HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kurikuri

252 karma · joined March 25, 2020

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/cbellii; my proof: https://keybase.io/cbellii/sigs/4ane0tmWHiznmsXZ51SB-h_TRtHFdLSz8rcB3erF6fo ]
submissionscomments
kurikuri··on Microsoft's Windows Recall feature is coming back in October
Ah, yes. I wonder how many federal machines will now never update to Windows 11 because of FIPS 140-3 SSP leakages.
kurikuri··on Former Colorado clerk Tina Peters convicted in computer breach
> An insider observing a simple way for a bad actor to gain access to voting machine hardware is evidence.

Is evidence of what? She abused her elected position to pursue a conspiracy theory and no evidence of that conspiracy was discovered. She, a week after having the cameras monitoring the election office turned off, knowingly allowed an unauthorized person to view election machine credentials. She, a person who was supposed to protect the integrity of the election as part of being a clerk and recorder in her county, betrayed her public office and the people who elected her.

There is no ‘blatant double standard’ here. Instead, you’ve drawn a false analogy to other situations to make this seem like something it wasn’t. Even if we were charitable and said the ends justify the means, there were no justifying ends that came about.

kurikuri··on Hetzner Pricing
> So it makes some sense that they would ban crypto mining: permitting it would significantly increase overall energy utilization and could quickly make their business model unprofitable.

Then adding an energy usage limit would make more sense instead of a broad-usage ban, and it is significantly less invasive to examine a server’s energy expenditure rather than the server’s productive use.

Also, how do they investigate and enforce this ban? If it is possible to get banned for ‘trading,’ does this mean they are inspecting all communication and activity on instances they host?

kurikuri··on Meta's mass layoff severance agreements illegal, says judge
> The NLRB is a joke, and they love to issue rulings against politically unpopular people, even if the ruling is clearly wrong.

You’ll need evidence your claim here… and are you implying that their ruling was wrong in this instance? In what way? The NLRB’s decision was linked and everything seemed sound while I was reading it.

kurikuri··on Majority of sites and apps use dark patterns in the marketing of subscriptions
What? What you replied to had nothing to do with ‘not paying,’ or ‘getting things for free,’ it only discussed their dislike for the subscription model.
kurikuri··on Supreme Court Ruling Threatens the Framework of Cybersecurity Regulation
Which he can only do because he has clean air to breathe…
kurikuri··on US to pay Moderna $176M to develop pandemic flu vaccine
What? They are effective and safe.
kurikuri··on Making AI better at math tutoring
> In all fairness, I don't think more time with an 'expert' would fill those gaps, I've personally observed several contradictions where the supposed expert fails to perform as a result of incentives.

Or, as a result of objectives? If the ‘expert’ in this regard knows the material well enough, then the objective and constraints seem relevant. When you are referring to an expert, what is the context? An expert teacher for a class maintains different skill set from an expert tutor.

One on one time with an expert tutor does help tremendously, but realistic goals have to be determined. I made my way through undergrad and grad school as a private tutor for math from elementary school to math majors. The student’s objective, time scale, and current state determine how thorough a tutor can be.

>The trouble these students are having is primarily because they've been taught by rote(authority and dynamics based in Marxism), instead of by rational first principles. It’s infected most publicly funded education.

Yes, but the Marxism aside makes little sense here. Crudely quantifying education outcomes into metrics and making the teachers responsible to said metrics is a primary reason for rote learning (i.e., teaching to the test). The ideas which inspire this type of metricizing come from Taylorism and Fordism, both of which are American schools of thought.

kurikuri··on Zero Tolerance for Bias
> The post here recommends using Intel's RDSEED, which is ironically trusted far less than /dev/urandom by most people who have a secret to keep or a process to protect.

What? If security is a special consideration for some form of data, why would someone choose a non-physical noise source over a hardware-based noise source?

kurikuri··on Routers cyber security best practices
Unless the infector retargets the same router (i.e., the payload has to be redelivered), then no it won’t.
kurikuri··on Galois/Counter Mode and random nonces
The counter starts from an initialization value (IV), which does not need to be secret. What should be ensured (to prevent forgery attacks) is that each possible (key, initialization value) pair is never used twice.

There are two standardized ways (from NIST’s SP 800-38D) of ensuring unique (key,IV) pairs:

1. Use either a random number generator to make a nonce for the entire IV, or 2. Construct an IV by concatenating two fields, one field for the most significant bits set it to zero and increment it every time the key is used, the other is simply a fixed at zero.

With the second option, some new limitations exist to maintain the constructed IV’s uniqueness. The first being how many blocks of data you can encrypt in an operation (2^(size(fixedfield)) because you don’t want to overflow into your key-reuse field. The second is being the number of times you can reuse the key is now limited to 2^size(keyreusefield).

kurikuri··on Cosine Similarity
While cosine itself has a range of 0 to 1, the cosine similarity is usually defined for tf-idf or bag-of-words vectors, in which the largest angle between any two vectors is 90deg.
kurikuri··on Can turning office towers into apartments save downtowns?
“Absolute level of safety” what does this even mean? Per capita crime rates seem quite relevant to this underlying property and can be well defined.
kurikuri··on I spoke with a Google worker fired for protesting $1.2B Israel contract
Using families as a counter example is quite a strawman, no?
kurikuri··on Childhood Loneliness Linked to Later Psychosis
> It irks me that you can find just a handful of conference proceedings on a condition which affects tens of millions of people in the U.S and that both ADHD and Autism have boomed in popularity because they both are associated with expensive or addictive treatments.

Because they are associated with expensive or addictive treatments? That is quite a claim in its own right; I’d argue that ADHD boomed in the US because we now understand how it affects people throughout their lives and it is no longer a ‘little boy’s’ disease.

One implication of your statement is that many (some significant portion) people diagnosed with ADHD shouldn’t have been, and that the reason for this over-diagnosis is drug seeking or pushing behavior.

Because of this implication, groups like the DEA make the manufacturing and distribution of these medically useful medications difficult and paradoxical to what they intend to treat. In some states, the patient with ADHD has to call monthly to get a refill because their provider isn’t allowed to prescribe more than one fill at a time, nor could the provider automatically send out a refill without contact with a patient. It is quite inconvenient for a patient who suffers from what is effectively time blindness.

This also maintains the narrative that the patients are seeking drugs for some form of abuse or diversion, causing the patients to feel like criminals. This is absurd.

So please, stop with this implication.

kurikuri··on Porn sites are banning Texas
The big difference between using an ID to buy alcohol and using your ID to access a site is data retention. I can get a drink by showing my ID, the person serving me doesn’t need to keep my information to keep an auditable record. Without an accountable third party auditing solution (some sort of accredited lab situation), I wouldn’t trust a website to take my ID and not save/redistribute that information for other purposes.

What is the result of this sort of regulation though? Now the sites which don’t operate in the US will simply skirt the regulation. What is Texas going to do, sue xHamster? Why would they bother to comply? Does Texas now start limiting the type of traffic allowed through the infrastructure within the state?

kurikuri··on First major act to regulate AI passed by European lawmakers
There are plenty of things which can have meaningful regulation when it comes to AI. Here are a few:

- where legal liability is placed in the event of an automated system making a decision (consider competing companies using the same AI-product to set prices (RealPage), or customer support chat bots agreeing to a provide a remedy to a customer) - considerations around training data containing PII - IP ownership of output - implications on the IP of input and derivative works (and, is the model itself a derivative work?)

Note, these topics aren’t too specific to the implementation or technology involved but instead pertain to the side effects of AI’s existence and use.

kurikuri··on Marilyn vos Savant and the Monty Hall Problem (2015)
The host’s knowledge does contribute to the 2/3, because that knowledge prevents an outcome from occurring. Let us consider the switching strategy and instead say selecting the correct door awards 6 points. Our question: what is the expected value of this strategy when the host knows, vs when the host doesn’t know.

Consider the scenario where the player’s first choice is the winner. This happens 1/3 of the time, and the host’s knowledge doesn’t change their behavior. With the switching strategy, the player always loses in this case, so the contribution of this scenario towards the expected value for either case(host knowing vs not) is 0.

Consider the other scenario where the player’s first selection does not contain the car, and note that this situation happens 2/3 of the time. For convenience, label the player’s selected door 1, and the car containing door 2.

If we assume the host has knowledge, then the host will select door 3. If the player decides to stay, they lose. In this scenario, the switch strategy always wins, so its contribution towards the expected value when the host knows is (2/3 * 6) = 4.

If we assume the host doesn’t have knowledge, he will pick either door 2 or 3 with equal probability. In the event he selects door 2, the winning door, so half the time, the player loses because they can’t switch. This occurs half of the time within this scenario, so this sub -scenario contributes 0 points to our expected value. If the host selects door three, then the switch strategy wins, meaning this sub-scenario contributes (2/3 * 1/2 * 6) = 3 points to our overall expected value.

When the host has knowledge, the scenario where the player loses because of the host selection will not occur, leading to the 2/3-probability. Without the host having this knowledge, our event space changes and the player switch strategy only has a 1/2 chance of winning.

kurikuri··on JSTOR is Now Available in 1k Prisons
What are you going on about with your first and second sentences?

Do you believe that people with different cultures/races cannot agree on a system of fair laws?

kurikuri··on Uniting the Linux random-number devices (2022)
The PRNG state is responsible for generating most of the users cryptographic material and is quite important to the system’s security. As such, the PRNG State is a security parameter that should never be exportable nor importable.

There are many new attacks that could surface if import/export were possible; off the top of my head: quiet preloading of an attacker-selected state while the machine is off.

kurikuri··on ADHD: Breaking the Red-to-Blue Loop
Because your comments lack citations, my rebuttal will too…

> As a medical diagnosis it is consistently overdiagnosed, and dangerously underdefined.

Maybe in your population, but it is under-diagnosed in the following populations: adults, women/girls, prison population, gifted/talented students, populations with an exceptional stigma towards mental disorders.

I don’t understand what you mean by ADHD being under-defined.

> You will suffer from the "symptoms" of ADHD.

Suffering the symptoms and having those symptoms significantly interfere with your life is what it means to have ADHD.

> Typically, unstable or volatile childhood environments are seen as a key driver of this.

This is false. Child rearing has little to no effect on having the disorder. However, genetic variation contributes to (i.e. has an effects size of) at least 70% of the disorder.

> Posses an above average IQ

IQ is negatively correlated with ADHD… are you discussing a specific type of person with ADHD with the second paragraph?

kurikuri··on Show HN: Pryingdeep – The new OSINT instrument for the Deep Web
The link goes directly to your own GitHub page, not the project’s repo.

Was that intentional?

kurikuri··on A secret deal let Spotify bypass Android's app store fees
This comparison doesn’t seem to address the issue of who you replied to. If I were running a streaming service, knew the business intimately, and still couldn’t figure out how Spotify had such an advantage against me, I would be both perplexed and need to admit defeat.

I wouldn’t have the same sentiment against YouTube music or Apple Music, because these are explicitly part of the same companies that host the marketplace.

kurikuri··on From email to phone number, a new OSINT approach (2019)
When arguing with an executive on why their company’s security posture needs to be updated, there is nothing quite as effective as an off the shelf demo.
kurikuri··on LinkedIn laying off nearly 700, mostly from core engineering teams
> But the divisiveness they employ makes them a political distraction.

What divisiveness? Most news I hear about unions paints them as a negative without backing anything up.

> We need workers’ rights for everyone. Not just those who are in a union.

Agreed, but we have to start somewhere. If unions are able to push for some type of labor benefit, then good for them.

kurikuri··on California governor vetoes bill that would have set a $35 cap for insulin
> insane law which would have taken parental rights away

It sounds like the law would have given more rights to children who’s parents refuse to accept their child’s gender expression.

To me, ‘parental rights’ could often be more aptly named ‘child ownership.’

kurikuri··on Debunking NIST's calculation of the Kyber-512 security level
> If Kyber-512 is actually this risky, then it deserves to be communicated clearly.

The statement djb seems to be making: It is not known if Kyber-512 is as cryptographically strong as AES-128 by the definitions provided by NIST.

This is an issue because these algorithms will be embedded within hardware soon.

> Besides the fact that nobody is deploying standalone PQ for some time

Now that an implementation has been chosen to be standardized, hardware vendors are likely to start designing blocks that can more efficiently compute the FIPS 203 standard (if they haven't already designed a few to begin with).

Given that the standard's expected publication is in 2024, and the 1-2 year review timeline for NIST CMVP review on FIPS modules, I wouldn't be surprised to see a FIPS 140-3 Hardware Module with ML-KEM (Kyber-etc.) by mid 2026.

> a succinct breakdown of why

The issue seems to be his statement from [1]: "However, NIST didn't give any clear end-to-end statements that Kyber-512 has N bits of security margin in scenario X for clearly specified (N,X)."

djb succinctly outlines the "scenario X" he referred to in [2], in which he only needs a yes or no answer. He is literally asking the people who should know and be able to discuss the matter, who would have the technical background to discuss this matter. He had received no response, which is why he had posted [1].

NIST's reply in [3] is a dismissal of [1] without a discussion of the security itself. The frustrating part for me to read was the second paragraph: "The email you cited (https://groups.google.com/a/list.nist.gov/g/pqc-forum/c/4MBu...), speaks for itself. NIST continues to be interested in people's opinions on whether or not our current plan to standardize Kyber512 is a good one. While reviewers are free, as a fun exercise, to attempt to "disprove what NIST _appears_ to be claiming about the security margin," the results of this exercise would not be particularly useful to the standardization process. NIST's prior assertions and their interpretation are not relevant to the question of whether people believe that it is a good idea to standardize Kyber512."

If NIST views the reviewers' claims about security to be "not particularly useful to the standardization process," (and remember: the reviewers are themselves cryptographers) then why should the public trust the standard at all?

> a smoking gun or two would be great

There wouldn't be a smoking gun because the lack of clarification is the issue at hand. If they could explain how they calculated the security strength of Kyber-512, then this would be a different issue.

The current 3rd party estimates of Kyber-512's security strength (which is a nebulous term...) puts it below the original requirements, so clarification or justification seems necessary.

[1]: https://groups.google.com/a/list.nist.gov/g/pqc-forum/c/4MBu...

[2]: https://groups.google.com/a/list.nist.gov/g/pqc-forum/c/4MBu...

[3]: https://groups.google.com/a/list.nist.gov/g/pqc-forum/c/4MBu...

kurikuri··on Snowden leak: Cavium networking hardware may contain NSA backdoor
> Irrelevant Except it was relevant as a response to the OP in that: I was pointing out their conflation of two different DRBGs.

Having an SP 800-90A DRBG does not mean you support all of them, nor does it imply the user could change between the 3 (or, in that hypothetical, 4).

Outside of that, it is unlikely that this module had Dual_EC_DRBG at any point in time for three reasons: 1) Submitting a hardware module that has an entirely new DRBG would require a lot of low level work from Cavium, and the modifications made to the physical module would likely constitute more than an updated certificate (i.e., a new certificate). 2) Even though the DRBG was withdrawn, the CAVP lists algorithm certificates, and this includes historic certificates. Cavium doesn’t have a Dual_EC_DRBG certificate for any operating environment. A list of Dual_EC_DRBG certificates can be seen here: https://csrc.nist.gov/projects/cryptographic-algorithm-valid... 3) the earliest security policy for the module that I could find dates back to 07/22/2014, and it still uses the CTR_DRBG. Security policy here: https://csrc.nist.rip/groups/STM/cmvp/documents/140-1/140sp/...

kurikuri··on Snowden leak: Cavium networking hardware may contain NSA backdoor
You are wildly incorrect here.

The cryptographic module uses the CTR_DRBG, not the withdrawn Dual_EC_DRBG. The Dual_EC_DRBG was withdrawn in 2014, but this Security Policy for this module was submitted well past that for FIPS 140-2 revalidation, and the CMVP would not have let a testing lab submit it at all.

This isn’t the back door.

kurikuri··on Spain’s Lessons for American Decline
> We have two criteria here: Hire on merit and try pick the best person for the job; or, subsume merit to picking based primarily on skin color and/or ethnicity.

The word ‘merit’ is doing a lot of work here. What traits/aspects of a person would you use to calculate into their merit? I’ll argue that between two people who’ve crossed a finish line at the same time, the one who started furthest from that line is more meritorious. From a hiring/placement perspective however, especially during the first screening, there isn’t a good way to determine a candidate’s starting line.

The dichotomy is a bit wrong as well, but I’ll get into that once we get past the first hurdle (for the curious, it is about a selection bias after an initial screen).

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →