6,791 karma · joined May 16, 2012
India and China are building coal power plants as they have a rising electricity use and don’t manage to build enough renewables and nuclear
In this case the greens are supposedly responsible for a proliferation of coal by being anti-nuclear.
The reality is that the greens fight hardest for an earlier exit from coal, not hard enough though as seen from some environmentalists. In this case the greens managed that the mine is getting closed earlier but some villages will still be destroyed for it. The way they want to replace coal is with renewables.
The other big parties, SPD (social democrats), CDU/CSU (conservatives) and FDP (mostly financial liberalism) were all more for keeping nuclear but also slowing renewables down because of coal miner unions or closeness to big electricity producers, to Putin or to the industry heavily relying on cheap Russian gas. Coal and nuclear plants were run by the same companies in Germany.
You often try to see the debate being steered towards being about coal versus nuclear while the reality is nuclear + fossil fuels versus renewables
Base load plus peak load is just one way to run electricity production. There is also load following for instance.
Germany replaced nuclear with renewables while also reducing both coal and fossil fuel use in general: https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Energiemix_Deutsch...
Nuclear reactors are pretty bad at it, but if you have a lot of nuclear reactors like France does you have to do it anyway, which is why France has a lower capacity factor for nuclear than other countries.
For fossil-fuel- and biogas-driven plants a low capacity factor usually isn’t a big problem as fuel costs dominate. For nuclear fixed costs mostly dominate which means that a low capacity factor also means much higher costs.
https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Energiemix_Deutsch...
There exist several answers that have to be combined:
Using biogas to load-follow. Currently biogas produces around 8% of electricity but mostly as base-load.
Directing the use of electricity. This was already done to deal with nuclear‘s similar issue by offering cheaper prices in the night. With smart meters we can offer hourly based billing.
Batteries for intra-day storage is already getting deployed as it’s already economical and we will see much more in the future.
For seasonal low-points we will probably first continue to use gas but in a much smaller quantity if the other points also get deployed. At some point hydrogen will make sense.
Renewables can be constructed faster and cheaper than nuclear and are the clear winner of the future.
All chemicals should be considered dangerous without any other knowledge. Coevolution of humans with chemicals (which has a big overlap with “natural” in contrast to synthetic chemicals) is just a prior that makes danger less likely.
[1]: https://reddit.com/r/uninsurable/comments/12agamh/german_ele... [2]: https://reddit.com/r/uninsurable/comments/12dtygj/comparison... [3]: https://reddit.com/r/uninsurable/comments/12afq01/germany_ke...
It’s a horribly written book that also I didn’t finish, but at least it’s ideology also goes a bit against the people that think it’s about them not getting enough.
It’s a concept that was created for nuclear, because it has a very similar problem as renewables: the cost lies in building the generating capacity, not in using it. For nuclear to be cheap it needs to get used 100% also in the night and during the weekend. In a purely nuclear power net you also need overcapacity to be able to generate maximum load.