137 karma · joined May 29, 2019
In theory, no, but in practice market failure is usually due to information asymmetry and consolidation. The real world is, unfortunately, not full of that economists call "perfect competitors".
> in a free market the consumer is free to choose different options if given producer does not adhere to their personal standards
This requires information symmetry -- per Wikipedia, a free market is "a system in which the prices for goods and services are determined by the open market". How can the this work if pricing information isn't available to one side of the market?
> A free market does not require a government ruling them to adhere to some business practices
Free markets in practice require legal guardrails around things such as information symmetry and anticompetitive behavior, in order to protect against market failure. Again, per Wikipedia: "[free markets] require a framework that allows new market entrants".
This regulation is not for its own sake, but _to keep a market free (i.e., open to competition) by protecting it from the grasp of one extremely powerful entity going forward_.
At least with a government you have a shot at being ruled by something other than a private entity's self-interest.
It would be very difficult to make a profit on generic insulin because it's a biologic drug, which means a generic manufacturer wouldn't be able to bypass the FDA approval process by proving bioequivalency.
EDIT: Upon further reading, there is a pathway[0][1] for "biosimilars", but it seems to have higher requirements than chemical generics.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biologics_Price_Competition_an...
[1]: https://www.fda.gov/drugs/biosimilars/biosimilar-and-interch...
Paying more than you're legally required to is simply paying extra.
The YC application has a question along the lines of "why is the thing you're building so compelling that customers will tolerate a buggy product?"
I imagine there's some reading of the CFAA that could theoretically land you in hot water for this, but this is silly.
Intent is very important. Can one sue or prosecute a popular food critic for writing something about a restaurant, causing lines so long that long-time regulars can't get a seat anymore?
On the other hand, you have things like booter services (essentially, DDoS as a service). Continuing the analogy, I imagine if you hired 100 people to physically block the entrance of a restaurant for some reason, you would be on the hook for damages in civil court and something along the lines of "disturbing the peace" in criminal court.
we have instances of cities facing outcry from residents for simply building homeless shelters within their own limits[0][1]. I imagine the outcry for a city "shipping out" their homeless to a shelter outside their bounds would be even worse.
[0]: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/mar/28/san-francisc...
[1]: https://www.ocregister.com/2019/04/02/huntington-beach-scrat...
"Family sues Tesla after accident" is a fact.