HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kshatrea

2,638 karma · joined July 17, 2011

submissionscomments
kshatrea··on The two things that could hurt Google
What you're describing, except search, are all "moats"[1]. They're all ways in which Google monetizes and generates revenue. Any threat to their bottomline has to come from people getting access to information in other ways: native mobile applications, Facebook's walled garden, television etc. To their credit, they saw the mobile juggernaut coming early unlike Microsoft and they dealt with it effectively, ditto for browsers and email. They did not deal with social that effectively. In each case, it was their ability to foresee an information flow paradigm and get on top of it. The argument here that can be made is that they're no longer that force that can monetize new information flow paradigms and that FB, Amazon, Apple are eating their lunch in some ways and whether they can make money without new sources of income (their new bets have not paid off yet). Whether this argument against them is stupid or thoughtful, the fact remains that this is a point that has been raised - not how good their products are, but how much money they can make, which is something a for-profit business must consider.

[1] http://techcrunch.com/2011/03/25/search-googles-castle-moat/

kshatrea··on India's pro-business Modi storms to historic election win
Thanks for the clarification - you've very politely reduced my objections to dust.
kshatrea··on India's pro-business Modi storms to historic election win
It is deplorable and a very tragic set of events. I wasn't there, so I had to depend on the media for my consumption of news. The Supreme Court of India has declared Narendra Modi as legally not guilty of any crimes. From the news it certainly seems the Court has erred, although it is a constitutional body and as a citizen I need to abide by its judgement. There are of course Indian citizens who charge that the media is bought and paid for, just like other countries. If you're asking why I voted for the BJP, in my city the local BJP leader is very good and the other party leaders are very corrupt.
kshatrea··on India's pro-business Modi storms to historic election win
An analysis of news reports suggests that you're mostly right, but there is a huge factor of the personal charisma of this man. Like Obama, he has played on the "hope & change" motto. Can he deliver, we will have to see.

You may downvote if you like, but I still do not see why this should be on the front page of HN!

kshatrea··on India's pro-business Modi storms to historic election win
All day I've been wondering when this or something like this would make it to HN. There's going to be polarization now - left wing or "secular" (believe me that is an overused term here in India) and so called liberals versus an opinionated group of people who believe in the Modi form of government and leadership. Not only is this not a good topic for HN - it is about as bad as saying "Pro big-government Obama wins" or "Right wing Conservatives take Britain by storm!" or "Abbott defeats the Labour Party!" or "Merkel gains at the expense of leftists!" or any other such article. Bottom line is: you can not be sure of what Modi or any other politician for that matter will do until he/she does it. Until today, we didn't even know he'd get such a landslide. As for the technological impact of Modi's win - he loves solar & infrastructure(so go long solar & infra stocks) and it is probable that the internet penetration in India will increase - although whether that is credited to him/his party or not is a matter of debate. This entire election is about a nationalist Indian party that has defeated a clutch of leftist parties (similar to other nationalist movements in many other nations) and there isn't a leftist versus nationalist debate in the world that deserves attention on HN.

For the record, I supported Modi's party in this election, so I maybe biased. Take with a pinch of salt.

EDIT: removed my comment about this not required on HN as in hindsight it seemed unimportant to me.

kshatrea··on Android coming to wearables
I am in the position of being torn apart by two very strong feelings. One is the world where information flow due to companies like Google does a real service to humanity: for e.g. wearing devices that can keep us reminded of our meds or monitor sugar levels, to talk just about the possibilities in healthcare. Then I think of Edward Snowden and I now know that what Google knows, maybe America/Russia/China/WhatHaveYou know. Although at this point I am as normal a citizen as you can find, that can't be taken for granted forever. For e.g. in my nation (India) being gay is illegal and so is marijuana, and so is alcohol (in some states) and so is a lot of stuff. This feeling makes me want to minimize my footprint.

Wish there was a way to combat either the wariness, or to exacerbate the joy. For, I must be assimilated into the Borg, too. :)

EDIT: spellings

kshatrea··on Google Doodle Upholds Gay Rights Ahead of Sochi Olympics
In India, the Supreme Court recently quashed an appeal and made homosexuality an illegal act under Section 377. Its reasoning was that it is the law that must be changed and therefore it was a legislative act that was required to quash what is an obviously discriminatory law. I applaud Google for their stand on Russia, but I question why they didn't do the same thing in India. Conspiracy theorists would say because Russia is a strategic foe of the USA and India is not. I am not in that camp, but I do find the question interesting.
kshatrea··on Google patents ad-powered taxi service that would offer free rides to shoppers
Very common in Delhi, India too. There are all these emporiums located not so close to the metro stations so footfalls are less. They pay the autorickshaw drivers to stop any customer there for a minute. Didn't know this existed until it happened to me :) The patent system of America needs to be shot in the head.
kshatrea··on Poll: Hacker News Person of the Year in Tech
Second that. He may be a good or bad politician depending on the person's viewpoint, but there is almost nothing he has done for technology. The closest he comes to tech that is covered on HN is to have covered a lot of area in his home state with solar projects.
kshatrea··on Software patent reform just died in the House
Ha, I don't live in the US, I live in a some times worse nation - India. We don't pay as many taxes though. I made my comment as an assertion of the fact that people blaming corporations must also blame the participating government as well. Good to know you're a dollar vigilante! I always wanted that lifestyle; can't get it, not yet anyway.
kshatrea··on Software patent reform just died in the House
Yes, these senators and congressmen are literally so impressionable that the very fact that IBM and Microsoft and other companies are objecting cause these political leaders to become nervous and kill the bills (to put it kindly). It seems to me that America is now on the same page as most other nations: your laws are also bought-and-paid-for by special interest groups in many cases, just like our more corrupt nations and especially mine. Very sad.

edit: grammar

kshatrea··on Software patent reform just died in the House
I am assuming you're changing your vote next time for the Green/Constitution/Libertarian party as well? Since I assume you'll treat the congressmen and their political parties who take the lobbying money the same way you treat the corporation that is giving the bribe.
kshatrea··on Everpix was great. This is how it died
This happens routinely at Disrupt. I remember a fabulous startup called Prism Sky Labs (could connect to any network camera with drag and drop software and was quite cool in ambition) lost to Qwiki.
kshatrea··on LG G Flex curved smartphone revealed
This technology (with the curved display) would look awesome on a watch, of course with the caveat that the curvature would need to be convex rather than the concave one shown here. If it is at all possible that they build a narrow band that can display rows of icons, that could be something different, who knows? A lot of ifs in my comment, but then it looks doable to me.

EDIT: removed the word "single".

kshatrea··on China to lift ban on Facebook, Twitter, NYT within Shanghai free-trade zone
<snark>

More like, they didn't want any competition with the government. </snark>

kshatrea··on Vodafone Hacker Accesses 2 Million Customers’ Banking Data
Oh come on. Hacking punishments should not be that severe, only proportional to the damage caused. Where has anyone demonstrated the property damage in this case? They have only estimated a number. Hackers get disproportionate sentences to what they have done, compared to for e.g. bankers who commit crimes.

EDIT: After reading the comments below, I guess I need to clarify what I said. I put it badly to say the least; I should have said "property damage" instead of financial damage.

kshatrea··on Vodafone Hacker Accesses 2 Million Customers’ Banking Data
I actually feel sorry for the hacker; once he/she gets caught, they're probably in for a lot of trouble with the law given the tough sentences handed out nowadays for minor crimes.
kshatrea··on Buy onions at Rs 9 per kg online from Groupon
Some context: Onions prices right now are in a state of inflationary flux in India and this seems to be a new way to tackle the problem.

EDIT: Noted that the seller was Groupon.

kshatrea··on Non-Indians have benefited most from patent regime in India
Tell you what. Let us enumerate the number of new advanced drugs that Non-Indians brought to India. That list will be long; the worst part is that all those technical drug lists may turn out to have at least one Indian working on them, our emigration is huge. To take a technical comparison, what would have happened if Satya Nadella & Sundar Pichai had stayed back over here? Anyway, that's an argument for another day.

To get back to the topic, Non-Indians may benefit from the patent regime; but they got the products here in the first place. In short, the "refutation" is a simple quid pro quo: the foreigners manufacture most drugs, and they get the most patents. There is no argument here on whether patents are bad, it is a stupid defense of an idiotic method of patent grants. Most Indian pharma firms have no meaningful R&D, they make their profits on generics. Socialists like the present government will never understand a free market, if they want these expensive drugs for free, they have to pay for them somehow. Not by abusing a bad patent system which is protectionist. Either they should abolish patents (which is the best way) and take the results, or they start applying patents the ostensible way they are meant to be applied, which is to pay attention to whether the pharma breakthrough is big enough to merit a patent, or not.

kshatrea··on Global Government Requests Report
I am not so sure the US is outpacing the rest by far. Assuming 179 million American FB MAU [1] and the next highest (India, a country I am a citizen of) having ~3200 requests for roughly 78 million MAU [2]. you get (78/179 * 11500) ~ 5000. So India is not too far off and I would suggest giving it time :). Btw, I used 11500 for America as the mean between 11k and 12k since only the range is given.

I guess all governments are spying on their citizens :).

[1] http://techcrunch.com/2013/08/13/facebook-mobile-user-count/

[2] http://www.livemint.com/Consumer/NwNFvLukHEbgbVQH9Dd7UK/Indi...

EDIT: corrected American FB user type to MAU from DAU earlier.

kshatrea··on Russia's Mark Zuckerberg offers Snowden a job.
> On the same day, Pavel Durov, CEO of the social network VKontakte, offered Snowden a job as a security software developer.

In his career, hasn't Snowden been more of a sys admin type?[1]. Putting all the hoopla/outrage over his leaks aside, from a career perspective, would Snowden be qualified for a developer role? I guess my question is whether Durov's motivation is to get PR points or to get a suitable engineer for that role.

[1]http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/01/us/job-title-key-to-inner-...

kshatrea··on Cyberscare: Ex-NSA chief calls transparency groups, hackers next terrorists
I am an Indian so I wasn't referring to the US in particular although my bad that I didn't make it clear.

Well, the voting system is not necessarily perfect, at least not here. In my country there are sects where people sell their votes for alcohol. I stand by my assertion that government != country on a philosophical level if not a practical one.

kshatrea··on Cyberscare: Ex-NSA chief calls transparency groups, hackers next terrorists
> For what it's worth, I take that form of "tl;dr" as emphasis, not as a literal tl;dr.

This.

I've been inured to using it in that way as well. I see the criticism above as a valid one though.

kshatrea··on Cyberscare: Ex-NSA chief calls transparency groups, hackers next terrorists
People need to start accepting that government != country; such people as such being called as "terrorists" or "communists" or other words that were bandied about as the bogeyman of the time are perceived as threats to the government by those most poised to profit from that government. A government that no longer represents the people, but corporations and those that benefit by it, will threaten those that question its legitimacy as that is only obvious. The word "terrorist" is only the latest in a long string.

tl;dr government != country.

kshatrea··on Microsoft's Bing introduces child abuse search pop-ups
Or... They simply might not have been as competent as their competition in addressing it. I realize MS-hating is popular around here but we need not jump to the worst conclusion every time.
kshatrea··on The state of democratic control over surveillance in France
I couldn't reply to your comment in response to my earlier comment so I am replying here.

I believe in natural rights, not designed in the human framework sense, so I totally agree with you on what democracy is actually: mob rule of the majority. Proponents of government actually must accept its truth: wealth transfer at the point of a gun. I live in India (a high-tax and high-tax evasion socialist paradise where even the roads are not good) and I wouldn't pay taxes at all, since I get nothing in return. But poor people get a lot (and of course, rich politicians steal most of the money), but there is no point in denying the truth: but for the State's implied threat of violence, I would not fork out what I earned. Period.

kshatrea··on The state of democratic control over surveillance in France
The answer is simple: with age, welfare and benefits increase.
kshatrea··on The state of democratic control over surveillance in France
I am totally going to have to ask you to define "we". All your talk, your speech here has an ambiguity based on your definition: "we" are all not the same. For e.g. your last question seems rhetorical; you feel that Joe and the President are not different. "My" answer is simply this: I can kill Joe in self-defense if he threatens my life; I cannot kill the President. Try to kill a cop in a threatening situation and you know the police force will come down on you harder. There's anecdotal evidence to prove it. Are you going to deny that?

Oleganza's question is simple: If I disagree with your morality or legal system, what would you do about it? If your answer is to say that I shouldn't ask you but read a book, then your value to me in a mutual free society is quite low and of course I don't intend to live at your expense. Therefore, I reject your "we" and "everyone" since those words imply consent, which I most certainly have not given.

kshatrea··on The state of democratic control over surveillance in France
Let us take some normal examples of services that exist. Let us say I own the home I live in for purposes of non-ambiguity. Would you say I own the water on my property? If I don't have water, would you be okay if I never paid taxes but paid for the water? Would you be okay if I never paid taxes but paid for the roads usage each time I used it? Or on a monthly basis? A thought experiment begins with the basic fact that you and I live in a society where certain things must be done, like paying taxes. If I refuse to pay, as oleganza says, will you come to an alternate arrangement with me? Or will you put me in jail?

In short, is my personal liberty a right? Or is it subject to the privilege of my citizenship?

kshatrea··on The Jobs Are Never Coming Back
Firstly, there is no need for an ad hominem attack on Austrian economics (which matterhorn did not identify in his small para) and so you cannot say it will not work since you obviously never tried it, and you never gave a reason for it to not work. Keynesianism has had control of the economy for the last 5 years atleast, and look at the result. Yet, you say it will work. I say it can only create bubbles. Bring on the attacks. And yes, I agree with matterhorn that government directed economic activity is essentially malinvestment. It is production that is important; most government activity has been focussed on spending/debt. EDIT: No socialist controlled economy? Which world are you living in? India,my country has strict labour laws for about 85% of the businesses, including all in manufacturing, textiles etc. You cannot make a profit without offering workers a fair wage as decided by them & the GOVERNMENT first. Have you heard of autorickshaw pricing here? Who controls the prices? Customers? No, rickshaw unions, & the GOVERNMENT. So, all investment into autorickshaws, clean cars is distorted by these disincentives. That is one of about a million examples. The only place where there is no intervention (or less intervention) here is IT, which is why you see so much progress in IT. Have you been to Vietnam? Sri Lanka? I have, and I know business owners and I do know workers as well in these nations. No more ad hominems please.
← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →