HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

laughinghan

2,942 karma · joined August 25, 2010

http://twitter.com/laughinghan

http://github.com/laughinghan

submissionscomments
laughinghan··on Reject Google Nest or Amazon Ring Corp Surveillance and a Dystopic Future
Does ADT encourage police to get the footage they record without a warrant?

That's a big difference from the smartphones tracking our location thing you mentioned—police need a warrant, companies don't actively work to make it easier for police to access that information without a warrant.

laughinghan··on Reject Google Nest or Amazon Ring Corp Surveillance and a Dystopic Future
>> developing a seamless process for government agents to request footage

> Can someone verify this? Because I was under the impression that customers had to opt in.

Opt-in to what? Opt-in to fulfilling the request, or opt-in to receiving the request? It appears to be the former, not the latter: https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/43kga3/amazon-is-coaching...

> They aren't capturing anything that isn't readily available.

In 1984, Big Brother monitors both public and private spaces, but in V for Vendetta I believe the roving vans and stuff only monitor public spaces. Am I interpreting you correctly that scenario like V for Vendetta but with CCTV, where the government monitors everyone's public movements and interactions at all times, you would fail to see anything wrong with?

laughinghan··on Reject Google Nest or Amazon Ring Corp Surveillance and a Dystopic Future
Aren't you contradicting yourself?

First, you say "I don't see how security cameras, or at least the video doorbells, are more dangerous than all of the other things we've just already accepted, like constant tracking of our positions via smartphones and our online browsing habits."

Then, you say "Entirely valid complaints, regarding Alexa devices. Its unrelated to Ring, and especially doorbell cameras."

They're not unrelated, you explained the relationship yourself (that they're both "dangerous" examples of pervasive corporate surveillance), and the article quite explicitly argues that we SHOULDN'T "just accept" these "devices that constantly monitor, track and record us simply for our own convenience or a sense of safety".

laughinghan··on Keyboard vs. The Mouse, Part 1 (1989)
> vi in Unix highlights the amount of time you spend watching the screen as you cursor around with hjkl

vi is four decades old. It's not the pinnacle of keyboard-driven interface design, vast improvements have been made since then.

For example, I use vim-sneak, which lets you jump to anywhere on your screen in 3 keystrokes flat 99% of the time (and the 1% of the time where you miss, well, 99% of those times, just one more keystroke is all it takes to get to the right spot): https://github.com/justinmk/vim-sneak

I also use relative line numbers, so I can select or delete most blocks of text in 3 or 4 keystrokes, for example d4j deletes the current line and the next 4 lines (5 lines total), or d23k deletes the current line and the previous 23 lines (24 lines total): https://jeffkreeftmeijer.com/vim-number/

Obviously number of keystrokes isn't the only factor that determines operation speed. This is actually exemplified by my second example, commands like "d23k" actually work out-of-the-box even in original vi, the problem is that counting 23 lines by eye is way slower than selecting 24 lines with a mouse by eye, which is solved by relative line numbers.

laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
What is the relevance of that part? Your claim that open source projects can't be sustainable is straightforwardly false, regardless of whether there are any Linux developers who are payed by other developers in order to use Linux-based software.

Similarly, your claim that "open source folks" don't value open source software as worth paying for is straightforwardly false, regardless of whether they pay out of their personal bank accounts or push their Fortune 500 employers to donate money and time (which every Fortune 500 calculates in terms of money).

laughinghan··on A Thread about Internet Archive's “Silent Killer”
In a reply to your sibling I explain how in my view, the fact that lay people have no mental model of what kind of information can be incidentally collected and how dangerous it is, whereas lay people are much more capable of understanding the dangers of a personally identifiable username, profile pic, and personal details revealed in posts, makes the former far more dangerous than the latter.
laughinghan··on A Thread about Internet Archive's “Silent Killer”
If Archive.org had your attitude, I would actively oppose it. Removing private, personal info is not censorship. And nothing about "just don't put it on the Internet" is simple. What if someone hacked your devices and then put it on the Internet for lolz? What if you shared it in confidence with someone you trusted, who is intentionally putting it on the Internet to hurt you? What if you accidentally pasted the wrong thing or uploaded the wrong file? What if you were a child and didn't understand the dangers?

There obviously should be ways to ameliorate your mistake, which is why it is absolutely critical that Archive.org has a removal process.

laughinghan··on A Thread about Internet Archive's “Silent Killer”
Was there something in particular I said that you felt was defending it with "literal religious fervor and dismissing all criticism out of hand", or were you referring to my grandparent? I don't think I dismissed anything out of hand, I specifically acknowledged both the value of ephemerality and the point that traditional libraries are curated.

I agree that there is a danger that people may not realize how public and permanent the things they published to Tumblr were, or how dangerous it can be to do so (and I downvoted a sibling comment dismissing this danger). However, I think you and I have different threat models.

In my mind, archiving PII that is intentionally published is not particularly harmful because most lay people do, in fact, understand that their avatar, username, and by default, posts are public on Tumblr. They have had the opportunity to remove that information this whole time, and they still do, Archive.org removes stuff if you ask them.

By contrast, lay people have no mental model for what kind of information is incidentally collected nor how dangerous or benign it is. Certainly, lay people also can and do misjudge how public and how dangerous the things they intentionally publish are, but the gap is far, far less than incidental information. "Would you tell a stranger this" or "would you write this on a bathroom wall" are decent heuristics: the only difference in danger between text written on a bathroom wall and written on Tumblr is due solely to the potentially wider reach and possibility of even going viral on Tumblr. (Photos, of course, can also subtly compromise privacy in ways surprising to a lay person, but the gap is still much smaller than incidental information.)

In my threat model, that gap in understanding is much, much more dangerous than the intrinsic danger of PII. That's why I think that as long as Archive.org has a usable removal process, I think pretty much all the danger is in surveillance capitalism's collection of incidental information, not Archive.org's permanent record of intentionally publicized information.

laughinghan··on A Thread about Internet Archive's “Silent Killer”
While I don't endorse your parent's over-the-top rhetoric, and I do agree that there is value in ephemerality and that it's worth noting that libraries are more carefully curated than a dump-and-archive, I think it's also worth noting that these are generally public pages.

All the stuff Tumblr users intentionally wrote and published publicly, but none of their IP address logs and other incidentally collected information, is exactly what ought to be archived and preserved, in my opinion. This is in strong contrast to incidentally collected data including clear PII like IP addresses that many companies today are hoarding forever, when they ought to be ephemeral.

laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
So...you're not disagreeing with anything I said, you're just trying to educate me on how difficult it is to build sustainable open source projects? Thanks, I'm painfully aware, I have experience maintaining an unsustainable open source project.

Or maybe you are trying to disagree with me, in the self-contradictory sentence in which you state that projects like Linux are not sustainable because community cares about them, but because community members find enough vested in them to support them. What's the difference between "care about" and "vested in and support"?

Or, for some reason, you and pjmlp don't consider people who work at corporations to be "community members". Turns out if you exclude most of the people who are paid to work on open source, then you find that there's no money being put into open source!

Look, I'm sorry to be snarky, but it's frustrating to be told facts that don't contradict nor add to what I've been saying, and that I'm already all too aware of. I don't know what point you're trying to make.

If you're just trying to point out that many important open source projects can't get corporate backing to become sustainable, again, I already know that from painful personal experience, but in the case of osxfuse it actually seems like it is in a position to get Google to pay up, and in any case the problem of sustainability in open source is squarely not the open source community's fault like pjmlp implied. That's been my point the whole time. I don't know what yours is.

laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
I don't understand. "Not even close to sustainable", you say, then complete the sentence by describing the situation in which Linux has been and continues to be sustainable.
laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
Interesting. To me, calling people "calm" doesn't sound particularly heroic, nor does calling someone "self-righteous" sound particularly villainous when I don't suggest they did any harm. Being harmlessly self-righteous may be embarrassing, perhaps, but hardly villainous.

By contrast, "free riders", "huge amount of unpaid work [for] wealthy software workers", "No world has ever produced a violin small enough to play an elegy for those “victims.”"—I don't think I addressed my parent in remotely approaching that much disdain.

laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
Would I say what is a more balanced take on what matter? The two quotes you pulled appear to be takes on different matters.
laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
Tiny part? Your immediate preceding sentence observes that the large pool of kernel contributors live on salaries provided to them by Fortune 500 companies.

Is that a roundabout way of admitting that you're wrong and open source can be sustainable?

laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
Yes, big corporations like Google, who is perfectly capable of paying for osxfuse, too.

Balk? You think the MBAs at those big corporations are pushing them to pay for Linux over the objections of the devs? No, devs don't balk, devs are the reason those companies are paying for Linux.

What in the world do any of your points have to do with the discussion at hand? My parent, pjmlp, claimed that (1) open source can't be sustainable because (2) open source supporters don't value open source work as being worth paying for, both of which are contradicted by the incontrovertible facts that (1) sustainable open source projects exist and (2) they're sustainable because of open source supporters who pay for it. Corporate supporters, yes, but corporations are composed of people, and corporate supporters of open source are only that way because their "open source folk".

laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
I fail to see how that is in any way the heart of the matter. The articles mentions someone being mad completely in passing, in a quoted tweet. If anyone in this HN thread is mad, they're a tiny minority because I haven't seen any.

Instead it seems more like the heart of your comment is that you view everything in terms of an ideological battle between the Free Software movement and everyone else. So when you came upon an article and HN thread calmly discussing a maintainer's decision to change their project's license for understandable reasons but in a somewhat underhanded way, you immediately sorted everyone into heroes and villains and self-righteously took a stand.

laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
But they demonstrably can allow for a sustainable project, the obvious example being the Linux Foundation.

And if you admit to the existence of donations, then do you admit that you were wrong to say "open source folks don't want to pay for anything"?

laughinghan··on FUSE for macOS is no longer open source
Fleischer isn't harmed by Google using it, in the same sense that Google isn't harmed by him releasing osxfuse 3.10 under a proprietary license instead of BSD.

For the community it's certainly a pity, but I guess if you consider open source projects to be "default dead", not contributing to keeping it alive isn't the same thing as harming a project community.

laughinghan··on The Nintendo Switch Switch
I think they mean out of ethernet-cables-that-are-usable-to-get-network-access. So there's loose cables aplenty, but a shortage of cables that work in the sense of the far end being plugged in, due to a shortage of ports.

From the perspective of a student walking into the room with their laptop, that's a shortage of cable-ends that they can plug into their laptop to gain network access.

laughinghan··on Syntax Highlighting Is Backwards (2018)
That seems like that would sacrifice A LOT of entropy, that doesn't sound worthwhile at all.
laughinghan··on The FBI considers FaceApp to be a potential counterintelligence threat [pdf]
Is President Trump representative of modern opsec norms?
laughinghan··on Syntax Highlighting Is Backwards (2018)
I totally get what you mean about loudness, I toned down the brightness (technically, saturation) of the colors in the palette I used once I started using semantic coloring.

I don't know what you mean about "when everything is highlighted, nothing is"—shouldn't they be highlighted different colors, often diametrically opposed colors?

With my coloring most of the time I don't even notice the semantic coloring except when I'm looking for it, especially when I type a long variable or method name and I'm thinking "did I spell this right?", if I see the same name somewhere else and if it has the same color, then I have high confidence I didn't make any typos.

laughinghan··on Syntax Highlighting Is Backwards (2018)
I thought this was going to be about semantic coloring: https://medium.com/@evnbr/coding-in-color-3a6db2743a1e

I think semantic coloring makes way more sense than this or syntax highlighting because it helps you see the actual flow of the code, unlike syntax highlighting which helps you see the syntactic structure of the code (should be second nature to any expert) and unlike this which merely helps you see comments (which even in the example in the blogpost is secondary information to what the code actually does, which is usually the main thing I want to know when I read code).

laughinghan··on Google cancels TGIF weekly all-hands meetings
> He denied her accusations and as it was all behind closed doors there's no way to ever resolve it. That shouldn't be in the public realm at all, let alone people having strong opinions about it!

That's true of every accusation the Miami Herald published against Jeffrey Epstein as well. Do you believe none of that should be in the public realm, either?

I'm not arguing that you're wrong, I'm just pointing out that if you want to live in a world where such accusations stay out of the public realm, then that means you want to live in a world where Jeffrey Epstein is still raping adolescent girls, and you have to admit that's a price you're willing to pay to protect the accused.

Conversely, I have no problem admitting that if I support such he-said-she-said accusations being publicized and having consequences, then even if Al Franken and Aziz Ansari did nothing wrong whatsoever, the hits to their reputation and earnings opportunity cost that they suffered is a price I'm willing to pay to reduce sexual harassment.

I also don't fully understand what you mean but "shouldn't be in the public realm". If me and some other person are the sole eyewitnesses to something, should I be muzzled from saying what I witnessed in the public realm simply because the other eyewitness disagrees?

laughinghan··on “We would like to apologize to the user for the error on our part this morning”
Yes, I'm agreeing with you and providing additional substantiation as to why a reader should believe you that Snowden would be unlikely to share Ellsberg's fate.
laughinghan··on “We would like to apologize to the user for the error on our part this morning”
Ellsberg himself has specifically defended Snowden, saying Snowden "made the right call" in fleeing the country [0] and "would not get a fair trial" if he returned [1].

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/daniel-ellsberg-nsa-...

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/may/30/daniel...

laughinghan··on “We would like to apologize to the user for the error on our part this morning”
The press release specifically states that the video was taken down: "November 27, 2019 @ 7:06am ET – Due to a human moderation error, the viral video from November 23 was removed."
laughinghan··on “We would like to apologize to the user for the error on our part this morning”
I downvoted you because I don't think this is constructive. If you think they're trolling, flag their comment.
laughinghan··on Vice Ventures is investing in taboo industries that other funds won’t touch
> VCs will absolutely be dragged into the mix and publicly shamed for contributing to the problem

In every example you gave, the investors whose names was "dragged" were already independently controversial.

Juul has plenty of investors who didn't famously exacerbate and suppress public awareness of what is still the leading cause of preventable death in the US [1]. WeWork and Uber have plenty of investors who didn't famously murder and dismember any journalists.

This undermines your claim that such "media shitstorms" can "trash [a] firm’s legacy and reputation". Cigarette companies and Saudi money already had trash reputations independent of Juul, WeWork, and Uber.

[1] According to the CDC: https://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/fast...

laughinghan··on Telling users why their content was removed reduces future issues [pdf]
It sounds like you've never worked in a restaurant, movie theatre, or supermarket, because I don't know a single person who has worked at one for an extended length of time who hasn't had to deal with people being an asshole and then arguing that they weren't being an asshole.

Of course most people can manage not to be an asshole on a day-to-day basis, but to deal with the small minority of bad apples who could ruin a whole barrel, it helps to spell out specific banned behavior in detail to quickly shut down arguments about whether a specific behavior is being an asshole or not.

The last sentence is pointing out that just because you've only ever seen someone be a nice person, doesn't mean they've never been an asshole when you weren't there.

Also, I didn't write that sentence. Everything after the first sentence is quoted from the link I provided.

← PreviousPage 6 of 27Next →