HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kirrent

1,739 karma · joined December 9, 2015

submissionscomments
kirrent··on Esports stars have shorter careers than NFL players
For the longer careers I think you have to look into BW players. Off the top of my head Bisu might be the standout, starting in 2005 and still competing at a decently high level in ASL aged 32. Flash's career is slightly shorter, starting in 2007. He was very young so he's only 29 now, but he's still the best in the world. Even Stork (33) made a (less impressive) comeback recently and with Jaedong (32) in the last ASL, every member of TBLS can make it to ASL which is just astonishing.
kirrent··on Neural nets are not “slightly conscious,” and AI PR can do with less hype
Come on, really? You think there's a significant subset of rationalists who are quasi-Dualists? Not just people who are bog-standard materialists who are just being sloppy with language when talking about emergent conscious systems because they don't care about or actively disdain most philosophy?

On the other hand, Searle confidently states that a perfect quantum mechanical simulation of a human brain would not be conscious. This is because it somehow lacks the intentional states of the brain it's perfectly simulating. He doesn't feel the need to justify that a human mind has these states, because our daily direct experience of consciousness cannot seriously be in question. The daily direct experience of consciousness that a perfect simulation of a human brain would assert that it feels is, somehow, different and we can't trust it.

At every step in his argument there's caveats, misleading allegory, and dismissals that are so much of a stretch it seems pretty obvious he's retroactively arguing from a position that our biological conscious minds are somehow special and mystic.

kirrent··on Lock the doors: Remembering Columbia's final homecoming (2020)
The EVA suits continue to operate on only oxygen though, which makes sense given that internal suit pressure is a major challenge for manoeuvrability as was famously demonstrated by Alexei Leonov during the first spacewalk. This does mean that astronauts spacewalking from the ISS need to prebreath pure O2 to purge nitrogen for preventing the bends, a detail that was captured in the Netflix SciFi film Stowaway.
kirrent··on How the modern world arose from imaginary numbers
"That this subject [imaginary numbers] has hitherto been surrounded by mysterious obscurity, is to be attributed largely to an ill adapted notation. If, for example, +1, -1, and the square root of -1 had been called direct, inverse and lateral units, instead of positive, negative and imaginary (or even impossible), such an obscurity would have been out of the question." - Gauss
kirrent··on Heuristics that almost always work
Exactly, the post is a Scott Alexander post so he'd never object to the concept of priors. There's nothing wrong with having a strong prior that the volcano's not going to blow up this year, that it's just the wind not a break-in, or that it's most likely an ear infection with a tumour so unlikely as to not be worth the radiation risk and cost of a CT.

Really, the article is about people who don't bother to monitor the likelihood that updates their prior because the prior is so damn explanatory anyway. But, a doctor treating an ear infection isn't doing this because the act of treatment is also a test. It's not the 'did the volcano erupt' or 'did we get burgled' test with huge downsides because even if there's a serious underlying issue a week or two is unlikely to change too much. If the purported infection doesn't clear up then it's time for the doctor to update their prior and reconsider what investigations or treatment options are now appropriate. Even better than taking your history to your next doctor, keep seeing the same doctor.

kirrent··on Daddy isn’t coming back
I'd steer clear of Hari. Having listened to an interview with him I found interesting I did a fair amount of digging into the sources of his claims. Some of his claims were known and fairly uncontroversial in the medical establishment but the manner he presented them, against some straw-man of medical practice, was a bit misleading (examples - https://www.theguardian.com/science/brain-flapping/2018/jan/...). Still, that didn't worry me because I'm sure plenty of people do receive the standard of care he was arguing against. As that article above suggests, best practice care is expensive and time-consuming.

Where he really lost me was that every fascinating and surprising claim presented by him with absolute certainty that I looked into was either an exaggeration or wrong. As an example, he had a striking statistic that the modal number of friends people used to be able to rely on in an emergency was something like 4 or 5. Ten years later in the present day that number has dropped to 0. Putting aside the fact that a mode can be pretty misleading, I still thought it was an interesting difference in only ten years so I was disappointed to find that the most credible explanation in the literature seems to be that it's an artefact of survey design. Even the original paper he got the statistic from was pretty equivocal on the validity of the finding, so even if he was a bit lazy in not reading through later papers, he still should have been less confident.

