HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kubrickslair

346 karma · joined June 10, 2011

harshit at openlocus dot ai

harshitsurana.com

submissionscomments
kubrickslair··on A study on robustness and reliability of large language model code generation
It does it pretty well for Python with code interpreter, especially for quant/ ML heavy code.
kubrickslair··on Modern Computer Architecture and Organization - Second Edition (2022)
No, we tried escalating the issues on those practices to the exec team, explicitly requesting a change in policies to enhance the quality of our book. The middle managers we were dealing with simply threw in the towel after that.

PS: This was several years ago, and the policies may have degraded even further since then.

kubrickslair··on Modern Computer Architecture and Organization - Second Edition (2022)
My experience with them was less than favorable. We started our book journey with them but had to abandon them because their editorial team & processes were so bad. Their insistence on artificially inflating the book's thickness with larger fonts was just the final straw.

We were fortunate to work with Manning & O’Reilly to complete our book. The quality, professionalism, and integrity we saw with them and the contrast with Packt was night and day.

kubrickslair··on Career advice for young system programmers
Yes, but George Hotz went to CMU after already accomplishing more than many of us might accomplish in our entire careers. So the broader point on pigeonholing still stands.

I agree that for the average programmer, the CS degree still helps, but these outliers remind us that talent can blossom in many ways!

kubrickslair··on Career advice for young system programmers
I think it’s a little more complex. Reflecting on a decade ago, my then relatively young PhD advisor, along with many colleagues, came from a myriad of backgrounds – applied math being a standout. And some of them ended up doing really remarkable work - almost everyone has used some work that came out of our lab.

So I think pigeonholing on CS is not a good idea. My stress on achievements was just to underscore this point.

kubrickslair··on Career advice for young system programmers
I think it's worth noting that some of the most celebrated programmers have been self-taught – think Aaron Swartz, John Carmack, George Hotz and so on. Among leading academics also, it's not unusual to find those without formal undergraduate degrees in CS. Many come from mathematics backgrounds, including several Turing Award recipients.

In the world of software development, degrees have often held less sway, and I think this trend will only become more pronounced. Too much focus on CS degrees I feel does not account for the inherent nature of the role - and I say this as a CS grad from a top school.

kubrickslair··on Getting a job at Apple without going to college or doing LeetCode
Some of the highest salaries I know are in core ML at big tech or some of the foundational labs like Allen AI. While whiteboard coding interviews are often part of the process, it is generally pretty basic LC.

The crux of the evaluation often revolves around have you built something amazing before? For most new grad folks it is the work done as part of their PhD thesis, but for non PhDs it often boils to amazing past work. And it’s a similar process for more experience folks except the reliance on LC fades even more.

If this works well for cutting edge ML why shouldn't it work for everything else?

kubrickslair··on Ask HN: How does ChatGPT work?
Yes, some variation of this iterative approach has been around for over 2 decades. Look at Oren Etzioni's early work on Open Information Extraction and so on.

I agree that applying this semi supervised approach to extend GPT for improving dialog models is what is unique & results are stunning. But the meta method has been around for a while.

kubrickslair··on Tips for Writing a Technical Book
I am skeptical on the point that a good publishers adds no value.

In our case, we authors have been publishing papers for over a decade. And together we have almost 1000 citations for our papers.

And yet, we were not able to think over and improve on certain aspects of a book that we discovered only after talking to our current publisher.

Maybe if you are completely clear on what your book is about and how will readers react to it, a publisher might not matter. But for us, it seems it was not the case.

kubrickslair··on Tips for Writing a Technical Book
Please don’t go ahead if it is for Packt. We had a horrible experience with them.

After a bunch of hunt we moved to what is called a first tier publisher. And the difference is so massive. We are now restructuring and rewriting all chapters. Our reviewers think it can be a landmark book. None of it could have happened with Packt.

I come from a startup world, and was partially able to stomach Packt at the start. But my co-authors have worked at Microsoft Research and Google AI. They just hated dealing with them. And in the end all of us decided we would rather self publish than go with them.

kubrickslair··on Ask HN: Is it possible to publish research work in CS without any affiliation?
I was in a similar boat as you many years back. Did not get CS at the older IITs, I was too interested in coding and entrepreneurship to be super involved in JEE.

I persisted and got an internship at a top CS place in India. Ended up publishing more research than most PhD students in just a year. And got admitted to all top 5 CS programs I applied to. Was advised by a very well known professor in grad school and even published with one of the grandfathers of machine learning.

I now mentor several undergrads who are going through the same phase. I think just partnering with the right professor helps. Having a vision helps. Most research students just blindly follow whatever the professor tells them to do. Being able to think independently really helps; most of my classmates who ended as Professors still crave for such students. And find it hard to encounter such folks.

To repeat, independence and persistence. You will make it. Good luck!

kubrickslair··on Ask HN: Who wants to be hired?
Bay Area, temporarily at home in India due to extenuating circumstances.

Available for full-time anywhere in 3-4 months. Have a US work visa for a quick transition. Can contract till then.

Looking for Data Science/ Machine Learning/ Algorithmic Development Roles. Recruiters welcome.

Went to a top 5 CS school, published more than half a dozen well-cited papers, wrote production code in various roles. Created a moderately successful startup. Work featured by major tech and general press.

Earlier related work includes recommender systems, combinatorial optimization, question answering systems and general NLP/ AI resource and algorithm development.

Stack: Java/C++/Objective C for production code, Python/R/Julia for scientific computing, HTML/CSS/JS for interactive viz and misc.

Please get in touch at: dataguy1729 at gmail.com

kubrickslair··on Get that job at Facebook (2012)
I don't disagree with anything you say. As I mentioned earlier that all people who hack such interviews do have basic understanding/skills requisite for the corp, quite enough to play the gymnastics of the interviews.

A good interviewer does try to gauge whether the answer was known to the interviewee. But I have seen that happen far more at hot startups than big companies- primarily because of their more stringent process which leaves less wiggle room for guess work and is more tuned towards concretely judged parameters.

I just don't like the facade of 'hiring the smartest people' in the world, when their mechanism largely filters just well-trained average people.

And I most certainly don't want to sound condescending, so I apologize before-hand. But I probably used a different definition of average than what you or most people here may have in mind. I know quite a few ACM ICPC world finalists, am a region finalist myself, and have conducted/ published CS research with reasonable impact. So I was simply using my PhD program peers as good, and people with lesser (proven) skills as average. My fault, but I hope you can see what I was trying to say.

kubrickslair··on Get that job at Facebook (2012)
>> where I happened to talk to a guy between written test sessions who even had taken very elaborate 'class notes' on clearing these interviews.

Pretty sure there would be coaching classes to get into coaching classes with higher hit rates of finally clearing the interviews. It's that broken.

Whenever people talk about the madness of India's youth, I can't help not quoting Soumen:

"It's hard to overstress the liability of a nation of a billion people out of which 700 million are functionally illiterate and the rest have no wish to follow instructions, even when they are asking for a favor."

http://www.cse.iitb.ac.in/soumen/APKGKAH/illiterate/Applicat...

>> As a side note, in all major IT services companies in India you have to take 'certification exams' for pay hikes and promotions.

Hope you are fortunate enough to be not working for such places anymore.

kubrickslair··on Get that job at Facebook (2012)
Agree on all points.

Interesting that you brought IIT up. Though I barely cleared IIT JEE and did not attend it for I could not get CS at any of the good schools, I had the feeling that it was becoming more and more hackable with the proliferation of coaching institutes. When I was in a top 5 PhD program which attracts the best of IIT K/B/M guys the quality drop became more evident over the years. There were and are still very bright IITians at my school, but I saw more noise coming in at later years.

And for those who are not aware- there are cram shops in India which 'train' you to clear Google/ Microsoft interviews. And this has been going for at least 6 years, if not more. Now from talking to my friends in India I get the impression that the superficial interview difficulty is higher in India than the Bay Area for similar companies. And that is despite the work quality being much higher in Silicon Valley.

It's all very funny and ironic.

kubrickslair··on Get that job at Facebook (2012)
Though I doubt that, it might be true that being good in algorithmic puzzle-solving (as opposed to real-world algorithmic research/ development) helps employees in their day-to-day work. And I do think they maybe missing some real gems because of it.

But in my opinion, they just need an easily definable and quantifiable process. And they are happy to look the other way when they see covert cheating/ hacking as long as it clears the process. And there is no denying that there is still a decent ability threshold which most covert cheating people too will pass, which I guess suffices the corp needs.

I am a far bigger fan of pair programming after a basic phone screen, but large companies just can't do that.

kubrickslair··on Get that job at Facebook (2012)
Another reason I am not fond of this- it is easily hackable. I know some pretty average people who prepared for months, went through all questions they could find online, ignored their day jobs and cleared the interviews, while some really talented people could not.

Funny that this got brought on the Facebook thread. Though I never applied at FB, I have 'mentored' two people who made it through the process. Mentoring as in, helped them make sense (and see the general pattern) of the solutions which they saw online but could not appreciate/ understand on their own. Though I guess they had lesser trouble regurgitating the solutions in the interviews.

kubrickslair··on Get that job at Facebook (2012)
Never interviewed at Facebook but have been offered roles at similarly hard to get places. Though I am working at my own startup now, the absurdness of the interviewing process at majority of such places confounds me.

In short, I can't cope up with them well without going through quite a few glassdoor type questions of that respective company. And partially it is because most interviewers already have a set of solutions that they are looking for, and can't appreciate novel solutions and at times even better time/space complexity if they do not fit the standard mold. In my experience only some very hot startups had smart/ open enough interviewers to appreciate new solutions or see the relevance of new CS research results that may solve their question.

Before one starts attacking me on being a CS philistine, I want you to ponder on my background- current work involves designing & implementing pretty intricate & complex algorithms, and earlier research & publications in a range of ML related sub-fields, mainly NLP & recommender systems. I also read CS papers for pleasure, code in multiple languages and did reasonably well in programming competitions- no longer participate, latter is many years ago.

For a similar experience, though from a far more accomplished person, see Tanya Khovanova's blog post on hiring 'the smartest people in the world': http://blog.tanyakhovanova.com/?p=402

Also, FYI I don't resent the system a lot. It is better than it being an old-boys-club; I just dread going through the bootcamp of memorizing/ revisiting trivial stuff in case I ever have to look for a job again.

kubrickslair··on Obsession
While I agree that this ability may help in certain kinds of development/ coding work, I do think they are various cognitive niches that different people can occupy well.

For instance, I think people with functioning ADHD do pretty well as dealmakers, traders and maybe even certain kind of managers. I suffer from a mild form of bipolar, and it allows me to be very creative & productive in my manic phases, but I cannot always be as consistent as an ops person.

kubrickslair··on Obsession
I too went to a top 5 school and took some of the hardest classes in a school which is famous for its hard classes. And yes, it becomes pretty obvious quickly that grades are not a reflection of intelligence. And when the threshold intelligence is high in the sample size, say at a good school, grades and intelligence may be very weakly correlated, if at all.

Personally, I do have the ability to be extremely focused for long hours. But I don't think that having that ability counts for a lot in real world. My cofounder is borderline ADHD and there are things he can accomplish that I just cannot.

kubrickslair··on I'm a loser and I want to change that - now
Can't help not quoting Matt Drance.

http://www.appleoutsider.com/2011/10/06/sj/

"And so more than ever, I find myself inspired. Steve’s untimely death reminds us we can never give up. He could have given up at any point in the seven years since his first cancer diagnosis, but he did not. The vast majority of Apple’s unprecedented resurgence took place while Steve Jobs stared death in the face. How many of us could have lasted this long at all, let alone accomplish all that he did along the way?

Ten years ago today, we still had not yet met the iPod. The last of Steve’s five decades on this Earth ended up being his most accomplished by far. Remember that whenever you think your best days are behind you. We can’t control when our lives begin, and we can’t really control when they end. All we have is what’s in between. Make it count."

kubrickslair··on Code Interview Reading List
I am a region finalist & happen to know a few ICPC world finalists, and though one of them is very sharp analytically, I am not sure how good a proxy such problems are for a web developer, or even for most technical positions. Some of the best problem solvers I know CS-wise (not algorithmic puzzle solving, but real CS research/ implementation) are not that fast of thinkers to do very well in such circumstances without a lot of pattern matching through practice.
kubrickslair··on Code Interview Reading List
There is a book called 'Algorithms for Interviews' by Aziz & Prakash. It is much more CS centric than CareerCup & does not provide explicit solutions to all problems- which is good.

It also has more difficult questions, on average, and many are not the kind that one would expect in an under hour interview. Nevertheless I find it more easy to read than something like say CareerCup, mainly because it is not so mundane and hence more fun.

kubrickslair··on Code Interview Reading List
Part of my current work involves designing & implementing pretty intricate & complex algorithms. Earlier I did research & published in a range of ML related sub-fields, primarily NLP & recommender systems. I also read CS papers for pleasure and code in multiple languages.

Yet, if I gave engineering interviews impromptu I am pretty sure I will fail many of them. It's a weird situation in the industry when an experienced person has to go through a bootcamp to revisit/ memorize rather trivial stuff to get a job for which he may well be overqualified.

kubrickslair··on Holding a Program in One's Head (2007)
In my experience, this is PG's most helpful/ reassuring technical essay.

Recently I was working on/ creating pretty complex algorithms with gargantuan cobweb of edge cases. Not only did I had to work for 15+ straight hours, but in order to maintain productivity fasted (bar caffeine, few nuts & water) every alternate day to keep the steam going.

Incredible times, and rather close to reaping the fruits now, but there is a pretty good chance that I would not have been here had I not read and internalized this essay- was grappling with several decades of CS research though in much less theoretical setting.

kubrickslair··on Taleb: The future will not be cool
I think this is pretty hard for me to explain, but please try to bear with me.

My observations are as anecdotal as anyone else's, but my experience is that there is a moderate negative correlation between someone's raw analytical ability and the capacity to appreciate the kind of ambiguity that good literature carries. Of course there are those rare gems who can juggle both pretty well- Poincare or Mandelbrot for examples.

And most of my personal experiences of very high raw analytical ability comes from academia, people who made through ICPC world finals & are doing their PhDs at top schools, and not startup world- where smart people are of a somewhat different mold.

Now there is nothing negative with not appreciating a broad set of literature, or having a more deterministic/ utilitarian view of life. They are to some extent different personalities and different mindsets.

I appreciate Taleb's world view to a decent extent [1], but I used to actively keep it in my head/ life when I was in pure research/ grad-school mode. Now as I am building shit/ taking big risks, my mindset is much more generic HN'ish view. For instance, earlier I used to read substantially more poetry, literature [2] and biological papers. Now I primarily focus on my core area - stats/ML/AI etc. and general HN stuff.

[1] To the extent of corresponding with him at length

[2] If there is a single book I would suggest to you or anyone else, it would be Kolyma Tales. It is probably the most despairing/ darkest thing I have ever read and made me appreciate human nature a lot more.

kubrickslair··on Over-specialization is the curse of our profession
Agree with the author on how over-specialization is a bigger curse on our profession than most others. But breeding of condescension is a rather petty justification for becoming a more broader human being/ programmer. Many bigger gains come from having ample breadth at personal and group levels.
kubrickslair··on The new way to land a job at Facebook
Besides the excellent suggestions by the parent, I might also look at the awesome work done by Jon Kleinberg for a more theoretical understanding. One may start with his pretty concise Networks book: http://www.cs.cornell.edu/home/kleinber/networks-book/
kubrickslair··on Artificial Intelligence Could Be on Brink of Passing Turing Test
As an ex graduate student in Natural Language Processing/ Machine Learning, I was curious what recent changes occurred that made you see things from a different perspective?

I have not been keeping track of newer research, so would love to know.

kubrickslair··on New OpenStreetMap tiles from Stamen: water color, black and white, terrain
Thanks, looking at the right textures, instead of texture generating algorithms helped here. I think I will purchase a bunch, and that should suffice.
← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →