138 karma · joined January 16, 2013
I'm all for a tighter integration between Ops and Devs, and infrastructure-as-code can help bridge that gap, but I don't know that doing each others jobs is the solution.
In other words if this analysis were complete, we would expect to see straight line growth.
The managers your describing sound more like PM's.
Probably true; I guess my comment can thought of more as counter-propaganda.
>Suppose, for example...
I imagine if I could get someone to question the premises of their hateful, retrograde philosophy I could get them to engage in further inquiry, which might open their eyes.
>You say you have lost your taste for intellectual debate online...
True, but I could also cultivate other interests. I'm sure eventually it will entice me again,
>Your starting point is that you know the truth
Marxists don't believe in absolute truth.
Do 'debate and reason' derive their power from the material world? It seems to me that they only exercise power in shaping one's consciousness to the degree that they reflect facts about the material world.
Following on the heels of that, what facts about a humans physical presence in the world carry more import for every other facet of their life than their economic position (position meaning, in particular, class)?
For what it's worth, people can and do argue against economic determinism. The degree of success that they have in that regard is a matter of continuing debate.
There are a variety of other arguments you could advance against it - for example that the self is social fiction with no scientific basis, the increasing communality of all labor, the inherent instability of Capitalism evidenced by the Long Wave cycle, the sociological fact that people's consciousness is shaped by their relationship to the means of production (evidenced, on their part, by their almost uniformly advantaged upbringings)...
Speaking for myself, I have lost my taste for extended intellectual debate on the internet, and all of these vectors of criticism would (if I were being intellectually honest) lead to extended debate. It may not be fair of me, but as a Marxist I do believe that the material world will change much more workers minds than some logic arguments arrayed in an online discussion.
As a consequence, 'Free exchange' then consists of people with massively unequal bargaining powers coming to an agreement. To see this arrangement as fair, one has to twist their sight up quite a bit.
A defense of the free market without redistribution to counter the effects of this and other historical crimes is a defense of oligarchical privilege.
He was listing the cities in the Northeast corridor.
It's cool. 5th largest city in the country and everything, but you know, whatever.
http://www.marxists.org/archive/trotsky/1923/04/capdevel.htm
Essentially, increasing competition drives down profit margins in existing market sectors. Companies respond by increasing automation so that they can generate arbitrage profits against the "average" price dictated by the cost of the generation of a unit of the good by their competitors. The other companies catch up, however, and this process itself is deleterious since profit is generated by accumulating the surplus value of the labor embodied in a unit of the commodity. As this process reaches it's nadir, the economic character of society is marked by speculation, increasing international tension, and market crashes. Once the fictitious capital that has outstripped the value in the real economy is destroyed, growth can begin anew. Based on Nikolai Kondratiev research, these growth and contraction cycles operate on approximately 30 to 40 year cycles.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kondratiev_wave
What's particularly fascinating (detailed in Trotsky's article) is how the growth / contraction cycles operate on human culture and thought. Thus 60 years ago, the United States could be a signatory to a Declaration on Universal Human Rights and today find itself denying that it's own citizens have a right to due process.
Anyways, I could go on, but I'd be rambling :)