HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kthejoker2

3,142 karma · joined June 7, 2017

Data and AI architect in Houston.
submissionscomments
kthejoker2··on The Political Biases of GPT-4 (are very much still there)
Do you think there is a universal objective answer to this?
kthejoker2··on How to explain the Monty Hall problem to a disbeliever
The easiest way is to convince them is with real money on the line.

Like the article, take a deck of cards. Ask them to pick a card for you without looking. Set it aside.

Tell them if they have the queen of diamonds, you buy lunch, otherwise they buy lunch. Ask if they want to swap decks.

After they inevitably say yes, go through the 51 other cards and turn over 20 cards that aren't the queen of diamonds. Ask if they're sure they'd like to switch.

Remove 20 more cards and repeat. Then 9 more (leaving you with 2 cards.) Ask again, turn over one last card, ask one more time. (This last iteration is the actual Monty Hall problem.)

The key thing is they should understand now that Monty Hall knows where the queen of diamonds/ car is and turns over other cards/goats precisely because he knows they don't change the odds of the original choice, but many people incorrectly believe that it does.

kthejoker2··on Dropping the SAT requirement is a luxury belief
I read extreme statements like this sand ask where is the proof?

Not because I don't believe it but if these things are well known, why isn't some clickbait journalist all over it?

kthejoker2··on New research finds almost 90% of women penalized due to work achievements
Since everyone is complaining about methodology, what would be a valid research experiment? What did they miss?

Is it just the self-reporting aspect?

kthejoker2··on The 24 Hour “Do Nothing” Challenge
There's a Twilight Zone episode with a similar premise (and nasty if foreseeable twist)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Silence_(The_Twilight_Zone...

kthejoker2··on “Forbidden-word” lists are a symptom of administrative bloat
You said a forbidden word, so no UBI for you?

Straight out of 1984.

kthejoker2··on Conversational AI will be used to Manipulate Us in real-time
It's sad how far we've strayed from Bellamy's Looking Backwards style utopias and straight into Orwellian dystopias.

I predict the rise of more seasteaders, Oneida style communes, digital retreats, maybe even extreme cosplay like The Village ... a ton of people are just going to nope out of this hellscape.

Maybe the metaverse is onto something...

kthejoker2··on Show HN: Graphic – A grammar of data visualization and Flutter charting library
This is some rando's interactive representation of the FT visual vocabulary, which itself is just a very simple poster, but the conceptualization of analytical purpose to visualization is straightforward and fits 99% of business intelligence dashboarding use cases.

https://github.com/Financial-Times/chart-doctor/blob/main/vi...

kthejoker2··on Show HN: Graphic – A grammar of data visualization and Flutter charting library
Why is there still such a gap between the grammar of charting (low level) and visual vocabulary (high level)?

https://ft-interactive.github.io/visual-vocabulary/

Tools like Lux, Plotly, PowerBI, all seem to shy away from being way more prescriptive about thr kinds of visuals needed for a particular analysis.

Everyone wants to unleash their inner data artist, but if you're looking for time series anonalies, you want a ARIMA style line chart with an uncertainty funnel and a big red dot where actuals exceed targets.

Super frustrating having to map these over and over again in every new GoG library.

kthejoker2··on Most young men are single. Most young women are not
I think this is a fallacy, the expected value of most monogamous relationships is zero or microscopic - most fail, many have negative value (abuse, homicide, mental illness), etc - so in some ways it's like playing the lottery.

A tax on the romantically challenged :)

Again, I say this as a proud and happy husband of 19 years!

kthejoker2··on ML would have advanced faster if another front-end language had been adopted?
This is just another "X eats Y for breakfast" snowclone, where somebody thinks deeply about Y, so they conveniently ignore X as it relates to why something they do/don't like with respect to Y is unpopular/popular.

"Culture eats strategy for breakfast" (Drucker's law)

"Data eats algorithms for breakfast" (Andrew Ng's deep learning lesson)

"Computation eats models for breakfast" (Sutton's bitter lesson)

"Descriptive eats prescriptive for breakfast" (Linguists everywhere)

and here, another

"Ecosystem and community eats language features for breakfast"

kthejoker2··on Most young men are single. Most young women are not
What I mostly see in this thread is nobody deeply caring about relationships, marriage, kids, and the like.

As the article points out, the rise of sexual gratification without relationships, coinciding with women's reshaping of the financial stability side of relationships, has mostly just resulted in a lopsided winner takes all market around biological attraction.

But sexual gratification is .. just ... that. Ephemeral, weakly bonding, "childish." You don't need another person for it, you definitely don't need a member of the opposite sex, even if you want someone from the opposite sex, you can pay for it, even with a more committed relationship it's more or less transactional.

The real question is was there ever any value in long term monogamous relationships? I say this as someone in a long term monogamous relationship who is super happy, but the divorce rates and gender imbalance in domestic violence tells a different story.

Instead, we should work on ensuring everyone having access to paid, consensual sex workers, and bring "dating apps" back from the hookup apps they largely are into something more like eHarmony or OKCupid were - a niche app for those looking for long term relationships.

People demanding other people choose sexual partners based on long term relationship dynamics that are completely irrelevant in this day and age is a weird hill to die on.

kthejoker2··on Most young men are single. Most young women are not
"we" is doing a lot of heavy lifting in your sentence but we're about 2 centuries away from complete population collapse of the species.

There are less babies born on this day than any day in history, and that will be true for the rest of our entire species' existence, barring major technological "Brave New World" style test tube baby advances (which are indeed extremely likely given this fact.)

kthejoker2··on ChatGPT launches boom in AI-written e-books on Amazon
Shouldn't there be a "massive barrier" to new people writing checks notes AI-generated children's books?

I've read now to 4 kids and the vast majority of children's books are terrible. A few are evocative, imaginative, have memorable characters, interesting, thoughtful messages - but most of them are a waste of paper and time.

Most children's books - even the ones more deliberately planned than a ChatGPT textdump - are very lazily conceived and executed.

kthejoker2··on ChatGPT launches boom in AI-written e-books on Amazon
ED Hirsch is looking more and more prescient every day.

I mean, really, sure: there are a few dozen really clever children's books that come out every year that deserve to be added to the "pantheon" but isn't this area basically saturated?

Imagine you read your child one book a day for their first 5 years, you and they co-read two books a day from age 5 to age 10 and then they move on forever to whatever arbitrary boundary we set for "children's books" versus the rest of literature.

Assuming a modest amount of re-reading your favorites, that's an ambitious local maximum of about 5,000 books.

Realistically, this number is more like 1,000 to 1,500 books. This space is already well curated - Scheherazade has you covered in a single compendium!

There's no way any random ChatGPT production is going to cut into the space.

kthejoker2··on Does hand-washing or wearing masks slow down the spread of respiratory viruses?
All of these studies continue to show that adherence is the key variable.

Of course in an absolute sense wearing mask, hand-washing, social distancing, etc. for a short period of time will marginally (even if microscopically) decrease your chances of acquiring a virus.

Just like brushing your teeth once absolutely reduces the amount of plaque on your teeth.

But it's adherence, over a long period of time which tells the tale of whether you get sick or have a cavity.

kthejoker2··on Text Is All You Need
I mean, I agree willful suspension of disbelief is a thing, but as someone who actually build APIs and worries about network latency and packing messages to be efficient blocks of data and that the method itself is a useful affordance for the product, I can walk and chew gum at the same time.

Just because people don't actively think all the time in terms of low level contexts doesn't mean that only simulating the high level contexts is a sufficient substitute for the whole process.

I think this whole concept is conflating "illusion" (i.e. allowing oneself to be fooled) and "delusion" (being involuntarily fooled, or unwilling to admit to being fooled.)

I personally don't enjoy magic shows, but people do, and it's not because they think there's real magic there.

kthejoker2··on Text Is All You Need
Other nonsense in this post:

> In fact, it is hard to argue in 2023, knowing what we know of online life, that online text-personas are somehow more impoverished than in-person presence of persons

It is in fact very easy to argue. No one on the Internet knows you're a dog, there is no stable identity anywhere, anonymization clearly creates a Ring of Gyges scenario, trolling, catfishing, brigading, attention economy, and above all, the constant chase for influence (and ultimately revenue) - what passes for "persona" online is a thin gruel compared to in-person personas.

When you bump into a stranger at the DMV, you aren't instantly suspicious of their motives, what they're trying to sell you, are they a Russian influence farmer, etc.

Night and day. Extremely impoverished.

kthejoker2··on Text Is All You Need
> Nor does our tendency to personify and get theatrically mad at things like malfunctioning devices (“the printer hates me”). Those are all flavors of ironic personhood attribution. At some level, we know we’re operating in the context of an I-it relationship. Just because it’s satisfying to pretend there’s an I-you process going on doesn’t mean we entirely believe our own pretense. We can stop believing, and switch to I-it mode if necessary. The I-you element, even if satisfying, is a voluntary act we can choose to not do.

> These chatbots are different.

Strong disagree, it's very easy to step back and say this is a program, input, output, the end.

All the people claiming this is some exhibition of personhood or whatever just don't want to spoil the illusion.

kthejoker2··on Tesla Terminated Dozens in Response to New Union Campaign, Complaint Alleges
Just based on their responses in this article thread, he's a Tesla apologist, if he doesn't work there, it's impressive volunteed work.
kthejoker2··on Half of Americans now believe that news organizations deliberately mislead them
Any you particularly recommend? Trying to stretch my reading material.
kthejoker2··on Half of Americans now believe that news organizations deliberately mislead them
To me, "news" is different than "journalism" (and obviously way different than "opinion") but most media orgs go way out of their way to just completely blur these.

Every "news" article (an election, a shooting, an earthquake, a new science study) is wrapped in spin - why this is bad or good for America, why it's racist or a sign of moral decay, how you should feel, what these other people think about it, who agrees with it.

I gave up and just use primary sources - reading the actual ArXiv paper or gov website or watching the eyewitness video is a better use of my time.

kthejoker2··on Half of Americans now believe that news organizations deliberately mislead them
But the ones who aren't cartoons don't really do enough to counter the ones who do. Just a bunch of whataboutism and "anything to own the libs" mentality.

And honestly being supporters of a person instead of a policy or a position is itself a psychological failing.

kthejoker2··on Half of Americans now believe that news organizations deliberately mislead them
What sources do you personally trust?
kthejoker2··on People can read their manager's mind (2015)
If I've learned one thing, repeatedly, experience by painful experience:

Time is an illusion, professional time doubly so. Don't waste it worrying about what might have been or never was, accept your failures, be magnanimous about others', and always work to make things better tomorrow.

Maybe there's a Sliding Doors world out there where you can try all the possibilities and see where they take you, but time's arrow flows in one direction here.

So choose the paths that you think move things up and to the right, and if you find yourself heading down and to the left, have a laugh and try again.

kthejoker2··on Poor people pay higher time tax
You have a very sheltered view of the time tax of public transportation.

https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2003/08/18/the-marriage-c...

> When a bus turned down her street, she stepped off the curb, but the bus did not slow down. Half an hour later, a second bus cruised by her outstretched, dollar-waving hand. It is an unhappy fact of Oklahoma City life that bus drivers bypass would-be riders in very poor neighborhoods, and blacks in less poor ones.

> After an hour, a bus pulled over. It took her to the center-city bus depot, which is situated in front of the county jail. Waiting for a transfer bus under a billboard for Crawley 24-Hour Bail Bonds, Kim was propositioned by a man wheeling a baby carriage and smoking a Black & Mild cigar.

> She then learned that the job required her to work until 9 p.m. There is no regular bus service to Sooner Haven or its environs after dark.

> Another bus was coming through the shopping plaza. Kim stepped forward, signalling furiously. When it swerved around her, she sank to the curb. The bus was not only the seventh one to pass her that day; it was the last bus to Sooner Haven until morning. In terms of landmass, Oklahoma City is the third-largest metropolis in America, and she was a five-hour walk from home.

kthejoker2··on Wikipedia’s Intentional Distortion of the History of the Holocaust
I believe the Holocaust happened, and I also believe

* the number of people who died as a result of ghettoization, genocide, and indirect deaths (disease, suicide, etc) was far higher than 6 million

* the number of Jews murdered by German SS, local blackguards, and in death camps is between 4.5 million and 5.5 million, with 6 million being an off the cuff estimate in the aftermath of the Holocaust ( https://yvng.yadvashem.org/ )

* investigating and accumulating evidence of the deaths of the Holocaust for the purposes of evidence and historical research is valid and should continue

* Litigating the number of dead is an extremely common tactic of Holocaust deniers, as if 1 or 2 million dead would be just reasonable domestic policy

* this article is conflating the latter with the former

* commentary on the above without deep knowledge of the research of Yad Vashem, the US Holocaust Museum, and other major reaearchers of the Holocaust (no matter one's position on Wikipedia or the Holocaust) is 100% ineffective

* including this comment.

kthejoker2··on Wikipedia’s Intentional Distortion of the History of the Holocaust
You can watch Shoah which has the video of this interview on YouTube (interview begins at 4:35:00 at the beginning of part 2)

Required viewing.

https://youtu.be/FirfB4jSK8Y

kthejoker2··on American Airlines jet and shuttle bus collide on taxiway
There isn't a uniform defintion of medical state, but fair typically means "conscious, no major instability" so e.g. broken leg, whiplash, lacerations from a fall

Serious typically means "unconscious and/ or unstable, but without other negative factors" (like other existing conditions, age, etc)

Moderate typically means "was serious but is recovering" e.g. was knocked out but came to, or had a seizure but is now stable.

kthejoker2··on Peter Hotez on the increase of anti-science aggression on social media
This comment thread is just supreme intellectual navel gazing and using hindsight to recast what happened.

Science is messy, communicating is messier, acting as if every bit of mess comes from some negarious agenda or that somehow the mess was avoidable with finite budgets, time, and knowledge is ... completely against the entire history of human behavior.

Your time on this planet is short, generally full of ignorance, confusion, and lying to yourself.

By all means learn from our mistakes and reduce that ignorance and confusion going forward, but if your conclusion is to reject scientific inquiry as the only tool we have to move forward, you are just contributing to the confusion and ignorance.

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →