84 karma · joined February 4, 2009
So not only salary are negotiated between company and management, two private parties, Treasury still do not have the right to "condition benefits on the nonassertion of rights".
Also, because the power to delegate TARP money was given to Treasury, something Napolitano also considered unconstitutional, and that the plan to cap executive salaries belongs to Obama, not Congress, Congress will have no role in setting these conditions.
So not only Congress do not have the right to make these stipulations, they're not even the ones doing the stipulating.
So the government cannot interfere with contracts already entered into and, unless the government owns the company outright, cannot interfere with any future contracts between the company and the executive.
Also, private parties such as between banks and clients can agree to whatever terms they wish, but the Article I clearly states that the government cannot do the same.
The point Napolitano is making that is unconstitutional for the government to ask an entity to surrender his constitutional rights in exchange for funding.
Just like the government cannot abridge free speech of welfare recipients or PBS.
Considering almost all Post-TARP financial institution are worth less than the amount of TARP accepted, if taxpayers are in a punishing mood they should just let them go bankrupt.
Now that these companies are no longer "too big to fail", that in my opinion is a viable option.
It's not perfect, but its better than the alternative. of friends coming to our house with their PC's having no idea what they did to it.