HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

kybernetikos

6,302 karma · joined July 11, 2012

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/kybernetikos; my proof: https://keybase.io/kybernetikos/sigs/yHgJmn4qufQOBXtQjZ-3EsFWRdtec9C5wGhHqz3ETYw ]
submissionscomments
kybernetikos··on Plain Vanilla Web
Web Components can have properties too, and in fact this is the norm.
kybernetikos··on Why Archers Didn't Volley Fire
I don't think 'plate' was a standard kind of quality either, so while the top quality plate might be effectively impervious to arrows except for an unlikely lucky splintering shot into a weak point or gap, there were probably lots of thinner, less coverage providing plate armours where the probability of defeat was still very low, but not completely zero.
kybernetikos··on Brian Eno's Theory of Democracy
Most countries with multi party systems use different methods for selecting their representatives. When you do a straight aggregation of geographical areas in which you take whomever gets the most votes in each area (sometimes called first past the post) it becomes possible for the most disliked party in a country to win, widely geographical distributed concerns (like ecological concerns) become underrepresented, and most relevant to this conversation, having multiple parties that are close to each other is a huge disadvantage compared to having a single party attracting more people. Because of this, countries with this system will usually see smaller parties merge and stabilise on a 2 party government / opposition set up.

The study of how different kinds of voting systems work and their advantages, disadvantages and consequences is called social choice theory. There's an interesting theorem called Arrow's theorem that proves that given a certain set of assumptions, there can be no voting system that works exactly as we would like. Sometimes this is used to argue that all systems are equally bad, but I think this is not true at all - even while imperfect, some systems are much better than others.

kybernetikos··on Careless People
Human instinct is a complex of different things acting in opposite directions, including things that work against hierarchy.

I'm shocked that you think this is an unbelievable reaction, I know lots of people who really do think like that.

I wonder if you might find C S Lewis's lecture on the "inner ring" interesting.

https://archive.org/details/1944-the-inner-ring

kybernetikos··on AI Horseless Carriages
I would describe that as a method or implementation, not as an application.

Almost all knowledge work can be described as "generating a useful sequence of words or word like tokens", but I wouldn't hire a screen writer to do the job of a lawyer or a copy editor to do the job of a concierge or an HR director to do the job of an advertising consultant.

kybernetikos··on AI Horseless Carriages
This challenge is a little unfair. Chat is an interface not an application.
kybernetikos··on Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired
Whereas I always take this phrase to be refering to a military kind of strength. For example, this whole article tells us that Oda Ujiharu got the nickname "weakest" because of his military incompetence. Your own examples of strength in this thread tend to be mainly martial too.

This kind of strength - the ability to force your will upon others (which is what military strength is, and also the kind of strength that 'Strong Men' dictators have), motivates the (usually incorrect) comparisons to historical empires. There are other kinds of strength - moral strength, resilience, determination, vision, etc they're just not what I think is being talked about with this phrase.

I don't know where you get 'weakness' is being described as a positive in this thread. Weakness can also mean many things, but in this context, it means being susceptible to others forcing their will onto you. It's not a good thing, but differences in strength are natural and impossible to avoid. What is a good thing is when the great mass of comparatively 'weak' people realise that together they are stronger than the tyrant.

Rather than 1984, for an appropriate comparison I'd go to the Bible: - "God chose the weak things of the world to shame the strong."

kybernetikos··on Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired
Of course! Fairy tales for children are how we communicate some of our best understandings of what it means to live a good life.

Many important things in life are fictions or rely on fictions - money, nations, property, family, art, justice, legitimacy, banks. All of them are fairytales. And like a fairy in Peter Pan, belief can make them real, powerful facts of our world while lack of belief can destroy them.

It works too - I know lots of real people who make the world a better place because of the fairy tales they choose to believe.

kybernetikos··on Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired
I'm really struggling to match your definitions of weak and strong here to anything like normal usage.

I think you're saying that it's strong to be employed? I'm not really sure how that matches up to being against the things you mention in connection with "weak".

Incidentally, I don't know if you intended this, but building roads and sewers and policing are, in most countries, socially funded programs.

kybernetikos··on Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired
I like your philosophy, but I think this phrase is a horrible way to express it. You should try to come up with a different pithy way of saying what you mean.

Perhaps

Beware those who make hard decisions easily.

Or

Hard times come when decision makers pay no part of the cost of their decisions.

kybernetikos··on Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired
It's a nice reading, and I do think that the ability to take the wider view, to be prepared to suffer and fight for principles rather than immediate personal gain, to band together with others even at personal cost is an enormous strength.

I just don't think it's what people using this phrase mean.

kybernetikos··on Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired
And perhaps this is the core of our disagreement - you see a country being attacked by another and you blame those hard times on the victim while I blame it on the attacker.

I say it's a problem of unrestrained strength, of strength misapplied, not a problem of some people being weaker than others.

And an enormous number of famines are caused by conflict, or historically by dumb central government by overly strong tyrants.

kybernetikos··on Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired
I agree, the ability to lend your strength to benefit others is a moral strength and it's key to human flourishing and achievement. Where I might disagree though is if you think that this is the kind of strength that most users of the phrase in question are thinking of.
kybernetikos··on Why Japan's "Weakest Samurai Warlord" Is Still Admired to This Day
Not only that, but "good times" and "bad times" are equally ambiguous - good times for who?

I have a feeling that the saying is used primarily by people who imagine themselves strong and think that the good times in history were when the strong were taking from the weak, whereas I think that good times in history are when the weak are protected from the worst abuses of the strong.

kybernetikos··on Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired
Strong together. Strong, when they choose to support each other. Weak otherwise.
kybernetikos··on Oda Ujiharu: Why the ‘weakest Samurai warlord’ is admired
This is such a dumb saying. Good times are created by weak people working together to defeat strong people. Most hard times are created by "Strong Men" fighting each other. Just take a look around the world - is it countries under the sway of warlords that have the best times? Or is it countries where the institutions are stronger than the individuals, where rulers have been limited or deposed by groups of individually weaker people? Weak people don't create hard times - it's tyrants that do that.
kybernetikos··on Standard Ebooks: liberated ebooks, carefully produced for the true book lover
Librivox https://librivox.org/ is the closest I know.
kybernetikos··on The Llama 4 herd
I love the look of it and if I were in the market right now it would be high on the list, but I do understand the confusion here - is it just a cool product you wanted to make or does it somehow link to what I assumed your mission was - to reduce e-waste?
kybernetikos··on Horror on the coast of Oaxaca, a tourist paradise plagued by mass disappearances
Countries with strong protections for individual rights score disproportionately well in quality of life metrics and crime statistics. I don't think that's a coincidence.
kybernetikos··on Horror on the coast of Oaxaca, a tourist paradise plagued by mass disappearances
You seem to be implying that the El Salvador project of brutal mass incarceration without spending too much effort checking that the incarcerated really are guilty could solve this problem too.

Firstly, it probably wouldn't because that program only began a long time after the majority of the improvement had already happened: https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_a... Bukele only began the mass incarceration after El Salvador had roughly the same number of homicides per person as the USA.

Secondly even if it really had been that program that produced the improvements, the gangs in El Salvador were very different to the gangs in Mexico. I found https://mattlakeman.org/2024/03/30/notes-on-el-salvador/ interesting for background on the gangs.

kybernetikos··on Crew-9 Returns to Earth
I'm confused by this. You can just go and look.

Hacker News comment from 6 months ago, you know, during the Biden administration. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41339804:

- They'll reconfigure Crew-8 for 6 occupants for contingency evac between Starliner undock and Crew-9 arrival.

- Starliner leaving ISS autonomously early September

- Crew 9 launching no later than Sept 24th with 2 crew + 2 empty seats

- Crew 9 coming back down in ~Feb 2025

The advent of Trump and Musk into government seems not to have changed that plan one whit, which makes absolutely no sense if they're telling the truth.

kybernetikos··on Did the Particle Go Through the Two Slits, or Did the Wave Function?
I do think there's something to this approach though - our sensory organs and processing ability are not abstract powers of understanding the universe - they developed exactly to give us enhanced survival chances. We should not expect to even be able to detect (let alone intuitively understand) aspects of reality that can't be used for survival.
kybernetikos··on Gödel's theorem debunks the most important AI myth – Roger Penrose [video]
Maybe this is just a conversation about what "fundamentally differently" means then.

Obviously the brain isn't running an exact implementation of the attention paper, and your point about how the brain is more malleable than our current llms is a great point, but that just proves they aren't the same. I fully expect that future architectures will be more malleable, if you think that such hypothetical future architectures will be fundamentally different from the current ones then we agree..

kybernetikos··on Gödel's theorem debunks the most important AI myth – Roger Penrose [video]
OK, let me be more clear, because I'm not sure what you're arguing against.

If the process in the brain is modellable at all, then it is certainly a model with at a minimum many billions of parameters. Your list of additional parameters if anything supports that rather than arguing against it. If you want to argue with that contention, I think you need to argue that the process isn't modellable, which if you want to talk about burden of proof, would place a huge burden on you. But maybe I misunderstood you. I thought you were saying that it's ludicrous to say we're using as many as billions of parameters, but perhaps you're trying to say that billions is obviously far too small, in which case I agree.

My second point, which is that there's a live theory that prediction may be a core element of our consciousness was intended as an interesting aside, I don't know how it will stand the test of time and I certainly don't know if its correct or not, I intended only to use it to prove that the things you seem to think are obvious are not in fact obvious to everyone.

For example, that big list of things that you are using as an argument against prediction doesn't work at all because you don't know whether they are implemented via a predictive process in the brain or not.

It feels that rather than arguing against modellability or large numbers of parameters or prediction you're arguing against the notion that the human brain is exactly an llm, which is an idea so obviously true I don't think anyone actually disagrees with it.

kybernetikos··on Gödel's theorem debunks the most important AI myth – Roger Penrose [video]
> I think we have a pretty good idea that we are not stochastic parrots - sophisticated or not. Anyone suggesting that we’re running billion parameter models

On the contrary, we have 86B neurons in the brain, the weighting of the connections is the important thing, but we are definitely 'running' a model with many billions of parameters to produce our output.

The theory by which the brain mainly works by predicting the next state is called predictive coding theory, and I would say that I find it pretty plausible. At the very least, we are a long way from knowing for certain that we don't work in this way.

kybernetikos··on Why young parents should focus on building trust with their kids
There are ways that people are set up psychologically that can lead to "discipline problems". A common companion of ADHD is oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) for example.

I've seen people with an instinct to resist everything when under pressure or stressed. I also know people who don't seem to have the instinct for understanding authority and hierarchy that most people do ("if I have to listen to the teacher, why doesn't the teacher have to listen to me?").

I'm sure having people with these behaviours can be very adaptive and beneficial for the whole society in some situations (I bet they do better on the Milgram experiment for example), but in many cases in modern life it can make it feel like everything is an unnecessary fight. I think for people dealing with such individuals the key is to understand that it isn't directed at you personally. I'm not sure what the best advice is for those with those instincts, but I would imagine that it's a combination of learning to use those instincts appropriately and not being too hard on yourself when it goes wrong.

kybernetikos··on The Deck: An open-source cross-platform multiplayer card game engine in Flutter
You may be interested in Tabletop Simulator from Berserk Games, which is on Steam and has VR mode.
kybernetikos··on Nontraditional Red Teams
I found this on scurvy and forgotten traditions to be fascinating https://idlewords.com/2010/03/scott_and_scurvy.htm
kybernetikos··on Chat is a bad UI pattern for development tools
I don't agree with this at all. Pairing where there's a big skill gap isn't proper pairing, it's more like mentoring or hands on training.

In pair programming as I learned it and as I have occasionally experienced it, two individuals challenge each other to be their best selves while also handing off tasks that break flow so that the pair as a whole is in constant flow. When it works this is a fantastic, productive, intense experience. I would agree that it is more than 2x as productive. I don't believe it's possible to achieve this state at all with a mismatched pair.

If this is the experience people have in mind, then it's not surprising that they think that those who think it's only for training juniors haven't actually tried it very much.

kybernetikos··on OpenAI says it has evidence DeepSeek used its model to train competitor
Fine tuning an llm on the output of another llm is exactly how deepseek made its progress. The way they got around the problem you describe is by doing this in a domain that can be relatively easily checked for correctness, so suggested training data for fine tuning could be automatically filtered out if it was wrong.
← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →