187 karma · joined February 8, 2014
I love it when this one gets pulled out. UH OH, NO MORE RESPONSES!
Well I'm also happy to leave it here, that the 13th amendment absolutely outlawed slavery and that people arguing for policy changes in law enforcement are making a weak case that their poorly justified agenda is somehow on par (or even more morally virtuous) with the 19th century abolitionists.
NOW I'M TAKING MY BALL AND GOING HOME.
Maybe it's actually wrong?
So you're saying we could do better I guess.
> You don't do that. You blindly follow some 20yr old colonials > who scribbled out a constitution 200 years ago.
I guess, but maybe better to follow 20 year old colonials who wrote a constitution 200 years ago than to blindly follow inbred royal families with even poorer claims to power? I mean, as long as we're just throwing insults at this point, you have to see that Europe is at least as ridiculous (and at least when it comes to politics, arguably much worse).
I get the feeling we've read different history.
Forget books or opinions provided by other people many years after the fact, forget my opinion, just look at what the seceding states themselves said to justify their secession.
For example, here's South Carolina: https://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/csa_scarsec.asp
The VERY FIRST sentence identifies the reason to secede being that the northern states are refusing to send back their fugitive slaves!
And if it's not clear enough for you, they repeat it in more detail just a little further down in the document:
---
"In the present case, that fact is established with certainty. We assert that fourteen of the States have deliberately refused, for years past, to fulfill their constitutional obligations, and we refer to their own Statutes for the proof.
The Constitution of the United States, in its fourth Article, provides as follows: "No person held to service or labor in one State, under the laws thereof, escaping into another, shall, in consequence of any law or regulation therein, be discharged from such service or labor, but shall be delivered up, on claim of the party to whom such service or labor may be due."
This stipulation was so material to the compact, that without it that compact would not have been made. The greater number of the contracting parties held slaves, and they had previously evinced their estimate of the value of such a stipulation by making it a condition in the Ordinance for the government of the territory ceded by Virginia, which now composes the States north of the Ohio River."
You can say that people in the north weren’t angels, they certainly weren’t, and that there were other issues that motivated people to enter the war and fight for their side, there certainly were.
But the central issue of the civil war was slavery. If it was any other issue, the seceding states would have said it, and surely a compromise would have been reached (as in fact even today states have “rights” if not just the “right” to hold slaves).
Some people today want the glory of abolitionist revolution without having to pay with their own blood.
Yeah, maybe you can make an argument that the justice system can work differently in one way or another with diff tradeoffs, but if you set up the argument so that you’re in a morally superior position to the people who fought and died in the civil war to end slavery, you should expect and you definitely deserve very strong opposition.
Or maybe we should figure out what we want to do by argument and consensus, instead of blindly following the old colonialists and ex-fascists in Europe?
Some people might argue that we should pursue even more extreme punishments, to dissuade people from committing crimes.
Freed slaves also were unfairly scrutinized for eligibility to vote. Does that mean we should never work to guarantee the integrity of our voting systems?
You can say “it codified [slavery] in the above sense”, but obviously this isn’t the sense that people meant when they went to war to end slavery. And neither you nor I had to make the sacrifice that those people made to end what they considered to be slavery in the US.
Maybe it’s worth considering what the purpose of the 13th amendment was? It’d be a pretty huge mistake to conclude that the purpose of passing the 13th amendment was to enshrine slavery in law, which so many people fought and died to abolish, right?
People in the South after the civil war grasped for any excuse to disenfranchise black people. Big surprise. That’s not an argument to treat prisoners any differently than we do today.
Are people incarcerated unfairly or are they convicted under unjust or unconstitutional laws? That’s a reason to agitate for change.
Are duly convicted criminals forced to do things they don’t want to do? Oh well, sounds like a good idea to me, I will invest in continuing that practice as long as the laws are fair!
We didn’t fight the civil war to end the concept of incarceration for duly convicted lawbreakers. It’s pretty easy to understand and accept that right?
And the people who fought the civil war believed that they were doing it to end slavery.
So perhaps your definition of slavery is inconsistent with theirs, and also out of step with the letter of the law.
Like, after you’ve convinced everyone that you’re morally superior to everyone else, do murderers get to walk free?
I built a similar typed PL and compiler for Morgan Stanley back in 2013: https://github.com/morganstanley/hobbes
Does the concept of a recursive array make sense to you? A recursive(ly typed) function? Or do you think such things can't exist? Like "[[[], []], []]" could be an instance of "mu X.[X]" right?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recursive_data_type#Isorecursi...
It looks like this method is aimed at doing user pattern-matching on expressions in the first stage, kind of integrating Haskell-style rewrite rules in the main user language (rather than bolting them on the side in comments).
Yes you could say it’s row oriented and not column oriented. It’s possible to arrange data in column vectors, and that does get better performance in some situations. I have some ideas to unify the two approaches (so either layout can be decided, ad-hoc), but need a better approach to dependent types.