HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kklimonda

330 karma · joined March 16, 2010

submissionscomments
kklimonda··on Append-only backups with restic and rclone
With borg, make sure that you read and considered drawbacks of the append-only mode: https://borgbackup.readthedocs.io/en/stable/usage/notes.html... I'm curious whether restic's append-only fares better here.
kklimonda··on Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
So this is yet another comments thread where I see numerous people not agreeing with OSI definition of "Open Source" and it got me wondering again, has there always been such a sentiment, or is it a recent one? I don't recall seeing it as much even a couple of years ago. Has there been some anti-OSI movement, and if so is there somewhere I could read about arguments against OSI? It seems most comments seem to be boiling down to "you are not going to tell me what I can do" but that's perhaps unfair.
kklimonda··on Affirmation of the Open Source Definition
Reading through new licenses, and getting them approved by your legal departament isn't fun to anyone, plus some licenses are very subtly non-free - see the JSON license with its "do no evil" clause as an example.
kklimonda··on Ask HN: Should I tell my colleagues there's a plan to make them redundant?
I can't tell you how to handle this, and I have never been in a similar situation before (closest being having to disable accounts for the other person on my team) but here are two thoughts:

Firstly, You don't know for sure what will the client do - with a high probability they will do just like you've said, but I'm not sure it is your obligation to force their hand so to speak, by making that possibility public. Also, if you decide to proceed with telling your coworkers I'd first think whether your employer can accuse you of disclosing what, in their mind, may be confidential information - you're part of the organisation, and "I found it by accident" may not be a strong enough argument to protect yourself from getting reprimended or even fired.

However, I think what's more important in your case is your wife's insistence on you not telling anyone. If I were in your shoes I'd probably try talking to her some more, explaining how not telling your coworkers is affecting your wellbeing, and that will probably become a bigger issue the closer to the April deadline it gets, as your uncertainty grows. I’d even suggest that you together talk with some close and trusted friends, or even a professional, to try and make some sense out of the situation. If you can't reach an agreement, I'd probably suggest siding with your wife - the knowledge you've acquired, while somewhat heavy, is nowhere heavy enough to put it over your own family.

In the end, I can only share my sympathy - It's not an enviable place to find oneself in. I just hope that, whatever you decide, you’ll be able to make peace with that and move on.

kklimonda··on MongoDB removed from RHEL 8 beta due to license
> Discriminating against such uses doesn't seem wrong to me since they clearly harm the creators and maintainers in their effort to actually make some income from the project

It may not be wrong, but it does stand in opposition to the definition of Open Source and Free Software (at least as defined by bodies that RedHat and many others see as authoritative on that subject).

So perhaps we could call MongoDB what it is - a proprietary software with shared code license that lets you run their code for free in some scenarios. I think that wouldn't sell to the investors and VCs as well as open source though, and would make it harder to build a community around.

And then we haven't even touched on the CLA required to make contributions to the project - I have no idea how many people and companies contributed changes or fixes to MongoDB, but they must be pretty happy right now.

Does that mean you can't have a business built around an open source project? It does seem that way to me, especially if we talk about something that scales in a number of employees and revenue. I do think that you could bootstrap a small, consultancy-style business, built around your open source technology, but definitely not something that VCs would drool over.

Also, on a related note, I'd like to add something that's rough around the edges and I'm sure someone else could make a much better case of it, but well, here I go.

There has always been a discussion on Free Software vs. Open Source [1] where the advocates of Free Software are arguing that Open Source does not protect freedom of the users (and communities) while Open Source advocates opposed that view with argument that Open Source is even more free and pure than Free Software. In my opinion, the recent changes made by MongoDB, Redis Labs [2] and even Elastic [3] show that without ethics backing the movement, the movement itself is in danger of having its core believes changed. If some software can't be made in a spirit of Free Software (or even Open Source) then perhaps it should be made as proprietary software with shared code license - it's not as cool, and perhaps will make the adoption harder, but at least it's more sincere.

