HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

laughinghan

2,942 karma · joined August 25, 2010

http://twitter.com/laughinghan

http://github.com/laughinghan

submissionscomments
laughinghan··on Ninth Circuit rules NSA's bulk collection of Americans' call records was illegal
To the extremely limited and minimal extent that whistleblowers have been pardoned, good on that president/governor, but I think it is atrocious that whistleblower protection relies on pardon power—we need much, much stronger protections for whistleblowers, in my opinion.

I think 90% of people are basically good but don't really want to stick their neck out of line—which means rules by themselves will never constrain the 5% of people that are malevolent. We need to empower the other 5% of people who are willing to stick their neck out to do the right thing. That includes institutionally empowering whistleblowers.

Snowden committed a crime, sure, prosecute him—just give him a fair trial, for goodness' sake.

laughinghan··on Ninth Circuit rules NSA's bulk collection of Americans' call records was illegal
Not having a pardon power allows bad judges to throw anyone they don't like into jail with no recourse by anyone.

Technically, all judges can be impeached, and all judges other than SCOTUS can be appealed (there's actually a specific writ you can file claiming to be jailed unjustly, habeas corpus).

In practice, impeachment hasn't proven to be much of a check on judicial power (recall elections have probably been more effective overall), but I think the appeals process more or less works and I don't think the pardon power has added much, on balance. I think unilateral pardon power by a political official has proven sufficiently ripe for abuse that I would even support adding limits like some kind of Congressional check, but it's definitely nowhere near a top priority.

Obviously the appeals process has had plenty of failings too, the Japanese internment camps being the most famous example, another high-profile one is Lincoln suspending habeas corpus during the Civil War.

laughinghan··on Ninth Circuit rules NSA's bulk collection of Americans' call records was illegal
I'm confused by your Bush and Obama references—both incidents occurred under Bush, the one that you attribute to Bush was revealed under Obama, whereas the one you attribute to Obama was revealed under Bush.

Are you attributing based on occurrence or based on decision not to prosecute? Did you accidentally switch them?

laughinghan··on Court dismisses Genius lawsuit over lyrics-scraping by Google
I think your parent was just trying to say "laws are important".

"Legacy" code that only "occasionally works" doesn't sound like something worth keeping around. It sounds like something to dump in the trash and never look back.

If you have working legacy code though, even if it occasionally fails because it's full of bugs and fundamental flaws, should be replaced very carefully, and only with in-depth understanding of what is working and what is broken about the existing system.

Based on the broken laws you list, I assume you're talking about America. American laws are indeed very broken, but dumping it in the trash and never looking back would be a one-way ticket to a bloodbath. It is both important very important to fix our very broken laws, and important to do so very carefully and only with an in-depth understanding of what is working and what is broken about the existing system.

If I were to give you as much benefit of the doubt as you give your parent, I'd say that "occasionally laws work" is the kind of thing someone says when they've never seen how much worse it can get.

laughinghan··on Court dismisses Genius lawsuit over lyrics-scraping by Google
Right. "Expression" isn't restricted to specific wording, it can potentially mean specific choices of what is included and what is included in a compilation; I could hold a copyright to such a compilation even if I don't hold the copyright to any of the items in the copyright.

For example, many artists publish playlists on Spotify to build their brand; it could plausibly be copyright infringement for one of them to verbatim copy a playlist I made and publish it as their own, even if I don't hold the copyright to any of the songs on my playlist, and even if one of the songs on the playlist was actually that artists' own song. The act of assembling a playlist is potentially copyrightable expression.

laughinghan··on Mozilla lays off 250 employees while it refocuses on commercial products
Since this is so useful, and has operational costs because they have to run a server, could they solve two problems in one go by just charging money for it? Like $10/year or something tiny. Bet the malware issue would go way down.
laughinghan··on Court dismisses Genius lawsuit over lyrics-scraping by Google
You seem focused on whether this case was the legally correct decision, which it sure seems to be. This article, like many readers, is more focused on whether this was a fair result. Nothing bizarre about that.

The judge may have done the correct thing, but readers may feel that Congress didn't. This case will doubtless be used in the future to argue for sui generis database rights like the EU has.

(My view is that in principle, some form of sui generis database rights makes sense, but for the things that US copyright law already covers it is currently far, FAR too restrictive and lasts too long, so I would vehemently oppose expansion of existing US copyright law to cover sui generis database rights.

However, if US copyright law were reformed such that it mandated blanket licensing (see [the EFF proposal]), strengthened fair use protections, and shortened copyright duration, then I would totally support similar rights for sui generis databases.)

[EFF proposal for blanket licensing]: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/05/plan-pay-artists-encou...

laughinghan··on Court dismisses Genius lawsuit over lyrics-scraping by Google
No, in the US you cannot copyright facts, only expression. So you have control over word-for-word copies of your article about a bird; but you have no control over dissemination of the facts you discovered about the bird. SCOTUS decided this in 1991, Feist v. Rural: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feist_Publications,_Inc.,_v._R....

You might be thinking of sui generis database rights, which DOES cover collections of facts. The EU, Russia, and Brazil recognize this right, but the US doesn't: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Database_right#United_States

laughinghan··on Spotify CEO: musicians can no longer release music only “once every 3-4 years”
I'm sorry that people dismiss the work it takes to make good art, that must be frustrating.

It's silly to compare the ease of making "working software" with a "hit record". Just like probably most of the music you worked on as a sound engineer, most "working software" made little money and got few customers, look at the long tail of apps that aren't hits in the iOS App Store, Google Play Store, etc.

Even comparing "financially successful software" to "financially successful music" makes no sense. Far more musicians have made six figures or more from a song that took tens of hours to make, than indie software developers have made six figures from an app that they only spent tens of hours on. Is that because music is easier? Yet far fewer technically competent musicians are able to make a living using those skills than technically competent software developers. Is that because music is harder?

It's almost like two things can require different talents, have different factors that go into their financial success, and still both be hard.

laughinghan··on Spotify CEO: musicians can no longer release music only “once every 3-4 years”
What is the relevance of offering insight into the process of creating music?

With or without insight, it's obviously apples-to-oranges to compare "working software" to a "hit record".

Most "working software" is rarely used and makes no money, look at the long tail of apps in the iOS App Store, Google Play Store, etc that didn't become hits.

laughinghan··on More than 1k people at Twitter had ability to aid hack of accounts
All of those sound like fairly harmless Twitter accounts to lose control of for a few minutes once in a decade?
laughinghan··on More than 1k people at Twitter had ability to aid hack of accounts
What do you think of Yonatan Zunger's proposed fix, to verify facts and not people?

So @sistersofmercy might get a Verified Badge saying "Religious Institute, Ireland", and @tsomofficial might get a Verified Badge saying "Musical Group, UK".

He wrote this in response to the Jason Kessler kerfuffle, well before the "factcheckUK" stunt, but it would have actually solved that too! Imagine seeing the username "factcheckUK" with the Verified Badge "Conservative and Unionist Party, UK 🇬🇧".

https://medium.com/@yonatanzunger/the-hard-lessons-of-blue-c...

laughinghan··on More than 1k people at Twitter had ability to aid hack of accounts
I think the Yonatan Zunger had the right solution to this: Verify Facts Not People.

Replace the checkmark with a Verified Badge that says their position if they're an elected official or major organization leader, or just Real Name if they've verified their ID.

He wrote this in response to the Jason Kessler kerfuffle, well before the "factcheckUK" stunt, but it would have actually solved that too! Imagine seeing the username "factcheckUK" with the Verified Badge "Conservative and Unionist Party, UK 🇬🇧".

https://medium.com/@yonatanzunger/the-hard-lessons-of-blue-c...

laughinghan··on More than 1k people at Twitter had ability to aid hack of accounts
pending verification that the blue check mark still applies to the person now in control of that account

Why would you want to ever allow an admin to transfer control of a verified account to an unverified person?

If you're saying that the account recovery process needs to be at least as secure as the credential that was verified (e.g. email address), then I agree. But I don't think reversion to a "pending" state would ever be desirable, though.

laughinghan··on More than 1k people at Twitter had ability to aid hack of accounts
Yeah, response time might be slower in the middle of the night, but a falsified tweet on a celebrity account in the middle of the night is also likely proportionally less damaging.

Response time during lunch hour might be slower initially, but after responding to the first compromised account I don't think they'd be any slower.

If an admin account is only supposed to be for use by a human employee, it should have a rate-limit tripwire that automatically suspends the account and alerts the security team.

laughinghan··on More than 1k people at Twitter had ability to aid hack of accounts
I actually had a similar idea for fighting SIM swaps—we should be able to ask telecoms "hey, when's the last time this phone number was moved to another device/changed IMEI numbers?" and distrust the number if it's been changed less than 48 hours ago.

I've looked but as far as I can tell, such an API does not exist, alas.

laughinghan··on More than 1k people at Twitter had ability to aid hack of accounts
No, according to The Block, @elonmusk repeatedly tweeted the scam at 4:17pm, 5:19pm, and 5:32pm, a span of 90 minutes, and the final scam tweet was at 6:05pm from @KimKardashian.

An hour after @elonmusk's first scam tweet, 7 celebrity or corporate accounts had tweeted the scam, all with the same Bitcoin address. With the two-click system I described, how many compromised admin accounts would you expect the security team to have been able to suspend by then?

8 more celebrity accounts went on to tweet the scam, plus @elonmusk and @kanyewest repeating the scam tweets.

https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/71906/twitter-account-ha...

laughinghan··on More than 1k people at Twitter had ability to aid hack of accounts
accounts with more than 10,000 followers should at least need two people to change key settings

For accounts that could start a war this might be necessary, but for celebrities with >10K followers this sounds expensive and unnecessary to me.

To me, it seems like you could instead ensure the admin view of every account has a timestamped log of recent settings changes, including changes done by admins, with a link to the profile of the admin responsible, and a button to suspend that admin account with one click.

This way, the security team could've seen that Elon Musk's account had just been reset by J. Random Employee minutes before tweeting the suspicious bitcoin tweet, messaged J. on Slack to be like "hey did you do that?", and suspended the compromised admin account within minutes.

Sure, some accounts might be briefly compromised initially, but it would be resolved in minutes and not the hours that it took Twitter, right? That seems fine for what should be a relatively low-likelihood, high-expense attack like compromised admin account (of course, you have to ensure that is the case).

laughinghan··on Peter Thiel on Progress and Stagnation
I'm biased because I already expected to disagree with much of his worldview, but I think a lot of Key Quotes Summary are bad takes:

The single most important economic development in recent times has been the broad stagnation of real wages and incomes since 1973, the year when oil prices quadrupled.

Actually the real price of oil was basically the same for the decade before 1973 (ranging $22.21 - $27.37) as 1993-1999 (ranging $18.86 - $33.63): https://inflationdata.com/articles/inflation-adjusted-prices...

It's true that it spiked in 1974-1985, and was elevated from 1986-1992 (ranging $32.48 - $45.65 — far from quadruple), and has been much higher than pre-1973 prices since 2000, but that doesn't really match up with the stagnation of wages. Policy changes in the 80s (Reaganomics) causing rising inequality are a much better explanation:

https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/

https://www.epi.org/publication/reining-in-ceo-compensation-...

Today a letter from Einstein would get lost in the White House mail room, and the Manhattan Project would not even get started.

He thought that was a problem under Obama and he sought to change that by elevating...Trump?

Tesla was out-competed by Edison, even though Edison had an inferior technology. The Wright brothers came up with the first airplane, but they didn’t get to be rich.

Edison having inferior technology is kind of a myth, or at least a vast oversimplification. DC is superior to AC in many situations; ironically, Tesla the car company is all about innovations in DC technology, as is Musk's SolarCity.

The Wright brothers are arguably the first to privately achieve powered controlled flight, and it's obviously impressive that they were "just" bicycle mechanics before, but it's an American myth that they "invented" the airplane. French-Brazilian aviator Alberto Santos-Dumont actually publicly demonstrated his independently developed powered controlled airplane in 1906 before the Wright brothers did in 1908, and there are many other claims to having been first, all independently developed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claims_to_the_first_powered_fl...

More importantly, the Wright brothers did a bad job of turning their prototypes into useful airplanes, while Glenn Curtiss and the European aviators did a better job; instead, the Wright brothers focused on guarding their patents and promoting their names as the first inventors. If anyone would agree that execution matters more than ideas, it would be the HN crowd.

If you're a professor in academia, [you say]: the tenure system is great. It's just picking the most talented people. I don't think it's that hard at all. It's completely meritocratic. And if you don't say those things, well we know you're not the person to get tenure. So I think there’s this individual incentive where if you pretend the system is working, you're simultaneously signaling that you're one of the few people who should succeed in it.

Um...and what reason is there to believe that the VC-based tech industry isn't exactly like this, and that is how Thiel himself became successful? Cancer researchers are at least objectively making progress against cancer. Thiel got rich by founding or investing in some companies that he sold to other rich people.

On the other hands, some of these are interesting thoughts:

Indefinite attitudes to the future explain what’s most dysfunctional in our world today. Process trumps substance [...] A definite view, by contrast, favors firm convictions. [...] In a definite world money is a means to an end because there are specific things you want to do with money. In an indefinite world you have no idea what to do with money [...]

I think there is a big hysteresis part to this where success begets success and then failure begets failure, where if you haven’t had any major successes in a number of decades, it does induce a certain amount of learned helplessness, and then it shifts the way science gets done or the way innovation gets done in to a more bureaucratic, political structure where the people who get the research grants are more the politicians than the scientists. You’re rewarded for very small incremental progress, not for trying to take risks.

The "two perspectives on China" thing might be interesting, but I'd want to see a lot more substantiation. Who is saying what, exactly?

laughinghan··on [dead]
Because I fucked up. Here's a more current tweet: https://twitter.com/GhostfromTexas/status/128423896421647564...

Here's the main HN thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23875692

laughinghan··on Cloudflare outage causing Discord, Medium, Patreon, ProductHunt, Gitlab all down
See also discussion at: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23875692

Also, many things seem to be back, for me and others: https://twitter.com/OhNoItsFusl/status/1284240273569128449

laughinghan··on [dead]
Because of Cloudflare: https://twitter.com/GhostfromTexas/status/128423896421647564...

See discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23875692

laughinghan··on [dead]
Because of Cloudflare: https://twitter.com/GhostfromTexas/status/128423896421647564...

See discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23875692

laughinghan··on Cloudflare was down
Discord confirmed Cloudflare is also the reason they're down: https://twitter.com/discord/status/1284237737638461453
laughinghan··on [2019] Cloudflare, Medium, Discord, Gitlab, DigitalOcean, ProductHunt All Down
Damn it, you're right
laughinghan··on [dead]
Likely connected to the Cloudflare outage: https://twitter.com/JacobCanfield/status/1146057756400504837

See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23875842

laughinghan··on Atlas of Surveillance
Even in the US there are exceptions, like the state secrets privilege:

https://www.eff.org/nsa-spying/state-secrets-privilege

laughinghan··on Atlas of Surveillance
This isn't a very good argument against parallel construction, because you are able to contest all of the evidence being used in court against you.

I don't think arguing against the legitimacy of the investigative means used to acquire evidence is ever an admissible argument by which to contest that evidence before a jury. If those investigative means were a poisonous tree, that's an argument you make to the judge to preclude admission of that evidence in the first place, before either side gets to contest any evidence.

I think lawyering over whether parallel construction is lying or not is tactically silly. You'll be on much firmer ground arguing that parallel constructions completely undercuts the point of the "fruit of the poisonous tree" doctrine, which is to disincentivize illegal means of investigation.

laughinghan··on Debubble
Let's say it does not match what many Americans think of when they hear "socialism". There's no such thing as a "textbook definition" of socialism.
laughinghan··on Debubble
I think a global warming debate could be quite enlightening. I am not a climate scientist, so if I were to discuss global warming with someone else who wasn't a climate scientist, the questions I would be most curious about are: do they acknowledge that there's a scientific consensus? If they don't believe a consensus exists, that's a present-day, non-forward-looking fact that someone could be convinced of. If they believe they know better than the consensus, I'd at least be interested in learning why in more detail than just "they're irrational".

I don't believe for a second anyone would actually admit to believing that "my convenience is more important than the certain loss of your life". There are situations where I would agree my freedom is more important than your life, self-defense being the obvious example. Even if that's logically what they're saying and don't realize it, I believe that for the overwhelming majority of people, if delivered in the right context, in the right tone, by the right person, they could be lead to empathize and see why that's not right.

← PreviousPage 3 of 27Next →