HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

knaekhoved

36 karma · joined October 16, 2022

submissionscomments
knaekhoved··on Functional programming should be the future of software
> a Feynman of that sphere so to speak

Hopefully people who read QED don't go around thinking that they know all they need to know to make an informed judgement about lagrangian QM.

knaekhoved··on Functional programming should be the future of software
> It's so divorced from writing software as to be gibberish.

Only if the software you're writing is A) aggressively simplified, so as to be amenable to informal analysis, or B) garbage.

If you're only interested in writing garbage, or perhaps you don't even notice that's what you're doing, then the appeal of FP is significantly reduced.

knaekhoved··on Cree releases LEDs designed for horticulture
The constraint in this hypothetical scenario is space for solar panels, not space for plants.
knaekhoved··on Functional programming should be the future of software
If you believe in the epistemic power of "studies" to convey useful information in these domains, I have bad news for you - you are the one in a religious fervor.

The only semi-objective metric you've proposed is compiled code performance, which is a fairly small component of most people's utility function, especially when the difference disappears in all but numerical-computation-centric applications.

knaekhoved··on Functional programming should be the future of software
> The typical argument for vaccines is much less shaky than the typical argument for pure FP.

I suspect you aren't that knowledgeable about either.

> For one, vaccine people can actually explain why vaccines are good.

Unless you have a very particular background, I'm suspicious that you can actually follow the frontier of that argument. More likely, you're getting the ELI5 explanation.

> FP people seem to mostly just repeat variations on "it's easier to reason about" and showing trivial functions that are generally not easier to reason about.

Well-designed FP languages reify coherent low-complexity formal semantics. When FP advocates say "reason about", they mean in a (semi-)formal sense. No popular imperative language has any kind of denotational semantics, so good luck reasoning about the compositional behavior of C++ libraries, unless your definition of "reason about" is "think about informally".

knaekhoved··on Functional programming should be the future of software
Care to elaborate? You literally wrote 3 words
knaekhoved··on Functional programming should be the future of software
Where did I say that FP was obviously beneficial? You're reading too much into my question. I was questioning the GP's epistemology.

> talking like engineers rather than sales people.

They do talk like this - go to any Haskell conference and it's 90% engineering papers - much better than e.g. a JS conference. It's just that most people don't even know what PL engineering even looks like, let alone how to interpret it.

knaekhoved··on Functional programming should be the future of software
> there's very little evidence that it produces better software in the long term.

Have you used other software? 99% of it is dogshit.

> libraries were full of bugs and performance problems

This is a really wild claim to me. IDK about Scala, but libraries in Haskell, Ocaml, and Elixir are all vastly better than libraries in C++, Java, Python, despite a smaller userbase.

knaekhoved··on Ask HN: How to deal with burnout and its consequences?
For sure, but the point is that breaking that cycle is sometimes the single most important thing to focus on.
knaekhoved··on Ask HN: How to deal with burnout and its consequences?
Have you considered that overeating is possibly exacerbating your issues? I had serious brain fog/energy issues until I stopped being overweight.
knaekhoved··on The first minute of every phone call is torture now
> I have never had any of the issues described in this article and I've been using AirPods w/ an iPhone and a MacBook since AirPods came out

I bought airpods day 1 and I've had every single issue described in the article. Carplay is unreliable. Airpods are unreliable. As apple hardware steadily improves, apple software steadily degrades.

knaekhoved··on Functional programming should be the future of software
How do you distinguish between people who are in a religious fervor and people who have figured out that something is obviously beneficial?
knaekhoved··on Functional programming should be the future of software
The popularity of various programming paradigms is mostly historically contingent and driven by social/business dynamics, not because of any reasonable constrained optimization.
knaekhoved··on Show HN: I made a volumetric audio visualizer
It's ok to ask questions about claims that posts make
knaekhoved··on Show HN: I made a volumetric audio visualizer
> lifting low-dimensional data into higher dimensional spaces

