HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

klelatti

10,089 karma · joined May 1, 2020

Writing a newsletter about computer history at thechipletter.substack.com
submissionscomments
klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
> But this doesn't answer the question as to where firms go if they want to license a core rather than design in-house

My original comment. Qualcomm won't be doing this. Or at least not for a fee that is in any way comparable to what Arm charges.

klelatti··on SiFive: The road ahead (post layoffs)
That sounds like a very fair comparison. And to be clear I was referring to SiFive's credibility in the comment above and not yours!
klelatti··on SiFive: The road ahead (post layoffs)
It might be cheaper but licensing costs = 0 does not imply that, which is what your original statement said.
klelatti··on SiFive: The road ahead (post layoffs)
Sorry I take all these SiFive claims with a huge pinch of salt since they did this, comparing 7nm vs 10nm:

https://twitter.com/dylan522p/status/1415395415000817664

Great way to undermine your credibility.

klelatti··on SiFive: The road ahead (post layoffs)
They have also just signed a new long term contract with Arm.
klelatti··on SiFive: The road ahead (post layoffs)
This seems to assume that development of ISAs is done for free, which is not the case.

When a firm pays Arm a licensing fee for the Arm ISA that fee helps support the development of the Arm ISA.

When someone who works for SiFive or Tenstorrent etc works on the development of the RISC-V ISA, they are being paid and those costs will be recovered through the price paid for the products they sell. Others may use the ISA at zero cost but someone is paying.

Now you could argue that costs will be lower in aggregate because of greater competition, but the cost isn't zero in total.

klelatti··on SiFive: The road ahead (post layoffs)
That's not my interpretation.
klelatti··on SiFive: The road ahead (post layoffs)
> RISC-V ecosystem growth slowing down? No.

Or (their business) not growing as rapidly as they planned or expected and so they have fallen short on their own financial projections and need to adjust.

Need to be careful not to conflate SiFive with RISC-V (despite the best efforts of this blog post to do so). They have made their own decisions as to where to compete and that may or may not be the right strategy.

SiFive's success or otherwise has implications for RISC-V but RISC-V being a success doesn't imply SiFive will be.

klelatti··on SiFive: The road ahead (post layoffs)
It's interesting that that they are arguing strongly (vs Qualcomm) for retaining an approach in the ISA that probably requires macro-op fusion - whilst holding at least one patent that relates to macro-op fusion.
klelatti··on SiFive: The road ahead (post layoffs)
Leaving aside the insensitivity of this post towards laid-off staff - which is bad enough - it doesn't actually tell current / prospective customers what has changed about SiFive's business and products.

Clearly something has, but this provides no real clues. Completely counterproductive. But all is good as SiFive will revolutionize computing in ways we have not yet begun to imagine!

klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
> Free to sell pre-made cores

You do know that Arm makes a tiny amount on each core licensed and that none of the firms you mention will have any interest in that business model. If they’ve spent a lot of money on a competitive design they will not be handing to competitors for peanuts.

klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
Sorry, this completely misses the point that many firms don't want to design their own CPUs, which is why Arm became so successful in the first place.
klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
We all get a bit hyperbolic at times! Yes, I'm sure it's a lot less than most customers pay.

I remember the WD announcement. They have open sourced the cores now I think. If you're shipping millions of drives those fees will add up.

klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
Badly wounded, maybe?!
klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
Update from SiFive via Ian Cutress. Looks like 20% of employees are being laid off.

https://x.com/IanCutress/status/1716921169553887296?s=20

klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
No. Now at Modular.
klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
It wouldn’t kill Arm. They would still license their own cores.
klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
Arm's case isn't about the ISA, it's about use of IP developed by Nuvia with help from Arm under Nuvia's Arm license being used in a way that isn't compatible with the terms of Nuvia's license.

IANAL but I'd be astonished if they get away with that IP making its way into RISC-V designs, if Arm win.

Plus, they won't have anything RISC-V based available in anywhere near the required timescales. They're still arguing about the ISA after all!

klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
Thanks for the correction / clarification. I agree 2016-2021 isn't really a long time!

Of course the Qualcomm's use of Nuvia cores is subject to the ongoing legal case so it's difficult to see how that will work out.

klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
But this doesn't answer the question as to where firms go if they want to license a core rather than design in-house. Arm grew in large part because firms decided that designing CPUs cores wasn't a central competency and Arm would do a better job. And for a long time even a firm with the resources of Qualcomm couldn't outperform Arm.

Maybe (say) Tenstorrent will take up the mantle but just saying that 'the industry will drive it' doesn't really describe how Arm gets replaced.

klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
It was very clear that they meant nothing at all.

> Apple pays nothing, because they do not license ARM cores in any way, instead having a full royalty-free license for ARM ISA (and afaik covering updates too) since before ARM got big.

klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
This isn’t true. Apple paid licence fees for the very first ARM Ltd processors - ARM would have had no income if they hadn’t.

And there is no way that any company gets a ‘forever’ and ‘all future IP’ license just because they had an early shareholding.

klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
But what would they be buying? The ISA is free. A few designs without the engineering teams that built them? Doesn’t seem that attractive.
klelatti··on The risk of RISC-V: What's going on at SiFive?
Just to add that Qualcomm have also proposed a new extension that will help keep code size down without using the C extension. It includes new load/store addressing modes, pre-post increment load/stores and load/store pairs amongst others.

It would seem to take RISC-V closer to AArch64 in approach?

klelatti··on A Brief Introduction to Military Pillboxes
Sorry for being a bit pedantic! Just think it's interesting that ITV did some good stuff in those years. TBF I think the BBC showed it later on (in the 2000s?)
klelatti··on A Brief Introduction to Military Pillboxes
The World at War is fantastic, but it wasn’t made by the BBC. Rather it was made by one of the companies, Thames Television, that owned one of the UK’s commercial franchises in the 1970s and broadcast across the ITV commercial network.

It’s worth sampling if only for Laurence Olivier’s narration.

There is a similar BBC made series about WW1 which is almost equally good called The Great War

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_War_(TV_series)

klelatti··on Microwatt: A tiny Open POWER ISA softcore written in VHDL 2008
Many thanks! Yes, all fits together.

By complete co-incidence I have a blog post on the various Mac CPU transitions in draft that should be out tomorrow.

One mildly amusing point, which I don't think is mentioned in either link is that the Cognac project was so called because the surname of John Hennessy, of Stanford RISC and MIPS fame, is also, of course, the name of a brand of Cognac.

klelatti··on Microwatt: A tiny Open POWER ISA softcore written in VHDL 2008
Interesting and surprising! Is there a source for this?

There seems to have been a lot of work on emulation by Gary Davidian from an early stage - starting with the AMD 29000 then 88k and then finally on PowerPC - according to his CHM oral history.

klelatti··on Why a bale of straw is hanging from the Millennium Bridge
The bridge will also be losing hundreds of tiny works of art painted on chewing gum by one man over the last two decades.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-england-london-67083141

klelatti··on SiFive Rolls Out RISC-V Cores Aimed at Generative AI and ML
> It seems they are trying to slap a riscv decoder with a minimum amount of work.

This doesn’t make sense to me. I thought that one of the selling points of the C extension was that it was a minimal amount of work to add to the decoder.

← PreviousPage 11 of 34Next →