I haven't read his book though. The above is just to say, caveat lector.

kirrent··on What it's like to spend 40-50 hours in VR every week
How do you block light away from the focal plane? There's been research headsets with incredibly long and convoluted indirect light paths so that an attenuation layer could be inserted at a separate focal plane. There's also out of focus attenuation layers which can be surprisingly effective. Neither seems sufficient for a consumer headset.
kirrent··on Court rules climate change “duty of care” to future generations exists
How is a federal Australian court able to pass on ruling on abortion when, in Australia, those cases relating to state law would be heard at state courts?
kirrent··on Charm delivers Stripe's carbon removal purchase ahead of schedule
For the moment, the best independent evaluator seems to be Stripe themselves. Hopefully they'll keep updating their apparently excellent evaluations:

https://stripe.com/blog/first-negative-emissions-purchases https://github.com/stripe/negative-emissions-source-material...

kirrent··on Oil companies buying up EV charging networks: Shell acquires Ubitricity
It's not so much that they continued operating. Everybody was still using their products after all and there was no alternative anyway. It's not even that they passively sat on it. It's that, in the same vein as the tobacco companies, they merchants of doubted us over the following decades, spending considerable amounts of money in questioning climate science and hindering action.
kirrent··on Is the Schrödinger Equation True?
> I haven't come across a QM book so far that explicitly (i.e. with an example) demonstrates how one morphs into the other as a variable, say size, changes.

Ehrenfest's theorem would be an example where Newton's 2nd law is recovered as the wavefunction's spatial extent is reduced on the scale of the system being studied. More generally, you won't get an explanation that shows a morphing based on size because size is not the limiting factor. It's how isolated your system can be from the outside world. This is obviously much much harder as your system gets bigger. Decoherence theory (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_decoherence) recovers classical probabilities as a system interacts with its environment.

kirrent··on Is the Schrödinger Equation True?
There's a discontinuous boundary? That's news to me. It's pretty well known that classical mechanics is reproduced by quantum mechanics in the large scale. There's no discontinuity between the two. There's also a whole heap of people competing on trying to put ever and ever larger objects in superposition. Finally, decoherence has seen plenty of study and seems to be exactly what you're lamenting the lack of.
kirrent··on John Le Carré Missed Nothing
The film is absolutely gorgeous. As one example among many, I'm blown away every time that plane gently drops down behind Esterhase and Smiley on the runway.
kirrent··on Google announces Pixel 5, Pixel 4A 5G, and Pixel 4A
They're all popular enough features for Samsung to keep making the Galaxy XCover phones.
kirrent··on The Grace of Manta Rays
Douglas Adams wrote about his experience swimming with Manta Rays in an article which is, to me, amongst his best bits of writing (https://douglasadams.com/dna/980707-08-a.html).

As a kid living on a boat on the east coast of Australia I have some happy memories of watching manta rays feed at the surface nearby. Happy once I'd realised that the wing tips silently breaking the surface weren't shark fins. They really do move absurdly gracefully, unlike anything else I've ever seen in the ocean.

kirrent··on The Incredibly Stupid One
One of my favourite facts about Jervis Bay Territory is that while:

-It is counted as part of the ACT for senate representation.

-It is part of the seat of Fenner in the ACT for the house of reps.

-It is governed under the laws of the ACT.

It is still legally a separate territory. Great for a tricky trivia question.

kirrent··on Shor's Quantum Factoring Algorithm (2017)
Just that if you have a quantum system, such as a qubit consisting of the |0> state and |1> state with a combination over the two (called a superposition) represented by a|0> + b|1> then a and b can be complex. This is in contrast to classical mechanics where, for example, pr(heads) and pr(tails) must both be real.

It's only once it comes to actually making a measurement that you need to get real again.

kirrent··on A free introduction to quantum computing and quantum mechanics
Of course they are. By design the flash cards are small atomic pieces of knowledge that can be answered simply. If the grand overarching concept is a web of interconnecting ideas, then the flashcards are supposed to help you maintain that by making sure you don't forget the small ideas the structure is made of.

It's also by design that some of the questions are, as you say, laughably simple. It's to catch people who aren't properly engaging with the text as early as possible.

Nielsen and Matuschak are sensible to these sorts of critiques. Quantum country is part experiment after all and they've been learning, adjusting, and experimenting with what works best. If you want a bit of context of where they've come from and where they want to go, I recommend this: https://numinous.productions/ttft/

kirrent··on A day using money in Cuba
The name for this effect where people try to hoard the more valuable currency is Gresham's law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gresham%27s_law
kirrent··on Dolphins at popular spot miss tourists and keep leaving 'gifts' on shore
I've sailed with dolphins plenty of times. They've tended to lose interest when I was on a windsurfer or dinghy after a minute or so, no matter what speed I was doing. On the other hand, when I've been on a cruising cat, they can't seem to get enough. As long as you stay over 7 knots under sail they'll follow along apparently having great fun, particularly around and between the bows. I've even seen a large pod travelling in one direction hook a U-turn when they saw the boat to play for ten minutes before heading back in their original direction.

All of this is to say what everyone else is saying. They're complex creatures with sometimes non-trivial motivations.

kirrent··on SpaceX's Starship became NASA's ace in the hole to get to the moon by 2024
It's hard to work out the actual cost of each SLS. Especially when you're trying to take development costs into account. The lowest sensible estimate I've seen is $3 billion, but if you amortise development costs over ten launches it could be higher than $5 billion a launch. A Falcon Heavy in expendable mode can be had for $150 million, and NASA paid no development costs. So, between 20 and 35ish times more expensive (assuming nothing much more goes wrong for SLS), and Falcon Heavy is already flying.
kirrent··on Facebook, Google to be forced to share ad revenue with Australian media
You might as well say "what any government who is trying to enforce revenue transfers from spotify and youtube to their local musicians is trying to do is called a state-funded music". "What anybody who is trying to enforce revenue transfers from cinemas to local movie studios is trying to do is called a state funded film industry". "What any government who is trying to enforce revenue transfers from carbon emitting power generators to renewable generators in the form of a carbon credit is trying to do is called a state funded clean energy system."

Oftentimes governments seek to redress one party whose work is being taken advantage of by another party whether that's from a principle of fairness, a desire to maintain the health of both parties, more mercenary reasons, etc. Doing this outside of the narrow regime of taxes and subsidies is not only not uncommon. It's entirely normal.

Also, it's worth mentioning that the most trusted media organisation in Australia is state funded so it can't be that much of a bad look.

kirrent··on A review of Thomas Piketty’s “Capital and Ideology”
That seems like a little bit of a cherry picked article to support your point. Scrolling through the front page of that website the top article is an opinion piece by Joe Biden which writes about the importance of supporting young people and those out of work:

"So we need to make sure that our economic recovery does not come at the expense of those who can least afford it or who are just getting started in life: Hard-working young people in service industries and retail that are being decimated by layoffs; all those who are hustling to make a living in the gig economy, and those who were already struggling to get by before this crisis, who are drowning in credit card debt or student loans, and who now are in even greater need of a lifeline."

When I scroll further down the page I can see a fundraiser for readers to support "people and communities who are more vulnerable and need extra support during this time" including the National Domestic Workers Alliance, Restaurant Workers Community Foundation, and One Fair Wage. Apparently readers and podcast listeners have contributed about $650 000 which at least from an Australian perspective seems non-trivial.

Finally, one of their most recent articles (I'm going through the articles because I'm not going to listen to the podcasts) on the politics of a pandemic titled "How Democrats Should Navigate Pandemic Politics" talks about the importance of directly supporting workers including with "paid-leave provision that’s much bigger than the one the White House watered down in the initial House bill, along with a broad Emergency Unemployment Insurance provision".

I can't reconcile all this stuff with being blind to it. It looks like the founders of this site were in the white house while the medicaid expansion was passed which, at least from an outside perspective, seems to be the most important legislation of the past few decades for the poorer working class.

Even that article you linked to doesn't seem like a damning indictment. If you read it a bit more closely it's at least partially a joke article where the writer talks about the resilience of the human spirit while writing on the walls in lipstick, getting gum in her hair, and napping in the middle of sentences. If it was a manifesto of values I'd agree with you that a lack of focus on unemployed people undergoing hardship would be notable, but it's not. It's just a joke.

kirrent··on Ask HN: How are you preparing for COVID-19 disruptions?
If only earthquake modelling was so simple as to say you were overdue for an earthquake simply based on accumulated stress. Unfortunately, the Gutenberg-Richter law is not prescriptive, but a time independent statistical observation which assumes independent events, which is why saying you're due for another one is very much like gambler's fallacy. Of course we know that there are underlying physical processes which make means there should be some underlying dependence to be found, and there are attempts at time-dependent models out there, but for our purposes independence works.

If you're interested in the statistics around recurrence times, can I recommend this [1]? It's fairly well written and clear and it deals with this issue fairly comprehensively and directly.

[1] - http://www.crm.cat/en/About/People/Researchers/ACorral/Docum...

kirrent··on Scientists use ML to find an antibiotic able to kill superbugs in mice
At least one disincentive is that if you do find an amazing new antibiotic effective against certain strains of antibiotic resistant bacteria, antibiotic stewardship means the medical community will try and use it only where necessary to slow any adaptation to the new drug. That makes your potential patient population much smaller.
kirrent··on No visas for low-skilled workers, UK government says
I assume these tradeoffs you're thinking of might be proroguing parliament for political intent, purging anyone Cummings can't dominate from the cabinet, withdrawing the whip from anyone wanting to vote their conscience, attacking the independence of the judiciary any time it finds the government has acted illegally, and expelling journalists from the lobby for unfavourable coverage? It's a pity such tradeoffs are inevitable (if you exclude all previous governments from both sides of politics).

Snark aside, I think your comment is a useful example of a kind of patriotic (or dislike of international orders in general) motivated reasoning. Is the population of natives (perhaps citizens/residents would have fewer negative connotations?) really willing to bear costs and risks? It's a bit hard to know when there's been so much noise on the potential financial upsides/downsides of leaving the EU. Will people become more welcoming when freedom of movement is ended or does insularity have other costs? These are hard questions with difficult answers and patriotic optimism is no substitute. I'm certainly not prepared for you to assert anything about the cabinet being promising without proper justification.

All in all, I hope you're right. As far as I can tell the evidence is against you, but people survive falls from aeroplanes so stranger things have happened.

kirrent··on SpaceX launches more Starlink satellites, misses booster landing
Yes, but you're already bandwidth constrained when getting grib files through a satphone which often means using coarser grids over a smaller area (constraining your options) less frequently. Not the largest limitation, but better bandwidth would be useful.

As you point out, it's largely a value judgement between worldwide fast internet and ground based optical astronomy and it's one I'm conflicted about. I comfort myself with the thought that because of the expense these constellations either will bring internet access to large numbers of people justifying continuing satellite replacement or they'll fail and the satellites will be gone sooner rather than later, but as I say, I'm conflicted.

kirrent··on SpaceX launches more Starlink satellites, misses booster landing
I used to live on a boat. It'd be nice to have access to the internet when I do so again even coastally. I can't even imagine how much of a boon getting internet access across an ocean would be. Not only to help with boredom, but also to get heaps of up to date weather observation and prediction data to do routing.
kirrent··on Battle of Alesia
"laying the groundwork for his eventual emperorship".

Worth pointing out that Julius Caesar was never emperor and its difficult to say that he really aspired to such a position. Yes, he was dictator for life but Sulla had fairly recently been appointed dictator with no time limit applied so that wasn't without precedent. Working out what could have happened of he hadn't been assassinated is difficult. Did he take on many of the trappings of a king? Yes. Did he seem to try and avoid that same perception, such as with the crown at Lupercalia? Also yes. Whatever he was though, he certainly was not emperor.

kirrent··on Patent: Electronic flashcards (2013)
And, don't read patent application publications and mistake them for patent publications. The USPTO labels the granted publication with a B after the number. In this case, the granted patent (https://patents.google.com/patent/US8595637B2/) has seen amendments to the claims during examination before grant.
← PreviousPage 3 of 14Next →