HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

klelatti

10,089 karma · joined May 1, 2020

Writing a newsletter about computer history at thechipletter.substack.com
submissionscomments
klelatti··on The American economy has left other rich countries in the dust
> and the few that are there

Completely wrong as roughly 25% of the UK population has a university degree. The U.K. has lots of problems but a lack of graduates isn’t one of them.

klelatti··on Hell Freezes Over as AMD and Intel Come Together for x86
> Another shoe to drop would be a super-computer powered by ARM chips instead of x86. I don't think that has happened yet.

Fugaku?

https://newsroom.arm.com/blog/fujitsu-a64fx-arm

klelatti··on UK will give sovereignty of Chagos Islands to Mauritius
> It almost feels like China is involved in this because the number doesn't sound like something Mauritius would come up with on their own. See other 99 year leases the CCP is involved in, they're obsessed with this number

Err 99 leases are common in lots of places. 99 years is a bit more than a lifetime so not many people care much about what happens afterwards. And it is a lot shorter than in perpetuity which would look bad for whoever is granting it.

klelatti··on Response to WP Engine’s Lawsuit
In that case I have no idea why Automattic would attempt to try to get WPE to license the trademark.
klelatti··on Response to WP Engine’s Lawsuit
That’s easy - limiting potential liability if they lose. It’s not an admission of guilt though.
klelatti··on Response to WP Engine’s Lawsuit
Fair enough - I can see there are limits but the material in Automattic’s lawsuit didn’t seem that problematic. Not sure how the law can distinguish between ok and too much use of ‘WordPress’.
klelatti··on Response to WP Engine’s Lawsuit
As I understand it the claimed trademark infringement is WPE saying they ‘provide WordPress hosting’. If they are successful can anyone built an opens source hosting business?
klelatti··on Response to WP Engine’s Lawsuit
Like many here I suspect I care less about who wins the litigation than about the third parties - businesses, individuals and at least one major charity - who will have been affected by Matt’s and Automattic’s actions.

Where is the blog post about the affect this has had on them?

klelatti··on UK to finish with coal power after 142 years
Mostly replaced implies >50% which is not the case. Gas is the most used fuel but has not 'mostly replaced' coal.
klelatti··on UK to finish with coal power after 142 years
'Mostly' isn't true over the last decade which is the period of the most recent big shift from Coal.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/electricity-mix-uk

klelatti··on Linux/4004: booting Linux on Intel 4004 for fun, art, and no profit
> Because of its purpose, Intel 4004 did not have many features that had been recognized as necessary already since the first automatic computers, for example the lack of logic operations, which was mentioned in the parent article.

So you're setting a range of instructions without which a device can't be considered a general-purpose computer even if the missing instructions can be recreated in software with instructions that do exist.

Sorry disagree with this completely, as does every definition I've ever seen.

klelatti··on Linux/4004: booting Linux on Intel 4004 for fun, art, and no profit
Your argument is that because the 4004 was built to power a calculator that disqualifies it as a microprocessor? Independent of the actual nature of the 4004 itself and its potential applications beyond its first intended use? Can’t see how that makes sense at all.

Your statement about Intel 'pushing back' the date to 1971 also makes little sense given Intel advertised [1] the 4004 as a CPU in Electronic News in Nov 1971.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_4004#/media/File:Intel_4...

klelatti··on Intel lost the Sony Playstation business to AMD
Otellini was not a dispassionate observer at the time he said this and there are very good reasons to believe that isn’t an accurate portrayal of what happened - including the fact that Otellini had just sold Intel’s smartphone SoC business and no x86 design was remotely suitable.

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/how-intel-missed-the-ip...

klelatti··on AT&T's Hobbit Microprocessor (2023)
The apology is for the parody of Tolkien not for the use of the word Hobbit.
klelatti··on Apple must pay 13B euros in back taxes, EU's top court rules
In fairness, the UK got a lot of 'opt-outs' which probably gave it a competitive advantage in certain areas.

I can think of one set of EU rules where the UK used its considerable influence to secure major changes to the original proposals only for UK regulation to limit the benefits of those changes.

Of course, those rules were later held up by the UK Govt as an example of where the UK could reap 'Brexit benefits'.

klelatti··on Ask HN: Resources for GPU Compilers?
> 17 lines of simple code

17 lines of very much not simple code

klelatti··on Apple Succession Strategy: Keep the Old Guard Around as Long as Possible
> keeping the old guard around only helps if the new leaders aren't having good ideas

Combining fresh ideas with experience is a bad idea?

klelatti··on Apple Succession Strategy: Keep the Old Guard Around as Long as Possible
You replied to me because your point has nothing to do with the point I made. Sorry still no idea why.
klelatti··on Apple Succession Strategy: Keep the Old Guard Around as Long as Possible
Quite the opposite. Lack of succession planning is unlikely to be correlated with the effort required to organise retention of staff as Apple do.

And an overly dominant CEO generally doesn’t like senior staff who might provide counsel to stick around.

klelatti··on Apple Succession Strategy: Keep the Old Guard Around as Long as Possible
So the labour market only operates correctly if people opt for the highest paid job and do the most work?

Hard disagree from me then.

klelatti··on Apple Succession Strategy: Keep the Old Guard Around as Long as Possible
You’re assuming it’s just about pay when that’s not necessarily the case. Lots of loyalty in many cases but still want to stay involved. Push them out of the door and they will find something to do and that may be at a competitor.
klelatti··on Apple Succession Strategy: Keep the Old Guard Around as Long as Possible
Lack of succession planning and an overdominant CEO are utterly distinct concepts to the approach being described here.
klelatti··on Apple Succession Strategy: Keep the Old Guard Around as Long as Possible
I made a general point about wider application without commenting on Apple's use so not sure why you have responded to me rather than commenting at the top level. Are companies in general heading toward antitrust issues?
klelatti··on Apple Succession Strategy: Keep the Old Guard Around as Long as Possible
This should be a more widely used tactic. It keeps the experience onboard and possibly stops them from consulting for a competitor!

And it's probably better for the individual too. Going from having a role that takes up a huge amount of your life to zero in a short time probably isn't healthy for that person (or their family).

klelatti··on How Intel Missed the iPhone: The XScale Era
Apple doesn't make their own chips TSMC does and TSMC generated net income of US$26 billion in 2023.
klelatti··on How Intel Missed the iPhone: The XScale Era
To be clear the article doesn’t frame it as being clear it was a huge mistake at the time - rather that it’s clear now - and seeks to explain why that decision was made.
klelatti··on How Intel Missed the iPhone: The XScale Era
> Apple demanding a (probably much) lower price-point to have the SoC applied in a mysterious unknown project without a volume-commitment could as well have destroyed the business and profit-margin for the entire Xscale business for Intel and its other customers...

One of the key premises of the article is that Apple likely didn't know it was bidding for the iPhone and the decision was taken on that basis.

Why is why saying 'Intel turned down the iPhone' is problematic.

klelatti··on How Intel Missed the iPhone: The XScale Era
> I don't like how this whole article is framed as how obvious it was that Intel made a huge mistake. Hindsight is 20/20, there was no such data available.

Possibly because Otellini framed it as such?

The latter part of the article answers your other points.

klelatti··on $50 2GB Raspberry Pi 5 comes with a lower price and a tweaked, cheaper CPU
Thanks, very interesting. One senses a nor entirely harmonious relationship between RPi and Broadcom.
klelatti··on $50 2GB Raspberry Pi 5 comes with a lower price and a tweaked, cheaper CPU
So the first version of the BCM2712 was made by Broadcom for RPi and included RPi IP and also included unspecified dark silicon that RPi didn't want and was materially more expensive as a result?

Seems like an odd situation. Did Broadcom want to sell the BCM2712 to other customers and insisted on the more expensive design?

← PreviousPage 6 of 34Next →