet a lot of it is still available some place but whoever archived it legally may not distribute it without permission.
I really don't care if TOR, IPFS, freenet or zeronet work out of the box. If it means access to more content its great. I don't even know how to use gopher atm.
Good stuff is happening[2] but where they apparently chose to make it an extension is pretty lame.
also..
If the user types "salvation army" into the browser we know what they want. Selling the rights to deny access is not what we need.
[1] - http://blog.archive.org/2015/02/11/locking-the-web-open-a-ca...
We also have lots of and continue to have more software monoliths that at first are just to good, one wouldn't bother writing their own. Later we wont even remember how to do it and end up with a final design. Could be epic, could be aweful. (I mean every ready made thing available for use either for end users or programmers)
Why? Software is a fantastic prototyping tool, its so good we don't bother making things into a chip. This for the most part because we wouldn't be able to update it. The need for updates will eventually go away. Things for now continue to be improved but at some point it stops making sense to do so. What [say] an email application should look like was completely unknown in the 80's but we all have expectations today. It seems unlikely for us to continue to write [say] new email clients from scratch forever?
Therefore it must be C) 60%
I think we can humble ourselves with the idea that the unknown is so large that puny humans will never figure out a significant part of it. Our knowledge to the whole will always be near zero. This perspective makes practical things a lot more interesting or a lot more important. I think there is a sufficiently infinite amount of work left close to the applicable.
Perhaps a good analogy is to first explore the forest close to the village rather than moving in a random direction. Its great of course to hear stories of far away lands but when it comes to funding we should aim to get something in return. At the same time we shouldn't be so quick to dismiss things that seem implausible to us. There are plenty of empirical results out there that are dismissed outright and will never see publication.
I use to play with magnets just for fun, in pure ignorance. I made quite a few setups that behaved in an interesting way to me. Nothing complicated, they take 1-10 min to make. When I told some book smart people they got angry and told me I was lying. I'm not trying to accomplish or refute anything. To me the effects were less interesting than their outright rejection. My ignorance of the art was quite the advantage. All I have is my hands and my eyes. You can't convince me I cant be seeing what I'm seeing but it is damn fascinating to see people try.
At that point they quickly restored my account. ha-ha
For example: If you are, from a truly objective perspective, firmly stuck with the idea that the earth must be round, you would have it no other way... then surely seeing objects that should be hidden behind the curvature means light must bend around the curve?
Its like person 1 arguing you cant look though glass, person 2 showing him a glass window then 1 argues woah! The picture travels around the window! Then the 3rd person argues the theory of transparent glass has now been refuted because we know the picture bends around it.
Out of curiosity I decided to install every IRC client I could find. Connect to a few servers, open a good number of channels and learn to use them one by one while looking at memory and cpu usage.
Like many I have deep thoughts. Mine are as hard to find for their potential audience as the many are for me. We do however pay a lot of attention to people who make a lot of noise.
I had this hypothesis that people would copy other peoples political ideology that are copies from that of others in long chains that, rather than start with a persons deep objective thoughts, are just connected in loops long enough for us not to notice - with a number of thinking nodes insignificant to the result. [lets call them dictator nodes for laughs]
In order to test this rather absurd hypothesis I took the entire list of US presidential candidates and looked at their social media.
This quickly confirmed the loops to exist, fuck, my hypothesis was optimistic compared to reality. I found that close to 100% had facebook pages and youtube channels that didn't enjoy enough traffic to account for friends and close relatives of the person.
Eventually I worked my way up to the green party, they had 250 views on their youtube channel. I wondered about the meaning of it.... what does it mean?
I think it means even journalists didn't bother to look at it. The huge apparatus of international journalism did not bother to look at the top 5 candidates most screamed about while I took a look at a really large number of them.
For democracy to work we ALL need to look at the menu then make up our own mind. In stead what we got is NO ONE looking at the ideas. If 99% of the population had exactly the same opinion about everything and one of us would write it into a political program no one would vote for it.
The point I'm trying to get to is this: We've already build the machine that contains us. Small groups of people who cared about something gathered and implemented their ideas. These things are now bolted down so firmly that unmaking their actions takes such an absurd unrealistic amount of effort that we can at best imagine doing it. We have millions of implementations like that and they are here to stay. It doesn't even need to be stupid. The idea could have been brilliant 200 years ago.
The stupidity in Artificial-stupidity will not be in the AI, the system will continue to "liberate" humans from having to think deeply which will move us further from a position of influence. If it does a bad job it will actually be beneficial to the end result.
Its terrible how disconnected we are from the things that sustain us. There are so many companies involved in producing something simple. We can gradually expose the consumers to all these business processes we've accumulated over many thousands of years. I think it could be mind blowing in many ways.
People aslo behave different if someone might be looking. Investors get a tour of the facility and everything seems designed for them rather than for the customer. I've seen places remove chairs and force everyone to stand all day simply because it looked good to investors. Open floor plans anyone? From an investor perspective the less room for livestock the better. Salaries cant possibly be low enough. etc
Have them make [say] a nice video showing the production process. Have some fancy committee sign of on it. Or if the product is to embarrassed to show how it's made have it pay the 1% extra taxes.
At least one supermarket forbids taking pictures tho.
> "BitTorrent, Gnutella, Freenet: Decentralized"
> "In a decentralized system like BitTorrent, every computer/node acts as a client and server"
F
But that was not what I ended up measuring. The widget (it was) was like someone looking over my shoulder and modified my behavior. I became insanely productive for a few days then had a weird kind off burn out where I declined to enter anything or wrote "watching youtube videos" for days.
Eventually I replaced the widget with a careful cut out from the movie 1984 so that it looked like a telescreen with big brother looking at me. A factory bell would ring and I would be "forced" to take a break. I got bored with that before figuring out the ideal work/break ratio. (It didnt care what I was doing)
I considered automating self-inflicted activity monitoring but any amount alters your behavior... much like your gut told you it would.
IMHO to be complete the law should require web widget providers to serve what it says on the tin.
AND NOTHING ELSE
If it is a button so that users can bookmark articles on the facebook website then it shall only do that, nothing else. And so on: the webmaster must host the image himself. If the functionality can be accomplished with html there shall be no javascript. If there is a need for javascript it will be hosted by the webmaster and shall require consent before calling home to the mothership.
For example, visiting a store doesn't give the store owner the right to search your bag.
Then lets not stop there and include all advertisement???
The advertiser knows the topic of the website he is advertising on, he knows what kind of audience is attracted by a specific article. He can place his advertisement at the top or the bottom to further filter down.
This gives him everything he need to advertise his product on that website. The web master can host the images. A neutral 3rd party, preferably a government agency, can track impressions and provide the advertiser with a crude estimate of traffic by region.
I think it shouldn't stop at having other people do all kinds of things and pay for it. The EU could easily fund its own technologies.
THE EU could give you [say] a Facebook like button in html and require you use it. That they have their own TOS is just irrelevant. Or worse, Facebook shouldn't have to invest in terms of service. We should have detailed laws removing the need for a TOS. Standard laws for social networks should apply.
A restaurant owner doesn't have to clutter up his place with 100 no smoking signs. There is no contract to sign before you can eat.
And you should expect this to take a much less straight forwards form than outright malicious intend.
Machine learning stuff, to us mere mortals, is a black box that seems to output that what we desire. However, we don't need a single black box to completely hide the effect from everyone involved. It can be simply spread out over many processes without anyone noticing the sum of countless, by themselves very sensible, pro-google decisions made by google and its employees.
Say on a fuzzy edge some human or automation has to decide if a website gets banned from the index or not. Since they use adsense or google analytics it becomes possible to contact someone running the site or even, long before the offense, present them with a machine generated report suggesting decline of quality.
The google hating webmaster doesn't want all that tracking crap on his site and therefore he might be punished by not having the warning in advance. It doesn't seem harmful, it seems perfectly reasonable, if however you create 1000 such effects the meaningless 0.1% adds up to 100%.
Say, we take a user profile that use to frequent sites now banned from the search index. If that profile moves to a new website. Does that merit close monitoring? If the AI is a black box you don't even get to ask the question.
It all seems to be fair and logical but the sum of those 2 would boil down to close monitoring websites not using analytics. We would praise the AI for noticing it so soon and so efficiently.
And so things further escalate without anyone connecting the dots.
To make it more sinister:
We have a system of pro-consumerism entities that collectively indoctrinates us to enjoy consumerism. We don't know how efficient or effective that system is. But all we need to know is that we can improve it.
How hard is it really to plant a seed, water it and eat the tomatoes? How hard is it to mix flour, yeast and water then shove it in the oven? It sure seems like an infinitely complex task to me, infinite as in: ill never do it. That apathy is great news for consumerism. Its behavior that deserves to be praised and rewarded by the entities benefiting from it. There is no evil man pulling levers behind a curtain. Its just the way things are.
And you can load news websites that "need" 2000 assets in less than 2 minutes. I think that is mostly it, so that you can suffer more advertisement in higher resolution.
my take: Cloths are what people you meet look at. They create a mood in the spectator and leave an impression of who you are. First you have to figure out who you are, who you use to be and who you want to become. Who are the people you meet? they use to be what? who do you want them to be? After doing that you pick cloths that compliment the becoming part without flying to far from who you/they are.
Try wearing a kilt or a lederhose and watch the world around you change.
If you look at today's fashion its like everyone is heading to a funeral. Like they got tired of carrying their soul around then forget where they left it.
The denial of that possibility continues to this very day on Wikipedia. There it is argued that validating credentials of named professionals is not possible.
In my mind it is as easy as adding a (hidden) token to the html for the professional profile on the university website or nuclear reactor. (Should also have a machine readable tag with the professional title in it)
Say for example:
You add a link to your professional profile to your HN profile, (check a checkbox if you want it to be on public display)
HN then provides you a html sniplet,
you paste it into your uni professor page,
HN crawls it and appends your title to your username.
The funniest anecdote: 2 users on a forum spend weeks disagreeing and fighting over subjects. Their blood was truly boiling. At one point one asked: How old do you think I am? (As a rhetorical) Then it turned out one of them was 14 and the other 72. It completely explained every single disagreement they "enjoyed".
Anonymity is great until it isn't.
For me the similar train of thought triggered when I was part of a [highly informal] network of bloggers. Everyone went out of his way writing articles to the best of their ability. Some had similar topics like social media today but rather than a picture of a cake with "I've made a cake!" under it the blog post would describe the recipe, its evolution and tried to get at the very essence of cake and the baking thereof. The difference with forums and comment sections (where the same authors would post) is that the later have guaranteed readership. If your blog sucks people will drop your feed in favor of something else.
Anyway, the article reads like someone who badly needs to get over his preconceived ideas about RSS, like so many people around here. Hacker news, Facebook, Twitter, etc are cakes made in a factory, they are not your personal cake recipe that you've carefully calibrated over decades.
Hating on RSS is like telling your grandma who spend the whole day in the kitchen that all that cooking is really a waste of time and you prefer a happy meal or a whopper. Then you pull out your phone and say, don't worry! ill just order a pizza!