HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

klelatti

10,089 karma · joined May 1, 2020

Writing a newsletter about computer history at thechipletter.substack.com
submissionscomments
klelatti··on Instruction Sets Should Be Free: The Case for RISC-V [pdf] (2014)
Yes, Apple is an Arm founder.

The comment implies, though, that they get a special deal because they are a founder. Neither Wikipedia nor the linked articles say that.

There won't be a source because the details of the current commercial contract between Apple and Arm will be highly confidential.

In any event, it's vanishingly unlikely that Apple gets some special unique rights to IP created in the 2000s as a result of having a big shareholding in Arm in 1991 which they sold completely in the 1990s.

Yes, Apple probably gets a great deal but because they are a huge, enormously high-profile customer who has worked closely with Arm on the development of their latest IP.

klelatti··on Instruction Sets Should Be Free: The Case for RISC-V [pdf] (2014)
I've looked at this several times and have never found a source that confirms what you have said.

Do you have a source or not?

klelatti··on Instruction Sets Should Be Free: The Case for RISC-V [pdf] (2014)
Source?
klelatti··on The future of foundation models is closed-source
> Open-source software started as an act of charity – the world owes the likes of Linus Torvalds and Fabrice Bellard for endowing humanity with Linux, Git, and FFmpeg.

So Linux is a simple act of charity from one person. If the author so fundamentally misunderstands what Open Source software is in principle and Linux is in particular then I struggle to see how he's qualified to come to such a definitive conclusion on a subject as complex as foundation models.

klelatti··on RISC vs. CISC by John R. Mashey (1995)
They always did didn’t they?
klelatti··on RISC vs. CISC by John R. Mashey (1995)
Six hours and only two comments. Perhaps the RISC vs CISC debate is over :)
klelatti··on Raspberry Pi Ltd is considering an IPO
A peer comment has refuted that there is a duty like this in the US. For the record, it's not true in the UK [1]

In any event, any such duty would be likely to be meaningless. There are so many possible areas of confusion or inconsistency:

- Profit over what time period? - Profit vs shareholder return. - What level of risk is to be taken in generating this profit?

And so on.

[1] http://in-houseblog.practicallaw.com/fallacy-of-the-duty-to-...

klelatti··on Compiler Explorer
Author here. Thanks for all the upvotes - and Compiler Explorer is awesome - but I’m not sure this should be on the front page as it’s mostly a collection of links. @dang
klelatti··on Chips and Cheese State of the Union
Huge congratulations to the Chips and Cheese team on what they have achieved. The quality and volume of posts on the site - particularly from clamchowder - has been stunning.

IMHO sustainability of the site should be a primary concern. The team should really do what they think is best, given their time and resources, to enable them to continue to deliver on their mission.

klelatti··on A History of C Compilers – Part 1: Performance, Portability and Freedom
> This totally neglects

> … Part 1 …

klelatti··on Opera for Beginners
You're welcome. The whole of Janáček's music is influenced by the Czech language and folk songs. Warning that Jenufa can get a bit intense though! Thank you for mentioning the Moravian Folk Songs - added to my playlist now.
klelatti··on Opera for Beginners
This seems, well, a little selective, being focused exclusively on 19C Italian Opera and Mozart. I think it's entirely possible not to particularly like these works, whilst enjoying operas by other composers.

My starting point in opera was Janáček. The Cunning Little Vixen and Jenufa, for example, are both stunning works, musically and dramatically, and sound entirely different from the operas mentioned in this piece. The recordings by Charles Mackerras are unbeatable.

But if you don't enjoy Janáček then try someone else's work as you never know what you might like!

klelatti··on Takeaways from the Jane Street bond prospectus
Great comment from the FT's comments section on this piece.

> A good mate who runs and wrecks expensive cars for hobby once reminded me that course plotting (i.e. research) and braking (i.e. risk management) are the two sine qua non contributors to a successful race.

Along with a reminder that disasters happen when businesses forget this (Boeing!)

klelatti··on Bytecode VMs in Surprising Places
The first software written for the first microprocessor - the Intel 4004 - powering the Busicom calculator, included a Bytecode VM.

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/bytecode-and-the-busico...

klelatti··on More on x86 – The Chip Letter
> Over time, the code density of RISC-V will increase

Why given the push back against adding new instructions tang would achieve this?

klelatti··on More on x86 – The Chip Letter
> This is an R&D economic disparity that cannot be sustained.

AMD already has enormous scale that it can spread development costs over. Tenstorrent won’t ‘win’ vs AMD solely because it needs fewer engineers and that reduces development costs (it might win for other reasons but that’s a separate argument).

Even if it does make a cheaper product then you have to take into account the fact that you’re asking hundreds of millions of users to switch ISAs with the corresponding economic costs in return for a small reduction in the purchase price.

klelatti··on AI cloud startup TensorWave bets AMD can beat Nvidia
> TensorWave will fund its bit barn build by using its GPUs as collateral for a large round of debt financing, an approach used by other datacenter operators.

Hmmm. This seems like an odd risk for the lenders. Asymmetrical with little upside and security depends on continuing demand for GPUs. When the AI tide goes out who will be left with the losses.

klelatti··on Open source versus Microsoft: The new rebellion begins
Not sure what point you're making here. They have lots of products, some of which are open source, but Office /365 is still a huge cash generator.

They most certainly do care about Office / 365's grip being weakened.

klelatti··on Herman Goldstine and the IAS Machine: Unveiling the Modern Computer (2023)
> he (von Neumann) and Goldstine are "the bad guys" in this story

Von Neumann and Goldstine are clearly at fault in not crediting Eckert and Mauchly at all in the 'first draft'. The precise role of the players in developing the concept is disputed though. The 'first draft' is the first complete description of a stored program computer - there is no comparable document from Eckert and Mauchly - and it's inconceivable that Von Neumann didn't contribute significantly to the design.

And if we are focused on practical designs, then Eckert and Mauchly weren't even the first to implement a working stored program computer using the approach set out in the first draft.

We can disagree whether distributing the 'first draft' was morally right. My personal view is that doing so and hence invalidating the patents was a huge net good.

klelatti··on TSMC was founded by Morris Chang when he was 55 years old
I wonder if there are few things going on here. If TSMC was a success then he would be well enough rewarded and not everyone wants to be a billionaire. Then there is the reduced influence from having no equity. I guess if Chang was dependent on government support and confident in his ability to influence government then having some equity makes little difference?
klelatti··on Sam Bankman-Fried sentenced to 25 years in prison
You can’t call it a bank run if it’s not a bank! Banks are highly regulated as they are vulnerable to this sort of issue and that’s why there is compensation. A run should not have been problematic for FTX without the fraud.
klelatti··on Intel Brags of $152B in Stock Buybacks. Why Does It Need an $8B Subsidy?
I don’t think that this is surprising at all.

Stock buybacks are undertaken as the return the company can get on the cash returned is lower than they think shareholders want.

Subsidies exist to get the company to invest in a project where the return would otherwise be inadequate for shareholders.

I suppose you could force a company to invest in a project that was perceived to have inadequate returns but that seems a little unfair?

klelatti··on Canva has acquired Affinity in an effort to compete with Adobe
> Serif can do quite well, but also in the burgeoning AI-assisted space, where Serif has zero ability to compete

I think you've hit the nail on the head. AI tools will become essential and if you haven't got the resources to compete in this area you're likely to fade into relative irrelevance.

And at a 20x multiple probably a steal for Canva too given what this deal will give them - even without raising prices / going to subscription model.

klelatti··on Canva has acquired Affinity in an effort to compete with Adobe
Serif’s owners not Canva’s.
klelatti··on Canva has acquired Affinity in an effort to compete with Adobe
Based on last published accounts (2022) Serif is very profitable and growing strongly: revenue £31.2m (up from £23.4m) and operating profits £17.9m (up from £14.4m). So it doesn't seem like they needed to sell.

Of course it is still small in the scheme of things - Canva seems to have revenue of c$2bn - and seems to be owned by three individuals in their 50s so one can probably understand why they wanted to to sell.

klelatti··on The Intel 8088 processor's instruction prefetch circuitry: a look inside
Is the definition of hacking writing code only for yourself? Surely (most of) the point of writing code is for other people to use it.

If you ignore the majority of devices out there that you can write code for then that's not really a sensible definition of market share.

klelatti··on The Intel 8088 processor's instruction prefetch circuitry: a look inside
Domination apart from the CPUs that power the main computing devices for the large majority of people (billions) around the world.
klelatti··on Picotron Is a Fantasy Workstation
Maybe check out the Colour Maximite 2 with a Cortex M-7 [1]

Very much in the spirit of the early home computers (inc a decent BASIC) but with a lot more oomph.

[1] https://geoffg.net/maximite.html

klelatti··on Britain enters period of mourning as Greggs unable to process payments
As my local Greggs said on the door this morning "Crumbs!"
klelatti··on Loongson 3A6000: A Star Among Chinese CPUs
MIPS ISA? Is this a problem in practice in 2024?
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →