HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

legulere

6,791 karma · joined May 16, 2012

submissionscomments
legulere··on The Singularity will occur on a Tuesday
On the other hand talking about those believes can also lead to real changes. Slavery used to be seen widely a necessary evil, just like for instance war.
legulere··on What if writing tests was a joyful experience? (2023)
But there is: https://www.meziantou.net/inline-snapshot-testing-in-dotnet....
legulere··on Orchestrate teams of Claude Code sessions
One of the outcomes of that study is that your own productivity estimate might not match up with reality.
legulere··on European Commission Trials Matrix to Replace Teams
I don't disagree with you that you need to have a singe cohesive design vision based on solving for users. But I think that certainly usability testing can lead to even better results and is mostly constrained by cost.
legulere··on We tasked Opus 4.6 using agent teams to build a C Compiler
It is very impressive indeed, but impressiveness is not the same as usefulness. If important further features can’t get implemented anymore The usefulness is pretty limited. And usefulness further needs to be weighed against cost.
legulere··on European Commission Trials Matrix to Replace Teams
> UX is a problem that is almost immune to money

Usability testing seems like something where you can get better UX with a lot of money: https://www.nngroup.com/articles/usability-testing-101/

legulere··on GPT-5.3-Codex
I don't think that the user you are responding to is anti-innovation, but rather points out that the usefulness of AI is oversold.

I'm using Copilot for Visual Studio at work. It is useful for me to speed some typing up using the auto-complete. On the other hand in agentic mode it fails to follow simple basic orders, and needs hand-holding to run. This might not be the most bleeding-edge setup, but the discrepancy between how it's sold and how much it actually helps for me is very real.

legulere··on Vitamin D and Omega-3 have a larger effect on depression than antidepressants
If you're not in the respective fields it can be pretty difficult to distinguish good from bad research. I am not able to do so.

If you (or your close ones) don't suffer from depression, then I guess it's best to ignore it until scientific consensus has formed. That will for sure show up on wikipedia. As far as I can see as a layperson there is a lot of correlation with Vitamin D that breaks down in interventions and Vitamin D is recommended mostly for babies and elderly people. On the other hand I see Vitamin D pushed as a miracle drug not unlike Vitamin C used to some decades ago and regular reports of overdosing of supplements leading to organ failure.

If you're suffering from depression, you should talk to your doctor. They will be able to help you to weigh potential benefits with risks

legulere··on ASML staffing changes could result in a net reduction of around 1700 positions
It can also be a measure of other market factors. In the case of Siemens Energy the high demand for electricity generation capacity from AI certainly plays a role.
legulere··on Vitamin D and Omega-3 have a larger effect on depression than antidepressants
> A 2014 systematic review concluded that vitamin D supplementation does not reduce depressive symptoms overall but may have a moderate benefit for patients with clinically significant depression, though more high-quality studies were determined to be needed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_D#Depression

legulere··on Meta announces nuclear energy projects
Building nuclear power stations includes a lot of labor-intensive hard to automate tasks like construction. Baumol's cost disease means it's getting even more expensive: rising general productivity leads to higher wages and higher costs in fields that cannot increase productivity as much as the general economic growth. That's why it's also still cheaper in countries with access to low-cost labor.

SMRs are a try to get out of it by building more but smaller reactors. The reality is however that nuclear has an issue with scaling down. Output goes down way faster than costs and most SMR designs have outputs far greater than what initially counted as an SMR.

Investment in renewable energy already greatly outpaces investment in fossil energy. The economic decision to keep using a fossil system is a different one than having to choose a new one. There's still problems that have no economically competitive renewable solution yet, but a lot of what you are seeing is inertia.

Base load electricity is simply an economic optimisation: demand is not flat, but the cheapest electricity source might only be able to create a relatively flat output. You'll need more flexible plants to cover everything above the base load. If you have cheap gas, base load does not make any sense economically.

legulere··on 2025: The Year in LLMs
Even if it will make software engineering drastically more productive, it’s questionable that this will lead to unemployment. Efficiency gains translate to lower prices. Sometimes this leads to very few additional demand, as can be seen with masses of typesetters that lost their jobs. Sometimes this leads to a dramatically higher demand like you can see in the classic Jevons paradox examples of coal and light bulbs. I highly suspect software falls in the latter category
legulere··on 2025: The Year in LLMs
The effects might be drastically different from what you would expect though. We’ve seen this with machine learning/AI again and again that what looks probable to work doesn’t work out and unexpected things work.
legulere··on Some Epstein file redactions are being undone
Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanlon%27s_razor

legulere··on I doubt that anything resembling genuine AGI is within reach of current AI tools
What exactly should get simulated and how do you think quantum mechanics will help with this?
legulere··on I doubt that anything resembling genuine AGI is within reach of current AI tools
How would simulating quantum mechanics help with AGI?
legulere··on Why is Venus hell and Earth an Eden?
I guess the argument is, that there is just some initial resource usage to get a self sufficient mars colony and all further development can happen without resource strain on earth
legulere··on World emissions hit record high, but the EU leads trend reversal
Why not? India could easily leapfrog fossil fuels, and replacing coal with renewables would even have a positive impact.
legulere··on World emissions hit record high, but the EU leads trend reversal
I can’t think of a single thing where people damaged their surroundings and following generations didn’t have to pay more for that then what earlier generations got out of the destruction.
legulere··on World emissions hit record high, but the EU leads trend reversal
> Housing market is the worst, too little houses are being build because of all the rules.

I find other reasons way more convincing:

Construction can’t keep up with efficiency gains of the rest of the world. This has less to do with regulation and more with failure to automate as much. Basically baumoll’s cost disease.

Centralization means that everyone wants to live in the same places. We hardly can create new land to build on, especially where we need it the most.

Missing or wrong regulation of cars in cities. They take up an enormous amount of space.

Financialisation of the housing market. Housing can either be affordable or a good investment asset. Not both.

legulere··on How can England possibly be running out of water?
Utilities are very capital-intensive and lining money incurs interest. If you let the state run utilities you will also pay profits in the form of the interest for bonds. The government pays lower rates, but there’s a strong push to keep government debts down while private debts are mostly ignored.
legulere··on AI adoption linked to 13% decline in jobs for young U.S. workers: study
It also means that with lower costs your service becomes more attractive and maybe attracts more customers, so might even grow the number of workers.

This is known as Jevons Paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox

legulere··on Google's Liquid Cooling
It's not so surprising when considering googles history coming from inexpensive commodity hardware. It's pretty similar to how it took decades for x86 servers and operating systems to gain mainframe functionality like virtualisation.

https://blog.codinghorror.com/building-a-computer-the-google...

legulere··on US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that spikes electricity prices
> Nuclear plants need to pay for the cost of storing their spent fuel on site indefinitely.

I highly doubt that. If you multiply annual costs with the timeframe needed (millions of years) you get absurdly high numbers.

legulere··on US attack on renewables will lead to power crunch that spikes electricity prices
I guess you’re talking about Germany. Shutting down nuclear reactors and huge imports of Russian gas are two entirely separate things.

Gas imports like explained in the Wikipedia article you linked started in the 70s. There certainly was too much of a reliance on Russia, not enough investment in alternatives like LNG terminals and warnings of partners in the east were ignored with the north stream pipelines. In the end Germany got a lot of economic growth from cheap gas for decades and managed to get off Russian gas very fast. The European nuclear industry on the other hand is still heavily reliant on Russia.

Broad German anti-nuclear sentiment can be traced back mainly to Chernobyl and the exit plan that was followed in western Germany was decided after Fukushima. Eastern German reactors lacked containment and were shut down after the reunification. Contrary to an often heard claim western German nuclear was not replaced by fossil energy sources, but more than compensated by the growth of renewables. You could certainly point out that coal plants should have been shut off first, but that was even less possible politically at the time. In the end you have to shut off nuclear reactors because of growing safety risks caused by material fatigue and new ones have questionable economics.

legulere··on It is worth it to buy the fast CPU
Even better is to measure real performance at your customers.
legulere··on It is worth it to buy the fast CPU
Efficiency costs development time and thus money. Computers getting faster is what made software development cheaper and possible to use for solving problems.

Usually software gets developed to be so fast that people just barely accept it with the computers of their time. You can do better by setting explicit targets like the RAIL model by google. Optimizing any further usually is just a waste of resources.

legulere··on GPT-5
> The ultimate reason for this is Moore's law, or rather its generalization of continued exponentially falling cost per unit of computation

Is it though? To me it seems like performance gains are slowing down and additional computation in AI comes mostly from insane amounts of money thrown at it.

legulere··on Kaleidos – A portable nuclear microreactor that replaces diesel generators
Recapturing the CO2 from the environment of fossil fuels is almost impossible is almost impossible. Recapturing radionuclides is much much more difficult. Also the duration in which radionuclides are a problem has to be taken into consideration, making even babysitting nuclear waste extremely expensive.
legulere··on .NET 10 Preview 6 brings JIT improvements, one-shot tool execution
Bitwarden
← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →