6,276 karma · joined April 4, 2012
This is my company: www.landeconomics.org
This is my book: www.landisabigdeal.com
This is my personal website: www.fortressofdoors.com
This is a game I worked on: www.defendersquest.com
The issue is that we tax the land and the buildings together. We should tax only the land. And we're often not taxing it enough.
> I for one enjoy having open spaces that are not developed
I enjoy those spaces too! You know what we have right now? SPRAWL. For miles in every direction. Pavement that gobbles up more and more greenfield spaces, for low-density, low-value uses. Outlying wilderness land is not very valuable, but land in urban centers is very valuable. Because we don't tax that land appropriately, we just encourage people to sprawl out further and further, and because we tax buildings, we discourage people from building densely. This leads to more land consumption and less of the open undeveloped space you like.
Those trees you love? They're being cut down to make way for parking lots and strip malls and self-storage units. Really wasteful uses of land. Denser building would make it so demand for housing, commerce, and amenities are fulfilled on a much smaller footprint.
If we taxed land appropriately, we would have way more undeveloped land, and more appropriate density in the city, and you wouldn't have to commute nearly as far to get to the wilderness.
When you put in a transit line, the surrounding land values go up -- it's as old as the railroads. The governing body needs to capture the increase in those land values. This is how transit is funded in many Asian countries -- the transit project goes from being a cost boondoggle to a profit center that pays for itself, either by taxing the uplift in land values, or the governing body owning that land and leasing it out to e.g. shops.
https://www.lincolninst.edu/publications/articles/2022-09-la...
EDIT: To be fair, clicking beyond the headline, it looks like the ongoing practice at zoos has been to feed them a carnivore diet of mostly meat, which is apparently bad for them, and this article recommends otherwise, which seems sensible.
UBI without LVT is probably inflationary, but LVT would provide a pretty natural mechanism for funding such a thing, and is the natural policy for preventing it from causing inflation, particularly in the housing sector.
I strongly recommend you read the book.
https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/no-the-us-didnt-outsource-...
Vitalik Buterin wrote an interesting analysis about how to allocate scarce domains, contrasting unstoppable’s approach with recurring demand based fees:
https://progressandpoverty.substack.com/p/should-there-be-de...
https://progressandpoverty.substack.com/p/norways-sovereign-...
https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2022/05/17/norway-the-once-and...
1) Rognlie[1] pointed out that Piketty's central premise -- that the returns to capital are growing faster than the overall growth rate of the economy -- falls apart when you properly account for asset class and depreciation. The accelerating returns are specifically to real estate, while the returns to capital (excluding real estate) are flat.
2) Tyler Cowen pointed this out on his interview [2] with Piketty and Piketty essentially conceded the point.
Tyler implied therefore that the natural conclusion is Georgism[3]
[1] https://www.brookings.edu/bpea-articles/deciphering-the-fall...
[2] https://conversationswithtyler.com/episodes/thomas-piketty/
[3] http://gameofrent.com/content/is-land-a-big-deal#a-brief-rec...
http://gameofrent.com/content/can-lvt-be-passed-on-to-tenant...