HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

larsiusprime

6,276 karma · joined April 4, 2012

I'm a real estate mass appraisal researcher, author, and former game developer.

This is my company: www.landeconomics.org

This is my book: www.landisabigdeal.com

This is my personal website: www.fortressofdoors.com

This is a game I worked on: www.defendersquest.com

submissionscomments
larsiusprime··on QGIS is a free, open-source, cross platform geographical information system
I work in the mass appraisal space, and I use QGIS all the time. The professional alternative is ESRI's ArcGIS.

A lot of shops I know (private and public) will use ArcGIS still, but I'm noticing an increasing number of people (particularly younger researchers/analysts) who are exclusively using QGIS.

QGIS is powerful and full featured, but it is admittedly a bit rusty around the edges, especially when working with very large datasets. If they keep working on fixing some of the sharpest edges I think it will go on to have a good future. Just in the past few years I've noticed significant improvement.

In many ways it feels like Blender -- long ignored and dismissed, but slowly but surely improved over time, and then suddenly became quite a big deal.

larsiusprime··on [dead]
> As a final thought to recursively illustrate this. The very best artist can utilize sound waves and directly manipulate energy to build one of the Pyramids at Giza by hand. However, the most efficient way for someone without that ability or time to master those techniques is to draw the design of a pyramid as an artistic rendering on paper or a computer screen and have 24/7, nonstop nuclear/solar powered robots build it.

???

larsiusprime··on Where did the Smurfs get their hats (2018)
That’s still arguably a classic Phrygian cap design. Whatever or not that was the intention/inspiration, it does resemble them - the hats you just showed are not perfectly conical, there’s a flip at the top.
larsiusprime··on Three farmers on monopolies and mismanagement in U.S. agriculture
All the subdivisions in Texas that have “ranch” in the name are that way for a reason
larsiusprime··on Three farmers on monopolies and mismanagement in U.S. agriculture
The single largest (legible) landowner by acreage is some timber magnate. Over in Australia a few ranching families own so much land it makes the American figures look like rookie numbers
larsiusprime··on Three farmers on monopolies and mismanagement in U.S. agriculture
Indeed. One of the chief causes of high land prices for farmland is unmet demand for housing in the urban core, so farm and ranch land gets bid up to development prices.

A lot of advocates of building restrictions did it in the name of preserving nature/farmland/greenspace, but in many ways it’s had the opposite effect:

https://youtu.be/-Qn4iZgQY8k?si=LFzuAdWgMxB1BpIG

larsiusprime··on GPT-5 Thinking in ChatGPT (a.k.a. Research Goblin) is good at search
My contention is if it’s going to just give me a Wikipedia summary, I can do that myself. I just have greater expectations of “PhD” level intelligence.

If we’re going to claim to it is PhD level it should be able to do “deep” research AND think critically about source credibility, just as a PhD would. If it can’t do that they shouldn’t brand it that way.

Also it’s not like I’m taking Matzat’s word for anything. I can read the primary source documents myself! He’s also hardly an obscure source, he’s just not listed on Wikipedia.

larsiusprime··on GPT-5 Thinking in ChatGPT (a.k.a. Research Goblin) is good at search
Okay, so let me break it down for you:

The Silagi paper makes a factual claim. The Silagi paper claims that there was only one significant tax in the German colony of Kiatschou, a single tax on land.

The direct primary sources reveal that this is not the case. There were multiple taxes, most significantly large tariffs. Additionally there were two taxes on land, not one -- a conventional land value tax, and a "land increment" or capital gains tax.

These are not minor distinctions. These are not matters of subjective opinions. These are clear, verifiable, questions of fact. The Silagi paper does not acknowledge them.

ChatGPT, in the early trials I graded, does not even acknowledge the German primary sources. You keep saying that I am upset it doesn't agree with me.

I am saying the chief issue is that ChatGPT does not even discover the relevant primary sources. That is far more important than whether it agrees with me.

> For example, just to continue with socialism, it's common for socialist believers to argue that this or that country is or isn't socialist in a way that disagrees with mainstream historians.

Notice you said "historians." Plural. I expect a proper researcher to cite more than ONE paper, especially if the other papers disagree, and even if it has a preferred narrative, to at least surface to me that there is in fact disagreement in the literature, rather than to just summarize one finding.

Also, if the claims are being made about a piece of German history, I expect it to cite at least one source in German, rather than to rely entirely on one single English-language source.

The chief issue is that ChatGPT over-cites one single paper and does not discover primary source documents. That is the issue. That is the only issue.

> I am saying you are seeing distinctions as more important than the rest of the literature and concluding that the literature is erroneous.

And I am saying that ChatGPT did not in fact read the "rest of the literature." It is literally citing ONE article, and other pieces that merely summarize that same article, rather than all of the primary source documents. It is not in fact giving me anything like an accurate summary of the literature.

I am not saying "The literature is wrong because it disagrees with me." I am saying "one paper, the only one ChatGPT meaningfully cites, is directly contradicted by the REST of the literature, which ChatGPT does not cite."

A truly "research grade" or "PhD grade" intelligence would at the very least be able to discover that.

larsiusprime··on GPT-5 Thinking in ChatGPT (a.k.a. Research Goblin) is good at search
You misunderstand. I’m indeed a Georgist, and I discovered that a popular Georgist narrative was exaggerated! The findings of the historically verifiable primary source documents contradicted a prevailing narrative based on the Silagi paper. The Silagi paper is pro Georgist! But it’s exaggerated!

The literature — the primary source documents — do not in fact support a maximalist Georgist case! This is what I have been trying to say!!!

You are accusing me of the exact opposite thing I’m arguing for!!! The historical case the primary sources show is inconvenient for my political movement!

The failure of chat gpt is not that it disagrees with any opinion of mine, but that it does not surface primary source documents. That’s the issue.

Its baffling to be accused of confirmation bias when I point out research findings that goes against what would be maximally convenient for my own cause.

larsiusprime··on GPT-5 Thinking in ChatGPT (a.k.a. Research Goblin) is good at search
It’s mostly that it was not citing verifiable - and available online - primary source documents, the way I would expect an actual researcher investigating this question would. This is relevant when it is billed as "Research Grade" or "PhD" level intelligence. I expect a PhD level researcher to find the German-language primary sources.
larsiusprime··on GPT-5 Thinking in ChatGPT (a.k.a. Research Goblin) is good at search
What are you talking about? There are verifiable primary sources that ChatGPT was not citing. There are direct primary historical sources that lay out the full budget of the historical German colony in extreme detail, that directly contradict assertions made in the Silagi paper, that’s not a matter of opinion that’s a matter of verifiable fact.

Also what “axe” am I grinding? The findings are specifically inconvenient for my political beliefs, not confirming my priors! My priors would be flattered if Silagi was correct about everything but the primary sources definitively prove he’s exaggerating.

> You published a blog about that opinion, and you want ChatGPT to say you're to accept your view.

False, and I address this multiple times in the piece. I don’t want ChatGPT to mindlessly agree with me, I want it to discover the primary source documents.

larsiusprime··on GPT-5 Thinking in ChatGPT (a.k.a. Research Goblin) is good at search
I find ChatGPT to be great at research too-but there are pathological failure modes where it is biased to shallow answers that are subtly wrong, even when definitive primary sources are readily available online:

https://www.fortressofdoors.com/researchers-beware-of-chatgp...

larsiusprime··on I used to know how to write in Japanese
If native speakers are starting to have character amnesia too, does that suggest in the long run you would expect the writing systems to simplify towards the phonetic syllabaries? Or is the fact that we have computers as a mediating tool going to forestall that and just make things weird?
larsiusprime··on Baltimore Assessments Accidentally Subsidize Blight–and How We Can Fix It
I mean couldn't you do the same thing in a property tax where the buildings are exempted (ie, a Land value tax)?
larsiusprime··on Baltimore Assessments Accidentally Subsidize Blight–and How We Can Fix It
Wouldn't this scenario also apply under conventional property tax regimes? Is or isn't this already happening in high property tax states? What is the specific bad effect you are invoking, and is it having the effects you predict in places where the effective tax rate on land is already fairly high?
larsiusprime··on Baltimore Assessments Accidentally Subsidize Blight–and How We Can Fix It
I want to point out that this is not really about revenue generation but about fairness -- the law requires that property be valued at market value, and so that's the policy that should be followed.

As for revenue, that's a political decision. The thing is that elected officials control the tax rate, not SDAT. SDAT only values the properties.

Rising property values don't have to mean rising taxes, the elected officials can lower the tax rate in response -- this what the term "no new revenue rate" is for.

It's also not just about pushing tax burden onto vacant lots. When property A is undervalued relative to property B, property B picks up more of the property taxes. So if a lot of vacant land is undervalued, that means a lot of improved land is paying more taxes proportionately. It seems sub-optimal that property where nobody lives is given a tax subsidy and the difference is realized in rising taxes for everyone else.

The main point is that the law requires that everyone be valued at market rate. That should be done first. Then any special case exemptions, write-downs, discounts, and the tax rate itself, should be handled at the political layer, where they are explicit and conscious rather than implicit.

We can debate what the relative impact of this is in the big picture, but this seems like something that is worth fixing.

larsiusprime··on Baltimore Assessments Accidentally Subsidize Blight–and How We Can Fix It
Rising property values don't necessarily mean higher tax bills if the property tax rate falls to match. You will see terms like "no new revenue rate" that reflect this.

The point of the article is not "Baltimore should raise more taxes" -- raising more revenue is a political decision, and that is not actually under SDAT's purview. SDAT's job is simply to assess property at market value. What to do with that value is for the elected officials (and the voters who elect them) to decide.

If property A is undervalued relative to property B, property B faces an unfair burden of taxes, and property A receives an unfair tax break. That's all this report is trying to say -- all property should be assessed at its market value, as the law requires.

Any exemptions, discounts, write-offs, and the tax rate itself, are political decisions. Those should be made explicitly by elected officials, not implicitly by unequal valuations.

larsiusprime··on Denver rent is back to 2022 prices after 20k new units hit the market
Could also just exempt the value of the buildings from taxation
larsiusprime··on In the long run, GPL code becomes irrelevant (2015)
I can think of at least a few counterexamples. The logic behind the hypothesis is decent and tells a plausible story, but I'd like to see a more robust analysis; has anyone done one since the article was first posted 10 years ago?

Noteable counterxamples (excluding e.g. Linux):

- Git (GPLv2)

- Blender (GPLv2 & 3, from the looks of it)

- Krita (GPLv3)

- MySQL (GPLv2) -- still seems very popular in 2025

- QGIS (GPLv2)

larsiusprime··on The Italian towns selling houses for €1
Maintenance of old crumbling European castles in inconvenient locations are also often famously bad deals for the owner.
larsiusprime··on The Italian towns selling houses for €1
There are indeed many places where the land value is effectively zero and the building is also worthless. But offers like these often have other obligations so the 1 euro cost is not the all in price.
larsiusprime··on How Georgists Valued land in the 1900's
What ax? I’m the author and a YIMBY. Read the linked article, that’s the exact title of it, and I largely agree with it! I wrote that line because it contradicted the expectations of a movement I myself belong to, which I found surprising.
larsiusprime··on How Georgists Valued land in the 1900's
I’m the author and a YIMBY for the record and it’s not meant as a snipe. The link is an article by that exact same title by Jerusalem Demsas
larsiusprime··on DuckDB is probably the most important geospatial software of the last decade
This is an excellent reply and what I wish the article had been, thanks!
larsiusprime··on DuckDB is probably the most important geospatial software of the last decade
“import geopandas” also exists and has for some time. Snark aside, WHAT is special about duckDB? I wish the author had actually shown some practical examples so I could understand their claims better.
larsiusprime··on Digital Ghost Towns: When Big Companies Acquire, Shut Down, and Sit on Domains
A proposed solution to this issue: https://progressandpoverty.substack.com/p/should-there-be-de...

(Vitalik Buterin's proposal for a Land Value Tax like structure for Domain Name like objects)

larsiusprime··on Dark Mirror Ideologies
Author here. I’ll grant “gray mirrors” without a fight. (Ideologies that admit to the same facts but one side just doesn’t care; multiply by zero instead of negative one).

Also note in the article I cop to at least one salient example being real

My main point is not to say dark/gray mirrors don’t exist, just that it should never be your first explanation. Your opponent tends to want things for their reasons, not yours, and the better you understand them the better you can oppose them. That’s it.

larsiusprime··on Dark Mirror Ideologies
Open source self describes its value system as being freedom for developers, free software self describes its value system as being freedom for users.

Most open source grants users far more freedoms than proprietary software, for instance, though not maximal freedoms. It’s not opposed to user freedom (“that’s bad actually”) it’s just not the goal being optimized for.

I think it’s a fallacy to accuse them of being dark mirrors of each other for the reasons stated in the blog post. They have different worldviews and different goals, they don’t just take each other’s goals and multiply them by negative one.

Open source doesn’t try to intentionally restrict users, it just trades off against their maximal freedom in favor of maximal developer freedom.

Free software doesn’t intentionally try to encumber developers, it just trades off against their maximal freedom in favor of users maximal freedom.

larsiusprime··on The highest-ranking personal blogs of Hacker News
no problem, thanks :)
larsiusprime··on The highest-ranking personal blogs of Hacker News
Interesting that if you were to combine AstralCodexTen and SlateStarCodex it would be around top #20. Even with the traffic split he's in the top 50 twice.
← PreviousPage 3 of 24Next →