HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

klelatti

10,089 karma · joined May 1, 2020

Writing a newsletter about computer history at thechipletter.substack.com
submissionscomments
klelatti··on NeXT Computers
The 68030 does look like a curious choice for a machine launched in 1988.

Wikipedia says that they considered the Motorola 88000 but with a source that I've not been able to track down.

klelatti··on AMD promises its new laptop chips will crush the Apple M2 and it’s got receipts
Also pretty implausible in 1990 say that Arm would be the highest performing surviving RISC architecture [1].

[1] yes, I know ARM64 looks nothing like the ARM ISA of 1990.

klelatti··on The RISC Wars Part 1: The Cambrian Explosion
Hi thanks so much for editing the comment. Much appreciated.

Completely agree with your succinct summary of the what RISC is all about and the 801's place in the story. I've heard others call Cray's CDC's computers the first RISC designs, which I don't think is quite right. Probably deserves a fuller explanation than I can manage here though!

klelatti··on The RISC Wars Part 1: The Cambrian Explosion
Author here. Thanks for the comment and feedback. Really interesting point on MIPS vs RISC-I approaches.

I was a bit puzzled by the IBM 801 comment as the second para of the previous post mentions the 801 and links to an earlier post that is all about the 801. Was there something you think I missed in these earlier posts?

klelatti··on British public support for monarchy at historic low, poll reveals
Largely agree but your wording is interesting - ‘generally considered’, ‘staying out of politics publicly’.

I think that there has been a degree of constructive ambiguity in the past. No more and it’s 100% clear now that the King / Queen would rubber stamp even the most extreme legislation. With FPTP, weaknesses in Lords appointments system, no written constitution etc then that’s a big weakness.

klelatti··on British public support for monarchy at historic low, poll reveals
In my view the elephant in the room is that the monarchy in the UK has demonstrably failed to be a check or balance on a party with a majority in Parliament.

Without a written constitution there is no limit on what a party with a majority in Parliament - which it can an achieve with a relatively small share of the vote - can do. Not a healthy situation.

klelatti··on CISC-y RISC-ness
Seems unlikely.

'RISC I: A Reduced Instruction Set VLSI Computer' appeared in May 81

https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.5555/800052.801895

(and of course the original RISC paper was even earlier in 1980)

The iAPX 432 paper in June 82:

https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/641542.641545

I should add that I only skimmed the 432 paper for references so I might be wrong on that!

klelatti··on UK Blocks Microsoft’s $69B Activision Deal
You can make these points without insulting the country. He’s not winning any friends with language like this.
klelatti··on CISC-y RISC-ness
And of course David Patterson did a take down of the performance of the 432 (which curiously doesn’t seem to mention RISC).

https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/641542.641545

klelatti··on UK Blocks Microsoft’s $69B Activision Deal
From the FT:

Activision, maker of the hit game Call of Duty, said the ruling “contradicts the ambitions of the UK to become an attractive country to build technology businesses”. It labelled the decision a “disservice to UK citizens, who face increasingly dire economic prospects”, adding: “the UK is clearly closed for business.”

What a petulant response.

klelatti··on UK Blocks Microsoft’s $69B Activision Deal
Sorry file a lawsuit on what grounds?

You seem to be under the impression that large firms can just ignore the laws of the countries they do business in. That’s not how it works.

klelatti··on LVMH becomes the first European company to surpass $500B in market value
> mostly made in sweatshops outside of Europe

Would you like to provide a link to support this claim in your OP rather than links about Europe or supply chain transparency.

klelatti··on RISC on a Chip: David Patterson and Berkeley RISC-I
Thanks. You’re right. Will correct.
klelatti··on LVMH becomes the first European company to surpass $500B in market value
None of those articles mention LV at all.
klelatti··on LVMH becomes the first European company to surpass $500B in market value
Can't vouch for the whole group but the outside Europe part is 100% not true for Louis Vuitton which is by far the biggest brand in the group. Obviously not true for the wines and spirits and retailing too.

> The Louis Vuitton leather goods collections are exclusively produced in our workshops located in France, Spain, Italy and the United States.

https://en.louisvuitton.com/eng-nl/faq/products/eu-where-are...

Edit: Of course my Europe comment is not quite right as some made in the US too.

klelatti··on RISC on a Chip: David Patterson and Berkeley RISC-I
RISC-I didn't have two instruction lengths. All instructions were 32-bit long. Otherwise, yes RISC-I is very similar to RISC-V.

Source, David Patterson:

https://aspire.eecs.berkeley.edu/2017/06/how-close-is-risc-v...

klelatti··on Intel Foundry Services and Arm announce collaboration on SoC design
Couldn’t disagree more with your second paragraph. Customers making SoCs with Arm CPUs can happily go to TSMC. Intel is desperate to get IFS working and if it hasn’t got an Arm offering it’s basically locked out of mobile SoCs.

Also Apple is a very small part of Arm’s business.

klelatti··on Intel Foundry Services and Arm announce collaboration on SoC design
That's not correct. Otellini did not serve as CFO at any time and did not have a finance background. Please check your facts before making a comment like this.

Edit: I see you've changed your comment without acknowledgment. Still wrong 'sales and marketing' isn't 'bean counting' and Otellini had extensive 'tech' experience.

klelatti··on Intel Foundry Services and Arm announce collaboration on SoC design
'Data center' doesn't necessarily mean Xeon competitors.
klelatti··on Intel Foundry Services and Arm announce collaboration on SoC design
This seems absolutely inevitable.

If IFS is serious it needs to be fabbing SoC's with Arm CPUs and to be as competitive as possible with TSMC.

Nothing forces IFS to make Arm CPU's that compete with Intel's desktop and server products.

Of course, the two companies have a long history of collaboration including Intel having an Arm architecture license via StrongARM. There is an interesting anecdote from Robin Saxby of Arm about when Steve Jobs phoned him and tried to persuade him to block the sale of StrongARM to Intel but Saxby convinced Jobs otherwise.

klelatti··on Intel Foundry Services and Arm announce collaboration on SoC design
> 18A will be half a node denser than N2, while also being 12 months earlier to market.

It would be interesting to hear what the consensus view is on Intel actually being able to meet this timetable. Surely a strong degree of scepticism is warranted given their recent record.

klelatti··on $70 RISC-V Computer from Pine64 Goes on Sale April 4 – OMG Linux
So you’re complaining that Arm make more than a dollar on the latest multi core CPU on an absolutely top end smartphone that retails for probably near $1000. Seems like a perfectly reasonable deal to me!
klelatti··on Substack Notes
Given they has specifically avoided an algorithmic recommendation engine for email this feels like an unfair criticism.

We’ll see how this plays out but a non advertising funded short form content alternative to twitter seems like potentially a good thing given Twitter’s current issues.

klelatti··on $70 RISC-V Computer from Pine64 Goes on Sale April 4 – OMG Linux
So if there are over a billion phones sold per year Arm clearly don’t charge anywhere near $10 per smartphone CPU.
klelatti··on Even if you can't write assembly, you can read disassembly
Given the popularity of Compiler Explorer there must be lots of people out there reading assembly language part time!

I’ve personally found it incredibly helpful in trying to understand exactly what AVX512 code compilers can be coaxed into generating. Thanks Matt!

klelatti··on $70 RISC-V Computer from Pine64 Goes on Sale April 4 – OMG Linux
No your numbers are wrong (1) by an order of magnitude. The cost per smartphone equivalent CPU will be around $1 and that’s for the whole design not the ISA.

[1] tens of millions is wrong and it clearly not true that Arm charges ‘as much as $10’ for an SBC that will cost $40 retail.

klelatti··on $70 RISC-V Computer from Pine64 Goes on Sale April 4 – OMG Linux
I think that’s an urban myth. They (and Acorn) had to pay fees in the early days of Arm and no reason why that would change.
klelatti··on $70 RISC-V Computer from Pine64 Goes on Sale April 4 – OMG Linux
10c is an average of course but yes eg WD
klelatti··on $70 RISC-V Computer from Pine64 Goes on Sale April 4 – OMG Linux
This emphasis on price is a bit misleading imho. Arm had revenues of less than $800m in the last reported quarter and there were 8 billion Arm cores shipped. So that’s less than 10c per core. And that’s not the fee for the ISA it’s the total cost of licensing the core. So if you’re expecting a big cost saving on the end user price from the ISA being open source then you’ll be likely to be disappointed.

More important is that more competition may lead to better designs and the RISC-V gives more freedom for firms to innovate.

klelatti··on iAPX432: Gordon Moore, Risk and Intel’s Super-CISC Failure
> Literally every feature any assembly language programmer could ask for, and then more on top of that.

I think that one of the key problems with the 432 was that they skipped talking to the assembly language programmers!

The 432 omitted stuff that most assembly language would deem essential (eg registers where I think an assembly language expert would have immediately focused on performance impact) and I think assembly language programming of the 432 would not be fun at all.

Agree 100% that upgrading it would have been a nightmare. I suspect that they simply didn’t have the bandwidth to think about v2.

← PreviousPage 14 of 34Next →