HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

knorby

358 karma · joined July 14, 2009

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/knorby; my proof: https://keybase.io/knorby/sigs/YCJsQTc3lWmdqNgcXo0T4M1AneUMgsItd-NRG1CVO9A ]
submissionscomments
knorby··on LAX becomes largest U.S. airport to allow Uber, Lyft pickups
Some airports, e.g. ORD (or at least it did), have special provisions for medallioned taxis to get priority access to the highly structured taxi line. It isn't just a tax on the special nature of the ride. In the case or ORD, some particular extra fuel-efficient fleet cars got priority on the generally highly lucrative rides.

There are other car services available and such, but in general airports fall under extra special taxi regulations given how much these rides rake in.

knorby··on Ellen Pao Is Stepping Down as Reddit’s Chief
The site banned posting personal information has enacted various community standards long before anything that happened recently. There is a pretty clear history, intent, and common sense around banning communities from using the to organize harassment and bringing other vile things into the world. They could have communicated that better, but there is no 180 to speak of.
knorby··on The “Sharing Economy” Is the Problem
There are plenty of shared spaces (owner is renting out an extra bedroom, etc..), and a few close to a classic B&B (house with several rooms rented out with few frills). Even a lot of the places renting the full place out tend to be people who are flexible in where they stay (they crash at the significant other's place or something), or they tend to only have a couple places. There are certainly cases of people managing pseudo-hotels, but I've used the service for years and I've never stumbled on to any.
knorby··on Front Page Subreddits Go Private in Response to Firing of Reddit Admin
Would you work for Reddit right now, or even then?

I got the impression then, and I definitely get it now, that the management has little respect for their employees. In the case of Yishan's spat, it was definitely relatable, but it definitely had the smell of the company that view employees as assets to be managed and controlled rather than people with emotions and opinions.

knorby··on U.S. Supreme Court Denies Google's Request to Appeal Oracle API Case
Well, recipes are specifically exempt from copyright, but the text of them is not. If you had a recipe for "Lobster Thermadore" that was a close copy of another published version, that would be infringement.

The basics of a recipe are hard not to duplicate, but if you start writing a lengthy description of how to do it, that enters a different territory. That seems like a decent analogy for this case.

knorby··on Britain pulls out spies as Russia, China crack Snowden files – report
He wasn't a contractor at all points in his career, and he moved jobs in-part to gain access to more material; he was often operating with a high level of access. He had several years of planning for his leak. He isn't that great of an example case.
knorby··on Texas Lawmakers Pass a Bill Allowing Guns at Colleges
Doesn't range shooting count as sport?
knorby··on Sand Hill Exchange Fined $20,000 by SEC
The SEC has incentive to stop growth of things it would shut down. Stopping scams is a big part of what they do, and a lot of the sorts of basic fraudsters that exist look more like this site than Goldman Sachs. The SEC needs to do both, and I assume those divisions are composed of very different people.
knorby··on Spiders Ingest Nanotubes, Then Weave Silk Reinforced with Carbon
"Spiderman and the Space Elevator"
knorby··on The Next Generation Open Compute Hardware: Tried and Tested
Facebook calls them "Sushi Boats"
knorby··on Making Plutonium-238 in large enough quantities is an ongoing challenge
Most of the groups who strongly oppose this stuff are against any nuclear material whatsoever entering space. The reasons span beyond basic safety to opposing any combination of space programs with nuclear programs.
knorby··on Making Plutonium-238 in large enough quantities is an ongoing challenge
There is some opposition to using nuclear material on space missions, since space travel isn't safe. The biggest fear would be a rocket blowing up at some perfect point in the launch to end up spreading plutonium-238 over a wide area.

I don't think that fear is in the end warranted, but as fears of such things go, it is more justified than many.

knorby··on California's Broken Jaywalking Law
Wish you fought that, since the cop broke CVc 21950(c).
knorby··on After Snowden, the NSA Faces Recruitment Challenge
Well, one of the most early ethical battles of Manhattan project nuclear physicists was questioning if the H-bomb should be built, and how did that turn out? The US ended up building a massive nuclear arsenal, well beyond any limit of absurd necessity or reason.

The NSA only has a hiring crisis because they are attempting to scale in similar ways. Hopefully there is a turn in ethics, but that isn't a solution.

knorby··on Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014)
It would be pretty nice if roads were such that things like deliveries, various public transit, and taxi/car sharing options were the only allowed options as far as cars go. If the roads become uncongested, and parking is no long a major use of cities, a lot of the existing uses for cars would disappear.
knorby··on “Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900”
I lived in Chicago before moving to SF a few years ago, and I can't imagine ever going back. There is an argument about jobs, people, and companies that's complex, but people pay so much for so little space because it really is that valuable. The weather is near perfect year round, the food/beer/wine is astounding, the landscape is glorious, and so on. Midwest winters, particularly as climate change is making them worse, would be enough to keep me here, but my quality of life has gone up in about every other way possible.

People pay the premium because it really is that good. If a big tech company decided to move to Milwaukee, every other tech company would just soak up all the people lost.

knorby··on FAA says monetized videos shot from drones are subject to commercial regulations
I think the greater point is that the FAA is meant to regulate aircraft, not the monetization button on youtube. The rule is senseless, and I think the FAA knows that; they are too inflexible to adapt to reality, and they should be practicing non-enforcement as a means of coping. Swarms of drone pilots could be flying and recording without the intent to monetize, and the FAA would have the same and only problem they are attempting to thwart.
knorby··on Google Calendar for iPhone
Inbox is a fairly different product and not a replacement for everyone
knorby··on StackOverflow Considered Harmful?
Why is that the author's problem rather than a problem of StackOverflow's? I'm not going to suggest I know a better way, but it is up to them to figure out. If you build a site around user-generated content, these are problems that can't be dismissed.

Anyway, I would say a user has a stronger right to delete content than other users' have to keep their connected content up.

knorby··on StackOverflow Considered Harmful?
But StackOverflow sites allows deletion, at least in part, as the author points out. So it is fair to say they aren't really enforcing that notion either.

I don't think I'm necessarily hinting at a copyright issue, though I think some control over attribution is pretty fundamental to it, but the point I'm trying to make is that the right of attribution is a stronger one than SO's right to maintain high-quality content. There are a number of ways that right can be accommodated, and it is the job of the publisher to figure out how.

knorby··on StackOverflow Considered Harmful?
There are plenty of collaborative communities where post deletion is allowed. There is clearly a different level of value between a SO question and a reddit comment thread, but deletions are almost always disruptive in some way.

But those posts have his name on them. He is judged by them, and he in some way has to stand by them. I don't know that deletion should be an assured right with all user-created content, but no one should be publishing someone else's content under their name without their continued consent.

knorby··on U.S. Spies on Millions of Cars
I'd rather have tracking of cars than most things. As a frequent pedestrian, cars scare me. Few common things can cause as much damage to humans and property. Would these efforts be more palatable if the goal was Vision Zero rather than the various low-output anti-terrorism efforts?
knorby··on How private armies will remake modern warfare
> Note how recently polities have taken away the freedom of restaurants to choose to allow smoking, selling certain sizes of drinks; the freedom of parents to choose their children's education and so forth.

Any policy related to the things you've mentioned were or were not enacted by popular support, on those issues in particular. Brutal slaver warlord can take away restaurants, high fructose corn syrup, and your children with a single vote.

knorby··on I Owe It All to Community College
> I have issues with the Obama plan[...]

It started as a Republican plan in Tennessee, funded with state money in a fairly anti-tax state as states go.

> Some local rich millionaire type (a real estate tycoon) setup an endowment to provide free tuition at BCC for any graduate of any Brunswick County high-school.

What happens when no local, benevolent millionaire decides to dedicate their fortune to free tuition? That takes many millions. Besides, sending kids to college for things you don't care about is boring--most rich philanthropists want to influence what their money will do. You are much more likely to see a real estate tycoon build a new building, which happens all the time.

> I'd love to see a concerted, nationwide effort to build a coalition of philanthropists of this nature to fund this "free college for everybody" thing, instead of taking it out of the federal govt. budget.

Because a tax is far easier and is almost exactly what you describe. This is absurdly inefficient and would only serve your worldview.

knorby··on Update on Sony Investigation
No matter what you believe, some group just caused massive damage to Sony. If the US was looking to justify "cyber defense" spending, how would a rogue group not be a bigger threat? A rogue group better fits the terrorism narrative that has justified much of the last decade's military and intelligence spending. You're reaching.
knorby··on Update on Sony Investigation
It is really quite safe to say that absolutely no one wants a war with N. Korea. It would be one of the most horrific wars in history, and everyone in the Defense department knows that. N. Korea has been looking to provoke conflict for a while, and the US, or anyone, doesn't want them to escalate. They have nukes.
knorby··on NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Test Flight
Yep, the Mars line is sales. NASA has been aiming for the moon as a more realistic possibility with this thing, which is why they rebuilt Apollo with modern rockets.
knorby··on Immigration is about talent, not costs
Of that group of STEM majors not in STEM, how many do you think could work in a STEM field after going through a professional masters program? Clearly, some do, but it takes a lot of money and valuable time. If under greater pressure, I'd imagine a lot more established tech companies would recruit with a masters program in exchange for a several year commitment. Some places do, but if it were harder to recruit, it is a fair guess more places would.

I'm not really sure what to think about those sorts of arrangements. If I were an employer, I'd greatly prefer skill-based immigration, excluding questions of exploitation, and that's the point, particularly when referring to STEM as a whole.

knorby··on HSBC, Goldman Rigged Metals’ Prices for Years, Suit Says
There has been some interest in creating laws against insider trading for commodities, but such laws don't exist, and this case is just a class action of jewelers angry about manipulation on an obscure metal commodity. The LIBOR scandal was a price fixing operation (most or all banks that could set the rate were colluding for collective interest), and the levels of impact are different worlds. The LIBOR scandal was a blatantly criminal action of an almost incalculable scale, and it has had little impact, so what does that say about a class action for legal trading activity?
knorby··on What Was Said at the Uber Dinner
And all that she's reporting is her own judgements of the incident and a light confirmation that the conversation took place. She confirms almost every detail that the buzzfeed article states, including the suggestion of targeting Sarah Lacy's personal life.

They built different narratives of the event, largely colored by the biases of each. The journalist had a bias towards building sensation and the friend had a bias towards downplay. If you don't read news articles expecting the bias of a journalist, then I'm sorry, I don't know what you are doing. But until that ending line in the article, she was a well-placed, mostly unbiased, bystander.

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →