HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lars_francke

1,393 karma · joined April 20, 2011

Working on an Open-Source Data Platform based on Kubernetes as a founder of Stackable https://stackable.tech - You can reach me at lars.francke@stackable.tech
submissionscomments
lars_francke··on xAI announces series B funding round of $6B
X.ai used to be a service similar to calendly. I still mourn its shutdown and, seeing this, had hoped that it is resurrected :(
lars_francke··on JetBrains releases RustRover IDE for Rust development
I can attest to that. Am using Ultimate and everything works and gets regular updates.

That includes Rust and web development.

I have been a happy paying customer for 10+ years.

lars_francke··on Slack AI Training with Customer Data
Exactly, yes.
lars_francke··on Slack AI Training with Customer Data
I contacted support to opt out.. Here is the answer.

"Hi there,

Thank you for reaching out to Slack support. Your opt-out request has been completed.

For clarity, Slack has platform-level machine learning models for things like channel and emoji recommendations and search results. We do not build or train these models in such a way that they could learn, memorize, or be able to reproduce some part of customer data. Our published policies cover those here (https://slack.com/trust/data-management/privacy-principles), and as shared above your opt out request has been processed.

Slack AI is a separately purchased add-on that uses Large Language Models (LLMs) but does not train those LLMs on customer data. Slack AI uses LLMs hosted directly within Slack’s AWS infrastructure, so that customer data remains in-house and is not shared with any LLM provider. This ensures that Customer Data stays in that organization’s control and exclusively for that organization’s use. You can read more about how we’ve built Slack AI to be secure and private here: https://slack.engineering/how-we-built-slack-ai-to-be-secure....

Kind regards, Best regards,"

lars_francke··on Firefox search update
Arc being such a generic term it'd be helpful to include a link or explanation what that is.
lars_francke··on Open Source Community Unites to Build EU CRA-Compliant Cybersecurity Processes
It is not so much an elite squad as more a bunch of people willing to spend the entrance fee and to commit their time. The exact requirements depend on the country you're in though. So if that is your only concern but you are willing to spend time feel free to reach out.

About your actual question: The answer is "not really" no. ETSI has a way to adopt existing standards: https://www.etsi.org/images/files/ETSI_PAS_Process_Guide.pdf But CEN and CENELEC (which are probably relevant here) do not.

The effort from the blog post is partially about a long term plan to get the EU to change this. But in the short term it'll be hard to change the rules in time for the CRA standards.

lars_francke··on Open Source Community Unites to Build EU CRA-Compliant Cybersecurity Processes
You present one possible outcome but it is far from certain.

Another possible scenario is that companies investing in these principles will be way ahead when similar regulation will pop up _everywhere_ else.

You also present your opinion as a factual statement: "Laws like these need to be..." -> No, they don't as can be seen by GDPR, CRA and others.

I am personally affected by the CRA, I have a startup here in Europe and I see this as a great chance for EU, FOSS and Software Development in general.

lars_francke··on Open Source Community Unites to Build EU CRA-Compliant Cybersecurity Processes
In case anyone is interested: The EU did publish the draft "standardization request" recently https://ec.europa.eu/docsroom/documents/58974

This is the request which will allow the three european standardization organizations (CEN, CENELEC, ETSI) to draft the required 41 standards for the Cyber Resilience Act (CRA). See page 17 and following for the list.

To participate in the standardization you have to be part of a "national body" and they will "send" you to participate in EU standardization. I know no one from my FOSS circles who has any experience there, as most relevant standards for us are written outside of these organizations (W3C, IETF etc.)

So we're currently trying to get an official seat at the table via the established ways (e.g. DIN in Germany, https://standards.cencenelec.eu/dyn/www/f?p=CEN:5 see this for your own country).

If you are interested in this please send me an email, we're trying to put together a guide on how to engage in "official" standardization efforts as Open Source people.

The effort from this blog post is (amongst other things) trying to establish a whole new way of engaging with the EU. We need both approaches.

lars_francke··on Open Source Community Unites to Build EU CRA-Compliant Cybersecurity Processes
But this is not a private matter.

The costs of poor cybersecurity are born mostly not by the people producing the "bad" software but by their consumers.

In the end we have law enforcement dealing with ransomware attacks, cybercrime etc. and this will never fully go away but some products don't even apply basic security principles and therefore distribute the cost of this amongst everyone. Yay, they get to produce cheap crap but at which cost?

I'd rather have securer products to get started with and then take it from there.

lars_francke··on Open Source Community Unites to Build EU CRA-Compliant Cybersecurity Processes
"Hyped" is not the word I'd use. Most of us are or were concerned and it took a lot of long meetings to even move "us" out of the category of "software manufacturer" and into a new category of "steward" which is currently not well defined.

Also not hyped because the required standards are written at the EU level and there is no established process for foundations to participate in these standards.

So it's more like: Trying to do the best with the cards we've been dealt.

I agree wtih everything else you're saying.

lars_francke··on ElephantSQL Is Shutting Down
Not OP but even setting up an AWS Account is a roughly hundred step process. Root account, IAM Accounts, I just tried using CLIv2 which asked me to set up something called Identity center first? Billing is complicated, setting up looking and metrics... Another two services. Some other best practice things... Also extra services. AWS is complicated. There is - for me and seemingly others - a lot of value in avoiding this complexity. AWS used to be easy to use for "drive by users". It's not anymore.
lars_francke··on Redis adopts dual source-available licensing
Not even to e.g. something from the Apache Foundation? Or Eclipse? Or CNCF?
lars_francke··on Grok
Clarifying questions if the initial prompt was unclear. I'd love it.

I regularly try to add something along the lines of "please ask clarifying questions if you could only give a generic or partial response otherwise" but so far it has never helped (ChatGPT 4).

lars_francke··on The Bevy Foundation
Can you explain the difference?
lars_francke··on Apache Superset
I think it's a great feature to have explicit lifecycle for open source projects.

Lots of other projects just die silently and/or you are unsure of the status.

Here you at least have a chance to revive them if you like as there is always an overarching organisation.

lars_francke··on Apache Superset
> almost everything I've ever worked with that was run by the Apache foundation turned out to be semi-abandoned disasterware over time

Can you name a few examples?

lars_francke··on Apache Superset
We've built a Kubernetes Operator for Apache Superset at Stackable: https://github.com/stackabletech/superset-operator/

It's part of our Open Source Data Platform and it's one of the few open source BI tools out there and there are not a lot of alternatives in this space. We generally like it.

lars_francke··on Deutsche Bahn is looking for Win 3.11 admin
Previous discussions:

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39168469

- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39160956

lars_francke··on Pkl, a Programming Language for Configuration
Because you asked for this feedback: Rust
lars_francke··on The European regulators listened to the Open Source communities
If you import a product the CRA applies.

And I personally think that's a good thing

lars_francke··on Stories removed from the Hacker News Front Page, updated in real time
> While I have no reason to doubt Daniel's good faith, it's hard to believe that HN users would be tired of LLM-related news.

I am, so you can believe it. But: I don't flag things that I'm tired of.

lars_francke··on The European regulators listened to the Open Source communities
The CRA still applies as soon as it is first brought onto the EU market. It might just be the distributor or importer having to do some things instead of the manufacturer.
lars_francke··on Scrum Sucks
We do that already, yeah. But they'd like estimates on a lot of issues so they can prioritize better. I believe it's a waste of time though. There is no good solution for this I believe.
lars_francke··on Scrum Sucks
Agreed. We use Kanban and are very happy. We used to not do any estimates but have voices from others asking for them to do better planning of marketing and sales activities. I understand where they are coming from but so far it's mostly guessing

So: Do you do estimation in Kanban and if so, how?

lars_francke··on Pocketbase: Open-source back end in one file
To me it seems as if both tools serve a pretty different purpose.

Redbean doesn't have authentication or the client SDKs at least.

lars_francke··on The One Billion Row Challenge
> No external dependencies may be used
lars_francke··on Show HN: I built ContainerCVE – a web tool to scan public Docker images
That's a good question and I encourage you to join the CISA Working Groups on VEX etc. It is only indirect work but it might help steer things in the right direction.

I'm repeating myself but: CVEs are useless. Please don't use them as an equivalent for "vulnerabilities".

Regulators might take a few years to catch up but if I'm able to DDoS my competition with bogus vulnerabilities then people will do just that.

The CRA says that only "exploitable" vulnerabilities have to be fixed and it does accept VEX statements. So that's good. I would have liked to see "exploited" instead of "exploitable" but it's better than nothing.

I assume/hope the US will follow.

lars_francke··on Show HN: I built ContainerCVE – a web tool to scan public Docker images
I have been tangentially involved in the Cyber Resilience Act (CRA). I'm more an interested party than a real expert.

We recently wrote a document on how we would like to approach our own vulnerability management process. It received a lot of comments and we'll gladly take more:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1QB3EaimrS0KlL6wIpfY5-SlE...

To answer your questions then :)

> Do vulnerabilities normally get a patch and are we expecting upcoming regulation to require the patches are installed?

Not all vulnerabilities get a patch, it's really up to the project. But this is what the CRA is about. In the commercial context it will require vendors to handle vulnerabilities by e.g. providing patches. And depending on which industry you are in you might also be required to install said patches.

> If action is required to be taken when vulns are published do we all have to just uninstall the thing until the bug gets fixed, lest we invalidate our corporate insurance policy?

I doubt it but it's a good idea to have a good overview of what you're running in your company. This extends to dependencies which might be included in things you're running. That is what SBOMs are meant for. They will be required in the future.

> Will I have to cease my current policy of running Trivy, reading the CVE output, and then declaring (and making a git commit saying) “while this stdlib library technically supports CORBA and our OS technically supports IPX, we don’t use CORBA or IPX… or networking… or this library… so I’m ignoring this!”

No. That is excellent! It will be formalized into a machine readable format. Currently often called a VEX statement: Vulnerability Exploitability Exchange. One popularish format for this is CSAF. But CycloneDX (an SBOM format) can also be used for this.

Having this in a machine readable format makes it easier for users to consume the information.

The tooling for this is not great yet, which is what our document above is about.

Hope it helps.

Happy to chat about this if you're interested. Reach out if you like. Details should be in my profile.

lars_francke··on Show HN: I built ContainerCVE – a web tool to scan public Docker images
I'm not sure if you're replying to the correct thread?

All I'm saying is that all CVEs are supposed to be vulnerabilities but not all vulnerabilities have a CVE. So, the name artificially limits the scope of the product. Trivy reports more than just CVEs

lars_francke··on Show HN: I built ContainerCVE – a web tool to scan public Docker images
It might sound like nitpicking but I find it dangerous to say vulnerability == CVE.

CVEs are one source of information about potential vulnerabilities but they are amongst the least reliable these days. I've heard them being called Curriculum Vitae Enhancer.

And Trivy itself uses more sources than just CVEs as well. With upcoming regulation like the Cyber Resilience Act we'll get even more sources of vulnerabilities. I believe the future will be/should be one of distributed sources for this information. Every vendor might want to be their own authoritative source of vulnerabilities.

This is a long way of saying: Useful tool, congratulations on the launch! I'd suggest a change of name as you limit yourself with the current one.

← PreviousPage 3 of 12Next →