HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

koko775

990 karma · joined September 27, 2009

submissionscomments
koko775··on Wrong man was executed in Texas, probe says
I can do that (I think I can flag, but this was not always the case), and silently grow to hate the content on HN as flagging fails to catch the borderline cases (and possibly devalue each individual flag).

Or I can break that rule to voice displeasure and hope that someone shared that opinion enough to point me somewhere better, create somewhere better, or effect change.

> If your account is less than a year old, please don't submit comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. (It's a common semi-noob illusion.)

My account is over a year old (and I've lurked for longer). Therefore, I'm good!

But in all seriousness, while it probably is not turning into Reddit, I'm certainly planning to relegate HN, for the purposes of my news browsing / time management, to a category shared with other spammy news sites, for somewhat similar reasons.

koko775··on Wrong man was executed in Texas, probe says
I know it's tacky to meta-complain, but public interest articles are one of the reasons I stopped reading Reddit.

I am looking for one particular kind of "signal" in that signal-to-noise ratio, and while this might be of interest to a population including hackers, a population of hackers would likely not identify this article as relevant, outrageous though the article may be.

I've noticed HN's articles growing steadily less and less interesting. Perhaps it's time to move again. Any suggestions? MeFi? Other sites? Does a new one need to be created?

koko775··on Lightbox is joining Facebook
Evan Priestley (lead on Phabricator) doesn't actually work for Facebook anymore. And he's doing what he like. What's so dubious about that?
koko775··on Head of Time Warner Cable Unfamiliar With Apple's AirPlay
But it is clunky. It's a threat, but it's clunky.

Roku - weird platform, but improving. BrightScript has its issues, but it does support HLS and VAST for ads.

Boxee - buggy.

SamsungTV - horrible platform, horrible (borderline abusive) approval process. Already fragmented between 2010 and 2011 models, poor and/or outright wrong documentation.

GoogleTV - possibly one of the best of the bunch, since Android is a worthwhile base, but still has a few screws loose.

Others - often too small/difficult to invest heavily in making something truly good.

koko775··on Three things you should never put in your database
Altering the logging table scheme once it reaches several million rows? Not fun. I think flat files are much easier to scale.
koko775··on Writing a CV in LaTeX
I always take a second look at a LaTeX resume, if only because learning enough LaTeX to make a decent resume is a positive indicator - albeit merely a cosmetic one.
koko775··on Meteor is now MIT licensed
I was also critical, and agreed, this is a fantastic change!
koko775··on "If you want to order it, use 'view source' to find the commented-out link."
I use prgmr and they are fantastic for the geek who knows how to handle themselves. You also get a pretty decent /64 IPv6 allocation.

Their hardware console was enough for me to install Arch Linux despite no official support for it. It's pretty sweet.

koko775··on Meteor meets NoGPL
Having developed and released something under the GPL a long time ago, I am not anti-GPL, but that doesn't mean I'm not wary of it.

> Obviously you want to release only code that will help you code less in the future

No, I want to release code other people might find useful.

> ie: let others maintain feature X for FREE for us

This sounds naive. Virtually nobody writes a library then abandons it when other people start helping out.

> don't give them what MATTERS

"What matters" is highly subjective and different to different people. What matters to Twitter is the userbase and user experience. So they open-source their database stuff, Bootstrap, and a plethora of other things. And why not?

It's not hypocritical. The GPL was critical to the fight against closed OSes and the closed tools that made writing software essentially limited and pay-to-program.

My view of open-source and programming in general is that there are many things that programming can help you do. More often than not, these are the same things. The more programmers can help each other to spend more time writing things that are great, the better off we all are.

The GPL fights proprietary software, but for things that are not products on their own, but are designed to be a component of or integrated into other products, it can also fight other programmers as well. I use GPL software, but I don't use GPL libraries or frameworks. (The LGPL is less selfish - the whole software ecosystem doesn't need to open for it to play its part, but the library damn well stay open.)

koko775··on Meteor meets NoGPL
I think you're turning this too corporate too soon.

At this stage your most powerful evangelists will be hobbyists and spare-timers. When I write code, I like to write it open-source. Setting the obviously negative connotation aside, it is objectively true that the GPL code, compiled or no, is a license virus that spreads so fundamentally that linking with non-GPL-compatible code violates the terms. Because the distinction between client and server code is blurred, this makes the territory murky and introduces overhead into the developer's mind as to whether what is being written can ever be open-sourced or not.

---

Besides dampening enthusiasm for using Meteor, this can also reduce the quality and usefulness of modules being released. This sounds counter-intuitive, but consider the following hypotheticals:

Company A develops and maintains a production-ready module that is especially useful for anyone using Meteor. However, the legal department says that the company cannot release software under GPLv3 (this is common). Company B and Person Z want to use it, the former with a commercial license, the latter with a open-source license.

Because Company A cannot release the module under a permissive license, they can 1) Release it permissively but in a GPL-incompatible license, thus banning all Person Z's from developing open-source software with it legally, 2) Opt not to release it at all to Person Z, and just license it to Company B. 3) Abandon Meteor for something they can both release openly (to give back and get more eyes and hands) and develop in-house.

Company C uses a closed-source library, because they're required to use it because it's the only one out there, and they're contractually obligated because that's the business they're in. They use Meteor to get the project off the ground and they never move off, because it's what they know and are good at. Company C can never write, for example, a white-label platform to distribute to Company X and Company Y, because at best they could only distribute the platform sans non-GPL parts. And while the licensing is viral, the understanding of it will not be. So it may lead to GPL violations down the road because Company X didn't understand, and Company C may be holding the bag. Legal doesn't want the company to take the risk and assume liability, so it says "no" and kills the project's use of Meteor.

Company D thinks about the hypothetical case of Company C, only it was just founded and is looking at Meteor. Maybe it was founded by Person Z. Because of the hypothetical of Company C, and because Company D doesn't know what their business is yet, they decide to avoid a potential future nightmare and write their own framework. Maybe they open-source it, because it's compelling and useful, and they want to get as many eyeballs and hands on it as they can, improving it.

---

tl;dr I was super-excited about Meteor, but now that it's GPL I will not be touching it with a ten foot pole. I am really sad about this.

Because I value developer freedom, I do not use GPL'd code in my projects, even if it is objectively good. Because I support open-source, and want to give back when I can I do not want use Meteor with a commercial license. So because of your choice of license - and for no other reason - I can not and will not use Meteor.

koko775··on C++ programming pioneer hacks off-grid, DIY, smart home
Don't know about you, but while I knew video phones existed a long time back, almost all of my calls with my parents recently have been over Facetime, now that there's a simple, intuitive way for us to use it (I bought them an iPad). Automated homes may just be a technology waiting to be designed right, not just solved. After all, home is our retreat from...well, anywhere, really. Design matters if you're going to be encountering it all your life.
koko775··on Poll: How long have you been programming?
Viewing source of the internet around the time I was just starting elementary school. Educated me a bunch, especially since the internet back then was super-primitive. People were using VBScript back then. I had no mentors, so when I took a look at Javascript, I got confused as to what curly braces were ("Where's the endif? VBScript has endifs! And what are those silly {} things for?"). I finally got into PHP around middle school early high school when I wrote a really primitive webcomic system for a friend, modeled after megatokyo. Full of SQL injection holes, though I started to figure out and create my own OOP-ish system.

Later: Python (Pylons), PostgreSQL, Java Servlets, Jersey, Play Framework, Jackson (in roughly that order, omitting a lot of detail).

Only ever had a mentor who taught me new things once, when learning the servlets stuff. The rest of the time, I had no mentorship :(.

koko775··on Google I/O Sells Out in 30 Seconds
Agreed! The only reason I want to go is to share wisdom and learn.
koko775··on Google I/O Sells Out in 30 Seconds
Sold out as of now. I had been trying since 7:00:00 - and still could not get a ticket.

And I need one for work, damn it - I actually care about Android development. I couldn't care less about a free device.

koko775··on Keeping bash history in sync between multiple terminals
I suggest some of the following setopt's: APPEND_HISTORY AUTO_CD HIST_IGNORE_SPACE HIST_IGNORE_DUPS HIST_NO_STORE

AUTO_CD is nice because you can just straight-up type a directory and it'll go there (i.e. .. or tilde).

HIST_IGNORE_SPACE and HIST_NO_STORE work out nicely when you want commands not to show up, i.e. stuff where maybe your password is inline, or you're handling something sensitive.

HIST_IGNORE_DUPS just saves space. HIST_IGNORE_ALL_DUPS even more so.

koko775··on How I survived a plane crash
Seems like the fate of any popular news aggregator is to aggregate things of general interest, no matter how well-targeted it begins.
koko775··on Why I decided to skip college, and how I've fared (10 months later)
I suggest you audit CS classes at Berkeley or Stanford if at all possible. I'm also a very practical programmer, but being exposed to the ides and theory are important, if for no other reason than you are aware they exist and gain an expanded ability to conceive of what is possible.
koko775··on GVM - the Go version manager
They take opposite approaches. Maven gives you scaffolding; it's up to you to customize it. Ant gives you practically nothing, but you can do whatever you want. If you want to code on the shoulders of giants then Maven will help you much more than Ant will, IMO.
koko775··on GVM - the Go version manager
You can set up Artifactory on a nearby server you own and proxy all of your package requests through it. Works quite well.
koko775··on GVM - the Go version manager
Maven.

* Cross-platform.

* Easy access to remote packages as soon as they're posted.

* Versions must specified, so builds are very repeatable. You bear the responsibility of updating your dependencies, but you don't get surprised if a version decides to break compatibility, either.

Also, very decentralized, and it's easy to create a directory locally to hold the dependencies within a project (specify a file:// repository relative to ${project.dir}), or on a per-system-user level (mvn install), or on a per-company/organizational unit basis (self-hosted repos are a cinch).

It's actually a fantastic package management system tailored to Java that works extremely well. Its main problem is that it's also fantastically verbose, and including more and more build plugins can grow exponentially more arcane the greater the number of plugins involved. However, with Go's standardized directory layout among other things (I admit, I haven't done much research into trying Go out), something akin to Maven may actually be a good fit.

koko775··on Poll: What's Your Favorite Programming Language?
As if the goal or intention were to approach UNIX's philosophy. UNIX is practically by definition decoupled. Integrated Development Environments are by definition integrated.

I spent years hating Java and embracing vim, but as I tried to shape my environment more, I grew increasingly frustrated. Finally, I was forced by necessity to use Eclipse and Maven with Java, and the lightbulb turned on for me.

Any language that takes 30-40% less code to do something for you is taking away some freedom. They're making convention easy but can make escaping it to be hard, or may slow down because of more dynamic-ness, or some other tradeoff. And there are many good tradeoffs to be had when creating programming languages, of course.

The deal with Java is that it is the pedant of languages. Half-answers and hand-waving to how objects interact (i.e. duck-typing) aren't good enough for it. This makes libraries or APIs very, very easy to reason about, because if it doesn't access to that information then that means that the library or API is broken or intentionally hiding those details from you. But on the other hand, it enforces a kind of light, but still present, agreement between classes on their relationships to each other.

The point at which your thoughts on IDE come into this is that because Java has a very rigid structure, it can make sweeping code changes at massive scale. This is something that, with shallower insight into the language, or without insight into the flow of code through a method (i.e. checking for dead code or invalid assignments), and so on, would take a massive number of man-hours to duplicate, or make use of the exact same code the IDEs themselves have written for the purpose (i.e. emacs and vim are capable of delegating certain functions to eclipse). Decoupling it in the UNIX way doesn't really make a whole lot of sense when everything is very interrelated in nature.

As well as generate, but given that some people think that if code can be generated, it should be done at runtime by the language instead, I don't want to argue this too hard in this reply. They're not wrong but they sure aren't right.

koko775··on What Does It Mean To Love What You Do?
Don't be too depressed. I've been programming in some measure since I was ~4, and I'm 23 now. Many of those years were me slowly teaching myself, because I had no mentors.

It's really not about time, it's about projects and people. You learn by doing, not by time spent. Don't worry about it.

koko775··on The Borderlands Gun Collector's Club
Oof. Hard to let that Fallout 3 comment slide. New Vegas was a spiritual successor to Fallouts 1 and 2, and was an amazing sequel. I'd like to know more about how she believes Fallout 3 exceeded New Vegas, as New Vegas was arguably closer to the original vision for Van Buren, and a heck of a lot of fun (and funny) to boot.

That aside, I've beaten Crawmerax probably nearly fifty times by now, so everything she says about addiction, I'll agree with. Multiple pearlescents and armory abuses for the win! :D

koko775··on New Reddit CEO reporting for duty
Nice! All the best to Yishan! He'll need it, that's for sure.

[edit: Okay, apparently pointing out struggles Reddit will have in maturing is not welcome here. Rest of post deleted.]

koko775··on Why I love Common Lisp and hate Java
Perhaps I should have clarified and added some more nuance. If the vast majority of the classes you write are, by design, intended to be directly run from the command line as their primary mode of execution, another language may be better-suited to what, to me, would sound like shell operations. Groovy, Python, or others may prove more concise and maintainable in such circumstance.
koko775··on Backbone 0.9.0 released
Thanks, I'll take a look at it. I'm always willing to invest cash in myself to buy good educational materials.
koko775··on Backbone 0.9.0 released
Can't rewrite that which doesn't exist...yet :)
koko775··on Backbone 0.9.0 released
For someone who prefers to write Java on the backend (it can be made elegant and not enterprise-y, I promise), can its rubyisms (on rails) be mapped easily onto other web frameworks?
koko775··on Backbone 0.9.0 released
I'm trying to learn Backbone, I really am. But there's so many tutorials suggesting everything that I don't have a clue how I should structure a project and what to think about as a codebase grows.

Granted, I'm fairly new to Javascript, but - no offense meant - I can't get excited about node.js. Backbone is the first thing about Javascript that really makes me want to write it. And I know enough to know what I lack is primarily practical experience, but every step I take with Backbone feels like a misstep, because it seems like there's no one right answer by design, so I'm paralyzed.

What to do?

koko775··on Why I love Common Lisp and hate Java
Seriously. I've been doing Java for years and it had been so long since I wrote public static void main etc. that I had to look it up. If you're writing mostly classes to be run straight-up from the command line, you're doing it wrong.
← PreviousPage 7 of 10Next →