1,306 karma · joined July 9, 2011
Maybe being indicted while free may even be a bigger psychological pressure on somebody than being in prison. When you are in prison, you can focus all your energy on your case, and the situation can only get better than your current one, not worse. You have certain legal protections, and your basic needs are taken care of.
Imagine having to work a job to earn an income (your assets probably being seized) and function in society with a constant feeling of danger looming ahead. They can fuck up your life one little piece at a time. Imagine working on your defence when the computer you are using to do so can be seized at any time (some DA having convinced a judge that you may be hacking right now). Imagine restrictions on travel that make making a living even more difficult. Imagine randomly being delivered a letter with one more bogus charge.
While being free seems to be better than in prison from an objective point of view, given the workings of the threat detection system in our mind, made for tigers in the savannah, not constant worry and fear, it may be much worse. It is well known that the functioning of our "higher" abilities like creativity and critical thinking are impaired under constant stress. It's easy to conceive what this means for the feeling of self worth of somebody who lives for doing cool, meaningful, big things (one of my favourite essays ever, btw): http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/productivity
Also, it neatly avoids the aura of illegitimacy that imprisoning peaceful activists would have for a government.
One lesson that could be learned from this is to try and consciously provide people in his situation with an environment that feels safe. Nut just a fund for legal and living expenses and therapy to cope with the stress, but much more importantly, reliable relationships with people who are supporting, compassionate and willing to listen.
While that is much worse than a law that can and will be enforced broadly, people will paradoxically seem to perceive it as less of a threat. The problem is that there are many such laws, which accumulate into a weapon the authorities have against you. You may be accused of something totally absurd (putting up a light installation in public), but instead of having to back down after discovering you aren't a terrorist, the authorities will find a law that will allow them to hold you responsible for their excessive reaction, or at least "punish" you for them embarrassing themselves.
This is why I think society would, to some degree, benefit from radical transparency. If all crimes were punished, people would be much more motivated to actually fight unjust, overly broad or unspecific laws, because everybody knows that they will be affected.
Personally, I have made a conscious decision to go out of my way to preserve my ability to start every unwanted encounter with a cop by asking him for the reason he stopped me and for his badge number (a right I have in my country), even though that may not be what I would actually do. However, that means that I cannot so some things I consider OK but aren't legal. But then, I live in a country with reasonably simple and understandable laws, even for a layperson.
They are the perfect example of a Black Swan. Quote Taleb (Black Swan, p.xxii): "... in spite of its outlier status, human nature makes us concoct explanations for its occurence after the fact, making it explainable and predictable", which is exectly what she is doing. And, one page later on 9/11: "had the risk been easily conceivable on September 10, it would not have happened".
He is not advocating abandoning risk management, he is in favour of risk management that doesn't need us to predict the future, as it is harder to reliably estimate the likeliness of very unlikely events.
Concerning the second example of earthquake risk and nuclear power plants: That, again, is a post-hoc rationalization. Everybody knew that earthquakes were a risk factor for NPP and was planning accordingly. They were just not planning for a Tsunami this size, as it was very, very unlikely. So including higher error margins for earthquakes next time is nice but not enough. Taleb on this: http://www.valuewalk.com/2011/03/nassim-taleb-black-swans/
Consider the aviation industry: After an accident, they find the root cause and eliminate it. It is now something expected, and can be directly dealt with. But also try to improve the system (e.g. via training) to be more robust towards all the root causes the didn't anticipate.
Wouldn't this useless regulation be a nice conversation starter in the right direction? It will establish a (moral) precedent that it's for politicians OK do get rid of rules that are "for safety" but actually aren't.
I want to add that Austrian law is very strict when it comes to the presumption of innocence. The right of a suspect not to be named, shown on a picture or otherwise identified is almost abolute (the only exception are suspects on the run, where this could help apprehend them). As an Austrian, I found it very disturbing to read the guy's full name in the ars article, something local media would not be allowed to do. If he is lucky and found innocent in court, the top search result with his name will forever be the ars article.