[1] For example, see Stallman's "Why Open Source misses the point of Free Software" article https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point....

[2] Calling their non-free licenses "Apache-2 + Common Clause" is a pretty disingenuous move, and the only reason why I see it less bad than what Mongo did being the fact that it only affects a subset of previously-closed extensions IIRC.

[3] Their announcement on x-pack did not call it open source, however the entire press release was full of "open source" this and "open source" - it felt like they tried really hard to ride the Open Source train without actually riding it.

kklimonda··on Making Bluetooth Work on Lenovo X1 Carbon 6th Gen with Linux
Well, by engaging with the community and perhaps even preparing a patch. Making changes to the distribution is not exactly arcane knowledge.
kklimonda··on Open source confronts its midlife crisis
When you say "everything else just pales" do you mean that licenses/subscriptions are the only viable options to make sure you don't go out of business, or are they the only option to justify multi-billion evaluations and multi-million investment rounds?
kklimonda··on Benchmark results of Kubernetes network plugins over 10Gb/s network
Was calico ipip encapsulation enabled or disabled?
kklimonda··on Ditching the MacBook Pro for a MacBook Air
I've switched from Linux (Thinkpad X240) to macOS (Macbook Pro 2015, and now 2018) because of those small issues [1]. However, nowadays I feel like your experience with Linux laptop really depends on what kind of work you are doing, and how often do you have to interact with 3rd party tools. I've been primarily desktop Linux user for something like 13 years before switching to Mac, and those small issues had only become a problem once I've started encountering them on a daily basis.

[1] For me issues were mostly interaction with random conference software and screen sharing (e.g. webex), or random hangs when connecting external displays (e.g. doing a presentation before CTO).

kklimonda··on Why There Will Never Be Another RedHat: The Economics of Open Source (2014)
But Canonical (and I assume SuSE as well) has quite a few proprietary bits (definitely more than RedHat), with some of their offerings being more or less "Open Core" (for examples, see comparison of MAAS free vs commercial, or how to distribute software to Ubuntu Core systems). That kinda matches what the article is saying.
kklimonda··on China systematically hijacks internet traffic: researchers
How does one use Tor without the internet?
kklimonda··on Topicbox – FastMail’s new product for teams
It's pretty good, especially after I've trained it with enough spam & ham emails to turn on its personal ruleset - probably not as good as Google spam filter, but at least I have some visibility into why given message was misclassified.
kklimonda··on OpenSSL Security Advisory
Why is it a joke? It has always been a case that Canonical will backport security patches and critical bugfixes, rather than updating the entire package to the latest upstream version. On the other hand, Ubuntu Backports is community project, and your snarkiness is unwarranted - as long as no one cares enough to backport and keep maintaining the backport, it won't be done.
kklimonda··on A Unikernel Firewall for QubesOS
I don't think Firewall VM is trimmed in any way, compared to their standard VMs, so it's running a lot of "cruft" [1] - Xorg, systemd and friends, extra Qubes plumbing. It all adds up to ~200MB, and then the rest is used by buffers/cache.

[1] at least on 3.1-RCx I have running, where I had to create Firewall VM manually, as installer has failed to deploy those "service VMs".

kklimonda··on Best Linux server backup system?
How are you backing up VMs? Using some kind of hypervisor API, or just run bacula file in VMs themselves?
kklimonda··on Atom.io build for linux
Have you tried logging in, using the link at the bottom of the page?
kklimonda··on Ubuntu Edge
It is a Fixed Funding project so if they don't gather the entire sum it won't get funded.
kklimonda··on Ubuntu Edge
What are the practical drawbacks of using libhybris? Have there been some benchmarks done yet?
kklimonda··on Ubuntu Edge
Maybe [1], but then Canonical is aiming at getting Ubuntu into as many phones as possible, and it working with the Android stack is helping in achieving this goal.

[1] On the other hand what would be a benefit of investing into getting drivers work with glibc, other than running your classic Linux distribution?

kklimonda··on Ubuntu Edge
bionic with libhybris
kklimonda··on Ubuntu 13.10 to ship with Mir instead of X
There is a good link below with some technical rationale (I think the most important part, at least according to Canonical developers, is "Server Allocated Buffers in Mir"), but I'm actually wondering - has Wayland officially added the support for working on the Android graphics stack? There has been at least two proof-of-concept projects, but I don't see either of them being actually committed to the Wayland repository. Given that Canonical is working against the clock it's not that surprising that they are going with their own solution - they obviously believe that they can get it working faster.
kklimonda··on Ubuntu 13.04: Getting Excited About Ubuntu Again
To be fair Canonical is using their servers as proxy so the data can be anonymized before it's sent forward to Amazon.
kklimonda··on I'm not too happy about Sublime Text 3
I'm kinda baffled that in every discussion that mentions ST3 upgrade and lack of bug fixes for ST2 words like "entitlement" are showing in the discussion. There has always been an implicit agreement between software developers and customers that they are at least put effort into fixing bugs and releasing those fixes as non-paid point releases. If the rules are changing (I'm not saying that they are, but comments like this seem to suggest that) then maybe software developers should state clearly on their page that they are not planning on releasing free bug-fix updates. It seems like something I'd like to know before I actually pay for software.

Some people are commenting that ST2 works great for them, and they don't see any bugs, but AFAIR in the ST3 announcement comment thread on HN someone has been writing on how he had to work around crasher in ST2 that has not been fixed after ST2 stable release.

kklimonda··on PEP 427 – The Wheel Binary Package Format 1.0
Hmm... How is it different from binary eggs?
kklimonda··on Systemd: The Biggest Myths
I remember watching this video and Poettering's argument were very sound and he has managed to repel most (if not all) Draxinger's points.

The problem with "it's not the UNIX way" argument is that a lot of people don't care about UNIX that much, they just want a good system. Poettering mentions in that video that all his, and his colleagues' work (pulseaudio, consolekit, udev into udisks/upower) has been done because there was an actual demand for those features. There is a reason why most distributions use their work even as people complain about them.

kklimonda··on Chrome Beta channel for phones and tablets on Android 4.0+
> - The much touted smart resizing of text is still completely broken. It still semi-randomly decides that particular bits of text on a page are unimportant [...]

Is this the reason why some HN comments are displayed using a smaller font than the rest of them? I always thought it had something to do with their score..

EDIT:

> - The edges of the screen are still wasted on the useless unsymmetric tab switching gestures.

Tab switching seems to be affected by your phone case.. when I removed mine from S3 it worked perfectly, but with it I can never reliably switch tabs.

kklimonda··on Canonical announces Ubuntu for smartphones
Chrome for Android does the same (you can change tabs by swiping left-right), and it's very unreliable - I manage to change tabs by accident by swiping, but can never do that on purpose...
kklimonda··on Without Babies, Can Japan Survive?
It's not about the number of people, but the age distribution. In 2100 half of the Japanese may be over 65 years old, and it definitely wasn't the case in 1920.
kklimonda··on GNOME (et al): Rotting In Threes
> Why would the windows manager be a "brand", rather than the distribution? (Red Hat, Ubuntu). But GNOME developers are not content with being just a middle man that distributions tear apart to take what they want. That's why they are burning a lot of cycles on making GNOME into an OS by itself.
kklimonda··on The Mac App Store Needs Paid Upgrades
Hmm.. this actually looks like developer is going to start making less money the moment they release the first feature pack. To make things fair to users [1] you have to start selling base version for less money at some point to ensure that the full price of the application stays the same, but if you do that you have no guarantees that people will buy "feature packs" - actually it's guaranteed that not everyone will buy those so you will get less money than you would if you could just stop selling version 1.0 and start selling version 2.0 for the same price (and provide an upgrade path for existing users)

EDIT: clarified a bit

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →