HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kolektiv

1,625 karma · joined December 25, 2008

London/Horsham (and anywhere else interesting).

Tech Theory + Practice. I care most about changing the world in meaningful ways through technology. I care very little about yet another X.

Contact me at andrew at xyncro dot com.

irc:kolektiv:irc

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kolektiv; my proof: https://keybase.io/kolektiv/sigs/0d5gliRyPmqTUqjf5C4XNh5y1sry6und7d3z4LYWCyo ]

submissionscomments
kolektiv··on The secret life of punctuation - ¶ (The Pilcrow)
I'll echo the other positives - very interesting and enjoyable read, looking forward to the next parts. If there was enough for a book at any point, I can think of several friends that would also enjoy it.
kolektiv··on Against UI Chrome (not the browser)
A little off topic, but if you're looking for iPad touch control of things like MIDI devices, hardware is already out there to do that. Projects like touchOSC are providing the graphical instances, as well as others like S1MIDITrigger. This is getting bigger and bigger, and I imagine that's the reason Jazz Mutant packed it in - the writing was on the wall that the iPad is storming this market.
kolektiv··on AppHarbor Sets their pricing and asks for feedback.
Background worker and job pricing are probably more interesting to me academically speaking. At the moment, have people been able to test those? I didn't think so, and I would think they will be more variable in their data usage.

Do you know yet what kind of restrictions/capabilities a background worker process may have? External ports/consistent URI, for example?

kolektiv··on Piracy Doubled My App Sales
iPhone app "piracy" is perhaps a little different from run of the mill software copyright infringement. It's one of the only places around where even for consumers, there's no way of trying before you buy. I can imagine that there is a significant (I have no idea how large, and not a majority certainly, but significant) number of people who will pirate an iPhone app and then later buy it if they find themselves using it. I'm honest enough to admit that I do this, and I very much doubt I'm alone.
kolektiv··on My Experiences as a Female Software Engineer
It's hubris to recognize it outside of your own head! Although that's rather a culturally biased observation I admit.
kolektiv··on My Experiences as a Female Software Engineer
I had to laugh, the same thing struck me as I read it. I'm sure she is very good, but in my own experience impostor syndrome merely increases with time. I came out of university thinking I was good. Now, I feel worse every year. In objective terms I'm clearly better, and make a huge effort on continual learning and improvement. But now I know enough to know how much I don't know.
kolektiv··on Ask HN: Please review my startup: TheSunnyTrail
I rarely comment on these threads, but I had a quick look at yours and I like it a lot. It's fresh, nicely designed (although some of it could be a little "tighter" perhaps although I'd struggle to quantify that). I also think it fulfills a useful niche. I think it's going to live or die by the price points to some degree - companies who can afford X probably already have the capabilities of visualising this data, where X is the problematic point, if that makes sense.

But I think there's a niche there. It's certainly something I'd consider using if a project had this requirement.

Only one design point I'm not so keen on - the cutting off of the descender on the "y" of sunny trail on internal pages - it just feels a little jarring to my eye. Fairly minor quibble though - nice project!

kolektiv··on Ugly Software (like Blackboard) Gives Education a Bad Name
I feel a similar way. My other half is a teacher, and every time I've looked at the software systems she uses (in the UK) I'm appalled. I've identified a few software tools which would make teachers lives much better and easier, based on problems she actually has. Are they hard to build? Not that hard. Could I get them in to schools? Not a chance.

Approved bidders, closed lists, hugely expensive bidding processes, it's calculated to keep the market sewn up by the education IT vendors (usual suspects, Capita, Fujitsu, etc.)

At a time when the UK is looking to save money, the state of school software provisioning is shameful on multiple levels.

kolektiv··on The Long Beard's Revenge
Ah, my apologies, I looked for it but didn't find it. I note that the previous submission seems to have exact same URL, something which I thought was prevented by the submission process. A bug perhaps? Sorry, nevertheless.
kolektiv··on Hard Core: What Porn's Ubiquity Says About Men and Women
If I wanted to be cynical and/or pretentious, I might draw a parallel between the infant-like nature of Hello Kitty products, the Freudian childhood wish that might indicate, and the fact that her asking you to buy something rather than buying it herself portrays an interesting father/daughter dynamic. But that would be truly weird, and wait, are we still on HN? OK I'm disoriented now.
kolektiv··on The dark side of open source conferences [about women being harassed]
To clarify, if you're flirting with someone, yes they may flirt back and perhaps "make a pass" at you. In this case however, she was not flirting with this guy. Just because someone is flirting with other people, does not make them open to flirting with you. If they wanted to be flirting with you, they would be already.

Someone being flirtatious with others is not a green light for you to make a pass. Not if they're not flirting with you. Even then, there's still plenty of nuance and context which would determine whether that's acceptable.

kolektiv··on The TCP/IP Drinking Game
Good grief I'd be hammered. Admittedly, not my area of expertise, but still. Bad for the ego. Which in turn is good for the drinking, so... Bartender, line some shots up...
kolektiv··on The dark side of open source conferences [about women being harassed]
Going for a kiss when someone has made no sign that they're in to you? When there are no signals that this is perhaps fine? No that's not cool!

Brought the passes on herself? No. You can flirt with someone, if they don't reciprocate, it's not cool. First move = kiss is not flirting, it's massively inappropriate.

kolektiv··on The dark side of open source conferences [about women being harassed]
But the point here is surely "flirting with other boys", not the one who then assaulted her. Can you flirt? Sure. Can you wear what you like, safe in the knowledge that people still have no right to assault you? Yes, you should be able to.

I'm a guy, but when I go out I try and look nice. Sometimes I'll flirt with people. That's fine. If I flirt with someone and it's not reciprocated, I stop. Immediately.

You're basically just rephrasing the "she was asking for it"argument there. And it's crap. So don't.

kolektiv··on Groupon 2.0, You Better Believe This Is The Future Of Commerce
I'll probably give away karma by saying so, but where is the interest in this article? I'm not saying that groupon is not an interesting model, but this article is basically a press release, stuffed with some utterly baseless claims like "how we will all probably be shopping in the future, i.e. socially"

Based on what? This is fluff. I work in retail technology, e-commerce, etc. and there are many interesting changes happening. But this kind of meaningless puff piece is just noise.

edit: also annoyed by the summary including "features a daily deal on the best stuff to do, see, eat, and buy in more than 150 cities around the world". Yeah. Where "around the world" means "around North America".

kolektiv··on WikiLeaks Archive — Cables Uncloak U.S. Diplomacy
If politicians no longer feel comfortable stating opinions or plans which would be unacceptable to the electorate and/or their own voters, I for one don't feel that's entirely bad. I'm pretty much in favour of politicians being open about their plans and principles.
kolektiv··on The Python IAQ: Infrequently Answered Questions
One of those times when I hugely miss languages with pattern matching/guards.

  fact(1) = 1
  fact(n) = n * fact(n-1)
Seems much more readable to me.
kolektiv··on [dead]
But in an odd kind of way, people do have a right to be annoyed. It's a little bit circuitous, but... People trade their data, pseudo-willingly, for a perceived service (which they like). They know that Facebook et al make money from this. Therefore, if Facebook still have their data, but start offering less, or take the service away, the terms have changed. If it goes down, it is now imbalanced. Annoyance results.

Admittedly, most of the people using these services probably haven't considered it very deeply, and more peeved that the shiny has gone...

kolektiv··on Wheretheladies.at Shows You Where The Ladies Are At
That's the kind of thinking which is likely to counteract the point of this app.
kolektiv··on Offshoring is not making UK computer scientists largest unemployed group
Sorry, I am just going to reply to myself with a slightly contrarian viewpoint - as the article points out, low skilled jobs are being outsourced. This might make it more likely that it's graduate jobs being replaced with offshore/outsourcing, in which case we'll be left with the classic "foot on the ladder" problem.

Saying that, it's not my experience that this is having a noticeable impact, for what personal experience is worth.

kolektiv··on Offshoring is not making UK computer scientists largest unemployed group
I know very well from trying to hire decent comp-sci graduates in the UK that it's very difficult right now. They're either very poor candidates, or they're being snapped up on very high salaries. If you're a good comp-sci graduate right now I would say that things are looking great.
kolektiv··on Don’t Click The WTF Link On Twitter Unless You Do Like Sex With Goats
Which is quite astounding. These aren't novice programmers fresh from a comp-sci course and in to the big bad world. Making this kind of mistake (which is a mistake on not one, but many grounds) is extraordinary. It's as if the ideas of idempotence, REST, basic security, treating external input as hostile, etc. have never even been mentioned between them.

I'm not foolish enough to imagine that this is anything other than a blip for them - their first mover momentum and market dominance is invincible for the time being, but they don't deserve it if they keep putting users at risk as casually as they seem to be. So far, we've seen nothing too nasty (though this could be embarrassing I suppose), but it's a bad sign looking ahead.

kolektiv··on The Genius and Tragedy of Patrick McKenzie (patio11)
Or possibly, he enjoys what he does, enjoys being his own boss, likes the challenges that the types of software he works on present, and values those things higher than going and shaving seconds off for some airline. If he is, his genius is more about finding a way of being happy than software, marketing, or anything else.

I know HN tends to be all about the money at times, but seriously, it's not everything.

kolektiv··on The Obligatory WePay "Company Culture" Blog Post
Yes, that's quite easy if the definition of personal life is "Sweet Jesus, sleep!"

More seriously, that's the kind of thing which does creep in to companies. They have a culture already. It's a long hours culture. You may or may not think that's a bad thing, but it's there. It's quite hard to lose as well. People come in, they can't work less than the people already there, so they jump in to it. Soon people that only work 11 hour days are regarded as slackers. Nip it in the bud. It can't work forever, and it'll get harder to change.

kolektiv··on Finding awesome developers in programming interviews
I wanted to echo the last part of this one. I've interviewed a lot of people and I see people "exaggerating" or outright lying about their skill levels and abilities more often than I would expect. It seems, anecdotally, to be increasing as well. If you find someone doing this - no hire. Instantly. If you're the one with the CV - please don't. For your own sake. It's poisonous, and it won't help you long term.
kolektiv··on Oracle set to merge Java virtual machines
"It's not an easy problem taking the best of each, figuring out what the long-term convergence plan is."

That's an understatement. The complexity of merging two fairly distinct VMs while trying to maintain feature parity with both separate previous versions, and taking the best features of both? Eighteen months seems optimistic. I also hope they have some incredibly good way of producing a combined test suite, because this seems like the most promising way of introducing myriad subtle bugs I can imagine.

kolektiv··on Review my site: AwesomenessReminders
Positive social feedback is useful, but I think that I would take issue with the definition of social here. Social means genuinely social, not a paid reproduction of social. I would think that people who would genuinely enjoy this service may have some self-image and narcissism issues which would be better served by spending the money addressing those.

This is the same kind of awesome as claiming to be an amazing Casanova due to having slept with many prostitutes. It's not always about the action, but the intention.

kolektiv··on Human-shaped pylons carry electricity across Iceland
Good lord don't do it again then! More seriously, yes Iceland does still have enough money and borrowing capability to keep the infrastructure going. They're not all on the streets.
kolektiv··on Free ("The iTunes Store is a failure.")
Spotify’s got it right. A perfect interface with free streaming and a paid for mobile app that allows thousands of tracks to live on your handset as if you owned them.

Wrong. As if I owned something isn't good enough for many people. It's the same problem as streaming. If I stop paying you a monthly fee I don't own them anymore.

Spotify does allow you to buy DRM free downloads. But there's not a huge difference in price between that and any other service as far as I'm aware. Spotify hasn't really changed the long term situation. Music is still seen as more financially valuable by sellers than by buyers. While the difference in price between legal and free (illegitimately) is still perceived as too high, "piracy" will continue.

(And yes, the quote marks there are a mark of disdain for that term. If I were to call parking infringements "illegal land invasions" I'd be a laughing stock. If you can't make your case with emotive terminology, improve your case)

kolektiv··on Good design for the rest of us?
Design? I don't really think that producing a knock off of the MacBook Pro counts as design. I'd also be extremely surprised if the build quality was anywhere close. The MacBook Pro required some fairly careful engineering and matching of parts, etc. to get the heat production situation under control. I would be more than hesistant in expecting this to work without flaws.
← PreviousPage 10 of 11Next →