HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kybernetikos

6,302 karma · joined July 11, 2012

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kybernetikos; my proof: https://keybase.io/kybernetikos/sigs/yHgJmn4qufQOBXtQjZ-3EsFWRdtec9C5wGhHqz3ETYw ]
submissionscomments
kybernetikos··on MCP is dead; long live MCP
I've just been discovering this pattern too. It's made a huge difference. Trying to get Claude to remote control an app for testing via the various other means was miserable and unreliable.

I got it to build an MCP server into the app that supported sending commands to allow Claude to interact with it as if it was a user, including keypresses and grabbing screenshots, and the difference was immediate and really beneficial.

Visual issues were previously one of the things it would tend to struggle with.

kybernetikos··on Elon Musk pushes out more xAI founders as AI coding effort falters
> you need humans to run datacenters.

As far as I can tell from random articles online, it seems that as a rule of thumb, you need about 6 humans +1.5 humans per megawatt - and that's just for running the datacenter part, different people maintain the power generation infrastructure. Now, if you have to house those people in space or fly them up whenever they have to do anything, that's going to destroy your budget.

If you want to assume a level of automation that makes that unnecessary, that's fine, but then you need to also assume that same level of automation in earth based data centers too, and everything that goes with that.

kybernetikos··on Elon Musk pushes out more xAI founders as AI coding effort falters
Everything relating to a datacentre that you can do in space you can do more easily on earth, regardless of 10,000x inference growth or supply chain or production or starship or silicon. I just don't think you can be cost competitive with earth bound data centres if 'protected from the poors' isn't a selling point.

By the way, 10,000x inference growth would look like what happened with cryptocurrency mining - after a couple of years, you'd be needing to upgrade all your machines with ASICs and the market would be flooded with very cheap graphics cards. I doubt that upgrading space data centres would be fun.

kybernetikos··on Elon Musk pushes out more xAI founders as AI coding effort falters
It's hard for an uprising of poor people to shut it off. It's the ideal place to run your CEO / President simulations.

I say this tongue in cheek, but in all seriousness, I can't really think of any other benefit, and I no longer have a lot of faith in the good sense of some of the people involved.

kybernetikos··on GPT-5.4
I don't think you should call your agents Eve. There's going to be a lot of examples in the training data of someone called Eve shifting the blame (from the book of Genesis on!) and acting deceptively (from cryptography research).
kybernetikos··on An AI agent published a hit piece on me
What about Dark Star? Humans strapped to an AI bomb that they have to persuade not to kill them all.
kybernetikos··on Claude Opus 4.6
I recently got junie to code me up an MCP for accessing my calibre library. https://www.npmjs.com/package/access-calibre

My standard test for that was "Who ends up with Bilbo's buttons?"

kybernetikos··on Qwen3-Coder-Next
Gpt3.5 as used in the first commercially available chat gpt is believed to be hundreds of billions of parameters. There are now models I can run on my phone that feel like they have similar levels of capability.

Phones are never going to run the largest models locally because they just don't have the size, but we're seeing improvements in capability at small sizes over time that mean that you can run a model on your phone now that would have required hundreds of billions of parameters less than 6 years ago.

kybernetikos··on Only What Is Alive Can Be Conscious
It seems that all of the comparisons with computational systems are either not really true (the supposed sharp distinction between hardware and software depends on whether you're considering the system as a software engineer, a firmware engineer or a hardware engineer. Computer systems are embodied just as much as any biological creatures) or contingent - if it were regarded as essential to consciousness that an organism have a source of true randomness for example, then we would simply add such a source to our systems (assuming consciousness was something we actually wanted them to have).
kybernetikos··on Only What Is Alive Can Be Conscious
None of the descriptive points of what it means to be a biological organism really seem germaine to the core question of consciousness, which as far as I'm concerned is the inner experience.

Every month, the thesis seems more certain that a mathematical model will be able to produce output indistinguishable from the output produced by a conscious, biological creature.

Once that's accepted, then the only interesting questions that are left are by definition unobservable. Is there anything that it is like to be that mathematical model?

kybernetikos··on Netflix Wants Movies to Restate the Plot Three or Four Times in the Dialogue
> Then I spent time in Asia

The worst show I've seen for this was american - mythbusters.

kybernetikos··on Sins of the Children
I was not particularly a fan of them - the plot seemed to find overly easy solutions to all the actual messiness that comes when dealing with others very unlike yourself, which given the rest of the stories, feels like it undercuts the entire point of them.

The Tchaikovsky novella I really like is Elder Race. Technology-as-magic is done in so many places (Ventus is another favourite), and I usually enjoy it, but I felt that in Elder Race it was pulled off in an unusually elegant way.

kybernetikos··on I Built a 1 Petabyte Server from Scratch [video]
Z-library mirror maybe.
kybernetikos··on Every country should set 16 as the minimum age for social media accounts
As you say 'social media' is not a good category, we should specify exactly the things that are concerning. Here are the ones where I'm concerned about their effect on young people:

1. a user is shown new content based on extensive profiling and a secret algorithm that the user does not control

2. a users activity can be discovered and tracked by people that intend to take advantage of the user

3. the operation of the site is optimised for addiction (or more euphemistically "attention")

I absolutely don't think that a book club or a kids own website comments or person to person chat systems should be included in the rules.

Note - I'm not saying these things should be banned, just that I think it's reasonable to restrict their use to adults.

kybernetikos··on Ford F-150 Lightning outsold the Cybertruck and was then canceled for poor sales
I suspect the reasoning was similar to the reason Tesla bought Solar City or X.ai acquired the site previously known as twitter. Pure unvarnished investor value.
kybernetikos··on Claude Code CLI was broken
AI approaches can churn code more than a human would.

Lines of code has always been a questionable metric of velocity, and AI makes that more true than ever.

kybernetikos··on Trump says Venezuela’s Maduro captured after strikes
I think the cycle is because people forget how destructive war is for all sides, how much human wealth is thrown away in order to achieve enormous human misery. If it's happened in recent memory, people are reluctant to let those who think they might benefit from it to pursue it. The more time that passes, the easier it is to distract people from the misery and the easier it is to persuade people that it's justified.
kybernetikos··on Fabrice Bellard Releases MicroQuickJS
While you're not wrong that JS has come a long way in that time, it's not the case that it was an extremely unusual choice at the time - Ryan Dahl chose it for node in 2009.
kybernetikos··on I've been writing ring buffers wrong all these years (2016)
Every implementation of "the lmax disrupter" I've come across uses this trick.
kybernetikos··on Australia begins enforcing world-first teen social media ban
I think a better approach might be to require that any algorithm used to suggest content to users must be made open source so that people whose world views are being shaped by the content you're feeding them can analyse how you're deciding what to show them.

I feel like there's definitely a problem here with social media and its effect on society, but our first approach should be to increase transparency and accountability, rather than to start banning things by force of law.

kybernetikos··on UIs Are Not Pure Functions of the Model – React.js and Cocoa Side by Side (2018)
Knockout js worked something like that. There are complexities with the observable approach though, especially around batched updates and avoiding update loops.
kybernetikos··on Fastmail desktop app
I assume that this app is not a mailing app, its an app to control your fastmail service, which includes email, file storage, webhosting, various dns controls, notes, contacts, billing etc. They already contributed JMAP. It would be impossible for them to get all of those features into k-mail - k-mail wouldn't want them.

And packaging the app in electron is relatively easy and a nice convenience for some users.

kybernetikos··on Aphantasia and Psychedelics
My aphantasia mainly feels like a super power, that I process at the conceptual level rather than the visual level. I feel like it helps me focus on the important things and ignore the extraneous. It's strange to read it described as a 'deficit' and as something needing to be corrected.
kybernetikos··on Themis (European Reusable Rocket) is assembled on launch pad
It took 100 million to get to falcon 1, and the company was probably not viable until NASA gave space X the crs1 contract for >1billion...

And where did that initial money come from? Musks sale of PayPal shares, which he got when PayPal acquired his payments company... Would that have happened if he'd started his payments company in Europe? Would Compaq or an equivalent have been interested in paying for zip2, which provided the initial money to found x.com if he'd built zip2 in Europe?

Musk deliberately and intentionally moved to silicon valley, and I think a big part of the reason was almost certainly that the US is more prepared to invest money in these kinds of ventures.

kybernetikos··on Themis (European Reusable Rocket) is assembled on launch pad
I think that often theres a difference in ability to put capital to work between the US and europe. Lots of innovative work has happened in Europe, but it often gets bought by US or Asian capital, or gets outcompeted by vastly more resourced US competitors, or just withers on the vine from a lack of investment.

Sabre seemed a really interesting space approach that failed from lack of funding.

kybernetikos··on Introducing Stargate UK
Are you saying this with an awareness that both DeepMind and ARM were founded in the UK?
kybernetikos··on Defeating Nondeterminism in LLM Inference
Arithmetic coding looks like an extremely interesting approach, given that you can use the model at each step to give you the probabilities of each token.
kybernetikos··on Defeating Nondeterminism in LLM Inference
I used exponential golomb coding, so the rank 0 logit is encoded with a single bit, ranks 1 and 2 are encoded with three bits, ranks 3-6 are encoded with 5 bits, etc.

In terms of performance, I've not done any serious testing, but e.g. the wikipedia article on volcanos compresses to about 20% using GPT2. I've seen other strings compress even further.

The big issue is that while encoding is not unreasonable, decoding any significant amount of data is incredibly slow, since I'm doing a model run for every token in the output. It's bad enough that the scheme is probably unworkable as it is. I'm thinking about changing my code so that it streams out the tokens as it decodes them, so you're not just left there waiting for ages.

kybernetikos··on Charlie Kirk killed at event in Utah
Do we know if this violence is politically motivated yet? (Other common motivations are mental health issues, paranoia, revenge, desire for fame etc). Of course it seems likely, but it also seems premature to jump to trying to use this as proof of a particular personal position.

I definitely believe that people should be more understanding of each other, and less quick to jump to insults and othering, but we know so little about this situation, to be so confident that it was caused by speech seems extreme.

I am also aware that a lot of the political violence of the last few years ended up not being motivated by the reasons one might naturally expect.

kybernetikos··on Charlie Kirk killed at event in Utah
You start your comment saying we should avoid making apocalyptic statements and end it by saying "the cycle is going to destroy our society".

My conclusion is that you don't mind making apocalyptic statements about actions you think are dangerous to society, which sits uncomfortably with your asking other people not to.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →