HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

lavabiopsy

77 karma · joined September 4, 2021

submissionscomments
lavabiopsy··on Building an Alternative Ecosystem
Interesting article but I want to clear up some very questionable statements that I see here.

>Linux users have long enjoyed the degree to which they are able to personalize their desktop apps and environments through theming [...] Reasonable expectations like these are being completely turned on their head by GNOME.

This is not new, GNOME 3 has never really supported themes. What these other desktops was doing was always unsupported, I'm confused as to how they could be developing a desktop based on GNOME and not deeply understand this.

>If you want to support and adopt the GNOME HIG via libadwaita but still offer third-parties the flexibility to make the app integrate well in their ecosystem, you cannot

>Through their enforcement of the Adwaita theme in their “platform library” libadwaita [...] they are eliminating both developer and user choice in the process

>If you are building a desktop Linux application at this point and you want to provide flexibility for your users or allow operating systems to ship your app, with users being happy with how well it integrates with the rest of their Linux experience, using GTK4 and beyond is going to be shooting yourself in the foot.

>Instead of debating more on technical merits, these developers are instead trying to devalue and discredit the contributions

These statements are all false. There are still plenty of ways for third parties to integrate apps, the only things you cannot do anymore with libadwaita are inject arbitrary CSS with environment variables or XSettings. The patch was rejected on technical grounds based on comments from other app maintainers that were not going to use the API, the comments on the developer's conduct were separate. I don't really want to comment any more on the rest of the article's related statements on the Twitter conversation as they all seem to be rooted in this initial misconception.

>some GNOME developers dismissing concerns by just claiming that nobody from System76 ever engaged with GNOME on the matter, which is materially false

This statement is false and based on a misinterpretation of an older conversation. The conversation from 2019 was related but was not about this specific issue. Some of the changes from that 2019 conversation are actually making it in to Adwaita. Other changes were not implemented and are looking for an implementer, which the Solus developers could have stepped up to do in 2019, but it seems they declined to.

>Instead, you need your own class that sub-classes GObject + GObjectClass, hold a pointer to a GtkHeaderBar or GtkListBox, and make changes to the widgets referenced by the pointer [which is] unnecessarily cumbersome

This is false, it's necessary as subclassing those widgets can break the CSS classes.

>Instead of having simple GTK functions to set the positioning, now everyone has to write their own APIs that interface directly with X11 APIs (risky if the developer is not familiar with them)

This statement as well as the entire section on X11 APIs is very baffling. If the developer is not familiar with various X11 APIs and quirks, they will have a hard time developing a desktop for X11 at all. And X11 as a whole is basically deprecated, new desktops should not be using that, the current focus is on Wayland.

After reading such a low quality blog post from the lead developer that has apparently led to major decisions, I currently would not suggest use of Solus or Budgie to anyone. But I wish them luck with their EFL migration in any case. EFL has pretty mature Wayland support by the way.

lavabiopsy··on Please don’t theme our apps
>I don't trust GNOME/GTK developers to keep their "every preference has a cost" philosophy limited to GNOME

That isn't a philosophy, it's just how development works. Preferences do have a cost, in any project. The actual GNOME philosophy is more along the lines of "GNOME would rather spend the cost of preferences elsewhere" which has been part of the project's philosophy for many years, if you disagree with that decision then feel free to use some other platform.

I don't see what your issue is with GNOME Screenshot, you don't have to use it. Just use Spectacle, nobody is going to take issue with you doing that. The builtin GNOME tools are designed to be simple and straightforward, not to include every feature under the sun. Which features an app has is entirely up to its developer, you can say they should or shouldn't do something but it's not your decision to make unless you are developing that app. The developer might listen to community suggestions but they don't have to, and they are very unlikely to if the suggestions are rude.

>I also stand by my statement of "GNOME not really being a community project" after reading the blog posts by Tobias. There is little room for disagreement besides what the "GNOME way" says and little care for downstream.

This paragraph doesn't make sense to me. The "GNOME way" is just what a group of loosely connected developers all agree on and those blog posts are just one developer's opinion. You're saying it's not a community project but that "GNOME way" is entirely the product of that community, there is nothing else there. Downstream is only relevant as far as they contribute back upstream, because there is no other possible way for there to be any relationship there.

But I would say in a lot of cases with FOSS communities, the well has been poisoned and interactions become toxic very fast, I just try to cut that behavior off at the head and correct any misinformation that is out there.

lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
Are you mounting them on NFS or using samba? That wouldn't be bash. Under windows you would just type the SMB path name.
lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
Nit pick: Bash is only standard on GNU, it has never been standard anywhere else. You may be thinking of the Bourne shell, although neither bash nor the Bourne shell include a standard for shared directories, so I'm curious what you mean is bog-standard there.
lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
>employees at large corporations attacking people who don't have a big corporate affiliation

That's interesting because on this forum I have seen quite a lot of the exact opposite: employees at startups attacking big corporation employees, seemingly because they (incorrectly) perceive them as their competitors. In fact any time Facebook, Google, Amazon or Microsoft seems to get brought up here in an article there is a barrage of negative comments and airing of grievances out of the blue. Honestly to me this is all just shades of the same open source drama, it really doesn't matter in the end who stands for what or represents what. Some people just won't get along and that's what the community has to deal with. When it's a prominent founder causing issues, then it becomes a problem for everyone.

lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
Or maybe it's just a coincidence? Please be careful not to get drawn into "doomsday" thinking.
lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
I'm afraid I don't understand your analogy, all of that has even less to do with Richard Stallman, who does not work on GNU software and hasn't done that in decades.

Edit: I had to look up Naughty Dog that made me more confused, they only make Playstation software, but as I said in a sibling post: GNU has always supported multiple kernels.

lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
I don't understand why this is relevant. To use the word from that article, please do not "shitpost" here, let's keep the conversation above ground.
lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
That's the GNU system though, which is a different thing entirely. It has always supported multiple kernels, in fact a lot of GNU software has ports for Microsoft Windows or can otherwise be cajoled into running there.
lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
I've also been using Linux for about 20 years and I would happily switch to Fuchsia if it had good hardware support and worked well on servers. POSIX is just a bad API spec, I'm personally sick of programming for it and dealing with it. It seems to me that new things like eBPF are just papering over the existing problems, which everyone is afraid to address out of fear of breaking legacy software.

But I actually don't think this will happen with Fuchsia and I expect to just deal with the problems of Linux for another 20 years. Oh well.

lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
I disagree, out-of-touch founders being kicked out is a good thing. It's a sign that the community is strong enough and can move forward irrespective of any one person's opinion. This video has it totally backwards.

Like, I get that there is an aspect of founder worship on this forum but there is no inherent value in this beyond the idea that someone can keep control indefinitely, which doesn't matter for an open source project. Maybe it matters if you want to hang onto your company's bank accounts but that's a fundamentally different thing compared to a project that exists entirely on public github.

lavabiopsy··on Linux Sucks 2021 – The End of Linux Is Nigh [video]
I don't understand why that would be relevant, Richard Stallman has nothing to do with Linux and has never worked on Linux at all.
lavabiopsy··on Facebook has exempted high-profile users from some or all of its rules
I don't understand what you mean, that's not censorship. To use an analogy, when you tell everyone you don't like Star Wars, your friends will likely decide to only talk to you about Westworld and not talk to you about what happens in The Mandalorian. Censorship would be if someone was actively trying to stop everyone from talking about Star Wars, which is not what is happening. I would advise against using that word without clear proof of it, as it's misused quite often. Also I don't understand why you were previously encouraging spam filtering but now seem to be against any kind of filtering?

>trying to decide what's true for any possible statement

Any possible statement that happens on their platform, yes. That's generally how it works when you have a company and I don't see how Facebook is doing anything out of the ordinary here -- any company can fire employees/customers for lying. If they know there are lies being posted on their site, it's perfectly reasonable to delete them. In fact I wish they would take more effort to delete more lies and falsehoods, the website is unusable when everybody is caught up in discussing a lie and doesn't want to hear the truth.

>To try and decide what's true for the entire space of arbitrary questions about politics or science is thus arrogance on a galactic scale.

I really can't agree. In general, we know what's true for politics: it's what the elections and the courts decide, at least in the US anyway. By design those are the authoritative sources. There is no authoritative source for science but with that you can verify the accuracy of any statement by testing it yourself and reproducing (or not reproducing) the results, that's the whole point. I don't see why it would be arrogant of a company to do this, as it's what a company is supposed to be doing in order for the system to work.

lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
It doesn't really matter who does the work, if you were writing a new DAW, you'd probably do it. But if you were working on an established & popular DAW, plugin developers could be convinced to do it if there was benefit to them (more optimizations, more features, more convenience, less bugs, etc).

I don't think it is currently popular for plugin developers to implement against VST themselves, the libraries you mention seem to be gaining a lot of traction, at least from my experience from trying to catalog open-source plugins on github.

lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
That's also another aspect where the plugin API vendors have not much incentive to fix things, because users can just use another thing on top of it (JUCE, DPF, etc) that makes better progress towards solving these issues from the developer perspective, but still DAWs are left with the tractability problem for other plugins that don't use that.

To me, if there is any interest in solving that, I would just expect someone to put a new plugin backend in JUCE/DPF that is specific to the DAW and then compile that together with the plugins into a big giant build. That's more what I mean by "dropping plugins", it's how you avoid the MxN problem too. But I think that many DAWs (including Ardour) gain little benefit from doing this at this time, so if that was what your original sentiment was, I agree.

lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
That's what I mean. The solution there would be to get Logic to run "auval" before loading the plugin which ensures that developers don't do that. But for users of Logic doing that serves no benefit as it doesn't actually guarantee the plugins run more reliably, so it won't happen. And even if it did happen, there would be no guarantee that the stress testing tool wasn't also written against other ambiguities in the spec.

Edit: I also think testing is hard in general for plugin developers to use correctly. I personally would prefer to see plugin APIs designed in a better way that make it so it's hard to accidentally cause race conditions.

lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
As per your other comment, it seems things are already going in that direction, if developers are treating their plugins as being written in a format that could be described as "AU that is compatible with Logic but nothing else" or something like that (substitute for any format/DAW combination that the developer wants). So I would say that in a way it has already flown regardless of how we feel about it.
lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
I have switched to Pipewire but last time I tried JACK2 there were tools that would auto-start a2jmidi for all available midi ports. This is trivial to do. If hotplug was a concern then someone could just write it to run based on udev triggers.
lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
I'm sorry, I don't get where this is coming from, the specialists don't need to be hired to write the same code again. The old code can just be re-used. If I could guess, I think this is stemming from a misunderstanding that "no plugins" means "no code re-use" which is an understandable misunderstanding (say that 5 times fast) but it isn't the case.

In my opinion, plugins only exist because it's convenient to package a synthesizer/reverb/whatever for users that way, but there is no reason that can't be supplanted with something that is more convenient. Of course if it's less convenient then that wouldn't be worth doing, if that is your concern then I agree with you there.

lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
It's not different, and in fact most DAWs are already doing something along these lines internally to actually implement an abstraction layer that can load various plugin formats and have them all interact. That's actually my key point: it wouldn't be significantly different for users.
lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
I still don't get how that is related, in my opinion, that is unlikely to change until there are tools that make it easy to resolve all those various threading/communication/latency issues on the developer side before a plugin is even distributed. So as long as you can just distribute any old shared object to get around that, I don't expect to see it to improve.

Maybe someone could come up with another way to do it that works across DAWs, and then plugins could still happen, but I consider this unlikely because with that there is never going to be a reliable way for the host to verify it that works better than what we have now (user reports X plugin works with Y host, etc).

lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
I don't understand why you are saying that either, please explain. Nobody needs to work for just one, as any code can be linked into any number of DAWs.
lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
I'm not sure what you mean extra hoop? You just start a2jmidi and then connect the device. Crashes would indeed be an issue, generally if you want to mitigate those, you would want to:

- Auto restart any important services (with systemd or similar)

- Use JACK/Pipewire session management

- Report the crash to the developers (of a2jmidi in this case, but it could be anything)

I honestly have never used LinuxSampler so I can't comment on that, I believe they have some strange licensing thing going on.

lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
That's the thing though, not having plugins would not mean that you can't delegate development duties for a synth or reverb out to another company. I am not sure where you are drawing that conclusion from. It just means that the development would be happening within the DAW.
lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
I think you are misinterpreting that comment, I believe the idea there would be to have built-in functionality that would be equal or surpassing to those plugins, possibly by merging the actual plugins with the DAW. Of course doing that in a way that will please everyone is a lot harder to do than it sounds and is likely not even feasible, but the supposed benefit would be that the DAW could better integrate that functionality and would not have to deal with a lot of the reliability issues that exist with plugins. (Disclaimer: I agree with the GP comment in the sense that dropping plugins from DAWs would be a great thing to do if it were at all possible, but it currently really isn't)
lavabiopsy··on Bespoke Synth 1.0 – open-source software modular synthesizer
Which problem are you referring to? a2jmidi should work fine as long as you have access to the device. But in any case that should not be necessary anymore if you use pipewire, which should be able to manage all the devices at once.
lavabiopsy··on Rainbow Six Vegas, SWAT 4 unplayable due to disabled ad server
Does it matter? The game developers I've talked to are well aware that they're trading some aspect of long-term historical significance for short term gain, and it doesn't seem to bother them.

To use a sports analogy here, do you think it really matters to football coaches that the players can't go back in time and play the game exactly as it was played 100 years ago, for various reasons? The equipment and safety practices have changed, the old fields have been rebuilt or destroyed, the minutiae of the rules have changed quite a bit over time, etc. People could try to do a historical re-enactment of sorts, it wouldn't be the same, but that's okay because the game would still be fun if it was done the right way.

lavabiopsy··on Why Firefox has been in decline for 12 years
>So, it is important to listen to vocal complainers, even in minority,

Maybe in some cases this is true, but I can't agree with that in terms of taking product direction from social media. In my (anecdotal) experience with areas where I have expertise, the loud and vocal complainers are almost always completely wrong about something or missing some key piece of information. In fact the angrier and more emotional the complaining, the more likely it seems to me that the complaint is based on false information. Maybe I'll have to do a comprehensive study on this at some point.

If you meant "listen" only in terms of hear what they have to say in order to educate them then sure, that can be important for marketing to explain product changes, but it's not a way to drive product changes.

lavabiopsy··on Facebook has exempted high-profile users from some or all of its rules
I'm also baffled by this comment. Wouldn't that same reasoning also apply to moderation, i.e. if you think Facebook's moderation is bad, you should just not go there? How are they "controlling people" if you acknowledge that going there is voluntary? Also what if their moderation is what is making a lot of people happy? I really don't get what your complaint is, please be more clear.

Edit:

>it's impossible to decide what is and isn't false

I can't agree with this, all organizations have to decide at one point what is false and what isn't, otherwise they have nothing to act on. It would be more convincing if you could suggest ways their moderators could resolve these disputes and determine what is actually true, because what you're suggesting sounds to me like they should just decide that everything is false all the time.

lavabiopsy··on Facebook has exempted high-profile users from some or all of its rules
>For years they didn't do things like fact check posts or try to auto-classify racism, the site was fine

>Gmail spam filtering [...] works fine, is uncontroversial and makes users happy regardless of their politics

>an attempt to guess what might inflame political activists of various kinds, mostly on the left

This is more of what I meant: I find these arguments to be unconvincing, if you're going to make these claims convincingly then you need to show proof of this. Remember we're talking about two billion users here. Your post does not read like an actual attempt to solve the problem but instead an attempt to attack "activists on the left" and "the NYT set" which I don't even know who you're talking about or what that's supposed to mean in this context, I would advise against making these type of statements. It would be more convincing to mention a specific person or persons, what their claims are, and what you disagree with and why.

>Finally, you edited your comment to add a personal attack claiming I'm making "off topic political comments".

This is false, there's no personal attack, I'm saying your comments are unrelated to the argument and are not convincing to me. If you're confused about this, a personal attack would be something along the lines of "X person is a bad person because they follow Y political persuasion" which your comments could be construed as doing about Facebook's employees. So please make sure not to do that. This is again why I highly suggest against making this a political argument, usually it results in someone getting defensive, when there's no reason to do that.

If you want me to put this more frankly: I don't care about your politics or facebook's politics, that's not an interesting subject to me. It's nothing personal against you or facebook. Just talk about the problem please, otherwise I don't want to continue this discussion.

>A major source of controversy inside Facebook was when it was realized that the system was protecting political incumbents simply because they were more famous than their political challengers, thus giving the ruling parties a literal exemption from the rules that applied to other politicians. The political nature of the system and impact of moderation on politics is an overriding theme of concern throughout the documents.

This also seems not really related to the argument. Sure it affects politicians but as has been established, that's a side effect of the way the system has been designed. I don't think it makes a difference whether the side effect was intentional or not.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →