HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kirrent

1,739 karma · joined December 9, 2015

submissionscomments
kirrent··on Meta to Wind Down Its News Feature in the US and Australia
Much less appealing to even read in the first place. Plus you're also in competition with other publishers who will happily gobble up the impressions you used to take. So even if you're willing to play hardball as a publisher, you don't have any real capacity to coerce the social media company.

It's this imbalance in bargaining power that the Australian law at least aims to change (and it's why it's administered by the competition and consumer commission).

kirrent··on Meta to Wind Down Its News Feature in the US and Australia
Yeah, the publishers want compensation for the headline, photo, and text excerpt that appear on the social network. While these are really small excerpts, the publishers contend that it's sufficient to reduce demand for the article itself from users who'll read the headline and preview, maybe interact, and continue scrolling on the social network.

It's not surprising that users will do that to me. We see plenty of people commenting on HN without reading the article, and that's just based on a text only headline.

kirrent··on Thomas Cochrane
I don't want to critique personal taste, because it's ultimately preference and who am I to judge yours? On the other hand, one of O'Brian's strengths is his wonderful characters along with his beautiful prose. Even to the point that later books, like The Thirteen Gun Salute to The Commodore (a 5 book stretch) have an awfully boring and uncompelling series of plots and I still liked them anyway.

I do like Hornblower. I've read all the books more than once, I bought the ITV show, and I even hunted down the Gregory Peck adaptation. To me Hornblower was a deeper character than I might have any right to expect in a historical adventure series, but his repetitive self-loathing in the face of his genius (genuinely a compelling choice) grates after so many books and so many successes and he begins to feel like a caricature of himself.

Like the grandparent, Aubrey and Maturin are my favourite characters in anything I've read. Everyone will tell you how they and their relationship is wonderfully depicted, but it could also have something to do with how many books there are and how often I've re-read them. At this point they're old friends so it'd be disloyal of me not to love them as much as I do.

kirrent··on Nikola founder to be sentenced for federal fraud charges
Despite being on shaky ground due to local minima, barren plateaus, classical simulability, and more, variational quantum computing is definitely a real field. ChatGPT can't even hallucinate properly.
kirrent··on Rolls-Royce calls off bets on electric planes, says low-carbon fuel is future
If you're going to try and get an aircraft to cruising altitude without using its own energy, surely the easiest concept is with a tug aircraft towing to altitude. Hell, there's even fairly speculative concepts like Magpie envisaging a series of tows.
kirrent··on On not noticing rather too many things
Pretty much yes. Trim to your desired speed in level flight and you can go hands free. Large fins mean strong yaw stability, long wings mean strong roll damping, dihedral on those long wings is relatively large as well so you're stable in level flight. Nearly all gliders are very well behaved in stall and mush forwards without being likely to drop a wing.

As far as pitch, elevators tend to be close to neutral or produce negative lift. There's generally not a noticeable pitch on the aircraft simply because you want the fuselage as closely aligned to the airflow as possible to reduce drag.

kirrent··on On not noticing rather too many things
Getting overloaded is common in stressful situations in aviation where it's often called getting behind the airplane. It's the reason we're taught to aviate, then navigate, and then communicate. It's a graceful degradation where by purposefully ignoring what's not currently most important you can focus on what's most important rather than failing at everything. For me flying gliders, the most stressful situations I've been in are winch launch rope breaks with questionable land ahead possibilities. In those cases I've never made a call that I'm entering a modified circuit. Despite a decent amount of experience, I'm just too busy.

Relatedly, gliders are really good at flying themselves. I heard a story about an aerotow where due to a miscommunication the instructor and student thought each other were on the controls. They only discovered this once the instructor praised the student for their best take-off yet. Similarly, learning to land feels like it's about doing the minimum possible. Keep the nose up and just wait. So not only are good pilots paying less attention to distracting inputs, they're also spending less effort controlling the glider on the output side.

kirrent··on Roundup herbicide ingredient connected to epidemic chronic kidney disease
I think we're talking past each other a bit. In this moment I'm not trying to persuade you of anything about glyphosate though I obviously disagree with you, just saying that there are plenty of us out here who do argue in good faith and asking you to consider that what may look like astroturfing is just honestly held opinions by people who disagree with you. In this case, I read the article, the paper, skimmed a couple of citations from the paper, the Wikipedia article, and a paper cited in Wikipedia on contaminants, especially fluorine, and kidney disease in Sri Lanka. I found it all quite interesting and didn't do it out of a desire to blow off a link (blowing off work on the other hand...).

Sure, if you find a comment section spammed by new accounts with thin histories that look synthetic, call that out. I'm not even trying to persuade you that it doesn't happen (though to me it would feel like a misallocation of resources to do it to HN if you were going to do it). Maybe I'm bad at detecting it as you say.

As for examples, I've mixed up message boards a bit as well as glyphosate/Monsanto, but here's me from 2017 implicitly arguing that controversy over Monsanto suing farmers is a bit overblown (no pun intended): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14794627

From around the same time here's me saying that Monsanto's editing of a paper related to roundup safety was dumb but didn't concern me as far as glyphosate safety: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14974180

In that second link in the wider comments Dang replied to a flagged comment: 'Someone holding a different view than you do is not evidence of bad faith, and the internet trope of you-must-be-a-shill is poison'. I agree with him and it's part of why I enjoy the HN community where this isn't the typical mode of reply.

kirrent··on Roundup herbicide ingredient connected to epidemic chronic kidney disease
If you think that people saying that glyphosate is safe are arguing in bad faith I can see why you'd think there's a lot of disingenuousness around here. I can't speak for other people but I've defended glyphosate in plenty of threads simply because I've seen no compelling evidence of any significant danger from it in general and the specific stories we're discussing are often even weaker, with the comments sections drawing massive conclusions from equivocal evidence.

Take this article as an example, people are drawing some quite radical conclusions from it when if you read the original paper, the data isn't strong and the stats are incredibly weak. The authors are hypothesising a quite long pathway from glyphosate in a country with a ban to water contamination to glyphosate-metal complex to kidney disease. Given the lack of existing compelling literature for this chain (and kidney disease in Sri Lanka has seen a lot of study), I'd want to see some compelling evidence, but this paper isn't it. I'm sure you don't want to argue over one specific case but it does bother me how they brush off the far more significant fluorine so easily, treat glyphosate differently in the analysis to all other contaminants, and didn't consider a dose response calculation over all wells between glyphosate and kidney disease.

This isn't me deflecting or gaslighting. Just disagreeing and trying to do it as intellectually honestly as I can on a subject which is massively important to the modern world.

kirrent··on Show HN: A nom parser for the Starcraft 2 Protocol Replay format
Oh, that's good to know. Shield battery is a great project. Thanks for your work.
kirrent··on Show HN: A nom parser for the Starcraft 2 Protocol Replay format
The same can happen in a live game. Apparently LAN games don't check for consistency in game state so you can just diverge over time. One of the observers in ASL desynced in the RO8 just the other day so it travelled over into remastered.
kirrent··on Ural Airlines is preparing to fly a stranded Airbus A320 out of a field
Or a lot of hot air balloons: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WSfMNEEnPoc
kirrent··on Artificial Intelligence and Copyright: Request for comments
I don't have any strong opinion either way but here is, to me, the best form of the argument.

I think the clear analogy is copyright in photographs. There is no a priori reason to believe that copyright should apply to either photographs or model outputs. In the US the copyright act was extended by congress to allow for copyright in photographs. When this was challenged in Burrow-Giles Lithographic Co. v. Sarony, the argument was made that a photograph only mechanistically captures the world and doesn't involve authorship and therefore doesn't fall in the scope of copyright outlined in the constitution. The court disagreed and found there is sufficient authorship in photography through the choice of lighting, framing, camera settings, posing of subjects, etc.

Similarly, one could argue that there is authorship in the choice of topic, prompting, framing, etc when using a generative model. Look at some of the very complex prompts on Midjourney's example page. I've spent a fair amount of time trying to make images which are just as striking and failing. Just as in photography, I think an extension of copyright in this case would probably need to involve an act of congress rather than a development in case law (though I'm outside the US and not that familiar with the act and relevant case law).

If you haven't read the Zarya of the Dawn letter from the US copyright office, I think it's a very cogent explanation of where things currently stand. An artist generated images for a comic book. They get no copyright in the images because they didn't sufficiently have authorship in them. They do get copyright in the entire comic book which involves a particular selection and arrangement of images. https://www.copyright.gov/docs/zarya-of-the-dawn.pdf

kirrent··on Abandoned and little-known airfields
If we're going to stay away from motor paragliders and other ultralights then you've still got the flight sustainer single seat gliders such as the Diana 2 which take off with an engine with peak 35hp power.
kirrent··on Tech sector Salaries have fallen up to 15 per cent as fired talent floods market
I understand your frustration but complaining about paywalls is not only off-topic and repetitive it's also explicitly called out as something we should try and avoid when commenting on HN - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10178989
kirrent··on Meta blocking news links in Canada
I've got mixed feelings about the news media bargaining code but I don't think the lack of designations is one of its problems. Only stepping in once negotiations fail seems to be how the law is intended to operate. 52E(3) of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 says that in making the designation that the code applies the minister must consider:

1. Whether a significant bargaining power imbalance exists.

2. Whether the platform has made a significant contribution to the sustainability of news media.

As to 1. the mere existence of the code seems to redress any power imbalance somewhat. As for 2. The actual deals Facebook and Google made in response to the law being enacted are confidential, but many news media companies said they were happy with the results so there wouldn't seem to be any reason to designate these organisations in the first place.

kirrent··on My Meeting with David Bohm
All of those statements were Maudlin's opinions. I personally don't see why it's objectionable for two branches of the wavefunction to exist simultaneously past entanglement with an outside system, but most of all I just don't care anymore.
kirrent··on My Meeting with David Bohm
Funnily enough, the first half of that interview was successful in killing my last bit of curiosity about arguing over interpretations of QM. He talked about young physics students eager to learn about the fundamental nature of the universe and wondered that senior physicists weren't eager to engage with these issues. I was interested to hear from someone dedicating themself to this field but the resulting conversation was so boring.

Copenhagen was messy because it introduced measurement as a separate process which is inelegant. The Everett interpretation preserves linear evolution but is messy because Schrodinger's cat experiment ends up with two cats (which seems like a mischaracterisation of MWI but whatever). Bohmian mechanics is good because it doesn't have the measurement problem and that Everettian weirdness. The conceit of having both particle and wave was brushed over because he didn't feel like it was too strange.

I listened with increasing apathy to a discussion on vibes about untestable and mathematically equivalent theories and when I got home I read Scott Aaronson's post 'The Zen Anti-Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics' and knew it for the first time.

kirrent··on Qantas is bringing back Airbus A380s from the California desert
I was living in Alice during the pandemic and loved seeing all those planes whenever I was at the airport. It seemed so surreal to have A380s at this small town. It was a great place to be during covid; no lockdowns and less traffic in tourist season.

I was a member of the gliding club flying at the airstrip north of town and a member told me that they were up when one of the A380s came in. They got a call from the tower that their danger zone in the airport's class C airspace was revoked and they had to vacate. This was a bit strange not only because they usually had no trouble routing around it, but also, which airliners were flying at the moment? When it turned out to be an A380 following a different approach with far greater separation requirements it made a lot more sense.

kirrent··on Most of my skills are now worth nothing, but 10% are worth 1000x
I've been using GPT-4 ChatGPT in this style so here's my specific use case. I'm currently studying MIT's 8370 quantum information science course because my background in understanding the fundamentals of error correction is pretty poor and I need it for work.

I have a bachelors in physics but I wasn't a great maths student in university (the folly of youth) so my linear algebra could be better. On the other hand, I'm not going to redo linear algebra as a pre-requisite for this course. I also haven't done the pre-requisite QC courses, though I'm much more comfortable in that domain.

I don't use ChatGPT to teach me the concepts in the course, I use it as an empathetic tutor to fill in the blanks. If I see a linear algebra identity I'm not familiar with I can ask ChatGPT, telling it the context and what I already know and it'll give me an answer in that context with solid mathematical grounding but (because I ask for it) intuitive justifications. The alternative of stackoverflow, wikipedia, or other online notes can be hard to search for and even when I find a good answer, it's often needlessly mathy and complex. I don't have to worry about hallucination because it is just a gap and once I understand it, usually what the lecturer said makes perfect sense.

In one lecture the lecturer had a throw-away line about stabilisers corresponding to syndrome measurements but didn't elaborate much further. I didn't get how the corresponding circuit would be constructed so I went to ChatGPT and asked it my question with what I knew and the context. In that case, it pushed back and told me that what I knew was wrong. I had formed a misconception which it corrected and gave me an example to show why I was wrong.

I guess I don't use it as a lecturer, or even a tutor. I use it as the really smart guy you sit next to in a lecture theatre who you whisper questions to.

kirrent··on The end of nuclear power in Germany
Yes.
kirrent··on Rotten meat may have been a staple of Stone Age diets
You seem very confident that a human can't catch a dog on a hot day. I hate to be that person, but do you have a source for that?

I've gone running with plenty of different dogs in temperatures of above 30 degrees over the years. Smaller or stockier dogs (like a staffy) fade very fast. Within a couple of kms. Working breeds (retrievers/poodles/kelpies/collies) will leave you in their dust but this is why the endurance hunting hypothesis relies on efficient tracking while running. If they're running on the lead, especially when it's a bit hotter, they seem to lose it after about 10kms. On a cooler day these same dogs would leave me dead.

kirrent··on Electric ferry uses a long extension cord [video]
A very good question for which I haven't been able to find any official answers. Here are some thoughts: - Wear of the cable at the shore ends. Just as abseiling reduces wear on rope compared to lowering, ferry mounted drive means limited dragging across what could be possibly very abrasive surfaces at each shore (sand, rocks, etc). Instead cables get lifted up and lowered down gently. - A cable ferry pulls tension on one side allowing the other side to drop down. If you've ever navigated around a busy cable ferry you'll know that you don't wait for it to stop at either side, you just pass behind it based on current direction. To replicate this functionality you'd need motors for pulling from either side (which you've identified). In that light an electrical cable running to the centre is a quite efficient solution. - The ferry could require power anyway for a range of functions like raising and lowering the drawbridge (I wonder what the proper ferry term for this is).
kirrent··on Delaware judge discovers hidden entity recruiting people to be patent trolls
I hope you don't mind if I ask a few nosy questions.

1. How much time do you get given to perform a search? How comprehensive is searching (and how much time is given) if PCT or EP searches have already been performed?

2. Given existing citations (e.g. from a US PCT search), how long do you get to perform examination? How long do you get given for later reports?

3. How common is searching following amendments and how long do you get given?

4. How much time do you get given for further reports?

5. Do examiners do classification as an additional duty? If so, how much time do you get?

6. Have you Epoque (the EPO's search software)? If so, how does it compare to the tools you use?

kirrent··on AlphaFold developers win $3M breakthrough prize
The Norwegian Nobel Committee which selects the recipients of the peace prize doesn't have anything to do with the physics and chemistry prizes which are awarded by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences.
kirrent··on Once seen as fleeting, a new solar tech proves its lasting power
Not really. Materials and manufacturing costs for perovskite probably already beat silicon if anyone scaled up. It's efficiency and durability we're waiting on.

If you look at pricing a large solar farm you'll be surprised that the cost of modules is probably only a third of the total cost but when you reflect on land, cabling, inverters, grid connection, and installation then it's not really surprising. Given these costs, you've got an obvious incentive to buy higher efficiency modules for a small premium for savings on installation, mounting, and land use and a disincentive to buy cheap and not yet high efficiency perovskites.

This is why companies like OxfordPV are targeting tandem perovskite-silicon cells with efficiencies at 30%. Even if this costs 1.5 times as much as a 20% efficient silicon cell, it'd still bring down the price of your solar farm.

kirrent··on Electric fan car shatters the Goodwood hill climb record
Not to be too much of a pedant, but the Brabham BT46B's excuse that the majority of airflow was used for cooling did stand, which was why Lauda's one race win wasn't taken away. It was protests from other teams, Ecclestone's personal interests, and rule changes after the fact that meant it only raced that one race.
kirrent··on X-Plane 12 Flight Model Update – Supersonic Transition, Delta Wings and Mass
A bit niche, but I'd add in Condor and its excellent thermal, ridge, wave, general weather simulations which make virtual soaring satisfying. It's good enough to have races in and you can even connect your normal XCSoar device.
kirrent··on Solar-powered desalination device wins MIT $100K competition
Without knowing more about this device it's a bit hard to make a true comparison to existing marine RO devices but there are a few reasons I've been following with (skeptical) interest:

- Low volume - RO devices don't scale down well. The Katadyn 40E is the smallest watermaker I can find and it produces 6l/h. This is an insane amount of water that I have no use for. 10l a day would be enough for two people. Unfortunately there aren't cheaper and lighter options available.

- Storage - No pickling would be really nice.

- Membrane - Not needing to replace membranes would also be nice.

- Efficiency - I don't care too much about efficiency because most of the time during the day we have plenty of power from 400W of solar panels sized for days and days of cloud. That said, smaller RO devices also have poorer efficiency, e.g. 9Wh/l in the 40E. Other results in the literature suggests there could be plenty of room left to improve in efficiency from the MIT prototype.

Depending on cost, I think there's a niche for something that addresses the lower end of the market in watermakers.

kirrent··on Wireless is a trap (2020)
My wired ethernet triumph was in my current rental. There's an old under-floor evaporative air-conditioning ducted system which is no longer used. I bought a $40 remote control car with large rubber wheels and a low CoG, strapped a GoPro and a head torch to it so I could stream video to a phone, and tied on a piece of string. The mission was to get from my study to the kitchen which is about 10m all up.

It was more of a challenge than expected. The ducting had ramps, multiple corners, debris/rubbish, and a mouse skeleton to navigate around. All of this wasn't helped by the terrible latency and needing to move the phone to different places to reduce distance and attenuation through the floor. I got stuck quite a few times but could always use the string to pull back a bit when I got wedged on a rock. Sometimes I just needed to gun it to get over an obstacle.

In the end, the car and ethernet cable were cheaper than a good wireless card or POE kit, and I got to give away the car to a kid.

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →