HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

knaik94

2,593 karma · joined September 29, 2015

knaik1994 a.t gmail d(o)t com github knaik twitter @knaikk
submissionscomments
knaik94··on What do historians lose with the decline of local news?
I agree with most of what you said, but you aren't being honest or charitable to the news anchors and you didn't present your argument in a respectful way. I remember this compilation of a bunch of news networks saying the same talking points in a similar cadence. These kind of mandatory talking points undermine the value and purpose of local news reporting.

I personally don't think local news still has the same value it did in a pre-broadband time. The primary source is now accessible directly, through social media. And in my opinion, a lot of powerful journalism and journalism adjacent independent reporting happens on youtube/twitter. This independence allows better and nuanced reporting that otherwise wasn't possible. Paper media is on a decline, paper news has been dead for a while. I imagine any paper that refused to embrace the internet is gone now.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fHfgU8oMSo

knaik94··on Searches for VPN Soar in Utah Amidst Pornhub Blockage
Blocking porn in this way doesn't meaningfully improve the protection of children. This kind of law often also negatively impacts access to sexual education.
knaik94··on Chess is booming among teens
Over the last few months Rozman has dominated short form content for chess, and I think this article doesn't give him enough credit. Both long form and short form videos of his hit millions of views, consistently over the last few months. The analytics for his channel speak for themselves.

Here he responds to a reddit question from 3 months ago about the rise in Chess and he reponds "me" in an implied tongue in cheek way. [1] He is very active in the chess community and feels very accessible. Unlike the original elitist culture that chess was known for, he works hard to make it accessible and makes an effort to praise brilliant moves from low elo games/moves. His video answering chess questions on the wired youtube channel is a great introduction to him as well as chess, regardless of your skill level.

Rozman's videos that focus on beginner plays made me feel okay to be low elo, and that's impactful coming from someone at his skill level.

I am weak with opening theory and don't enjoy learning it. I enjoy playing intuitively, and have started playing much more chess960, a variant where starting piece positions are randomized. Lichess has recurrent chess960 torunaments. [2]

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/10glwhg/does_anyone_...

[2] https://lichess.org/team/lichess-chess960

knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
The Nokia n900 still seems almost mythical to me, because it has an fm transmitter. The galaxy note with an ir transmitter is a close second.
knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
I hadn't checked out GrapheneOS in a while. Based on the current trajectory, in a few years it might become more practical to add play services back into GrapheneOS rather than continue to fight Google's android releases. I have been doing the worst alternative possible, refusing to upgrade. I was even considering of upgrading to an older flagship. I require a phone with a microsd card and headphone jack on my phone, so that rules out a new GrapheneOS device for now, but I hope that changes.
knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
I think we fundamentally value different things from our mobile devices. Waydroid is a low level compatiblity layer, but that's still not native and not guaranteed compatibility. I want all social media apps to work, I don't want to ask others to change apps.

If you want full freedom from google, GrapheneOS feels like the best de-googled solution. In some ways, PRoot is to android what waydroid is to linux, except PRoot is way more capable. Google free AOSP, like GrapheneOS exists so it's not fair to say it's the same problem. I appreciate having access to things like Kali NetHunter and value that over being able to install and run a mainline kernel on bare hardware. I don't see a difference in installing a completely different OS vs PRoot, because I am focused on the functionality. I wouldn't be able to tell you a meaningful difference in function between iperf3 running on a Librem phone vs native termux vs PRoot.

Here's someone that's installed Termux on waydroid, installed on manjaro installed in Termux on an android phone. https://www.reddit.com/r/termux/comments/y0kupg/termux_on_ma...

https://github.com/termux/proot-distro

knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
Yt-dlp exposes all of the codecs, I think I remember newpipe hiding some options when I last used it. I struggled to find how to download just the ~140k opus audio (-f251) or maybe the combination audio+video I wanted wasn't there. I'm sure things have changed since the last time I checked.

But Yt-dlp is still more powerful, it has extractors for way more sites. If I download a video, I usually care to archive it for a longer term, so I add things like subtitles and metadata. For opus files, I don't like the webm container, so I would end up installing ffmpeg for that anyway. I also make heavy use of the regular youtube app, I appreciate the interface. Although I haven't had the need, Termux + yt-dlp also allows using aria2c for downloading. And yt-dlp has also been useful in bandwidth starved situations, because the url and format flags are enough to get the video, it doesn't hang while waiting to download related/recommended video metadata.

knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
I understand the sentiment, but I disagree. From the last time I checked, the big compromise with GNU/Linux phones is still the lack of social media and messaging apps and appstore ecosystem. Android, with root, is every bit as much a computer as a Pinephone and Librem 5, but the opposite isn't true. Termux has PRoot, a user-space implementation of chroot allowing a full distro install. I personally don't have any problem depending on Google, I have a problem with things being locked away with no alternative. Given the option, I will happily accept the risks and void my warray to root.

https://wiki.termux.com/wiki/PRoot

knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
Not all phones allow you to root, even if you paid outright for the device. Termux is different from a custom ROM, Termux gives you things like native nodejs, python, ffmpeg, git, and nmap. It's independent from the underlying OS. All phone come with a bootloader lock and only some companies allow you to unlock it. You need to do a bootloader and oem unlock in order to have the ability to root. Certain devices have sensors/parts that aren't supported via AOSP, back in the day I remember reading "not working: wifi" in the feature list for custom roms. I think wifi is usually okay now, but camera and cellular modem are still not guaranteed.
knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
One of the most unfortunate things in the US is locked bootloaders. AT&T has even started whitelisting phones for Wifi Calling and VoLTE. And with 3g shutting down, it means international phone variants won't work at all on the network, regardless of the underlying band support. Many companies, including Samsung don't allow you to unlock your bootloader to root your phone even if you bought it outright. I found that midrange phones are now the best option if you want things like AOSP. The only true flagship left, that I know of, with a headphone jack and sd card and good rooting support is the Sony Xperia phones.
knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
The restrictions are regarding specifying the root folders, /emulated/0 and /sdcard as well as android/data and /obb folders. You are able to pick folders, other than data and obb, manually one by one but that would be over a hundred folders on my sdcard to use a gallery app. The /data and /obb folders are inaccessible to users even though it's in user space. As of android 13, third party apps can't open /data or /obb, you have to install an app that creates a shortcut to the hidden AOSP files app and drag/drop manually. Rooting/usb gives you access, but play store guidelines about android app api targets make things difficult for third party apps.

By "protecting" users from security threats, they are pushing power users to daily drive a rooted device, which is a bigger security risk. I expect incomplete/broken file storage access from Apple devices, not Androids.

The thing I hate the most is that certain apps only store files in their respective android/data/ folder and delete that data on uninstall. These workarounds are the only way to backup that data.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Android/comments/j3zgmm/managing_fi...

knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
Termux allows the same kind of scripting ability you would expect from a desktop. Termux-api almost rivals tasker in what you can automate with it. I use the "share with termux" function and git pull/push shortcuts more than anything else, and they are both effectively 1 touch functions. The share with termux function allows you to script how termux will respond to shared urls, I have it set up to auto-start yt-dlp and fill in certain formats and details and starts downloading. It was a little bit inconvenient to set up, but I managed without a fullsized keyboard. There's an app called hacker keyboard that makes it easy.

The original script I wrote was initially set up with youtube-dl, the most recent change was to yt-dlp. For a lot of little things, like to SSH/reboot my rpi, wget a link I want to archive/send, small python programs (and yt-dlp), the keyboard is perfectly adequate. I've even converted a couple of audio files to send to a friend on iOS, from opus to mp3 on the phone. Bash alias are really useful, and because the phone isn't also general use, they can be very specific.

Termux also makes the phone into a very powerful network diagnostics and pen testing tool. But even something as basic as ifconfig makes my phone feel as powerful as a computer. https://github.com/may215/awesome-termux-hacking

Chromebooks have the ability to install and run android apps. The lightweight environment afforded by Termux is perfect for them. I do use VIM with my chromebook. I know I can use crostini, and in the past I was running crouton, but I realized I can handle 99% of those things in termux, and I can use VSCODE dev for the remaining 1%. I appreciate how much more flexibility termux gives me.

https://wiki.termux.com/wiki/Termux:API

https://github.com/klausw/hackerskeyboard

knaik94··on Termux is an Android terminal emulator and Linux environment app
Termux singlehandedly makes me feel like I'm living my childhood dream of having a full computer in my pocket. I use git to blog from my phone, I have ffmpeg and yt-dlp installed to download videos for when I am going to be away from internet access for a while, and I even have some home automation scripts setup that control the lights over the local network. But I am concerned about the direction Android is headed, Google policies have been aligning closer to Apple's. I don't like having to stay on a previous generation OS just to make sure I don't lose "power user" fuctionality. Just recently I had to install a root mod to allow apps complete access to SD cards, a recent update caused me to get the dreaded "To protect your privacy, choose another folder" while trying to give a gallery app permissions. I am grateful for Termux devs for working hard to maintain functionality via workarounds.

https://github.com/termux/termux-app/issues/2366

knaik94··on Ask HN: Most interesting tech you built for just yourself?
I have been struggling with my circadian rhythm and have been exploring light therapy and novel techniques that will help me wake up. I learned that a smart light I bought, from Kasa, has a solid community written python library that controls it on the local network. I made a little app that adjusts the lamp color based on sunrise and sunset hours. It's relatively simple technology wise, but it's forced me to rethink how I evaluate "smart" technology.

I am thinking of expanding it to be a notification light of sorts. Not for anything related to the internet, but for chores, like the laundry machine finishing, or reminders to take a break from work. It's helped me remember to grab lunch more than a few times this week. There's something pleasant about light notifications compared to vibrations or sounds.

I am working on making an advanced wifi enabled timer using an esp32. I love the idea of a dedicated timer, seperate from my phone, that I can use day to day. I have a basic display and webserver for scheduling countdowns/alarms, but I want to incorporate some sort of keypad and a couple input buttons. There's plenty of ways in can be improved.

I also have a first generation raspberry pi monitoring my washing machine, it sends me notifications when a cycle finishes. It uses a simple ultrasonic sensor and is hosting a web server showing a readout.

knaik94··on European DSA Recipients of Services Report
That would imply that Amazon app store or Samsung app store apps are illegal content. While they are not as popular in the US, these alernate apps stores have existed for years on android without issue.
knaik94··on Tell HN: Google search partial outage while rolling out new search?
Fixed for me, as of 9:29pm northeast us.
knaik94··on About three-in-ten U.S. adults say they are ‘almost constantly’ online (2021)
I think the moral panic, in part, comes from a strong cultural bias of valuing extroversion over introversion. The additional layer to that is the difference in how people understand the nuances of being online. The main arguments I have heard against my screen time is that it takes me away from meeting "real" people. The complexity of how people can interact with each other online is lost to them.

Seeing different amounts of introversion from live streamers helped me understand this divide. For some people, the idea of staying in your room all day and playing video games sounds like one of the most isolating things you can do. The amount of other people you are playing with online doesn't make a difference. But from the other side, there's streamers that get consistently 1000+ concurrent viewers to every stream and they make an effort to interact with individuals over time. Not everyone is chatting, but even if 1% are, thats a group of 10 people constantly chatting. Should the steamer be considered introverted or extroverted.

I think the difference between people who see screen time as good vs bad relates to whether they consider online interactions as social vs not. There is a large population of people that see any screen use as the same, but that comes from a place of not understanding the different uses of technology. The divide falls on generational lines because younger generations grew up using the internet and don't remember a "before". Those that didn't, and failed to adapt to social interactions moving online, feel nostalgic and see screen use as a "problem". I think younger generations also aren't valuing extraversion the same way older ones did because there is a better understanding of things like social anxiety and neurodevelopmental disorders.

I used to be bothered a lot and got defensive when people tried to screen shame me, but I don't care anymore. I recognized it's just part of the cycle of new technology making people feel uncomfortable when they can't or choose not to adapt. The same divide happens over and over at different scales. Ebooks are a great example, paper vs computer, paper vs eink, eink vs computer, book vs movie vs audiobook. I just finished working my way through an excellent Youtube analysis series of Dune, there hours of a book club discussion with a content creator. As a deeply introverted person, even online discussions can feel exhausting. People that try to screen shame me demonstrate they have zero nuanced understanding of that.

knaik94··on Thinking hard makes the brain tired
There's free links if you look on google scholar https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096098222...
knaik94··on Why are movies so dark these days?
I started using MPV or VLC or Daum Potplayer to manually adjust the brightness and contrast of tv shows and movies I'm watching. I stopped valuing the "filmmaker's choice" when I saw the analysis of how dark that beach scene was in House of Dragons was. [1] It's not just that consumer equipment is differently calibrated from color grading equipment, that specific scene was graded to 1 nit brigtness. Hbo later tweeted that it will not be fixed and is absoultely intentional. [2] The offical recommended viewing conditions of HDR according to the ITU and Dolby is an ambient 5 nits.

The artists aren't respecting or grading with consumer equipment in mind. I'm not getting an optimal viewing experience or even getting the artist's creative intent by trying to recreate the intended viewing settings. Dolby Vision still isn't completely supported when playing back a file on desktop. Certain DV profiles can be passed through to TVs that support it, but that's not possible for Blu-Ray Dolby Vision files. Neither the Xbox nor PS5 support Dolby Vision disk playback. Many playback solutions for playback of Dolby Vision from PC throw away the dynamic data defeating the point of caring about DV over HDR10. This is also ignoring how streaming changes colors can change due to compression, and some shows and movies are only available via streaming.

My TV can detect ambient light, Dolby Vision IQ already exists, but in my experience fails too often. Some would argue DV IQ also moves away from filmmarker's intent.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D83SXcguwBU

https://twitter.com/HBOMaxHelp/status/1576793465010135040

https://www.trustedreviews.com/explainer/what-is-dolby-visio...

knaik94··on Dumb phones are on the rise in the U.S. as Gen Z looks to limit screen time
Dumb phone cut you out of the majority of communication protocols, no whatsapp, imessage, facetime, or discord. Gen Z is one of the first hyperconnected generations that grew up using social media since they were born. Dumb phones are not on the rise, this is a terrible article. In the US, it's actually hard to get a dumb phone for certain carriers since 3g/gsm bands were turned off making VoLTE a required feature. I personally can't see myself ever choosing to get a phone with a bad digital camera.
knaik94··on OpenAI Usage Policies
Replika Ai is a good case study showing that people will become attached to these models. The OpenAI user base is large enough to justify a super conservative policy and not take the risk. But I also dislike how this policy and filtering unintentionally makes all output less useful.

Part of Eugenia Kuyda, the ceo of Replika, statement addressing concerns about a recent update that changed/filtered people's personalized AIs sums the issue well. "... The most important thing we've learned from these conversations is that for many of you, Replika is much more than an app. It is a companion in the truest sense of a word — for some of you it was the most supportive relationship you have ever experienced. "

https://www.reddit.com/r/replika/comments/1214wrt/update/

knaik94··on Microsoft's paper on OpenAI's GPT-4 had hidden information
Without the context of how the reviewer rates other movies, it's not possible to say whether 7 is high or low. I would say 7 is mid or mediocre, something I wouldn't go out of my way to watch. The trend I've noticed is that most people only use the top half of the scale, anything 5 and less is bad. The funny thing, and I am guilty of this myself, is when they only use 6 through 10 but then use decimal points too.
knaik94··on Microsoft's paper on OpenAI's GPT-4 had hidden information
The part of the review where it says "he must have never in his life seen a flick about any small towns" could be classified as sarcastic. The reviewer also says "you should watch the movie" if you are curious about the ending, but the overall intent of the review seems to be the opposite.
knaik94··on Microsoft's paper on OpenAI's GPT-4 had hidden information
I got confused about whether the review was positive or negative too. The part of the review where it says "he must have never in his life seen a flick about any small towns" could be classified as sarcastic. The review isn't very clear in terms of prose and conclusion. The reviewer clearly says "you should watch the movie", but after re-reading it a few times, I would consider that as sarcasm too. I can't say for sure whether the reviewer enjoyed it themselves.
knaik94··on Microsoft's paper on OpenAI's GPT-4 had hidden information
The authors go into more detail about their reasoning and the nuances between mechanistic and functional explainability. The authors only said related not required. No clear reason was given for why the commented sections stayed commented out.
knaik94··on Microsoft's paper on OpenAI's GPT-4 had hidden information
I think you might have a misunderstanding. The "error" was misclassifying the sentiment of this imdb review [1], the human labeled it as positive but the LLM labeled it as negative. The researchers concluded that the model was more sensitive to sarcasm than the human reviewer.

https://www.imdb.com/review/rw1756778/

knaik94··on Microsoft's paper on OpenAI's GPT-4 had hidden information
The comments in interpretability read like science fiction to me. There's paragraphs on DV3 explaining other models and itself and the emergent properties that appear with bigger models. There's so much commented out related to functional explainability and counterfactual generations.

"we asked DV3 for an explanation. DV3 replied that it detected sarcasm in the review, which it interpreted as a sign of negative sentiment. This was a surprising and reasonable explanation, since sarcasm is a subtle and subjective form of expression that can often elude human comprehension as well. However, it also revealed that DV3 had a more sensitive threshold for sarcasm detection than the human annotator, or than we expected -- thereby leading to the misspecification.

To verify this explanation, we needed to rewrite the review to eliminate any sarcasm and see if DV3 would revise its prediction. We asked DV3 to rewrite the review to remove sarcasm based on its explanation. When we presented this new review to DV3 in a new prompt, it correctly classified it as positive sentiment, confirming that sarcasm was the cause of the specification error."

The published paper instead says "we did not test for the ability to understand sarcasm, irony, humor, or deception, which are also related to theory of mind" .

The main conclusion I took away from this is "the remarkable emergence of what seems to be increasing functional explainability with increasing model scale". I can see the reasoning for why OpenAI decided not to publish any more details about the size or steps to reproduce their model. I assumed we would need a much bigger model to see these level of "human" understanding from LLMs. I can respect Meta, Google, and OpenAI's decision, but I hope this accelerates the research into truly open source models. Interacting with these models shouldn't be locked behind corporate doors.

knaik94··on Ask HN: What's the best TTS engine you've heard?
I have had some fun playing with TorToiSe TTS, which is mixed when it comes to being better than ElevenLabs. In small snippets it does sound better, but overall it does not. I mention it because it's openly available and runs locally. I didn't spend more than a weekend on it, and it's popular enough to have a small community collection of voices. You have to search for them, but they're small in size and it's zero shot generation. It's very similar to how stable diffusion felt when it first came out, a lot of trail and error and no consensus of the "right" answers.

The main reason why I liked it, even though the bad generations are really bad, is because you have full control of the training data set. I haven't kept up with it in a few weeks so I am sure there have been advances I'm not aware of.

https://git.ecker.tech/mrq/ai-voice-cloning

knaik94··on Fork of Facebook’s LLaMa model to run on CPU
I have been using similar models like LLM for helping draft fictional stories. The community fine tuned models are geared towards SFW and/or NSFW story competition.

https://github.com/KoboldAI/KoboldAI-Client To read more about current popular models.

https://koboldai.net/ is a way to run some of these models in the "cloud". There's no account required and the prompts are run on other people's hardware, with priority weighting based on how much compute you have used or donated. There's an anonymous api key and there's no expectation that the output can't be logged.

The models that run on hardware locally are very basic in the quality of output. Here's an example of a 6B output used to try to emulate chatgpt. https://mobile.twitter.com/Knaikk/status/1629711223863345154 The model was finetuned on story completion so it's not meaningfully comparable.

It's less popular because the hardware required for the great output is still above the top of line consumer specs. 24 gb vram is closer to a bare minimum to get meaningful output, and fine-tuning is still out of reach. There's some development with using services like runpod.

knaik94··on New cognitive skills in the age of AI tailored information
I am similarly having a different experience than you. It gives me Lakers results and also correctly says the correct upcoming game vs Memphis Grizzlies today. I searched "laker latest result" and "lakers upcoming". I apologizie if there's a different team/game you're referring to, because I don't know it. And like I said, I would normally search using many more keywords. It also corrected me when I queried "laker" with a different sport like football. All on "concise", I wouldn't be surprised if posting the query here on HN has enough people trying it that Bing learns by the time others get around to searching it. I know this is still anecdata.
← PreviousPage 4 of 23Next →