HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

klelatti

10,089 karma · joined May 1, 2020

Writing a newsletter about computer history at thechipletter.substack.com
submissionscomments
klelatti··on Comparing the 1970's Cray-1 supercomputer against the Raspberry Pi
Oh wow! Thanks, that's a great discussion.
klelatti··on Comparing the 1970's Cray-1 supercomputer against the Raspberry Pi
Nothing against AdaFruit, but this really should link to Roy Longbottom's detailed comparisons [1] that this very short post links to.

[1] http://www.roylongbottom.org.uk/Cray%201%20Supercomputer%20P...

klelatti··on Leaving Arizona – the Story of the Motorola 6800 part 2 and creation of the 6502
From the Oral History [1] on the rationale for the move:

> [Bill] Lattin: And Jack Henneshen [senior Motorola manager], it is claimed that he wanted to move down there because he wanted a windmill on his property.

> [Tom] Bennett: I thought it was the Texas football games. <laughter>

[1] https://archive.computerhistory.org/resources/access/text/20...

klelatti··on Leaving Arizona – the Story of the Motorola 6800 part 2 and creation of the 6502
The really remarkable thing about the 6502 is how the designers managed to get such strong performance out of such an economical design. It used less than half the transistors of the Z80. As a result it really was the design that helped to kick start the home computer market.

The original Arm team were big fans and the ARM1 followed in that tradition of making the most of the resources available. I guess we could say there would be no ARM without the 6502.

(Disclosure - I wrote the original post)

klelatti··on Linkhut: A Social Bookmarking Site
Open source and written in Elixir.

As someone who is a heavy user of Pinboard and has had Elixir on my 'to learn properly after dabbling' list for a while, looks like a great project to explore.

klelatti··on Transputer.net
If anyone is interested in the Transputer instruction set, I wrote a short post on the topic last year. In short few registers, stack based but with a tiny stack, heavily microcoded.

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/inmos-and-the-transpute...

klelatti··on Transputer.net
It is an interesting piece of economics / public policy history. I think using the phrase 'throw money at any UK firm' though does a bit of a disservice to how credible Inmos's technology was. They were building at or close to leading edge RAM chips and the Transputer, although it looks like a curiosity now, had lots of interesting (not really flashy) innovation.

There were lots of issues with the running of the company of course, but I think it was the sale to Thorn-EMI (a really unsuitable owner) that ultimately sealed the fate of the firm.

klelatti··on Happy New Year HN!
And huge thanks to dang for all his work over the year!
klelatti··on Q&A With Bill Mensch, co-creator of the 6502
Not 100% sure I understand your question but if you're asking about 4040 vs 6502 as contenders for Apple II in 1977 - the 4040 was a much more limited design than the 6502 and would not have been viable as the Apple's CPU.
klelatti··on Q&A With Bill Mensch, co-creator of the 6502
Thanks so much! There is so much to cover in Part 2 so it might take a little while.

Completely agree that the 6800 needs more love. It was a really important design.

PS I'd not seen Mensch's comment that Peddle's intention was to raid Motorola for engineers before - that's an interesting angle!!

klelatti··on Q&A With Bill Mensch, co-creator of the 6502
Thanks for sharing this - it's a great interview.

I do think there is a subtlety about the 'wasn't intended to compete with the 6800' line though.

Chuck Peddle recognised the market for a much cheaper version of the 6800 which Motorola refused to make, possibly because they couldn't make it that cheaply with the contact lithography process they were using.

So Peddle went off to MOS Technology (taking lots of Motorola engineers with him including Mensch) to make the cheaper version. To achieve that goal, they had to cut down on some of the 6800's features. Reducing the size of the stack pointer, only one accumulator, and so on.

As it turns out, the end result - the 6501/2 - was actually very competitive with the 6800. So whilst the original intention wasn't to compete with the 6800, in the end it did compete with it very successfully in some important markets.

Of course, in addition MOS Technology didn't have the resources of Motorola and so also couldn't compete with them in terms of support, peripherals and so on.

Note: I wrote the original post on the 6800 that led to the discussion [1] and I'm now deep in the writing of Part 2 of the 6800 story. (So I've now provided spoilers for Part 2!)

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38616591

klelatti··on The BBC Is Hacked Live on Air [video]
Looks like it. 8-bit 6502 at 2 MHz.
klelatti··on Milk-V Pioneer – native RISC-V computer
Cortex A76 hardware was first available in 2018. Just because A76 happened to appear on an SBC 18 months or six months ago using this as a milestone doesn’t give a realistic impression of the relative timelines of the two architectures.
klelatti··on The 8-bit era: Eight processor designs
Hi, Author here. Apologies, I should have made it clear that this was intended to be a short list of microprocessors only, mostly to leave room for a follow up on microcontrollers like the 8051. Completely agree that the 8051 deserves a place on any list of important 1970s architectures.

If anyone is interested in the results of the poll which looks like a dead heat between the 6800/9 and Z80, then the winner was Motorola. So I'm now deep in research on the 6800, hopefully to result in a post in the near future.

klelatti··on New Loongson chip matches Intel's 14600K in IPC tests, overclocked to 3 GHz
ASML? Swiss?? Nee!

Don’t disagree with your general point though. Also there is always the option of industrial espionage as we have seen.

Leaving the politics aside, it will be interesting to see what technical solutions emerge if the ‘easy’ option of spending a few hundred million dollars on a couple of EUV machines isn’t available.

klelatti··on BBC Basic returns on multiple platforms, open sourced
Agreed and - perhaps apart from the integrated assembler - these were common features of 8-bit machines.

I had a ponder on the attractions of the 8-bit era a few days ago ...

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/the-virtues-of-the-8-bi...

Closest I've found to a modern version is the Colour Maximite

https://geoffg.net/maximite.html

klelatti··on Making it clear when we're on a call with you to protect you from fraud
I had a similar experience with Sainsbury’s Bank in the U.K.

Called me out of the blue after a failed transaction, I refused to give them the info they wanted and so they locked my account. Unlocking needed me to send them physical info that would have cost me.

Easy to sign up for an alternative. Lost a customer after 15 years. Well done Sainsbury’s Bank.

klelatti··on Spotify will end service in Uruguay due to bill requiring fair pay for artists
> Were you really expanding you home collection that much?

An album and a half a month?

There are lots of people who would buy dozens of CDs a month. I know many.

klelatti··on Spotify will end service in Uruguay due to bill requiring fair pay for artists
So you get a vast amount more choice for the same price? That doesn’t factor into your assessment of value at all?
klelatti··on Spotify will end service in Uruguay due to bill requiring fair pay for artists
> Revenue is broadly in line with what it's been:

More precisely revenue has just caught up to the level it was 30 years ago

klelatti··on Spotify will end service in Uruguay due to bill requiring fair pay for artists
And the value being delivered to you is a huge amount more than you got with 1-2 CDs a month.

But you’re not prepared to pay more for that value?

klelatti··on Spotify will end service in Uruguay due to bill requiring fair pay for artists
Piracy did well for a while in the CD era. There is no evidence that current prices represent a ceiling for what would work in 2023 before people would turn again to piracy.
klelatti··on Spotify will end service in Uruguay due to bill requiring fair pay for artists
This may be an unpopular opinion but streaming music prices have to rise for artists to get a fair deal.

Current prices are an incredible bargain and only so because they don’t reflect the true value of the product.

Anything else is just trying to square the circle.

klelatti··on Intel vs. NEC: The Case of the V20's Microcode
Author here. Just wanted to share one point I've been pondering after writing the article.

The legal action over the V20 started when NEC sued Intel, not the other way around. I wonder if Intel held off suing NEC first as they felt that their legal case was weak - the two microcode programs were very different after all. Only during discovery would it have become clear that members of the NEC team who had seen the 8088 code had also worked on the V20.

In the end a four year court case was probably a good outcome for Intel and starting the case possibly a mistake by NEC.

klelatti··on Raspberry Pi receives strategic investment from Arm
Why did you reply then?

I've removed the snark but perhaps it's better to engage with the substance of a comment.

Edit : You didn’t engage with the substance of the comment which was about RPi’s perspective but instead made an unrelated comment about why Arm would do the investment.

klelatti··on Raspberry Pi receives strategic investment from Arm
My point was that it's not about price (which the current top comment says).
klelatti··on Raspberry Pi receives strategic investment from Arm
RPi is a member of the RISC-V foundation but I don't think that that is anything about saving money, it's about the extra flexibility that it would have given RPi, as they are doing quite a lot of their own silicon these days.

Complete speculation, but perhaps with an investment from Arm both sides would be more comfortable with closer collaboration and more tailored Arm cores. Plus, RPi probably need the capital.

klelatti··on A new view of the Manchester Computer
There has been quite a bit of debate [1] about who was first with a working electronic von Neumann (in the widest sense of the word) design, the modified ENIAC or Manchester Baby. I have to say that I'm a bit torn and can see both sides on this.

I would say though that the Manchester machine, architecturally and in other ways, looks and feels to me much more like a modern computer than ENIAC.

[1] https://computerhistory.org/blog/programming-the-eniac-an-ex...

klelatti··on Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages
Hi Jacob,

Apologies, for some reason my memory failed me and I didn't make the connection between your Medium post and the Substack update!

Of course on the recommendations, delighted to. Added just now. Best of luck.

klelatti··on Apple CPU Architecture Through the Ages
By complete coincidence, I also wrote a post about Mac transitions a few days ago - with perhaps a bit more emphasis on the architectures that almost made it into the Mac - which may be of interest.

https://thechipletter.substack.com/p/apple-transitions-68k-t...

← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →