HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

konstruktor

1,306 karma · joined July 9, 2011

submissionscomments
konstruktor··on Aaron Swartz commits suicide
Some of your son's essays have contributed to my outlook on life in a significant way. Please accept my sincere condolences for your loss.
konstruktor··on Aaron Swartz commits suicide
I would agree with you if the separation of powers would work flawlessly, but it seems to me that even in many modern democracies, prosecutors have the means to do things that are quite punishing.
konstruktor··on Aaron Swartz commits suicide
Because most academic research is at least partly funded by taxpayers (even more so everywhere but in the US), and scientists pay submission fees (again, with taxpayer money) to cover what the journals consider their contribution to the process. For some more information about the business practices of this industry, this is a nice, short text: http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2012/apr/22/academic-pu...
konstruktor··on [dead]
Also, this is from 2011, before the prosecution.
konstruktor··on Aaron Swartz commits suicide
Aaron Swartz did something he knew was morally right but very probably illegal in some way, and, him being a prodigy, I'm very confident he was aware of this. It is called activism, and is a very brave and noble thing to do, something most people don't have the guts for. Governments often try to break activists who threaten their agenda (or in this case, that of a dying industry), and it seems they have succeeded with him, which I find very sad and which makes me so angry.

Maybe being indicted while free may even be a bigger psychological pressure on somebody than being in prison. When you are in prison, you can focus all your energy on your case, and the situation can only get better than your current one, not worse. You have certain legal protections, and your basic needs are taken care of.

Imagine having to work a job to earn an income (your assets probably being seized) and function in society with a constant feeling of danger looming ahead. They can fuck up your life one little piece at a time. Imagine working on your defence when the computer you are using to do so can be seized at any time (some DA having convinced a judge that you may be hacking right now). Imagine restrictions on travel that make making a living even more difficult. Imagine randomly being delivered a letter with one more bogus charge.

While being free seems to be better than in prison from an objective point of view, given the workings of the threat detection system in our mind, made for tigers in the savannah, not constant worry and fear, it may be much worse. It is well known that the functioning of our "higher" abilities like creativity and critical thinking are impaired under constant stress. It's easy to conceive what this means for the feeling of self worth of somebody who lives for doing cool, meaningful, big things (one of my favourite essays ever, btw): http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/productivity

Also, it neatly avoids the aura of illegitimacy that imprisoning peaceful activists would have for a government.

One lesson that could be learned from this is to try and consciously provide people in his situation with an environment that feels safe. Nut just a fund for legal and living expenses and therapy to cope with the stress, but much more importantly, reliable relationships with people who are supporting, compassionate and willing to listen.

konstruktor··on Memorizing a programing language using spaced repetition software
What you mention is one more thing to remember when starting on a specific project/team: Which of the possible library functions should you use for a given Task?
konstruktor··on Memorizing a programing language using spaced repetition software
Having seen a lot of code that duplicates basic functionality of libraries used in the project I'm working on, just writing code might even be counterproductive as opposed to a systematic way of learning the libraries and their usage in the project, reinforcing bad behaviour.
konstruktor··on What one book could give me a new, useful superpower?
I second Guide to the Good Life by William Irvine. It contains applicable techniques and a modern explanation of Stoicism. Stoic Serenity by Keith Seddon is very nice too, it is a guided introduction to Stoic concepts and to Seneca and Marcus Aurelius.
konstruktor··on What one book could give me a new, useful superpower?
I would absolutely recommend the Roman Stoics. The privileged ones lived like kings, but were prone to lose everything if the political climate changed. Their lives were absolutely unpredictable and they found ways of dealing with it in their heads. One can read advice from a philosopher/teacher who was later killed by his disciple (Seneca, forced to commit suicide by Nero), maybe the best Roman emperor ever (Marcus Aurelius) or a slave who was freed only later in life (Epicetus). Those guys knew that nothing was theirs forever but dealt with it in a graceful way.
konstruktor··on "I've got nothing to hide" and other misunderstandings of privacy
I think the problem with laws like the one you mentioned is that they aren't perceived as a threat because of selective enforcement. Assuming your posting reflects the legal situation correctly, many people who consider themselves law abiding citizens have committed a felony, but it is only enforced on, say, the guy who gets into an argument with a cop at a traffic stop and then has his vehicle searched.

While that is much worse than a law that can and will be enforced broadly, people will paradoxically seem to perceive it as less of a threat. The problem is that there are many such laws, which accumulate into a weapon the authorities have against you. You may be accused of something totally absurd (putting up a light installation in public), but instead of having to back down after discovering you aren't a terrorist, the authorities will find a law that will allow them to hold you responsible for their excessive reaction, or at least "punish" you for them embarrassing themselves.

This is why I think society would, to some degree, benefit from radical transparency. If all crimes were punished, people would be much more motivated to actually fight unjust, overly broad or unspecific laws, because everybody knows that they will be affected.

Personally, I have made a conscious decision to go out of my way to preserve my ability to start every unwanted encounter with a cop by asking him for the reason he stopped me and for his badge number (a right I have in my country), even though that may not be what I would actually do. However, that means that I cannot so some things I consider OK but aren't legal. But then, I live in a country with reasonably simple and understandable laws, even for a layperson.

konstruktor··on Stop Conflating Violence and Mental Illness
One of the first things I, as a European, thought after hearing speculation on mental problems of the shooter was the following: If they just focus on the mental health issues on the shooter and start stereotyping, ostracizing and discriminating mentally ill people a bit more, maybe even with some law that limits their freedoms, people in the US will be able to avoid their two big taboo topics: Healthcare (and, by extension, taxes) and gun control. I would absolutely hate to be right on this one.
konstruktor··on 'Black swans' and 'perfect storms' become lame excuses for bad risk management
"reasonably forseeable" is hard to define. Let us, for a moment, use being able to implement countermeasures without seeming like a crazy lunatic as a definition. As a politician in a pre-9/11 world, if you had done what would have been necessary to prevent a 9/11 (not go and arrest the very guys who did it, that would have required perfect foresight), i.e. add bulletproof doors to planes, implement the very invasive searches the TSA does etc., maybe ground commercial aviation until those measures would have been in place, it would be the end of your career. The remote possibility of a terrorist attack has only become a justification for about everything after 9/11. Also, 9/11 was just one of many terrorist threats at that time, it's just in hindsight that we consider this particular one inevitable. Edit: Spelling
konstruktor··on 'Black swans' and 'perfect storms' become lame excuses for bad risk management
She obviously fails to grasp what Taleb calls a Black Swan, or ignores his definition for some cheap publicity: "The attacks of 9/11 were not black swans, she said. The FBI knew that questionable people were taking flying lessons on large aircraft."

They are the perfect example of a Black Swan. Quote Taleb (Black Swan, p.xxii): "... in spite of its outlier status, human nature makes us concoct explanations for its occurence after the fact, making it explainable and predictable", which is exectly what she is doing. And, one page later on 9/11: "had the risk been easily conceivable on September 10, it would not have happened".

He is not advocating abandoning risk management, he is in favour of risk management that doesn't need us to predict the future, as it is harder to reliably estimate the likeliness of very unlikely events.

Concerning the second example of earthquake risk and nuclear power plants: That, again, is a post-hoc rationalization. Everybody knew that earthquakes were a risk factor for NPP and was planning accordingly. They were just not planning for a Tsunami this size, as it was very, very unlikely. So including higher error margins for earthquakes next time is nice but not enough. Taleb on this: http://www.valuewalk.com/2011/03/nassim-taleb-black-swans/

Consider the aviation industry: After an accident, they find the root cause and eliminate it. It is now something expected, and can be directly dealt with. But also try to improve the system (e.g. via training) to be more robust towards all the root causes the didn't anticipate.

konstruktor··on Facebook Users Must Be Allowed To Use Pseudonyms, Says German Privacy Regulator
They are not deciding what Facebook must do in general, but what Facebook must do so that they can sell Germans to their advertisers. Clarification (edit): With this I mean that they don't have to make pseudonyms available to, say, the French.
konstruktor··on Heirloom Technology
In the context of this article, I want to recommend Design For The Real World by Victor Papanek. Many of the ideas mentioned here have been made popular by Papanek decades ago.
konstruktor··on Thinking the unthinkable
If a sudden moment of clarity would be a repeatable cure for mental illness, we would not need mental healthcare. Please read up on confirmation bias.
konstruktor··on Patented Book Writing System Creates, Sells Hundreds Of Thousands Of Books
And at least you can return a physical book to the seller when you find out it is auto-generated rubbish. Is this possible on kindle?
konstruktor··on Mona Lisa in 50 polygons, using a genetic algorithm (2008)
Thanks for the link. Looking at the Images, I find that the polygonal representation also yields a very cool visual effect.
konstruktor··on Sen. McCaskill to FAA Chief: Fix Electronic Device Rules or Face Legislation
> If the Senator wants to put her attention somewhere related to aviation, I would think there are more interesting issues surrounding airport security.

Wouldn't this useless regulation be a nice conversation starter in the right direction? It will establish a (moral) precedent that it's for politicians OK do get rid of rules that are "for safety" but actually aren't.

konstruktor··on Sen. McCaskill to FAA Chief: Fix Electronic Device Rules or Face Legislation
That private business property is flying in public airspace over other entities' private and public property. The federal agency is staffed according to regulations put into legislation by elected individuals.
konstruktor··on Sen. McCaskill to FAA Chief: Fix Electronic Device Rules or Face Legislation
Also, you can test/certify specific devices for cockpit use on specific planes.
konstruktor··on That square QR barcode on the poster? Check it's not a sticker
On the other hand, targeting can be very precise using this technique. Think bank advertisements.
konstruktor··on The Raspberry Pi web server speed test
"not possible" is quite a strong claim in the realm of concurrent software, and so is "simply". Benchmarking is taking a measurements of a nondeterministic process, i.e. a statistical sample. Yes, some problem with the setup is quite likely given the result, but other explanations are possible as well. What if some threshhold for some action that helps the server deal with more concurrent connections was just not hit at 100 connections? unlikely but not imposible.
konstruktor··on Apple - Think Twice
AFAIK, as a consumer, you cannot sign away these rights for physical products. For software, which you license, i.e. acquire usage rights, the situation seems to be different.
konstruktor··on Apple - Think Twice
For an example, see this summary of the baseline for warranties in the EU http://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/shopping/shopping-abroa... I suppose the reason why the software industry gets around this is that you can't buy software but only license it.
konstruktor··on Apple - Think Twice
In most markets, the law does not allow beta products and caveat emptor. Warranties against product flaws are mandatory. Personally, I would consider ghosting as shown by the OP a defect covered by warranty. In addition to that, a premium brand should treat early adopters well, especially those who bought the flagship product. This is the point OP seems to be making. However, due to their own design decisions, they have made this very expensive, which incentivizes them to provide shitty service, which is damaging their brand image.
konstruktor··on Apple - Think Twice
When batteries for my 2006 MBP's model had problems, Apple issued a recall. I got a new one in a UPS box that I could use to send the old one back. This cost apple parts and shipping, not even a technician's time. Service like this is much harder to provide if the computers you build are not repairable at all. They created a situation where fixing one problem means exchanging the whole unit. That is their own fault. Are you seriously blaming the customer for wanting a fault fixed in his 3kUSD computer with paid warranty extension?
konstruktor··on Norway is building thorium reactor
Thanks for, without giving actual examples, telling us that the people opposing nuclear are uninformed and unable to form complete sentences. Without this enlightened information one might have listened to them and judged them based on their arguments. Edit: spelling
konstruktor··on A Warning for Airbnb Hosts
I really hope that your are right. Everything else would be a very perverse incentive.
konstruktor··on Tor operator charged for child porn transmitted over his servers
IANAL, TINLA. I just had a look at the law concerning service providers (E-Commerce-Gesetz - E-Commerce Law) in Austria. It is quite liberal in its definition of a service provider, i.e. it does not only cover commercial service providers, and does not require any kind of license, but basically defines a service provider as a personal or legal entity that "provides a service of information society". Also, it contains several clauses that give providers immunity for the data they store and transmit. However, one explicit requirement is that the provider may not change any of the content transmitted to claim immunity. I am very interested in seeing whether the decryption/encryption of the data will prevent him from claiming immunity.

I want to add that Austrian law is very strict when it comes to the presumption of innocence. The right of a suspect not to be named, shown on a picture or otherwise identified is almost abolute (the only exception are suspects on the run, where this could help apprehend them). As an Austrian, I found it very disturbing to read the guy's full name in the ars article, something local media would not be allowed to do. If he is lucky and found innocent in court, the top search result with his name will forever be the ars article.

← PreviousPage 7 of 11Next →