This is only useful if you actually do something with the extra dimensions, e.g. lifting with a kernel. Duplicating the exact same data into more dimensions is not helpful

knaekhoved··on Show HN: I made a volumetric audio visualizer
What is the point of making this 3D when it seems to be circularly symmetric? Just replace the circle with a line and make it 2D, yeah?
knaekhoved··on Centralization is inevitable, but decentralization is right behind it
"The highway network is not scale-free" - no shit, highways refer to roads of a specific size. You're taking a slice out of the road distribution.
knaekhoved··on Gross domestic product is a misleading measure of national success (2014)
"... and replace it with a metric which explicitly optimizes for all the policies I personally like."
knaekhoved··on Physicians’ attitudes about caring for people with disabilities
DNMs have minimal issues with adulterated drugs, especially compared to street drugs. They typically have extensive third-party testing.
knaekhoved··on Physicians’ attitudes about caring for people with disabilities
> And we're taking about a nail color change, a fingers temperature change during winter

This sounds like pretty normal stuff...

knaekhoved··on Physicians’ attitudes about caring for people with disabilities
Absolutely - the ADA makes it incredibly risky to deal with disabled people in any kind of formal interaction, so anyone who can avoid it rationally will do so.
knaekhoved··on Physicians’ attitudes about caring for people with disabilities
You can order xanax on the darkweb, FYI.

I mostly agree with you - the problem is that doctors are trained to deal with the lowest common denominator of patient: an addictive idiot who would kill themselves with benzos or opiates, given the chance. 90% of doctors are absolutely not equipped to deal with high-agency, high-intelligence patients. I've had a few doctors that were smart enough to work with me on experimentation or nonstandard treatment, but they are few and far between.

knaekhoved··on Disk Prices
That's like 90+% of HN users
knaekhoved··on Salary Transparency
Where are people free to achieve massive success without being clawed back by punitive taxes etc? In most places, envy is codified in law.
knaekhoved··on Salary Transparency
I've had to deal with very bizarre behavior like this a few times in my career. It's been shocking to me to learn how vindictive, petty, or simply mentally unstable some people are.

I once had a coworker concoct a story about me and report it to management because I interrupted him during a yoga session in the office gym...

Anyway, the less people like that know about the details of my employment, the better.

knaekhoved··on Salary Transparency
I see. I can imagine that happening once or twice, but if it happens a lot, there are probably some behaviors you can change on your end to get a better idea of fit before jumping into the job. Either that, or the specificity of what you want would scare me as a potential employer. I wouldn't want to hire someone if there was an 80% chance they would decide the job was mentally unhealthy and leave within a few months.
knaekhoved··on Salary Transparency
Yeah honestly that seems like a pretty terrible sign. What happened there?

From this person's website, as a recruiter I would get the impression that they are smart but probably volatile/unreliable/???

knaekhoved··on Salary Transparency
Things I worry about, as someone who's (I think) very/moderately/somewhat far to the right for my industry/sub-industry/company:

* Coming across as bragging

* Having people who earn less than me be jealous/envious/resentful

* Making it harder for employers to justify my salary because people will be publicly envious about it and cause a stink. This could be anything from coworkers/candidates/random people saying "well why are you paying Knaek $X and not me?" (I have experienced people harassing my employers for lesser reasons) all the way to people seeing my industry as a political outlet for their envy

* It's leaking strategically valuable information, probably more valuable than the info I would get in return (plus no solution to free rider problem)

* It might help less aggressive people negotiate a larger slice of a finite salary budget, which has a negative impact on me

And so on

knaekhoved··on Salary Transparency
I feel like a lot of the people who are into salary transparency stuff are not high earners. I would like to see some game-theoretic analysis of salary disclosure dynamics from someone who is on the right tail of the distribution; my suspicion is that salary disclosure is bad for the rightmost X% of the distribution, where X is somewhere in the 10-50 range, depending on things like:

* What is the scope of the distribution? Industry, company, friend group?

* What are the social dynamics of their company/industry like?

* Is there a partitioning mechanism that reduces the stress of having a wide range of salaries for the same conceptual job type?

knaekhoved··on Ask HN: HN, but for Scientists?
When you say "the science community on twitter", are you referring to a group of actual scientists, or the group of "science communicators" and misc academic hangers-on, plus non-scientists who interact with them?
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →