2,942 karma · joined August 25, 2010
http://github.com/laughinghan
For the record, I actually agree with you that this is a good policy and will be a positive outcome for users. But while you seem to agree that Google could have handled this better, you're not doing a good job of acknowledging just how developer-hostile Google was here, which is why you're getting a lot of pushback.
Do you have any contrary empirical evidence?
Why would there be a fundamental tradeoff between whatever "clean" means, and being confusing? Surely it's possible to build a UI that isn't confusing, but also has whatever positives a "clean UI" has?
All I needed to substantiate my claim was convincing examples of results from field A whose impact, added together, most people would agree is more than the combined impact of field B in the 20th century. The fact that the person I was replying to then agreed with me is strong evidence I succeeded. So is the fact that, of the people who read my comment, 19 more of them upvoted it than downvoted it.
Good luck trying to convince people that someone is wrong not by providing convincing examples or reasoning against their conclusion, but merely by pointing out that their reasoning, though convincing, didn't amount to a logical proof.
Good luck believing, and acting on, solely information for which you have found a logical proof.
(Ironically, I mentioned my minor in undergrad was physics, but my major was pure math, so I used to live and breathe logical proofs, and I still love them. But acting like they're the only kind of argument worth making is pure foolishness.)
If you think one could come up with similar lists, by all means, please do. I actually did mention the impact of nuclear energy (I called it "the atomic age" to include nuclear weapons as well), but surely you wouldn't claim that has had as large an impact on society as petroleum alone, which powers most of our electricity, internal combustion engines that made modern trade and supply chains possible, and is the raw material for the hundreds of pieces of plastic in the very room you're sitting in?
For example:
"Novelty in science – real necessity or distracting obsession?" https://phys.org/news/2018-01-novelty-science-real-necessity...
"Facts Are More Important Than Novelty: Replication in the Education Sciences" https://journals.sagepub.com/stoken/rbtfl/w5mrNxPVD8zSg/full
In the text: "Funding bodies and academic journals that value “novelty” over replication deserve blame too." https://theconversation.com/science-is-in-a-reproducibility-...
Etc.
I haven't made it through the entire 43-page paper yet, but a quick search for "replic" and "repro" suggests they don't address this point at all.
Nothing about markets magically solves the problem that if it's hard to evaluate quality, there will be junk masquerading as quality.
Chemistry brought us:
- the Haber-Bosch process, artificial nitrogen fixation that revolutionized food production
- the Bessemer process, modern steel production, necessary not just for modern buildings but also engines, modern guns, cars/boats/planes, modern supply chain via shipping and trucks, industrial factory and farm equipment, etc
- modern plastics. Seriously, look around your room, wherever you are. How many things don't have some amount of plastic in them? Less than half, probably?
- petroleum extraction and processing, which powers those steel engines, powers most of our electricity, and is the raw materials for plastic
- modern explosives, especially smokeless gunpowder (did you know that people totally built Gatling-style rotary machine guns in the Victorian Era? The were useless because black powder creates too much smoke for you to be able to aim a black powder-powered machine gun)
Biology brought us germ theory and modern medicine, and of course these fields are all interrelated because engines required thermodynamics and electricity is mostly physics, but none of that required relativity or quantum mechanics.
Quantum mechanics is the foundation for the physical chemistry subfield of chemistry, is crucial to modern silicon integrated circuit manufacturing, and of course—the atomic age. But none of those have had the impact on society as oil alone, for example.
As mentioned, I love physics, but the fact is, details about the fundamental laws of nature just did not have the impact on society that higher-level, less fundamental scientific advancements have had. The Wright brothers created aviation without any quantitative understanding of aerodynamics; and 100% of the societally impactful advancements in aerodynamics since then has had no relation to relativity or quantum mechanics.
If I were in the position of making or advising someone making the decision of whether or not to use Julia, an unsubstantiated, untestable assertion like that makes virtually no difference in my decision or advice. I hope it's clear this is not an insult, it's just that if I have no way to evaluate your assertion or its applicability, there's no way for me to incorporate it into my decision or advice.
By contrast, if you could point to even one concrete example, I could file it away in my head as "someone on HN pointed out that Julia has X, Y, and Z problem". If I were in a position of making or advising a decision on Julia, I would be able to evaluate whether it applies the use case in question, whether it points to some deeper design problems with Julia, or whether I even think it's a problem at all.
Grocery stores across the country could do (or may be already doing) all the creepy things you're describing without implementing "Just walk out", with the security cameras they already universally have installed. Or, they could implement "Just walk out" without doing any of those creepy things.
They're irrelevant to each other.
I don't see why you have a problem with "Just walk out", it seems to me like your problem is with the prevalence of security cameras. That's a valid criticism of, say, Ring, because it's pushing to increase the prevalence of home security cameras, but "Just walk out" isn't going to increase the prevalence of retail store security cameras, they're already ubiquitous.
How? Stylesheets can't use fingerprinting or Flash cookies or anything like that, only scripts can.
I'm actually pretty sympathetic to Wacom in this instance, more sympathetic than the blogpost author at least. But unethical actions are unethical regardless of whether acting ethically is "a real challenge" for some companies.
Some premeditated crimes (e.g. first-degree murder, bribery) can be deterred by threat of punishment, but when people are making the snap-decision to commit a crime of opportunity, they aren't carefully weighing the risk vs reward.
"All Cloudflare plans offer unlimited and unmetered mitigation of distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) attacks, regardless of the size of the attack, at no extra cost."
https://www.cloudflare.com/ddos/
Do you know of an example of an attacker "easily demolishing" Cloudflare's free DDoS protection for a website with a few hundred dollars worth of botnet?
Neither of those are bigger, in fact they're dramatically smaller, Amazon has 49.1% of the online retail market to eBay's 6.6% and Walmart's 3.7%, according to: https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/13/amazons-share-of-the-us-e-...