374 karma · joined February 7, 2008
YC Badge: 0x6d00d85db5b1ea92ae449f04d8e4933e4936df61
Thanks for the comment.
I'd much rather be called a "deal" than a "project" -- the former implies that someone's investing in your start-up; the latter is just demeaning.
We thought it would be cool if we carried an alert through the sign-up process and added it afterwards. I guess we didn't realize how confusing it would be when the registration was complete. We'll be making this a lot more clear; thanks for the feedback.
The page you're viewing (the Dashboard) allows you to:
- View comments by people you're following (/home)
- View alerts you've subscribed to (/home/alerts)
- View comments shared by people you're following (/home/shared)
We're going to revisit that welcome msg; for now, you should visit http://www.backtype.com/home/alerts to find your alert and subscribe to more. Alternatively, you can perform searches on http://www.backtype.com/comments and subscribe to them from the results page.
Thanks again.
We'll be releasing an API soon so that the apps/tools/etc we don't build can still be built.
Individual comments make up a very small percentage of a page's content, so what we're doing is more similar to Google than you suggest (they also index your comments -- search for them). We display excerpts of pages; we attribute them liberally. A search result on Google leads you to the full page of content; a search result on BackType leads you to a full page of content. We index content for purposes of discovery i.e. search.
== Fair use
Also, it's pretty obvious that we're not in competition with content publishers, and we provide a very effective way to prohibit BackType from indexing comments.
We try to respond to every single e-mail we get; not sure how yours was missed. I apologize.
We've talked about our policy on re-publishing comments in a few places:
- http://www.markevanstech.com/2008/08/30/five-questions-withb...
- http://blog.backtype.com/2008/08/on-republishing-comments/
- etc
In summary: what BackType is doing is very similar to other search engines. We make every effort to provide content publishers with familiar methods to restrict BackType from indexing their site's content: http://www.backtype.com/faq#q14
We're trying to be as transparent as possible. We attribute comments to their authors so they can be rewarded for the thoughts and insights they share in comments across the web. Additionally, BackType is already becoming a recognized source of traffic for publishers and we want that to continue.
The answer isn't do to one or the other -- it depends on the situation.
Unfortunately, now we're on EC2 and there's no way to pass reverse DNS lookups on e-mail originating from an instance. That's bad.
Looked through many third-party solutions, but they are expensive and impose artificial limitations, so we're basically going to get another machine outside of EC2 and use that.
Delivering e-mail reliably does have a slight learning curve, but it's really not worth it to go third-party unless you're sending heavy HTML newsletter type e-mails to hundreds of thousands or millions of people. Knowledge of e-mail and the issues surrounding its successful delivery is knowledge you can carry from project to project or start-up to start-up, so it's not such a bad idea.
Scary.
Try this to compare: http://compressorrater.thruhere.net/
http://www.knallgrau.at/code/colorpicker
I use it on my web app; Twitter also uses it.