HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

klelatti

10,089 karma · joined May 1, 2020

Writing a newsletter about computer history at thechipletter.substack.com
submissionscomments
klelatti··on How to fit a large program into a small machine (1980)
Thanks so much! It's a really interesting design.
klelatti··on Lotus 1-2-3 For Linux
Are you contesting that it was more approachable? I didn’t say the Spectrum was more interesting - it definitely wasn’t!
klelatti··on Lotus 1-2-3 For Linux
The simpler hardware of the Spectrum was much more approachable. And the basic was so slow that you really had to learn some Z80 assembly!
klelatti··on How to fit a large program into a small machine (1980)
I was surprised to find that a VM was used in the Busicom calculator that was the motivation for and first use of the Intel 4004 microprocessor.

Wrote about it here:

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/bytecode-and-the-busico...

klelatti··on Projects Innovating Around RISC-V
Author here. As noted elsewhere this originally had a paywall in the middle but I’ve removed it for the time being. Hope the extra projects are of interest.
klelatti··on Zen 5's Leaked Slides
Your definition of ‘push’ here is make compulsory - which doesn’t make sense in the context anyway.

I’ll leave others to judge if the quoted paper pushes it and move on.

klelatti··on Zen 5's Leaked Slides
> Yet, it does not push macro-op fusion in implementations

Yes it does. It pushes it as an alternative to adding instructions to the ISA. It says we don’t need these extra instructions because architects can use macro-op fusion to remove the penalty associated with having two instructions rather than one.

klelatti··on Zen 5's Leaked Slides
Seriously? You weren’t aware of this?

The Renewed Case for the Reduced Instruction Set Computer: Avoiding ISA Bloat with Macro-Op Fusion for RISC-V

https://people.eecs.berkeley.edu/~krste/papers/EECS-2016-130...

klelatti··on Zen 5's Leaked Slides
That’s such a strange criticism given how keen the designers of RISC-V have been to push macro-op fusion.
klelatti··on Slovenia’s beautiful beehives turn apiaries into art
About twenty years ago I hosted a group of business visitors from Slovenia in the U.K. and was surprised to receive a beehive panel as a ‘thank you’ at the end of the meeting. It was a lovely gift and I still have the panel.
klelatti··on Arm’s Cortex A510: Two Kids in a Trench Coat
Thanks so much for a super helpful reply!
klelatti··on Arm’s Cortex A510: Two Kids in a Trench Coat
On a slight tangent, as you've worked on both Arm and RISC-V cores, could you comment on how the two ISAs compare from a design standpoint? How much more complexity does designing for an ISA like ARM64 add when compared to a more 'purist' RISC design like RISC-V? Many thanks!
klelatti··on What is RISC-V, and why we're unlocking its potential
> Qualcomm sent them ~$270m last fiscal year > ARM is pushing them away > “tens of millions” in Qualcomm’s telling > ARM “winning” this case looks like losing to me.

I'm sorry, this is once again a very one sided portrayal of this case. Qualcomm is utterly reliant on Arm's technology and if - as you admit is a possibility - Qualcomm has materially breached its licenses in a way that is detrimental to Arm's interests, Arm is supposed to say 'fine, please go ahead'? Of course not!

klelatti··on What is RISC-V, and why we're unlocking its potential
> a terrible idea

Well you’re not really holding off judgment then! It’s also a terrible idea to let big customers breach their contracts but as you say we haven’t seen the contracts concerned.

klelatti··on What is RISC-V, and why we're unlocking its potential
> on the idea that Qualcomm did not get the same rights as Nuvia had to use Arm’s designs

The point being that they wanted the rights Nuvia had but without the obligations that Nuvia license implies - most specifically on fees.

And yes they have an architecture license but no the lawsuit is still open.

klelatti··on What is RISC-V, and why we're unlocking its potential
Qualcomm took the first step in this case by trying to sell Nuvia derived designs under their own license agreement. Whoever wins it’s not really Arm going on the ‘attack’ if there is a reasonable case that the license has been breached.
klelatti··on What is RISC-V, and why we're unlocking its potential
> For a product developer, it eliminates the issue of being tied to the limited portfolio of cores available from a proprietary ISA.

Hmmm this is the same Qualcomm that had an Arm architecture license for years and ended up using off the shelf Arm cores?

klelatti··on Arm IPO to kick off today
> Apple holds a rare Architecture license to the ARM ISA due to their role as a founding partner, and can make original implementations without incurring licensing dues

Sorry, the architecture license wasn’t a thing when Arm was founded and there is no way that Arm would hand out free licenses at a later date. It’s just a myth.

klelatti··on Arm IPO to kick off today
They have an architectural license (for Arm v8/9) because they are a huge customer with deep pockets not because of a shareholding they sold a decade before that architecture was announced!
klelatti··on Arm IPO to kick off today
> renamed Acorn Electron

Actually renamed Acorn Proton. Electron came later.

klelatti··on Inmos and the Transputer – Parallel Ventures
That's great - thanks for sharing!
klelatti··on Inmos and the Transputer – Parallel Ventures
That’s really interesting- thanks so much.
klelatti··on Inmos and the Transputer – Parallel Ventures
Hi everyone, author here. Just to note that this is just Part 1 of a multi-part series.

I’d love to cover some of the real world applications of Transputers in Part 2 so please share if you think of interest.

klelatti··on Arm Announces Public Filing for Proposed Initial Public Offering
Fair enough, but I don’t see how this supports her thinking the internet was a fad not worth investing in.

Also it denies agency to those in power in the decades that followed. I mean did that decision bind the policymakers that followed when it became clear how important the internet really was?

klelatti··on Arm Announces Public Filing for Proposed Initial Public Offering
Ah, the Apple has a perpetual royalty free license meme. Almost certainly a myth.

Very, very unlikely anyone would get a perpetual license that covers all future products just because they were a founding shareholder.

I did some detective work on this a while ago for my newsletter (link in bio) from behind the paywall:

> … Apple and Acorn were paying royalty fees soon after they founded the company why should that change to grant Apple a royalty-free license at some point later?

klelatti··on Arm Announces Public Filing for Proposed Initial Public Offering
I think in many ways Arm is (or should be) a sort of large 'Mittelstand' [1] business. Long term focus, independence, customer focus etc are key to the success of this type of business.

Trouble is, its success and its sector has given it a profile that attracts attention from the likes of Softbank who have other ideas. A company doesn't need to have a Nvidia like P/E ratio to be successful.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mittelstand

klelatti··on Arm Announces Public Filing for Proposed Initial Public Offering
> But the Nvidia + ARM combo made sense from a technical and strategic standpoint though.

Made sense for Nvidia. Not for other Arm customers.

klelatti··on Arm Announces Public Filing for Proposed Initial Public Offering
> the UK is by far the best country in the EU

The UK is no longer in the EU. Quite a significant point!

klelatti··on Arm Announces Public Filing for Proposed Initial Public Offering
No fan of Thatcher, but she left power before the world-wide-web even left CERN.
klelatti··on ARM’s Neoverse N2: Cortex A710 for Servers
I sense a degree of disappointment, both in the article and in some of the comments here, that Arm hasn’t made more rapid progress in getting competitive server CPUs to market.

It’s clearly not the instruction set architecture. I wonder if the problem is that Arm’s business model makes it hard to justify the investment needed given the licensing fees they feel they can charge.

My reading between the lines on Nuvia was that Arm was looking to make more on Nuvia cores and providing Nuvia with substantial help. But Qualcomm broke into the party.

Happy to be told I’m wrong though.

← PreviousPage 12 of 34Next →