HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kmontrose

350 karma · joined January 9, 2011

Microsoft employee.

Formerly I worked on Stack Overflow and Stack Exchange.

http://stackoverflow.com/users/80572/kevin-montrose

submissionscomments
kmontrose··on Stack Overflow is now the official support platform for Facebook Developers
No, Facebook is replacing their forums with Stack Overflow.

See their blog post: http://developers.facebook.com/blog/post/545/

Their documentation remains independent, the alternative is insane.

(disclaimed: SE Inc. employee)

kmontrose··on Introducing BrowserID: A better way to sign in
In the literal sense that you are not your e-mail, yes email != identity.

In a practical "on the internet sense," your email really is your identity (maybe SSN or name would be a better description; you can change it, but to do so is catastrophically disruptive). After all if you can't be contacted you really can't be identified, and the universal way of contacting someone online is through email.

Now, you should definitely try and provide some redundancy (store multiple email addresses, long living sessions, whatever) and make your anonymous/unauthenticated/drive-by user experience stellar. But when push comes to shove if you can't send them a "forgot your username/password/open-id/samoflange" email, you've lost that user.

(anecdote: I've had the same primary email for >7 years)

kmontrose··on Don't Forget Your Logged Out Users
I definitely get the impression that Jeff is more surprised than upset by users who have used cookie-based accounts for long periods. If I recall correctly, the record for longest "active unregistered account" is around 2 and 1/2 year (Stack Overflow is just shy of 3 years old, for comparison). That's a loooong time to go without clicking a Google/Facebook/Whatever button.

Of course, not having to register is completely by design and almost certainly never going to change, it's such an obvious win from a user experience point of view.

Disclaimer: Stack Exchange employee.

kmontrose··on Google indexes Stack Overflow at a rate of 10 requests per second
SO gets well over 10k completely new posts (Q&As) on a typical day.

A few thousand older posts are edited a day.

Throwing comments into the mix more than doubles the number of "new things", and of course every question, answer, comment, or edit is displayed on multiple pages (generally, on the owning user's page).

tl;dr - there's a lot more page churn than you might expect.

kmontrose··on Quora vs. StackExchange: Why, Joel, Why?
Its mostly a distinction between "can login with one click (Registered with OpenId/Facebook)" and "can login with a crazy convoluted path (provide email [again], check email for link, etc.) (Unregistered)".

You can get the lion's share of a Stack Exchange's utility without registering, and this is quite intentional.

kmontrose··on Quora vs. StackExchange: Why, Joel, Why?
Ah, my bad; been a long time since I've had to do anything as an unregistered user, mis-remembered.

Looking at the code, we do require something that looks like an e-mail, for recovery purposes (I assume, that code predates me by a bit). It is not, however, verified.

kmontrose··on Quora vs. StackExchange: Why, Joel, Why?
No, you can participate (well, post answers/questions; no rep is gained) as an unregistered user without giving us an e-mail address at all (or even giving us a bogus one, we don't check).

If you do provide one, it lets you recover your cookie based account is all.

The "account" is as throw away as you want it to be, basically.

kmontrose··on Quora vs. StackExchange: Why, Joel, Why?
There is a way to recover your account if your cookie is lost.

http://stackoverflow.com/users/account-recovery (this is linked from /users/login)

It does require that you provided a valid e-mail address at some point, which we don't require.

kmontrose··on StackOverflow clone, created entirely with Redis and jQuery
Expanding on antirez...

An overview of how we use Redis for caching at Stack Overflow can be found at: http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/69164/does-stackover...

Our "global inbox" and "frequented tags" features are built on Redis as well. There's a bit of traditional SQL behind global inboxes (mostly for persistence and backup purposes), however.

← PreviousPage 4 of 4