HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kobayashi

1,421 karma · joined September 8, 2015

Keyser Söze was taken.
submissionscomments
kobayashi··on The Problem with AMP
It's from the era before which Google defaulted to TLS. Nowadays, the only known difference relates to clicking of links. Here's the info from SE[0]:

>1. Clicking on an ad:

> - https://google.com : Google will take you to an HTTP redirection page where they'd append your search query to the referrer information.

> - https://encrypted.google.com : If the advertiser uses HTTP, Google will not let the advertiser know about your query. If the advertiser uses HTTPS, they will receive the referrer information normally (including your search query).

>2. Clicking on a normal search result:

> - https://google.com : If the website uses HTTP, Google will take you to an HTTP redirection page and will not append your search query to the referrer information. They'll only tell the website that you're coming from Google. If it uses HTTPS, it will receive referrer information normally.

> - https://encrypted.google.com : If the website you click in the results uses HTTP, it will have no idea where you're coming from or what your search query is. If it uses HTTPS, it will receive referrer information normally.

[0] http://security.stackexchange.com/questions/32367/what-is-th...

kobayashi··on There is no WhatsApp 'backdoor'
>there is no protection

To my understanding, that's simply not true. What you can accurately say is that with key change notifications turned on, any one* message could be exposed without any means of recourse, but subsequent exposures would require user error.

*Question for anyone: could this apply to a "batch" of messages? That is, could servers hold back the delivery of some number of messages and then the attack could be applied to all such undelivered messages? But once the attack took place, the double check would be displayed on the sender's phone and the notification of key change would appear. My understanding is that the answer to the question is 'Yes'.

kobayashi··on China has wealth of data on what individuals are doing at a micro level
This seems to be standard in many Asian countries.
kobayashi··on $2T in Proceeds of Corruption Removed from China and Taken to US, AUS, CAN, NL
Which tax breaks?
kobayashi··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People
I did not say that the a machine intelligence mustn't share motivational complexity a la humans. I said that a SAI need not share such complexity. Those are two very different statements.

And to understand how/why a machine intelligence could arise without being substantially similar to a human intelligence and sharing similar motivations, well, I suggest you read the book or similar articles. In short, just because humans are the most sophisticated intelligences of which we yet know, it would be a very callous and unsubstantiated leap to believe that a machine intelligence is likely to share similar traits with humankind's intelligence. If this is unclear to you, I recommend you learn about how computer programs currently work, and how they're likely to improve to the point of becoming superintelligent.

By the way, there are many types of SAI, for example an SAI who's superintelligent portion relates to speed, or strategy, or a few other types.

kobayashi··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People
Of course, it does have a cheeky tone, though I think all of my points stand. The "interesting points for a layman" are actually a series of straw-man propaganda arguments. It does not argue in good faith and it should not be afforded the legitimacy of a thoughtful opposing position.
kobayashi··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People
>The only way out of this mess is to design a moral fixed point, so that even through thousands and thousands of cycles of self-improvement the AI's value system remains stable, and its values are things like 'help people', 'don't kill anybody', 'listen to what people want'.

Bostrom absolutely did not say that the only way to inhibit a cataclysmic future for humans post-SAI was to design a "moral fixed point". In fact, many chapters of the book are dedicated to exploring the possibilities of ingraining desirable values in an AI, and the many pitfalls in each.

Regarding the Eliezer Yudkowsky quote, Bostrom spends several pages, IIRC, on that quote and how difficult it would be to apply to machine language, as well as what the quote even means. This author dismissively throws the quote in without acknowledgement of the tremendous nuance Bostrom applies to this line of thought. Indeed, this author does that throughout his article - regularly portraying Bostrom as a man who claimed absolute knowledge of the future of AI. That couldn't be further from the truth, as Bostrom opens the book with an explicit acknowledgement that much of the book may very well turn out to be incorrect, or based on assumptions that may never materialize.

Regarding "The Argument From My Roommate", the author seems to lack complete and utter awareness of the differences between a machine intelligence and human intelligence. That a superintelligent AI must have the complex motivations of the author's roommate is preposterous. A human is driven by a complex variety of push and pull factors, many stemming from the evolutionary biology of humans and our predecessors. A machine intelligence need not share any of that complexity.

Moreover, Bostrom specifically notes that while most humans may feel there is a huge gulf between the intellectual capabilities of an idiot and a genius, these are, in more absolute terms, minor differences. The fact that his roommate was/is apparently a smart individual likely would not put him anywhere near the capabilities of a superintelligent AI.

To me, this is the smoking gun. I find it completely unbelievable that anyone who read Superintelligence could possibly assert "The Argument From My Roommate" with a straight face, and thus, I highly doubt that the author actually read the book which he attacks so gratuitously.

kobayashi··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People
Too late to edit, so I'll post just a few examples here:

>The only way out of this mess is to design a moral fixed point, so that even through thousands and thousands of cycles of self-improvement the AI's value system remains stable, and its values are things like 'help people', 'don't kill anybody', 'listen to what people want'.

Bostrom absolutely did not say that the only way to inhibit a cataclysmic future for humans post-SAI was to design a "moral fixed point". In fact, many chapters of the book are dedicated to exploring the possibilities of ingraining desirable values in an AI, and the many pitfalls in each.

Regarding the Eliezer Yudkowsky quote, Bostrom spends several pages, IIRC, on that quote and how difficult it would be to apply to machine language, as well as what the quote even means. This author dismissively throws the quote in without acknowledgement of the tremendous nuance Bostrom applies to this line of thought. Indeed, this author does that throughout his article - regularly portraying Bostrom as a man who claimed absolute knowledge of the future of AI. That couldn't be further from the truth, as Bostrom opens the book with an explicit acknowledgement that much of the book may very well turn out to be incorrect, or based on assumptions that may never materialize.

Regarding "The Argument From My Roommate", the author seems to lack complete and utter awareness of the differences between a machine intelligence and human intelligence. That a superintelligent AI must have the complex motivations of the author's roommate is preposterous. A human is driven by a complex variety of push and pull factors, many stemming from the evolutionary biology of humans and our predecessors. A machine intelligence need not share any of that complexity.

Moreover, Bostrom specifically notes that while most humans may feel there is a huge gulf between the intellectual capabilities of an idiot and a genius, these are, in more absolute terms, minor differences. The fact that his roommate was/is apparently a smart individual likely would not put him anywhere near the capabilities of a superintelligent AI.

To me, this is the smoking gun. I find it completely unbelievable that anyone who read Superintelligence could possibly assert "The Argument From My Roommate" with a straight face, and thus, I highly doubt that the author actually read the book which he attacks so gratuitously.

kobayashi··on Superintelligence: The Idea That Eats Smart People
I can't disagree enough. Having recently read Superintelligence, I can say that most of the quotes taken from Bostrom's work were disingenuously cherry-picked to suit this author's argument. S/he did not write in good faith. To build a straw man out of Bostrom's theses completely undercuts the purpose of this counterpoint. If you haven't yet read Superintelligence or this article, turn back now. Read Superintelligence, then this article. It'll quickly become clear to you how wrongheaded this article is.
kobayashi··on Matthew Green to audit OpenVPN
This is phenomenal news as Green is one of the most respected cryptographers in the field
kobayashi··on Amazon Go
I'm more interested to know how it handles one person taking something off the shelf and handing it to another person.
kobayashi··on UBlock Origin for Safari
Yes! Been waiting for a uBlock Origin for Safari for a while.

I looked into Ellis Tsung, the listed dev, but can't find much about him. The LinkedIn profile most likely (IMO) to be his only has 35 contacts and I've never heard of his other projects listed on his personal webpage. Throwing this out here in case somebody as something to add.

The most important aspect one should look for in an app (/extension) before installation is whether or not the dev is sufficiently trustworthy. Not yet sure about this individual.

Also, if we're making wish lists, somebody please look into uMatrix for Safari!

kobayashi··on War Is a Racket by General Smedley D. Butler (1933)
I'm currently debating if this ludicrous comparison deserves my time to debunk this lunacy.

I sure hope that HN readers see the many faults in the logic and morality of such a statement.

kobayashi··on CBC asks for $400M in increased government funding to go ad-free
For those of you who are outside of Canada, and even for the many within, please take some time to consider the possibility that the CBC is not a benevolent public broadcaster, and is perhaps not actually putting out high-quality, unique, and novel information that would be inaccessible to Canadians without its public subsidies. Tristin Hopper[0] does a wonderful job of explaining a centrist's argument against funding the CBC/the CBC's modus operandi.

[0] Tristin Hopper: Maybe CBC could use its resources to do something other than steal other people’s ideas http://www.nationalpost.com/m/wp/full-comment/blog.html?b=ne...

kobayashi··on The new MacBook Pro is kind of great for hackers
I'm not sure what you mean
kobayashi··on The new MacBook Pro is kind of great for hackers
As someone who took good care of my MacBook charging adaptors and cables, I found them to be perfectly durable. Those arms are only problematic when one wraps the cable 'immediately', instead of giving an extra loop and then beginning the winding.
kobayashi··on WOT Firefox Addon selling user data
Uninstalled from Chrome, Firefox, and Safari. Sick to my stomach. Now I have to let my contact network know, as I've endorsed WOT to many of them.
kobayashi··on Instapaper Premium is now free for everyone
Hi Brian, would you PLEASE consider increasing the maximum read speed in Instapaper. Pocket's much speedier maximum read speeds (with iOS' great Alex voice) are a huge pull that I can't leave behind.
kobayashi··on Disclosing vulnerabilities to protect users
Agreed. Though Analemma_ has a point about Google's decision not to provide security updates to Android devices/OSs which are just 2 years old.
kobayashi··on Instapaper Premium is now free for everyone
Regarding accessibility aspects, Pocket provides a great "Listen" (Text to Speech) function (at least on iOS) with maximum speeds far faster than Instapaper. It's pretty much the biggest reason that I use Pocket.
kobayashi··on Was a Trump Server Communicating With Russia?
Ensure that your logless VPN provider runs their own DNS service. Test at https://dnsleaktest.com
kobayashi··on Was a Trump Server Communicating With Russia?
Can you say as to how long the trump-email[dot]com was active before it started SERVFAILing?

Also, I'd love to see the evidence if you're actually able to provide it.

kobayashi··on DMCA exemption for repairs, modifications, research on your vehicle takes effect
For those who don't take the time to read the (short) article, here's the most important part (IMO):

>The downside: In 2018, advocates will have to ask for permission to repair their cars again—a daunting process that costs a massive amount of time, effort, and legal fees.

>But we’re trying to change that. Yesterday, iFixit and Repair.org submitted comments to the Copyright Office in support of carving out a permanent exemption for all repair and security research—for cars and everything else. Hopefully, fixing your tractor or hunting for security vulnerabilities in your car won’t be a jailable offence ever again.

>If you want to help make the world safe for repair, join Repair.org—they’re on the front lines every day, fighting for your right to fix everything you own.

kobayashi··on Total Nightmare: USB-C and Thunderbolt 3
That's a really big wart on the outside of the computer. Hopefully it won't need to be that big on the Mac.
kobayashi··on The bizarre role reversal of Apple and Microsoft
I totally can, as I'm in the same boat. And the 240 CAD increase just for an extra 8GB of RAM - what a ripoff!
kobayashi··on Apple’s new MacBook Pro kills off most of the ports you probably need
I held out hope for this reveal. Did I mention that I'm tremendously disappointed?
kobayashi··on Apple’s new MacBook Pro kills off most of the ports you probably need
This was a company that said they cared. That made products which were far and away better than the competitors. I paid the Apple Tax, but it was worth it because I didn't have Windows headaches and because I had a better quality system that was truly optimized for both easy use and for power users. It was great. I actually feel crushed by this news. I valued the trust I had in Apple.

And I don't say all of this lightly. I've read the threads the occur after every major Apple release. They're always replete with naysayers. I've never been one of those people. This seems different.

kobayashi··on Apple’s new MacBook Pro kills off most of the ports you probably need
Throughly enjoyed the Apple ecosystem for the past 13 years. Multiple AirPorts, Watch, iPhones, iPads, Macs. Never have I ever been so extremely disappointed with Apple. Actually, I'm not sure that I've ever before been rather disappointed Apple. I wasn't a fan of the Sierra release because I don't like using Siri but ultimately it didn't ruin then OS, it was just a new feature that I wouldn't use.

But now? The pricing is insane. The max at 16GB of RAM is a joke. I was looking to buy a MacBook to last me years of heavy power-use. Has Apple forgotten about me?

kobayashi··on Apple’s expected Mac event on October 27 is official
Seems very likely, and they'll probably go over that aspect in the address.
kobayashi··on Why an unhackable mobile phone is a complete marketing myth
The point of the article is true, but it's also a pretty poor-quality piece. Few links to references events, and even a basic fact like the name of the company that used the Trident attack is wrong. It's the "NSO Group", not "NOS".
← PreviousPage 4 of 14Next →